Covid19 pandemic and the resilience of European-South Asian apparel production networks: Implications for firms and workers in moments of crisis

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sussex
Department Name: University of Sussex Business School

Abstract

The world economy has become increasingly reliant on the organisation of global supply chains, with industries such as apparel leading the way. However, the Covid-19 pandemic made visible many of the key vulnerabilities of global lead firms, local suppliers and workers at the heart of these globally integrated systems of production. Supply chains have been disrupted, orders were reduced and cancelled, factories were closed, and workers have lost jobs. This project will examine the resilience of a key European supply chain (the European - South Asian apparel production network) in a post-Covid19 context to shed light on the implications of the pandemic for the organisation of work and workers, the majority of whom are women. In so doing, it takes the Bangladeshi and Sri Lankan apparel industries as comparative case examples. By 'post-Covd19', I refer to the pandemic and its aftermath, essentially, the post-2019 era. Supply chain resilience is understood here as: a) the way European lead firms and South Asian manufacturers have negotiated fluctuating contract manufacturing relations (involving flexibility in relation to order volumes, prices, delivery times and ethical codes, etc.) during and after the pandemic in the attempt to sustain production, and b) how workers have coped with and responded to the implications of these changes to the organisation of work and employment conditions.

To do so, the project develops a novel 'labour regimes' framework that will be of value not only to this research, but also to understand employment outcomes in supply chains in general. The essence of this approach is that it connects both global production dynamics (contract manufacturing relations including order prices, delivery times, and ethical codes) and territorialised characteristics (production practices, state policies, labour politics, and socio-cultural relations) in investigating employment outcomes. In so doing, it offers an integrated framework for assessing the key drivers that shape employment outcomes beyond a single focus on the workplace. This connection is of direct value, given the way structures of global production networks straddling both 'global' and 'local' boundaries are irrevocably shattered and altered, and thus, the research on the global apparel industry in post-pandemic era calls for a holistic approach to understand the magnitude of the changes that the industry is undergoing, both from the perspective of global lead firms and their purchasing practices; and local, territorially bounded production and labour regimes.

The project has an inter-disciplinary relevance and speaks to scholars working across many disciplines including development studies, economic and human geography, sociology, business and management studies, global labour studies, and industrial relations and employment. The study's focus on the apparel industry and its significance for the economy, employment, and welfare standards in Bangladesh and Sri Lanka also enhances its relevance to a spectrum of non-academic audiences, including national and international regulatory bodies, apparel industry authorities, lead firms and manufacturers, national and international human rights agencies, national and international civil society organisations, and think tanks. Therefore, in addition to advancing debates on labour regimes and the resilience of the global apparel industry in the post-Covid19 context, the project also considers public and private policy formulations to alleviate supply chain vulnerabilities through a range of outreach engagements.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Minimum wage revisions in Bangladesh
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Description Future Leaders Fellows Development Netowrk PATHWAYS Programme
Amount £0 (GBP)
Organisation United Kingdom Research and Innovation 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2023 
End 09/2024
 
Description Future Leaders Fellows Development Network Plus Fund
Amount £22,396 (GBP)
Organisation United Kingdom Research and Innovation 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2023 
End 06/2024
 
Title Survey Data - Sri Lankan apparel workers 
Description This data set was obtained through a 'mini-survey' individually administered to 80 apparel workers in Sri Lanka through a pre-designed and structured questionnaire. The questionnaire collected pre and post pandemic data on working and personal lives of apparel workers. Key questions included job specific information such as the job role, wages, working hours, leave, income, expenditure, production targets, incentives, money management strategies, crisis responses, trade unionism, and demographic information to understand how they changed in the post-pandemic context. All data were recorded anonymously. The final data set does not carry any names or identification information of workers. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This dataset is not yet available for public. It will be publicly available at the end of the project as per UKRI data sharing guidelines. Currently, two academic journal articles based on this data are under review by Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space; and Competition and Change. 
 
Title Survey data Bangladeshi apparel workers 
Description This data set was obtained through a 'mini-survey' individually administered to 80 apparel workers in Bangladesh through a pre-designed and structured questionnaire. The questionnaire collected pre and post pandemic data on working and personal lives of apparel workers. Key questions included job specific information such as the job role, wages, working hours, leave, income, expenditure, production targets, incentives, money management strategies, crisis responses, trade unionism, and demographic information to understand how they changed in the post-pandemic context. All data were recorded anonymously. Around 25 more apparel workers in Bangladesh will be surveyed during my next field trip in late 2024 / early 2025. The final data set does not carry any names or identification information of workers. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This dataset is not yet available to public. It will be made available to public as per UKRI data sharing guidelines at the end of the project. I will be writing at least 2 academic articles based on this data during the lifetime of the project. 
 
Description Collaboration on a Special Issue 
Organisation University of Sydney
Country Australia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Prof. Neil Coe is the Head of the School of Geography at the University of Sydney. I invited Prof. Coe to be a co-editor of the Special Issue I am organising in the Journal of Economic Geography (JEG). Bridging distant locations, this collaboration is crucial for both the School of Geography in Sydney and University of Sussex Business School given the nature of the intervention at a crucial time for our world: which is investigating the resilience of global production networks in the current polycrisis the world is facing. For Prof. Coe, this intervention is of particular important as he is a pioneer of the Global Production Network (GPN) concept having developed the concept with his colleagues in Manchester University in the early 2000s. This collaboration has allowed space for Prof. Coe to re-imagine the future of global production networks through a multi-disciplinary and diverse set of work emerging across the world.
Collaborator Contribution - As the third editor of our SI, Prof. Coe's guidance has been essential for the development of the Special Issue. Prof. Coe's former editing role in JEG, as well as senior editing positions in multiple top academic journals have provided valuable insights for Dr. Lawrenuik and me in our early stage of the career. Prof. Coe's expert guidance has been instrumental in the successful application of our SI to JEG. - Prof. Coe was my PhD supervisor who expertly guided me through my doctoral studies. Having my previous mentor as a collaborator in this SI has provided me the opportunity to continuously learn from him. But more importantly, it has placed me in a unique position, where as the lead editor of the SI, I am now leading my former mentor. I see this as a very special growth opportunity for me. - Prof. Coe would be investing an average of 2 days per month (across 9 months) in the SI and the paper development work: reading and commenting on the SI proposal, screening 58 abstracts, reading and commenting on 16 draft papers, facilitating sessions at the paper development work; and any follow-up work for the SI. His in-kind monetary contribution is estimated at GBP18,000.
Impact Successfully submitted a proposal for a Special Issue to Journal of Economic Geography (JEG - a top journal in the field) titled: The Restructuring and Resilience of Global Production Networks in the Age of Polycrisis. This was approved by JEG in November 2023. This SI and its associated paper development workshop will be multi-disciplinary in nature, bringing together scholars and papers across: anthropology; business and management studies; development studies; economics; economic geography; economic sociology; politics; political economy; and supply chain studies. This is reflected in the 58 abstracts we received by the deadline 15 February 2023.
Start Year 2023
 
Description In-country consultant Sri Lanka 
Organisation Centre for Poverty Analysis
Country Sri Lanka 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution - Provided financial support by subcontracting some of the work to CEPA, which is a local level research organisation. - Introduced and facilitated access to grassroots worker organisations by getting CEPA involved in organisation and facilitation of the Solidarity Workshop with local level trade unions. - Provided access to information and emerging data of the apparel industry in the post-Covid19 context that CEPA did not have an access to before. - CEPA team working on the project (Research Fellow and Research Assistant) gained experience in collaborative partnerships.
Collaborator Contribution - Recruiting and training the Research Assistant to carry out focus groups and the mini-survey with apparel workers - Coordinating and planning the focus groups and mini-survey involving 80 garment factory workers most of whom were women - Communicating and liaising with grassroots level trade unions in facilitating the focus groups and the mini-survey - Hosting and facilitating the solidarity workshop with 4 key trade unions working in the Sri Lankan apparel industry, all headed by female labour leaders
Impact - Findings from the focus groups and the mini-survey resulted in two academic articles: (1) The 'Polycrisis' and the restructuring of working conditions in global production networks: Limits to ethical codes during crises in the Sri Lankan apparel industry; and (2) Intersection of crises, discourses, and gender ideologies in change making: The case of Sri Lankan labour law reforms. They are currently under review by Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space; and Competition and Change respectively. - Findings from the focus groups and the mini-survey were presented at a specially convened seminar at the Social Scientists Association Sri Lanka in June 2023 invited by the Association for academics, media, and think tanks. - Discussion points at the Solidarity Workshop with trade unions will have been summarised into a brief to be presented at the Industry Dialogue with apparel lead firms, manufactures, and the government to be held in January 2025, for the purpose of lobbying and developing policy papers.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Organising a Special Issue 
Organisation University of Nottingham
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution In mid-2023, I reached out to Dr. Sabina Lawreniuk of the School of Geography at the Nottingham University and invited her to be an editor of the Special Issue (SI) I was planning to organise in the Journal of Economic Geography (JEG). Dr. Lawreniuk and I have since then collaborated on all aspects of the SI including an academic paper development workshop titled: "Diversifying the Academy: A Workshop and Special Issue Towards Engaged Pluralism in Economic Geography." aimed at bringing in an inter-disciplinary angle to the studies of economic geography. This workshop, held ahead of the final paper submissions to SI is aimed at giving opportunities for early career researchers, women, and marginalised groups to develop their papers and submit to JEG - a top venue in the field. Dr. Lawreniuk and I were successful in obtaining a grant valued GBP22,396 from the UKRI FLF Development Network Plus Fund for this paper development workshop. The workshop will be held in June 2024.
Collaborator Contribution Dr. Lawrenuik's involvement in this project was instrumental in securing funds for the paper development workshop as only a current FLF can be the lead applicant of the grant. While I was registered in the grant as the co-applicant, I would not have been able to apply for this without Dr. Lawrenuik. Dr. Lawrenuik's role as an editor of the SI is crucial for the success of the SI given the theoretical, conceptual, editing, and administrative expertise she brought in. Dr. Lawrenuik's would have contributed about 5 days per month (averaged across the 9 months of the process) in co-writing the Plus Fund grant application, co-writing the proposal of the SI, screening abstracts, reading and commenting draft papers of the 16 selected abstracts for the workshop, organising and facilitating the workshop, and follow-up tasks for the SI. The total in-kind contribution of Dr. Lawrenuik to this project is estimated at GBP45,000. The Special Issue and the paper development workshop is a planned project deliverable of my ESRC grant. Collaboration with Dr. Lawrenuik and her expert contribution as well as the funds we secured allowed me to successfully execute this. JEG approved our SI in November 2023 and we are well on track to publish our SI in 2025. We already received an overwhelming number of interests (58 abstracts by the deadline of 15 February 2024) for the SI titled: The Restructuring and Resilience of Global Production Networks in the Age of Polycrisis, a timely and crucial intervention of academic scholarship at this juncture. This will also allow me strong collaborative and networking opportunities with a diverse set of interdisciplinary scholars.
Impact - Secured funding for a paper development workshop titled: Diversifying the Academy: A Workshop and Special Issue Towards Engaged Pluralism in Economic Geography" from the UKRI FLF Development Network Plus Fund. Total value of the grant: GBP22,396 awarded in November 2023. This workshop will be held in 24 - 26 June 2024 in Brighton UK - Successfully submitted a proposal for a Special Issue to Journal of Economic Geography (JEG - a top journal in the field) titled: The Restructuring and Resilience of Global Production Networks in the Age of Polycrisis. This was approved by JEG in November 2023. Both these outputs will be multi-disciplinary in nature, bringing together scholars and papers across: anthropology; business and management studies; development studies; economics; economic geography; economic sociology; politics; political economy; and supply chain studies. This is reflected in the 58 abstracts we received by the deadline 15 February 2023.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Visiting Fellow - CBS 
Organisation Copenhagen Business School
Country Denmark 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution As part of collaborations and networking, I have gained a Visiting Fellowship at the Center for Business and Development Studies at the Copenhagen Business School (CBS) for the duration of my project. This resulted in two outcomes in 2023. First, I carried out collaborative, interdisciplinary research with Prof. Lindsay Whitfield who is a political economist. Prof. Whitfield focuses on industrialisation and industrial policy in sub-saharan African countries. Supported by me, Prof. Whitfield expanded her field to Sri Lanka, where she visited Sri Lanka in June 2023 to carry out joint-fieldwork with me. While I was investigating labour regimes in the post-pandemic and crisis context in Sri Lanka, Prof. Whitfield studied how the re-location and diversification of business away from Sri Lanka is negotiated by the Sri Lankan apparel manufacturers and lead firms, and the challenges and opportunities faced by these firms in the industrialisation process. We are currently in the process of planning a joint-article combining her firm data and my labour data. Second, I completed my first visit to CBS in 2023 (10 - 16 September). During the visit, potential to collaborate on two academic articles with Prof. Peter Lund-Thomsen (Professor of Social Responsibility) and Dr. Rachel Alexander (Visiting Fellow of Johannesburg University and Postdoctoral Fellow of CBS) was discussed and initiated. One article based on the concept of Deliberative Democracy in the apparel industry was completed and is currently being reviewed by Business Ethics Quarterly, a top journal in the field of Business and Management.
Collaborator Contribution The collaboration with CBS has brought in a strong inter-disciplinary angle to my work, resulting in inter-disciplinary academic outputs. It has also enabled me to network with scholars working in topics related to my project.
Impact Lund-Thomsen Peter., Wickramasingha, Shyamain., Alexander, Rachel., and Rehman, Uzma. CSR in global value chains: Is deliberative democracy a useful theoretical construct? Under review by Business Ethics Quarterly.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Focus Group Discussions with apparel workers in Bangladesh 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Focus group discussions were held in Bangladesh in November-December 2023 (4 focus groups altogether) with around 90 workers. These focus groups provided a platform for workers to share their grievance and issues - especially amid the revisions of minimum wages and ongoing strikes that were curtailed by the government and employers. Workers were very vocal in these sessions. These sessions provided valuable data and information to be included in the Solidarity Workshop scheduled for early 2025 and the policy dialogues scheduled for mid 2025 in Bangladesh.

The focus groups were organised and facilitated by the Bangladesh Center for Workers Solidarity (BCWS), headed by Kalpona Akter, renowned labour activist and former child labourer in association with the partner organisation - Bangladesh Garment and Industrial Workers Federation (BGIWF), headed by another former apparel worker. The opportunity to collaborate with the University of Sussex on this was a great learning experience for this organisation, especially BGIWF. It was the first time BGWIF directly collaborated with an international partner (as upto that point they were attached to BCWS). This partnership gave BGIWF important training on working on collaborations and navigate the administrative work. Thus, this also served as a capacity development opportunity for BGWIF.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Focus Groups with garment workers in Sri Lanka 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact 50 Garment workers attended focus group discussions (in 4 sessions) to discuss current situation of their work and working lives in in the post-pandemic and crisis context. This gave them the opportunity and a platform to share their issues and their expectations from both the manufacturers, lead firms, and policy makers in terms of salaries and employment conditions. This was a particularly crucial moment to have such focus groups, as labour law reforms were proposed and being negotiated in Sri Lanka at that time at the policy level. Prior to attending focus groups it was evident that garment workers either did not know about the labour law reforms or did not have a clear idea of what was happening. As the focus groups were run as interactive sessions with senior labour leaders present, it was possible to create awareness among garment workers of the proposed labour law reforms. Thus, in addition to sharing their experience of work and working lives in the crises context, the focus groups served as a crucial platform to better inform garment workers of the labour law reforms. The insights gained from the workshop were included in the subsequent solidarity workshop with labour representatives and will be incorporated in the industry dialogue that will be held in late 2024 - early 2025 and the planned policy briefs. The focus groups were thus a way of co-producing policy outputs from the insights gained from the grassroots.
The focus groups were organised with the help of four trade unions between May - June 2023. Three of the four trade unions were headed by female labour leaders emerging from the grassroots: Dabindu Collective, Standup Movement and Textile Garments and Clothing Workers Union.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Seminar - Social Scientists Association Sri Lanka 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited presentation by the Social Scientists Association in Sri Lanka to share the findings of the emerging research. This was the first study of its nature conducted in Sri Lanka in the post-Covid19 and polycrisis context (global crises, Sri Lankan debt crises). Therefore, the emerging findings were novel and there was a keen interest among other scholars, researchers and think tanks to understand the situation of the garment factory workers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Solidarity Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Solidarity Workshop was organised among key national and local trade unions actively engaged in the apparel industry in Sri Lanka. This was the first time such a workshop was organised, as participants commented. It brought four different unions together under one platform when the unity of unions have been a challenge in the industry. The platform provided them the opportunity to discuss common labour issues in the industry and collectively agree on key points to be put forward to the Industry Dialogue and Policy Dialogues. The platform also gave a voice for female labour leaders who, often do not get heard. More importantly, the platform provided the opportunity for labour leaders to review, discuss, and debate on the proposed labour law reforms. These inputs will then be shared with the Industry Dialogue - a policy dialogue between lead firms, manufacturers, and the government in Sri Lanka scheduled for end of 2024 - early May 2025.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023