Developing the evidence base for innovation in social care for children and families affected by domestic abuse

Lead Research Organisation: University of Stirling
Department Name: Applied Social Science

Abstract

WHY DO WE NEED THIS STUDY? Children and young people who live with domestic abuse (DA) are at risk of a range of negative mental health, educational and social outcomes. Despite increasing recognition in recent years of the impact of DA, we lack enough evidence of how to improve outcomes for children. Our team consulted with children and their carers in setting up this project and were told that there are too few good services to help children recover after DA, that some services (especially criminal justice and social care) do not listen enough to children and carers, and that there needed to be better communication between services. DA is major concern in public policy, but there is wide variation in what services children can access in different local authorities. People who commission services also note that there is not enough good evidence of what works in supporting children who have experienced domestic abuse.
Our study addresses this gap by assessing promising innovations in social care in England and Scotland in police and criminal justice, social work and in domestic abuse and children's organisations in England and Scotland. We will assess how these innovations have developed, how children and their carers experience the innovations and whether it improves their wellbeing and sense of safety, how the innovation changes service responses, and how easily the innovation could be used in other services, nationally and internationally. This will contribute to the evidence of what works in support for children who experience domestic abuse, and will also provide an understanding of how other
organisations in the UK and internationally might adapt and implement similar services effectively.
WHAT WILL THE STUDY INVOLVE? We will evaluate the client, service and implementation outcomes of 6 innovations: Safe and Together, which aims to improve social work responses to families who experience domestic abuse; Operation Encompass aims to ensure support to children after police have been called to a DA incident; an innovation to support children who want to be involved in Domestic Homicide Reviews after a loved one has died because of DA; and 4 interventions to support mothers and children or babies recovering from DA. We will work with children and carers through co-production groups to design, deliver and share our research. In each setting we will talk to children and their carer / parent about their experience of the service, and whether they felt it helped them. We will use questionnaires to assess whether the services positively impacted their wellbeing and feeling of safety. We will also talk to professionals who deliver the service, managers and other professionals, to explore what has worked well, what has worked less well, how other organisations could adapt and use the same kind of intervention. In addition, we will analyse routinely collected anonymous service data (like referral patterns, what happens to families after the service, whether they drop out, etc) to see if there is evidence that services have been improved because of the innovation. We will share what we learn with policy makers, practitioners and service managers. This will include our analysis of what works to support children who experience DA, but also our insights into how social care innovation can be built more broadly in a way that involves children and carers in service design, delivery and evaluation.
WHO WILL BENEFIT? By finding out what works, we will improve services and outcomes for children and carers affected by DA. People make policy and commission services will be better informed about the effectiveness of each innovation, and will also understand better how innovation can be supported in social care. Our project will also help to build the social care work force, with skills in supporting children affected by DA, and skills to work with children and carers to develop,deliver and evaluate innovative services in social care

Planned Impact

This is an ambitious project that draws together an interdisciplinary team of applied social scientists and voluntary and public sector innovators to enable a rigorous consideration of how innovation is developed and sustained in the social care sector, particularly in the field of domestic abuse. It is anticipated that this project will have a significant impact on several beneficiaries in policy, practice, and in the experiences of children and families affected by domestic abuse. Our project will contribute to the evidence base on innovative responses to children and young people (CYP) who experience domestic abuse . The research is co-produced, centring on the experiences of those who use domestic abuse services - particularly child survivors - and professionals who deliver services that support them. Innovative practices in social care will be evaluated at client, service and implementation level, enabling analysis of how innovative models

