Multi-functional aggregates for enhanced concrete performance and its application

Lead Research Organisation: University of Aberdeen
Department Name: Chemistry

Abstract

Concrete materials are ubiquitous in the developed world due to their versatility and cost-effectiveness as a construction material, but their great potential for increased functionality remains underdeveloped. The prospect of 'multifunctional' concrete is not new; examples of reported research include photocatalytic and electrically conductive concretes and concretes with enhanced thermal and acoustic properties. The importance of the multifunctionality theme has driven some significant commercial interests, and some projects have even developed through to scaled demonstrations and commercial structures.
Concretes comprise a binder (the cement), aggregate (stone in different size fractions) and water. There may be additional additives to provide setting control. Conventional approaches to the incorporation of functional materials to concrete have typically focused on modification of or addition to the binder phase (the cement powder). Performance can be strongly influenced by poor dispersibility or occlusion of the active additive by cement hydration products. The novel approach addressed here is in the dispersion of the active additive (photocatalyst or electrically conducting material) on the aggregate.
Preliminary experiments have shown important improvements in performance when compared with conventional functionalizing approaches. Much of this can be attributed to the stabilization of active additive dispersion prior to mixing in the wet concrete. Spatial distribution on the aggregate is preserved during mixing and casting and, in some cases, porosity control of the aggregate can be expected to limit the degree of cement occlusion. For electrically conducting materials, continuity of contact throughout the matrix is important. By combining conductive aggregate with conventionally mixed conductive materials in the binder fraction, a more continuous, and therefore more conductive matrix can be expected.
The project brings together groups from the UK and China with complementary expertise in photocatalysis and materials chemistry and focuses on photocatalytic and electrically conductive concretes. Each has applications with potentially high social and economic impacts. A concrete that electrically senses itself for structural defects or can de-ice itself without the use of de-icing salts would have obvious advantages and environmental benefits, and its improved electromagnetic shielding characteristics could be important in enhancing information security. Both the UK and China has centres of high population density and air pollution. China is also rapidly developing its built infrastructure, offering a significant and growing concrete surface area in intimate contact with the polluted atmosphere and an excellent opportunity for the support of photocatalysts. These are effective in the removal of environmental pollutants, particularly in urban areas where vehicular traffic emissions (containing volatile organic carbons (VOCs) and oxides of nitrogen (NOx)) are known to have adverse effects on the health of the population.

Planned Impact

The successful demonstration of multifunctional concretes through the novel use of additive-aggregate composites is likely to have significant impacts. Concrete structures contribute significantly to the total surface area of the built environment and represent the interface between polluted air and a potentially effective solution in the form of a photocatalytic concrete substrate. Even where photocatalysts are inefficiently distributed via cement binder, improvements in air quality have been demonstrated, particularly in congested urban areas where high levels of traffic congestion (vehicle emissions). Photocatalysts supported on aggregates for optimal dispersion and exposure, are likely to be considerably more efficient bringing significant further improvements in air quality with consequent benefits to public health. The supported catalyst composite may also find application in other environmentally significant themes, e.g. water quality (a global issue), gaseous effluent treatment, etc. Electrically conducting concretes, anticipated from the inclusion of conductive elements, are also expected to contribute social and environmental benefits should they prove effective de-icing substrates and have the capacity to be self-monitoring, e.g. for structural damage. The improved conductive composite structure, i.e. optimally distributed conductors in porous aggregate and in binder phase, offers potential cost reduction relative to alternative integrative approaches due to a lower conductive materials content requirement.

From the examples given, there is evidently considerable potential for an effective 'multifunctional' concrete to have significant impact on society. The impacts of concrete-based photocatalysts on air quality alone represent not only a better quality of life for the population but could lead to alleviating the financial burden on the health service. Local authorities and airports may be expected to find a reduction in the need and costs of de-icing, should the resistive heating of electrically conductive concretes prove effective; this would also reduce the environmental impact of de-icing salts on water courses and greatly reduce the corrosion of steel in affected reinforced concrete. The project addresses the impact of functional aggregate incorporation, ensuring that formulations are optimised to maximise functionality but to minimise disruption to the practical mixing and placing characteristics of concrete.

The implementation of a successful research programme might be expected to be relatively rapid; the project will engage with the relevant industry representatives in UK and China, via well publicised workshops, to ensure that the benefits of the research are disseminated effectively to those who can drive implementation forward. Concrete technology is a well established industry and technologists are constantly modifying formulations to accommodate different exposure conditions and customer requirements. Consequently, end users will also be targets of the dissemination exercise.
 
Description In this study of NOx interactions with TiO2 photocatalysts supported on quartz, it has been shown that the nitrate selectivity, i.e. the avoidance of the more toxic NO2 production by the photocatalytic process, is correlated with the quantity of water adsorbed on the composite, mainly TiO2, surface. In addition to the efficiency benefits of separating the photocatalyst from the concrete, which we have confirmed using these TiO2-quartz composites mounted on the surface of the concrete, this correlation identifies a potential approach to engineering TiO2 photocatalysts which have significantly improved catalytic performance in the treatment of atmospheric NOx pollution, with corresponding impacts on public health.

The advantageous development of supporting the photocatalyst on to a surface mounted aggregate means that the aggregate bond to the concrete surface is imperative. The different approaches taken have highlighted that measuring the strength of this bond to the concrete substrate or the exposed area of photocatalyst-decorated aggregate resulting has not been easy or straightforward. We have utilised microCT to explore the microstructure of the boundary region and how it is affected by weathering, using accelerated techniques. Understanding these processes is particularly important for a construction industry that must produce or utilise these materials at low cost. These findings and others will be reported in publications currently being prepared
Exploitation Route During our funded research programme, we had been producing concretes with exposed, surface-mounted, photocatalyst-coated aggregates. The photocatalyst-coated aggregates were prepared to maximise their nitrate selectivity, as above, and were tested under accelerated exposure conditions during the remainder of the project to assess the durability of this improved deNOx performance.

The surface aggregate - concrete bonding test methods developed will enable optimisation of a range of supported photocatalytic concrete systems, ensuring stability of the surface structure and how it is likely to be affected by weather-related strain and chemical attack.
Sectors Construction,Environment

 
Description The effectiveness of photocatalysts in managing air quality, particularly NOx pollution, has been well established in the laboratory and in limited field trials. However, when integrated into concrete, they can demonstrate low performance efficiencies, accounting for their relatively low global level of construction sector penetration. This research recognised some of the limiting factors, subsequently highlighted in Highways England report (HE607699-MMSJV-EGN-000-RP-LE-00; 2021), and introduced the novel concept of separating photocatalyst from cement by binding photocatalyst particles to surface-exposed aggregates. The research showed around a 10 times improvement in the abatement of the toxic NO and NO2 concentrations in air, in laboratory studies, when compared with the conventional configuration in which photocatalyst is embedded in the mortar. This photocatalyst work of the group has been highly cited in the scientific literature (e.g. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apcatb.2017.10.013; http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconres.2018.11.002) and its novelty has provided an important platform for further investigations in the laboratories of our Chinese collaborators (from the joint EPSRC-NSFC programme). As with many innovations, accessing opportunities for scaled demonstrations can be challenging and opportunities for implementation of these aggregate-photocatalyst composites in construction have not yet arisen. Durable photocatalytic aggregates took longer to develop than expected but this research enabled the importance of photocatalyst-aggregate binding, and variance in the ambient exposure conditions to be quantitatively characterised. However, despite the significant improvements in performance, the pathway to impact remains challenging. The most likely application for aggregate-photocatalyst composites in managing air quality is currently being pursued through our Chinese collaborators. As an outcome of the project, strong links have been maintained between the collaborating researchers since project completion in 2018. Donald Macphee holds a Visiting Professorship at the State Key Laboratory of Silicate Building Materials at Wuhan University of Technology and is a participant in the '111' project ' Overseas Expertise Introduction Center for Discipline Innovation ("111 Center") in Environmental-friendly Building Materials', funded by the Ministry of Science and Technology of the People's Republic of China.
Sector Construction,Education,Environment
 
Description NRP Research Studentship
Amount £72,000 (GBP)
Organisation Northern Research Partnership 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2016 
End 10/2020
 
Description CSC Researcher 
Organisation Hunan University of Science and Technology
Country China 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Based on the research outputs from the EPSRC-funded programme, Dr Gongxun Wang successfully applied for a research scholarship from the China Scholarship Council to undertake a 1 year research program on the durability of photocatalytic concrete at the University of Aberdeen
Collaborator Contribution Dr Wang assessed the integrity of the bonding between the surface-mounted, photocatalytic aggregates and the underlying cement mortar.
Impact None so far
Start Year 2018
 
Description EPSRC-NSFC joint project 
Organisation Chongqing University
Country China 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The collaboration is based on supporting photocatalytic and electrically conductive materials on concrete aggregates. Photocatalyis and cement chemistry expertise is provided by University of Aberdeen; specifically, the development of aggregate-photocatalyst binding and assessment of the impact of binding on photocatalytic efficiencies.
Collaborator Contribution Wuhan University of Technology also provides photocatalytic and cement chemistry expertise but in complementary elements of the project, Chongqing provides electrical materials inputs and Dundee provides concrete technology expertise
Impact Paper draft in preparation
Start Year 2015
 
Description EPSRC-NSFC joint project 
Organisation University of Dundee
Department School of Engineering, Physics and Mathematics
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The collaboration is based on supporting photocatalytic and electrically conductive materials on concrete aggregates. Photocatalyis and cement chemistry expertise is provided by University of Aberdeen; specifically, the development of aggregate-photocatalyst binding and assessment of the impact of binding on photocatalytic efficiencies.
Collaborator Contribution Wuhan University of Technology also provides photocatalytic and cement chemistry expertise but in complementary elements of the project, Chongqing provides electrical materials inputs and Dundee provides concrete technology expertise
Impact Paper draft in preparation
Start Year 2015
 
Description EPSRC-NSFC joint project 
Organisation Wuhan University of Science and Technology
Country China 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The collaboration is based on supporting photocatalytic and electrically conductive materials on concrete aggregates. Photocatalyis and cement chemistry expertise is provided by University of Aberdeen; specifically, the development of aggregate-photocatalyst binding and assessment of the impact of binding on photocatalytic efficiencies.
Collaborator Contribution Wuhan University of Technology also provides photocatalytic and cement chemistry expertise but in complementary elements of the project, Chongqing provides electrical materials inputs and Dundee provides concrete technology expertise
Impact Paper draft in preparation
Start Year 2015