Disabled People Work and Small-Medium-Size Enterprises
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Leeds
Department Name: Sociology & Social Policy
Abstract
The UK Government aims to get one million more disabled people into paid work by 2027. Small and medium size enterprises (SMEs) dominate the UK business population and have been a more robust employer of the unemployed compared to larger firms. Consequently, it is critical to understand how SME employers experience the recruitment and retention of disabled people but the SME employer voice is largely missing from disability employment studies. It is also important to know how disabled people experience employment in SMEs. The government has consulted on strengthening the right to request flexible working, in efforts to address work-life-balance, but this does not prioritise disabled people as beneficiaries despite flexibility being the key adjustment that enables many to work.
My PhD research found that disabled people often feel welcome in SME workplaces and consider smaller employers to be more accommodating of their needs because of close interpersonal working relationships. It was this closeness that reduced a fear to 'disclose' their impairment, thus reducing a dilemma for people with hidden impairments in particular. Disabled people were also positive about informal approaches to receiving workplace accommodations, and flexibility to arrange their working hours, location and tasks around impairment effects. On the whole, SME workplace cultures tended to be viewed positively, suggesting that larger employers could learn from this. It was also evident that SME employer experiences are nuanced and informed by the sector in which they operate, the level of knowledge they have about their legal obligations to provide reasonable adjustments, their understanding of disability as either socially created or as an individual problem. Employer attitudes and values are shaped by earlier proximity to disabled people (either through having a disabled relative
or previous experience of hiring disabled people) and these prior relationships are an important proxy for inclusion. The research found that employers were also more inclined to consider recruiting people from the same impairment category. The study also found evidence that small employers often worry unnecessarily about the cost implications for their business and making adaptations. Promoting schemes like Access to Work (AtW), which offers practical advice or financial support to businesses and disabled workers may encourage more small employers to recruit disabled people.
My fellowship has three main aims, which will allow me to build an academic career that engages with and informs disability employment policy and practice. First, I hope to make a significant contribution to understandings of inclusive employment practice. I will focus on submission of two articles in high-ranking journals. Second, I will build connections with policymakers and non-academic audiences who can influence SME employer behaviour. As part of the dissemination process, I will organise an online workshop with policymakers, SMEs, disabled people, and stakeholder organisations including the Federation of Small Business, CIPD and ACAS. Third, the fellowship will provide professional development opportunities, including training, building international relationships, and occasional research-related teaching opportunities relevant to my research. The various activities will feed into the development of a three-year Early Career Fellowship proposal to conduct international comparative research on disability employment policy focussed on the SME business population.
Overall, the fellowship will enable me to develop my academic career whilst contributing to a much needed policy focus on the role of SMEs in the recruitment and retention of disabled people.
My PhD research found that disabled people often feel welcome in SME workplaces and consider smaller employers to be more accommodating of their needs because of close interpersonal working relationships. It was this closeness that reduced a fear to 'disclose' their impairment, thus reducing a dilemma for people with hidden impairments in particular. Disabled people were also positive about informal approaches to receiving workplace accommodations, and flexibility to arrange their working hours, location and tasks around impairment effects. On the whole, SME workplace cultures tended to be viewed positively, suggesting that larger employers could learn from this. It was also evident that SME employer experiences are nuanced and informed by the sector in which they operate, the level of knowledge they have about their legal obligations to provide reasonable adjustments, their understanding of disability as either socially created or as an individual problem. Employer attitudes and values are shaped by earlier proximity to disabled people (either through having a disabled relative
or previous experience of hiring disabled people) and these prior relationships are an important proxy for inclusion. The research found that employers were also more inclined to consider recruiting people from the same impairment category. The study also found evidence that small employers often worry unnecessarily about the cost implications for their business and making adaptations. Promoting schemes like Access to Work (AtW), which offers practical advice or financial support to businesses and disabled workers may encourage more small employers to recruit disabled people.
My fellowship has three main aims, which will allow me to build an academic career that engages with and informs disability employment policy and practice. First, I hope to make a significant contribution to understandings of inclusive employment practice. I will focus on submission of two articles in high-ranking journals. Second, I will build connections with policymakers and non-academic audiences who can influence SME employer behaviour. As part of the dissemination process, I will organise an online workshop with policymakers, SMEs, disabled people, and stakeholder organisations including the Federation of Small Business, CIPD and ACAS. Third, the fellowship will provide professional development opportunities, including training, building international relationships, and occasional research-related teaching opportunities relevant to my research. The various activities will feed into the development of a three-year Early Career Fellowship proposal to conduct international comparative research on disability employment policy focussed on the SME business population.