Our main beneficiaries are:
CHILDREN, YOUNG PEOPLE AND FAMILIES WHO HAVE EXPERIENCED DOMESTIC ABUSE: Research indicates CYP who experience domestic abuse are at particular risk of negative social, health, mental health and educational outcomes, but there is limited evidence of the best interventions to enhance resilience and reduce their risk of poor outcomes. Our participatory focus centres on CYP's experiences of services. This will enable the study to add significantly to evidence of good models of support for CYP and families, and will empower CYP and families by making their service
experiences more visible and understood, offering them a platform for advocacy and service change,and involving them in capacity building through the co-production of study design, delivery and outputs.
PRACTITIONERS AND MANAGERS IN SOCIAL CARE AND THE DOMESTIC ABUSE SECTOR: This project involves collaborative working with Local Authorities, domestic abuse and children's sector organisations and police and criminal justice organisations, to understand innovation in this area and how to maximise its potential. This will enable services to embed further innovations that work, and to adapt or transform innovative practice as needed. Our implementation science
based approach will enable recommendations on future implementation, upscaling and translation to contexts beyond the immediate partnership, benefiting social care / local authorities, domestic abuse organisations, children's sector organisations, and police throughout the UK and internationally.
By BUILDING CAPACITY IN SOCIAL CARE in the understanding of innovation and implementation science in social care, and in responses to children affected by domestic abuse, our collaborative approach will enhance skills and research infrastructure of partner organisations supporting research capacity building in the practice sphere, and will extend this learning beyond the project through public events and toolkits that will secure a legacy beyond the lifespan of the project.
POLICY MAKERS AND COMMISSIONERS: The project will also be of benefit to policy makers in informing the development of an evidence led and theoretically informed approach to developing social care and criminal justice responses to domestic abuse when children are involved. The study will contribute to policy, practice and public debates around domestic abuse, and services for survivors. These debates occur in a range of different context and spaces, and so dissemination efforts will take a range of different forms, including use of networks in Westminster and Scottish
Government to share findings at the highest level of policy development, stakeholder and knowledge exchange events, public exhibitions, policy forums, in person and written briefings for commissioners and professional bodies, and engagement with media / social media.
 
Description Phase 1 of the project focused on the history of innovation and implementation in each organisation, exploring barriers and enablers to innovative services for children impacted by domestic abuse.

Key findings include:

Whilst competitive tendering produces a demand for innovation, it does not provide an optimal context for longer term implementation. This can result in high turnover of staff, challenges in maintaining successful tried and tested programmes, and organisational innovation fatigue.
Children's participation and involvement in the design and delivery of innovative services is quite limited. Involvement can be costly both financially and in terms of staff time, and is not easy to maintain in a precarious funding context.
The mainstreaming of innovative practice in the domestic abuse sector can also produce unintended consequences in terms of the bureaucratisation of services, and risks the loss of relationally focused, compassionate and emotionally and materially responsive services for adult and child survivors of domestic abuse.

There is a need for a model of innovation that is rooted in feminist principles and guided by children's rights, rather than the current models that are based primarily in approaches derived in the business sector.

The project also explored how organisations had adapted services to meet the changing demands placed on them as a result of the covid 19 pandemic. The growing digitisation of social care offers many opportunities for the engagement of child and adult survivors, but there are risks attached. These need consideration as many of the digital adaptations introduced through the pandemic are mainstreamed and maintained. There is a need to balance the efficiencies these adaptations enabled against the safeguarding risks and the loss of relationality that these measures introduce.
Exploitation Route Our project partners in local authorities and the third sector are already making use of insights from the study, and the second phase outputs will be of particular value to them in enhancing services for children impacted by domestic abuse. The research will aid commissioners in their selection and implementation of services, by contributing to the evidence base on frequently used innovations in this sector. It also promises considerable impact for national policy on domestic abuse response, and social care innovation and implementation more broadly.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice

 
Description Prof Callaghan presented evidence to the DFE national review panel on Domestic Abuse - Child Safeguarding Practice Review. Dr Morrison, Dr Houghton and Dr Warrington facilitated an event in which domestic abuse adult and child survivors presented their views on specialist services to the chair of the Violence Against Women and Girls - Independent Strategic Review of Funding and Commissioning. In addition, Dr Houghton sits on the VAWG strategic review panel https://www.gov.scot/groups/violence-against-women-and-girls-strategic-review-of-funding-and-commissioning-of-services/ The CAFADA interim report on the youth work service 'Space' was used to help the service secure funding for a continuation of service through the Big Lottery.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description National Panel Review meeting on The Child Safeguarding Practice Review
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Description Submission to UN Call for Evidence on Custody cases, violence against women and violence against children
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
URL https://www.pure.ed.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/315316424/Morrison_and_Tisdall_UN_Call_SUBMIT_15.12....
 
