Bilateral Austria: Order Book Foundations of Price Risks and Liquidity: An Integrated Equity and Derivatives Markets Perspective

Lead Research Organisation: Lancaster University
Department Name: Accounting & Finance

Abstract

Buy and sell orders are aggregated at financial markets into limit order books (LOBs). Each asset has its own LOB. Our research will be the first project to combine the information in a stock's LOB with matching information in the LOBs for derivative option contracts. These derivative prices depend on the stock price, their variability through time (called volatility) and other contract inputs known to all traders. We will use empirical and mathematical methods to investigate the vast amount of information provided by integrated stock and derivative LOBs. This information will be processed to measure and predict risks associated with volatility, liquidity and price jumps. The results are expected to be of interest to market participants, regulators, financial exchanges, financial institutions employing research teams and data vendors.

We will investigate how posted limit orders, i.e. offers to buy or to sell, contribute to volatility and how they can be used to measure current and future levels of volatility. Derivative prices explicitly provide volatility expectations (called implied volatility) and we will compare these with estimates obtained directly from changes in stock prices. We will discover how information is transmitted from option LOBs to stock LOBs (and vice versa) and thus identify the most up-to-date source of volatility expectations. Previous research has used transaction prices and the best buying and selling prices; we will innovate by using complete LOBs providing significantly more information.

The liquidity of markets depends on supply and demand, which are revealed by LOBs. Each stock has many derivative contracts, some of which have relatively low liquidity. We will provide new insights into the microstructure of option markets by evaluating liquidity related to contract terms such as exercise prices and expiry dates. This will allow us to find robust ways to combine implied volatilities into representative volatility indices. We will identify those time periods when price jumps occur, these being periods when changes in prices are very large compared with normal time periods. We will then test methods for using stock and derivative LOBs to predict the occurrence of jumps. We will also model the dynamic interactions between different order types during a jump period.

The success of our research depends on access to price information recorded very frequently. We will use databases which record all additions to and deletions from LOBs, matched with very precise timestamps. For stocks, we will use the LOBSTER database which constructs LOBs from NASDAQ prices. For derivatives, we will use the Options Price Reporting Authority (OPRA) database. Our research is the first to combine and investigate the information in these separate sources of LOBs.

Planned Impact

The planned research into the microstructure of equity and derivative markets will make an impact upon academic researchers and the finance community. This will be achieved by creating an international research team which combines and builds on proven individual expertise. This expertise applies to the analysis of very large financial datasets and relies on skills regarding data management, empirical methods, economic theory and relevant mathematical theory.

The finance community includes regulators, policy makers, financial exchanges, data vendors, banks, other financial institutions, high-frequency traders and retail investors, all of whom can benefit from the proposed research. We will investigate which sector (equity or derivatives) first reveals new information, for the first time at a high-frequency level using order books, and will also seek to identify which market features enhance fast and correct information processing. We will also investigate whether or not high-frequency traders (HFTs) and algorithmic trading destabilize markets when there are large price fluctuations.

The results of our data analysis should benefit regulators and financial exchanges. We will obtain new results about the prediction of price volatility and the frequency of price jumps by studying the information in order books. The research team will make use of existing contacts in the market microstructure division of the Bank of England, EUREX and NASDAQ to distribute the research results.

We will obtain new results about the prediction of price volatility and the frequency of price jumps by studying the information in order books. These predictions are important for risk managers and are of value for all traders. We will also obtain new insights into the construction of volatility indices, which will be relevant for data vendors and of general value for retail investors.

We will provide new insights into the microstructure of derivative markets and their links to the microstructure of corresponding equity markets. This will be made possible by building up a unique and innovative database, bringing together state-of-the-art high-frequency data from limit order books for the markets of stocks and corresponding derivatives. Matching this data on a micro-level will yield new results on transmission and spill-overs in volatility and liquidity. This information should be important for regulators and market operators. Existing contacts of some of the team members at EUREX and NASDAQ will allow for explicit transmission of knowledge.

The academic impact of the research will primarily benefit researchers in the areas of financial econometrics, market microstructure and statistics, with a secondary influence upon areas such as asset pricing, risk management and market efficiency.

This impact will be achieved by publications in leading peer-reviewed journals, by presentations at international conferences and through two meetings organized by the applicants. The first meeting will share methodology, while the second will share our research results. Participation by finance practitioners will be encouraged at our meetings.

We will contribute new results to the academic literature on derivative markets, on market microstructure, on the information content of high-frequency order books, on volatility and jump prediction and upon the estimation of implied volatility surfaces. We will innovate by being the first team to analyse limit order books for both equities and their derivatives.

The research programme will contribute significantly to the career development of early career researchers, by giving postdoctoral researchers the opportunity to acquire new skills and knowledge by working in an international team. It is intended to also use the programme to develop the skills of PhD students supervised by the research team.
 