Overall, the fellowship will enable me to develop my academic career whilst contributing to a much needed policy focus on the role of SMEs in the recruitment and retention of disabled people.
Organisations
Publications
Molyneux C
(2023)
Why employer inflexibility matters for the recruitment, retention and progression of disabled workers
in Disability & Society
Molyneux, C.
(2023)
Disabled People, Work, and Small-Medium-Size Enterprises (SMEs)
Description | During the postdoctoral fellowship I have focused on publications, policy engagement and professional development activities. I have aimed to influence policy and employment practice through credible and persuasive research, by incorporating both direct and indirect policy and stakeholder engagement activity and outputs. This includes production and sharing of a policy brief for DWP colleagues, and a good practice guide for SME employers, both publicly available on my personal website www.caramolyneux.blogspot.com. I was invited to add my research on disabled people's experience of work in SME to a Parliamentary POSTnote on Invisible Disabilities in Education and Employment. I was also invited to speak with members of the DWP Employers, Health Inclusive Employment Policy Group to disseminate findings from my thesis. I have contributed insights to the annual disability employment statistics, on behalf of the DWP Disability Employment Monitoring team. In addition, I was invited to present my research to DWP colleagues (alongside four other labour market academics) as part of the DWP In-Work Progression (IWP) Academic Scholar Kits (ASKs): What does `progression' mean to whom? And what does it mean for IWP policy? |
Exploitation Route | Other academics can build and expand upon the insights found in my publications. Industry can learn how to embed inclusive practice in their recruitment and retention of disabled people by referring to my Hints & Tips. Disabled people and their organisations can raise awareness of disabling employment practice and use my research as a robust evidence base to influence change. |
Sectors | Aerospace Defence and Marine Chemicals Construction Creative Economy Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software) Education Electronics Energy Environment Financial Services and Management Consultancy Healthcare Leisure Activities including Sports Recreation and Tourism Government Democracy and Justice Manufacturing including Industrial Biotechology Culture Heritage Museums and Collections Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology Retail Security and Diplomacy Tran |
URL | https://caramolyneux.blogspot.com/ |
Description | I view the non-academic impact of my research as three-dimensional. First, I can support disabled people to gain confidence in how to approach the difficultly of disclosure, focusing upon their rights for non-discrimination at work. Second, my research can support SME employers by supporting them on the benefits of operationalising inclusive workplace cultures that can include embedding employee-orientated "flexability" (a concept developed in my thesis). Third, I can influence policy makers by sharing my research insights in policy briefs and by engaging in policy-related discussions with DWP and JobCentre Advisors. |
First Year Of Impact | 2023 |
Sector | Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Construction,Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Electronics,Energy,Environment,Financial Services, and Management Consultancy,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Government, Democracy and Justice,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Pharmaceu |
Impact Types | Cultural Societal Economic Policy & public services |
Description | CV |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Contribution to new or improved professional practice |
URL | https://caramolyneux.blogspot.com/2023/01/interested-in-disabilitypolicy-studies.html |
Description | Personal website to share my research publications and outputs with civil society, promoting Open Access |
Geographic Reach | Multiple continents/international |
Policy Influence Type | Contribution to new or improved professional practice |
Impact | SME employers have advised improved confidence to implement inclusive practice and to raise awareness of their own actions in combating ableism in their workplace |
URL | https://caramolyneux.blogspot.com/2023/01/flex-ability-employee-well-being-health.html |
Description | Research Briefing - Parliamentary Office for Science and Technology - POSTnote |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Citation in other policy documents |
URL | https://post.parliament.uk/research-briefings/post-pn-0689/#:~:text=An%20invisible%20disability%2C%2... |
Description | Engagement focused blog |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Policymakers/politicians |
Results and Impact | I have set up a personal blog site to share my policy related recommendations, supportive practical information for SME employers to help them to develop their inclusive practice skills to recruit and retain disabled people. Also, I share my academic outputs open access. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
URL | https://caramolyneux.blogspot.com/ |
Description | International research visit to Deakin University |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
Results and Impact | During the visit to Deakin University I was introduced to share my research with the leading policy group - Disability Employment Australia and also with several Australian Federation of Disability organisations based in Victoria, Australia. Further knowledge exchange activities with industry including with SME employers in the UK and internationally, with trade unions, with employer support service providers (including JobCentres and Local Authority services), with private and third sector trade associations, with skills development agencies and with policy makers across Government departments are planned for future international comparative research (if successful with obtaining grant funding). |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |