Multivariate Max-stable Processes with Application to the Forecasting of Multiple Hazards
Lead Research Organisation:
KING'S COLLEGE LONDON
Department Name: Mathematics
Abstract
Due to climate change, extreme meteorological phenomena such as heavy precipitation, extreme temperature, strong winds and sea level rise, seem to be growing more severe and frequent, but the actual estimation of this evolution in extreme weather events remains subject to large uncertainty. For example, in December 2015 when storm Desmond hit the UK, several communities were badly affected by water level rises. Rainfall in this storm crept up to new record levels and provided us with critical lessons on how we can better prepare to withstand similar hazards. However, these lessons learned are in hindsight. When looking at the occurrence probability of such an extreme event that out-spans the range of previously recorded data, Extreme Value Theory (EVT) is the most appropriate branch of probability theory to be implemented as risk assessment and forecasting have a strong probabilistic foundation. In many operational settings, risk mitigation measures are required to balance costs with safety. For example, in insuring systems and infrastructure against extreme events, it might not be enough to sift through extreme record events that emerge from historical data, but it would also be nonsensical to channel most resources into a safety system so robust that it would spectacularly exceed the actual risk being protected against. EVT offers an appropriate statistical toolkit for forecasting extreme outcomes to a high degree of accuracy, thus providing critical evidence for assessing risk more accurately in preparing a proportionate response.
There are varying layers of complexity in EVT enveloped in the recently introduced class of multivariate max-stable processes. These are promising models for the structural components that capture how extremes from multiple phenomena (hence the prefix multivariate) are likely to manifest themselves jointly across a certain region over time (hence the so-called space-time processes, also termed random fields). Real life applications abound in the multivariate infinite-dimensional max-stable processes frameworks. For example, the Fukushima nuclear disaster in 2011 was ignited by the combination of a huge earthquake followed by a tsunami.
The main goal of this research proposal is to develop a general theory for multivariate infinite-dimensional extremes (extremes of two or more random fields) that will culminate in the development of statistical methodology for modelling interactions of two or more related extreme events. Recent studies have found that there exists significant long-term impact of climate change on storms that combine wind speed and precipitation, deeming it critically important that any fragility analysis be conducted in such a way as to ensure probabilistic safety levels of a nuclear power plant for extreme weather events. For example, the sting jet phenomena often unleashes very extreme local wind speeds, heavy rainfall and extreme temperatures on a nuclear plant. This is therefore the first application area of the developed statistical methodology. It is intended that this research programme will not only lead to improvement in safety standards and operational reliability of the nuclear energy fleet but also carries with it the potential of reducing costs in expensive overprotection measures that could run into millions of pounds.
In addition to the nuclear energy sector other application areas will be explored. Energy supply and renewables power systems are so unwieldy that people are still trying to unravel some intriguing aspects of time dependent peak demands. The statistical methodology developed as part of this research programme will enable a better understanding to be gained of the characteristic features in smart-meter data, which will ultimately give people access to more affordable energy, providing more interaction and safety and thus more choice.
There are varying layers of complexity in EVT enveloped in the recently introduced class of multivariate max-stable processes. These are promising models for the structural components that capture how extremes from multiple phenomena (hence the prefix multivariate) are likely to manifest themselves jointly across a certain region over time (hence the so-called space-time processes, also termed random fields). Real life applications abound in the multivariate infinite-dimensional max-stable processes frameworks. For example, the Fukushima nuclear disaster in 2011 was ignited by the combination of a huge earthquake followed by a tsunami.
The main goal of this research proposal is to develop a general theory for multivariate infinite-dimensional extremes (extremes of two or more random fields) that will culminate in the development of statistical methodology for modelling interactions of two or more related extreme events. Recent studies have found that there exists significant long-term impact of climate change on storms that combine wind speed and precipitation, deeming it critically important that any fragility analysis be conducted in such a way as to ensure probabilistic safety levels of a nuclear power plant for extreme weather events. For example, the sting jet phenomena often unleashes very extreme local wind speeds, heavy rainfall and extreme temperatures on a nuclear plant. This is therefore the first application area of the developed statistical methodology. It is intended that this research programme will not only lead to improvement in safety standards and operational reliability of the nuclear energy fleet but also carries with it the potential of reducing costs in expensive overprotection measures that could run into millions of pounds.
In addition to the nuclear energy sector other application areas will be explored. Energy supply and renewables power systems are so unwieldy that people are still trying to unravel some intriguing aspects of time dependent peak demands. The statistical methodology developed as part of this research programme will enable a better understanding to be gained of the characteristic features in smart-meter data, which will ultimately give people access to more affordable energy, providing more interaction and safety and thus more choice.
Planned Impact
An EPSRC Innovation Fellowship will help to establish a dedicated research program, which is uniquely positioned to tackle real world problems on rare events. While the immediate impact of the project will be academic (through the development of a rigorous probabilistic underpinning to the modelling of multiple hazards), this will be a crucial component in the pathway to industrial impact.
Following development of the methodology, the first users of the planned research are planned to be the nuclear industry. The nuclear energy sector is a major hazard industry and this proposed research programmes sits ideally within this context: forecasting the joint development of extreme weather events posing catastrophic threat is critically important in evaluating site installation and safety infrastructure. Nuclear power plants are subject to strict safety measures, being closely regulated by national nuclear safety authorities. The Office for Nuclear Regulation Strategic Plan (2016-2020) highlights ''the importance of engaging with the broader science and research community to improve understanding of known nuclear hazards and to gain insight into potential hazards and risks''. This research programme can improve the hazard characterisation used within EDF Energy, enabling more accurate and feasible risk estimation, which will in turn provide direct input to regulatory bodies worldwide and be of influence in advising on complex safety issues. In addition to specific application to the nuclear sector via EDF Energy, I will focus on profile raising and networking activities in the following areas:
1. Energy sector
Solar panels and electric batteries reduce pressure on the electricity grid, but the increasing number of electric vehicles and charging stations for these vehicles are pressuring the demand. Rarely, though inevitably, businesses and households may experience power outages. Understanding the interplay of solar radiation with electricity consumption will help to forecast peak energy demands. It is envisaged that this research proposal will assist SSE Scottish Southern Energy in designing fit-to-purpose solutions for meeting their target of a 10% reduction in the uncertainty in risk estimation of a power outage. The described activity can be used to assist other companies in the energy sector, such as Centrica and TenneT in identifying-cost effective energy efficient opportunities, reaching out to other providers with interest in batteries (Western Power).
2. Meteorological services
The statistical methodology developed as part of this research proposal, drawing on the semi-parametric estimation of a time-space trend in extreme outcomes, will be potentially useful in improving ensemble-based forecasts of extreme events which, in the current state-of-the-art Met Office's practice, tend to infer optimistically extreme occurrences. The main research findings in the analysis of extreme values can be a valuable resource in identifying and mapping those risk regions capable of generating similar extreme weather events. It will be possible to develop a systematic statistical procedure for mapping those regions with similar vulnerability to water level rise, whose implementation could feed into optimal alarm systems of flood-warning, particularly those aligned with the Met Office-National Severe Weather Warning Service. The proposed research programme tackles statistical estimation and testing for random fields at their extreme levels by drawing on data readings from sources scattered across different points (sites) within a region. Thus, there is potential to collaborate with the ECMWF-European Centre for Medium-range Weather Forecasts on their new probabilistic point-rainfall product for supporting the prediction of flash floods across the globe, and develop it further into the forecasting of various levels of storminess which involve the combination of strong winds with very heavy rainfall.
Following development of the methodology, the first users of the planned research are planned to be the nuclear industry. The nuclear energy sector is a major hazard industry and this proposed research programmes sits ideally within this context: forecasting the joint development of extreme weather events posing catastrophic threat is critically important in evaluating site installation and safety infrastructure. Nuclear power plants are subject to strict safety measures, being closely regulated by national nuclear safety authorities. The Office for Nuclear Regulation Strategic Plan (2016-2020) highlights ''the importance of engaging with the broader science and research community to improve understanding of known nuclear hazards and to gain insight into potential hazards and risks''. This research programme can improve the hazard characterisation used within EDF Energy, enabling more accurate and feasible risk estimation, which will in turn provide direct input to regulatory bodies worldwide and be of influence in advising on complex safety issues. In addition to specific application to the nuclear sector via EDF Energy, I will focus on profile raising and networking activities in the following areas:
1. Energy sector
Solar panels and electric batteries reduce pressure on the electricity grid, but the increasing number of electric vehicles and charging stations for these vehicles are pressuring the demand. Rarely, though inevitably, businesses and households may experience power outages. Understanding the interplay of solar radiation with electricity consumption will help to forecast peak energy demands. It is envisaged that this research proposal will assist SSE Scottish Southern Energy in designing fit-to-purpose solutions for meeting their target of a 10% reduction in the uncertainty in risk estimation of a power outage. The described activity can be used to assist other companies in the energy sector, such as Centrica and TenneT in identifying-cost effective energy efficient opportunities, reaching out to other providers with interest in batteries (Western Power).
2. Meteorological services
The statistical methodology developed as part of this research proposal, drawing on the semi-parametric estimation of a time-space trend in extreme outcomes, will be potentially useful in improving ensemble-based forecasts of extreme events which, in the current state-of-the-art Met Office's practice, tend to infer optimistically extreme occurrences. The main research findings in the analysis of extreme values can be a valuable resource in identifying and mapping those risk regions capable of generating similar extreme weather events. It will be possible to develop a systematic statistical procedure for mapping those regions with similar vulnerability to water level rise, whose implementation could feed into optimal alarm systems of flood-warning, particularly those aligned with the Met Office-National Severe Weather Warning Service. The proposed research programme tackles statistical estimation and testing for random fields at their extreme levels by drawing on data readings from sources scattered across different points (sites) within a region. Thus, there is potential to collaborate with the ECMWF-European Centre for Medium-range Weather Forecasts on their new probabilistic point-rainfall product for supporting the prediction of flash floods across the globe, and develop it further into the forecasting of various levels of storminess which involve the combination of strong winds with very heavy rainfall.
Publications
Einmahl J
(2022)
Spatial dependence and space-time trend in extreme events
in The Annals of Statistics
Ficchì A
(2021)
Beyond El Niño: Unsung climate modes drive African floods
in Weather and Climate Extremes
Konzen E
(2021)
Modeling nonstationary extremes of storm severity: Comparing parametric and semiparametric inference
in Environmetrics
Related Projects
| Project Reference | Relationship | Related To | Start | End | Award Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EP/S001263/1 | 28/06/2018 | 30/08/2021 | £439,055 | ||
| EP/S001263/2 | Transfer | EP/S001263/1 | 31/08/2021 | 30/07/2022 | £42,815 |
| Description | The are two main discoveries as part of this funded programme of work, which are outlined as follows: (i) Creation of a novel statistical framework for multivariate max-stable processes, as well as their dual representation of Generalised Pareto processes, which underpins data-driven methods for risk assessment in settings that involve a spatiotemporal evolution in the frequency extreme events, also taking into dependence between them. This links with the recognisable feature to many natural hazards that already significant impact arises from an increased intensity of extremes events with similar magnitude to those we have already witnessed in the past, even without new record shattering events playing out in our planet; (ii) The development of a new extreme value characterisation that uncovers links between hitherto distinct statistical methodologies in extreme value statistics, both 'Annual Maxima' and 'Peaks over Threshold" approaches. Not only this characterisation generalises statistical inference on the relevant parameters of familiar dependence models aimed at describing joint occurrences of extreme events, it also unifies existing related work. As a result, an effective method for reducing bias of well-known mainstream estimators has been found. An appealing property of the latter is that, unlike previous attempts published in the literature, the proposed bias reduction technique does not necessarily lead to an increase in the asymptotic variance. |
| Exploitation Route | The research on a space-time trend in extremes, published in the Annals of Statistics, contains an element with practical interest for meteorological applications. Namely, the selection of a unique threshold for exceedances of an already extreme event in relation to a given (large) spatial region provides actionable insight for the pooling of extremal data in a physically meaningful way. This approach has been picked up by an inter-disciplinary research team based at the University of Reading and forged a new collaboration with ECMWF -The European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts. The potential for rapid pull- through of the research generated by this EPRSC Innovation Fellowship award has been realised in the expert guidance I have been providing in the analysis and interpretation of research data to both academic (meteorologists and hydrologists) and industry-based research staff at ECMWF, as well as in adapting statistical methods developed as part of this Fellowship, and designing news one to tackle problems that currently lie outside ECMWF's research capability. |
| Sectors | Energy Environment |
| URL | http://claudianet.co.uk/ |
| Description | These findings have been used to update EDF Energy's knowledge in relation to the modelling of very rare events such that with a 1 in 10,000 years occurrence rate. This central to EDF Energy's core of business as nuclear energy producer because the Office for Nuclear Regulation Safety Assessment Principles state that: "values should be derived conservatively to take account of data and model uncertainties", while nuclear power plants must be designed to withstand extreme events with a return period of 1 in 10,000 years. By challenging key tenets that had been underpinning EDF Energy's statistical analysis, the statistical methods developed during this research programme, while based on reasonably general theoretical conditions of a qualitative nature which makes them self-evident, were understood, well-received and subsequently exploited to deliver radical change. The paradigm shift that the new proposed methodology brings sparked the interest of EDF Energy Innovation in France, leading to a follow-on research contract for a project conducted between the years 2022 and 2023. Important multi-dimensional challenges that have been overcome as part of the programme of activity for this Innovation Fellowship include the deployment of statistical tools that are robust and fit-for-purpose for EDF and SSE Networks, mostly as a result of the enhanced capacity building by the PI with understanding and quickly adapt to changes arising from the industrial partners' various sets of circumstances and evolving business constraints; the broadening of the relevant knowledge-base for making useful recommendations; the enhanced academic standing and credentials for building partners' trust, which is key for having decision-makers on board and ensure that the teams working at the two sites (university and industry) go along with the recommendations issued and share the same vision; the common narrative of opportunity and risk that was created and shared between to two sites, with ensuing transparency (inasmuch as possible within confidentiality agreements) and accountability, confidence in the knowledge exchanged and promoting equal access. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2023 |
| Sector | Energy |
| Impact Types | Societal Economic |
| Title | General functions for performing extreme value analysis on a circular domain |
| Description | This package tackles the problem of threshold selection for statistical inference on non-stationary extremes events that evolve on a circular domain (space or time, for example over the years). The threshold selection procedure that is proposed also brings a novel and fresh perspective to employing already existing estimators with proven efficacy. |
| Type Of Material | Improvements to research infrastructure |
| Year Produced | 2022 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | Accessibility, reproducibility of the research findings this awards has determined. Importantly, there is guidance documentation for making this an off-the-self tool. Does not involve animal use. |
| URL | https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/circularEV/circularEV.pdf |
| Description | Estimation and testing for spatiotemporal trends in flooding events in Europe |
| Organisation | European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasting ECMWF |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Public |
| PI Contribution | This is a research collaboration with the University of Reading and the ECMWF aimed at improving the forecasting of flooding. The collaboration involves training of a PhD student based at the University of Reading under the supervision of Prof. Sarah Dance and Prof. Hannah Cloke OBE. |
| Collaborator Contribution | I am leading the statistical stream of this research as part of a PhD project in collaboration with industry. |
| Impact | Presentation at ECWMF. |
| Start Year | 2023 |
| Description | Estimation and testing for spatiotemporal trends in flooding events in Europe |
| Organisation | University of Reading |
| Department | Department of Meteorology |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | This is a research collaboration with the University of Reading and the ECMWF aimed at improving the forecasting of flooding. The collaboration involves training of a PhD student based at the University of Reading under the supervision of Prof. Sarah Dance and Prof. Hannah Cloke OBE. |
| Collaborator Contribution | I am leading the statistical stream of this research as part of a PhD project in collaboration with industry. |
| Impact | Presentation at ECWMF. |
| Start Year | 2023 |
| Title | Statistical methodology for non-stationary multivariate extremes |
| Description | General functions for performing the extreme value analysis as part of the application in the paper "Spatial dependence and space-time trend in extremes" have been wholly implemented in R and are available at https://github.com/zhouchen0527/rainscedasis. |
| Type Of Technology | New/Improved Technique/Technology |
| Year Produced | 2021 |
| Impact | Reproducibility of the results with enhanced uptake by applied sciences, notably meteorology, energy systems modelling and ocean engineering. |
| Description | Presentation at the Net Zero Centre, King's College London |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | This is part of the Seminar Series run by the Net Zero Centre at King's College London whose mission is to foster an interdisciplinary environment to provide a focal point for King's science and engineering research in net zero. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
| URL | https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjVJxOj4c14Oo0zoafDo7QtVMQvMwyMgS |
| Description | UKRI workshop: Interactive workshop to define research needs, spin out partnerships and identify funding opportunities. |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | This one afternoon workshop was part of the Energy Forecasting Innovation Conference which took place in May 2022 at King's College London. The aim was to provide an ideal forum to discuss research needs and to seed the process of partnership formation and eventual formation of projects/research consortia to fulfil these needs. The participants were drawn from across the academic and industry sector. There were just over 100 registered participants: 1/3 attended in-person and 2/3 opted for online attendance. Our commitment was to bring together people who are active in research and innovation, whether their activity is taking place in academia or in an industry setting. This meant that the workshop has to appeal to a wide range of different backgrounds with staggering different levels of familiarity with statistics, from methodological to applied. In order to maximise the potential for successful outcomes as well as to ensure that all participants felt they were offered plenty of opportunity to get the most out of the planned group discussions and brainstorming (including those attending online), we hired the company Research in Focus Ltd the running of this event. A report of the key outcomes of the workshop was produced at the end and subsequently shared with EPRSC. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| URL | https://www.kcl.ac.uk/events/energy-forecasting-innovation-conference-building-capacity-from-modern-... |