Description Our research project has obtained numerous achievements fulfilling its objectives. Most significant achievements are detailed below.

First, the project has constructed a comprehensive dataset of millisecond-stamped high-frequency option trade and quote data disseminated by the Options Price Reporting Authority (OPRA). The dataset spans the first 8 months of 2015 and covers all option classes traded in 12 US security exchanges and written on more than 3,500 equities, more than 500 exchange traded products and about 50 index-driven assets. This dataset is the most comprehensive and granular option dataset available to scholars.

We provide a thorough empirical description of the high-frequency characteristics of option data (such as frequencies of special records, trading and quoting activities, option spreads) across different maturities and moneyness and for different exchanges. We further demonstrate the significant incremental information provided by high-frequency option data in creating reliable intraday risk-neutral return variation measures and in extracting and examining intraday changes in the risk-neutral density (RND) following important news events, which cannot be obtained using daily option data. This research, which has been published in the Journal of Financial Econometrics, addresses research outcomes 1, 2.1 and 3.1 of the project.

Second, we have developed new econometric methods, based on point processes, to estimate spot and integrated volatility and detect jumps and their locations that are robust to market microstructure noises and various market imperfections. We also demonstrate the usefulness of limit order book information in explaining and predicting future high-frequency volatility. Besides, we significantly improve the RND estimator based on the mixture-of-lognormal (MLN) approach both theoretically, by providing a solid asymptotic theory for the estimator, and empirically, by proposing feasible techniques to avoid various implementation issues and substantially improve the estimation. These new developments address research outcomes 4, 5 and 8.1 of the project.

Another key achievement of the project is the establishment of new research collaborations between enthusiastic research teams at University of Lancaster, University of Vienna and University of Manchester. We are also fortunate to have two world-renowned authorities in the fields of financial econometrics and market microstructure from Northwestern University, namely Professor Torben Andersen and Professor Viktor Todorov, join our research group. Research collaborations between different research teams have been strengthened throughout the course of the grant, leading to a series of research projects between members of the broader research team and signifying a sustained research connection in the future.

Finally, during the duration of the project, we have written a considerable number of papers (15+) investigating various aspects of the project objectives. These papers make significant contributions to the literature by addressing important research questions in the fields, both theoretically and empirically. Many of our papers have been published at top-quality journals such as Econometrica, Journal of Econometrics, Journal of Finance Econometrics, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, while others are being prepared for future submissions.
Exploitation Route Results from our project highlight the usefulness of high-frequency option data, in combination with high-frequency data on the underlying assets, in producing more efficient and reliable estimates and forecasts of various important high-frequency measures such as spot volatility, jumps and their associated risk premia, which are indispensable ingredients in many financial applications and risk management. We expect that our results would create and fuel a new research agenda in financial econometrics and market microstructure that combines high-frequency information from both equity and derivative markets. This will not only benefit the academic community but also have great impact on the wider finance community.
Meanwhile, the investigators of the "Bilateral Austria" project, their collaborators and students will continue to work on on-going research topics in the project and other related research topics in the future. We aim to extend our research to employing the integrated information from both equity and derivative markets to detect and predict other market phenomena/failures such as flash crashes.
Sectors Education,Financial Services, and Management Consultancy

 
Description Our research project has created significant impact upon both academic researchers and the finance community. Regarding the former, results from the research project have been disseminated widely to researchers in the fields of financial econometrics and market microstructure via our publications in leading peer-reviewed journals and other research portals such as the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) as well as via our presentations at international conferences, workshops and seminars. In particular, as part of the project, we organized a workshop on "Limit Order Book and OPRA Data" in Vienna Austria in March 2018, an international conference titled "Financial Econometrics Conference: Market Microstructure, Limit Order Books and Derivative Markets" at Lancaster in September 2018, and another virtual workshop on the "Econometrics of Option Markets" in Vienna in April 2021. We also organized and chaired two invited-sessions at the international CFE-CMStatistics conference on "High-frequency option data research" in 2019 (in-person) and on "Financial econometrics: Intrinsic time, volatility estimation, jump testing" in 2020 (online). In addition, during the investigation period, we presented our research outcomes in multiple top-quality international conferences, including annual SoFiE meetings (by the Society for Financial Econometrics), annual IAAE meeting (by the International Association for Applied Econometrics) , EC^2 (European Conference of the Econom[etr]ics Community). All these events were very well attended by academic researchers, professional practitioners and postgraduate students from different countries who showed great interest in our research and data. These events were also opportunities for us to physically meet and work with our research collaborators (for the in-person events) and to expand our research connections to invited speakers and interested conference/workshop participants. We also received great and constructive feedback from the participants on our research methodologies and results. Research from the project has also created a significant spillover to PhD students at both University of Lancaster and University of Vienna. Research topics from and related to the project have attracted a number of talented PhD candidates to the two universities and provided the basis of their PhD theses. During the course of the project, 6 PhD students have been supervised by the project's investigators at both universities, and 4 of them have successfully completed their PhD and later secured highly competitive positions in both academia and the industry. These PhD graduates continue to work with us on various research projects from the project and other extended topics. Results from our project are of great interest to the wider finance community, including regulators, policy makers, financial exchanges, data vendors, banks, other financial institutions, and investors. This is demonstrated by the great attendance and well-perceived feedback of professional practitioners at our organized workshops and conferences. Our publications at leader peer-reviewed journals are not only relevant to academic researchers but also to the general public audience. Shortly after the publication of our research paper in the Journal of Financial Econometrics that provides a thorough description and analysis of high-frequency OPRA data, we were contacted by an interested practitioner from Amazon who would like to replicate our work, create a blog on how to analyze high-frequency option data and publish the blog on Amazon FinSpace that is highly followed by the wider practitioner community. Our research teams are now working closely with the team at Amazon, with the aim to transfer and modify our code to make it work on FinSpace, and then extend our analysis in our publication to a more comprehensive 10-year OPRA dataset held at Amazon. We hope to complete this project in the near future, which is expected to attract great interest from the finance community on our research. Current work with the Amazon team is also expected to create further research collaborations that will make significant impact beyond academia.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Financial Services, and Management Consultancy
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Title OPRA cross-section price extractor 
Description The tool is aimed to extract and prepare cross-sections of option prices for further analysis. It applies to intra-daily options trade or quote data from OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority). For an underlying asset, trading day, expiration date and frequency selected by user, the tool extracts the intra-daily panel of option prices for put and call types of contracts, for all available strikes prices. The extracted cross-sections of option prices are pre-filtered and aggregated to match a required frequency. The tool is implemented in Python programming language. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The tool can be useful for option price analysis at high frequency, where the cross-section of strikes is required. In particular, the extractor is helpful for analyzing put-call parity violations, arbitrage opportunities in option markets, construction of spot and implied volatility indices, risk neutral densities at intra-daily frequencies, etc. The tool has been developed as a part of the project on descriptive analysis of high frequency trade and quote options data from OPRA. 
 
Title OPRA data analyser 
Description The developed algorithm allows to efficiently process, analyse and store large amounts of financial data (high-frequency trades and quotes data) supplied as compressed .csv files. It uses parallel processing and is written in Python/bash scripting language. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The developed algorithm allows to process large volumes of data reasonably fast and perform initial descriptive analysis. It is part of the project which is a first attempt to perform econometric analysis on the high-frequency trades and quotes' data supplied by the Options Price Reporting Authority. 
 
Title OPRA data filtering tool 
Description The tool is aimed to detect, treat and (optionally) filter several classes of irregular records from the raw intra-daily options trade and quote data reported by OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority). The tool is implemented in Python programming language. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The tool allows to prepare and clean intra-daily options trade and quote data for a subsequent analysis. In addition, it provides a statistics on a presence of non-informative, irrelevant, outlying and other types of irregular records in the raw data. The tool has been developed as a part of the project on descriptive analysis of high frequency trade and quote options data from OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority). 
 
Title OPRA data selection tool 
Description The tool is aimed to efficiently extract user-specified intra-daily options trade and quote data from a large remote database and to deliver the requested data in a convenient format. The tool is implemented in Python programming language and contains unix shell fragments for communication on the server side. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The tool is essential for working with OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority) intra-daily options trade and quote data as it allows to efficiently access and prepare the required amount of data for further analysis. 
 
Title OPRA real time MFIV constructor 
Description The tool is aimed to construct an option-implied variance index based on a model-free non-parametric methodology by using rich intra-daily OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority) data. The resulted model-free implied variance (MFIV) is constructed for a given underlying asset on second-by-second basis and incorporates information from high frequency option prices (mid-quotes and/or transactions) recorded concurrently on several exchange platforms (which can be selected by user) for a specified expiration period. The cross-sections of price records used for the MFIV construction are pre-filtered and aggregated to match a required frequency. The tool is implemented in Python programming language. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The tool allows to construct a model-free implied variance (MFIV) index using high frequency trade and quote options data from OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority). The MFIV index constructed by this tool is special as it incorporates information from multiple concurrent exchange platforms which allows to extract an efficient signal of option implied variance even on a second-by-second basis. The tool has been developed as a part of the project on descriptive analysis of high frequency trade and quote options data from OPRA. 
 
Title OPRA spread analysis tool 
Description The tool is aimed to compute spread statistics for several popular spread measures. It applies to intra-daily options quote data from OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority). For a given underlying asset and a trading day selected by user, the tool extracts spread statistics separately for put and call types of contracts, all available strikes and maturities. Spread statistics are computed for a selected frequency that can be adjusted by user. The tool is implemented in Python programming language. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The tool allows to extract and aggregate spread statistics for high frequency option quotes from OPRA (Options Price Reporting Authority) data. The produced output is essential for liquidity and microstructural analysis of intra-daily options data. The tool has been developed as a part of the project on descriptive analysis of high frequency trade and quote options data from OPRA. 
 
Description Bilateral Austria: Order Book Foundations of Price Risks and Liquidity: An Integrated Equity and Derivatives Markets Perspective 
Organisation University of Vienna
Country Austria 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Our grant is a Bilateral Grant together with the FWF in Austria, with the Austrian Project Number: I_2762_G27 and Prof. Dr. Nikolaus as the CI.
Collaborator Contribution As agreed in our joint proposal our partners in Vienna employed Dr. Ilya Archakov as a post-doc researcher to work on the project and they employed a technician to help with the complex data preparation.
Impact The first stage of the project, the joint data preparation, has partly been concluded and depending on the individual research question will continue throughout the project. A draft of a working paper, involving all team members, detailing the stylized facts of complex high frequency option data is currently been written. The theoretical work on research themes 1 and 2 started early on resulting in new working papers, new versions of earlier working papers and publications as listed in the publication section.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Organisation of "Financial Econometrics Conference: Market Microstructure, Limit Order Books and Derivative Markets", 13th and 14th September 2018, Lancaster University 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This conference was attended by more than 50 people from academia and the relevant industry. Keynote talks were given by Prof Torben Andersen, Northwestern, Prof Viktor Todorov, Northwestern who are our main collaborators in the US and Dr Randolf Roth from Eurex Group. Dr Roth is member of the executive board of Eurex and responsible for market design and hence a representative member of one of the key user groups of the research in our project and also the latest research in the area by others, who presented on our conference. The interaction with Dr Roth, also helped us to understand the technical challenges faced by derivative exchanges and their regulators better, which are very important insights for our research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://wp.lancs.ac.uk/finec2018
 
Description Organisation of an Invited Session on "Financial econometrics: Intrinsic time, volatility estimation, jump testing" at CFE-CMStatistics 2020 Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A special invited session titled "Financial econometrics: Intrinsic time, volatility estimation, jump testing" chaired by Ingmar Nolte was organised at the at the CFE-CMStatistics 2020 Conference. The purpose of this session was to present intermediate results of the project to the academic and the practitioners community. The session was online this year and very well attended by about 70 people who showed great interest in this part of our research. The session had three speakers who presented results related to the project: Y. Li, I. Nolte, S. Nolte - Volatility estimation and sampling efficiency: An intrinsic time approach; S. Yu, Y. Li, I. Nolte, S. Nolte -Testing for jumps: An increment censoring approach in boundary-hitting intrinsic time; S.Y. Hong, O. Linton, X. Zhao - Separate noise and jumps: A price duration approach
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL http://www.cfenetwork.org/CFE2020/fullprogramme.php
 
Description Organisation of an Invited Session on "High-frequency option data research" at CFE-CMStatistics 2019 Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A special invited session titled "Financial Econometrics: High-frequency option data research" chaired by Ingmar Nolte was organised at the at the CFE-CMStatistics 2019 Conference. The purpose of this session was to present intermediate results of the project to the academic and the practitioners community. The session was well attended by about 50 people who showed great interest in the project's results and underlying datasets. It helped to make other academics/practitioners aware of this research and showed how high-frequency option data can be used to overcome shortcomings in option data research which is predominately based on daily option data. The session had four speakers (all of them team members or project team partners) who presented results related to the project: Viktor Todorov - Northwestern University - Aggregate asymmetry in idiosyncratic jump risk; Torben G Andersen - Northwestern University - Spatial dependence in option observation errors; Manh Cuong Pham - Lancaster University - A descriptive study of the high-frequency trade and quote option data from OPRA; Ilya Archakov - University of Vienna - A multivariate realized GARCH model.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://cmstatistics.org/CMStatistics2019/programme.php
 
Description Vienna Workshop on "Econometrics of Option Markets", April 19-21, 2021, University of Vienna 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The theme of the workshop was on new econometric methodologies and advances in option research, and it featured 16 invited talks by world-renowned and leading researchers in the fields of option research, financial econometrics and market microstructure. The workshop was well-attended by about 100 people, including both academics and practitioners, and it provided us with great opportunities to not only disseminate our research outcomes but also connect with and learn from other leading researchers in the fields. Interactions with the invited speakers and other workshop participants, together with feedback received, significantly improved our research and brought about new research ideas.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://econws21.univie.ac.at/