Description Violence Against Women and Girls: Strategic Review of Funding and Commissioning of Services
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
URL https://www.gov.scot/groups/violence-against-women-and-girls-strategic-review-of-funding-and-commiss...
 
Title Children's Sense of Safety 
Description Developed with our young collaborators through involvement activities, this assessment measure is designed to assess children and young people's subjective sense if safety after domestic abuse. It was developed to more finely assess the impact of interventions offered to children and young people fairly soon after domestic abuse has occurred. More commonly, evaluations of interventions focus on symptom profiles, resilience and wellbeing. However, it is suggested here that these are more distal outcomes for children impacted by domestic abuse, whilst feeling safe (not just from physical risk, but an ontological sense of safety) were more foundational for children and young people's recovery. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact It will be available for us by all partner organisations during the lifespan of the research, and will be a lasting legacy of the project. In addition a manualised version of the measure will be published for wider usage as the project draws to a close. 
 
Title Feeling safe after domestic abuse 
Description This measure was devised to be used alongside the Children's Sense of Safety measure, to offer an appropriate assessment of outcomes for adult survivors of domestic abuse. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The measure will be available to all partner organisations for use through the lifespan of the project, and will be a last legacy of the research. The measure will be published once associated project data has been published, before project end. 
 
Description CEDAR and EYDAR (Fife Council) 
Organisation Fife Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Briefly describe the contributions made by your partners to this collaboration or partnership. *
Collaborator Contribution The council are a major project partner, supporting the delivery of workstream 2. They facilitate access to social care staff, child and adult survivors, adult perpetrators and other stakeholders to enable the research on EYDAR and CEDAR to proceed.
Impact A report was written on the adaptations made to the delivery of CEDAR and EYDAR at the height of the COVID pandemic.
Start Year 2020
 
Description CEDAR and EYDAR (Fife Council) 
Organisation Fife Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Briefly describe the contributions made by your partners to this collaboration or partnership. *
Collaborator Contribution The council are a major project partner, supporting the delivery of workstream 2. They facilitate access to social care staff, child and adult survivors, adult perpetrators and other stakeholders to enable the research on EYDAR and CEDAR to proceed.
Impact A report was written on the adaptations made to the delivery of CEDAR and EYDAR at the height of the COVID pandemic.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Edin 
Organisation City of Edinburgh Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution City of Edinburgh council will benefit from the provision of independent evaluation of the implementation of the Safe and Together model
Collaborator Contribution City of Edinburgh Council provide referrals to the CAFADA team for child and adult survivors of domestic abuse who have been supported through Safe and Together trained social care professionals. They have also participated in focus groups with professionals and stakeholders on the implementation of S&T.
Impact Focus groups have been conducted with professionals and key stakeholders to document the implementation of S&T in Edinburgh
Start Year 2019
 
Description Falkirk Council 
Organisation Falkirk Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We have worked with Falkirk council to explore their implementation of Safe and Together. This has included discussions with senior managers and frontline staff. Initial findings have been fed back to the partner team.
Collaborator Contribution The council are a major project partner, supporting the delivery of workstream 1. They facilitate access to social care staff, child and adult survivors, adult perpetrators and other stakeholders to enable the research for the Safe and Together workstream to proceed.
Impact Feedback on phase 1 Development of a manual on how to use the Safe and Well measure.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Hackney and Waltham Forest 
Organisation London Borough of Hackney
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We have worked with Hackney council to explore their implementation of Safe and Together. This has included discussions with senior managers and frontline staff. Initial findings have been fed back to the partner team.
Collaborator Contribution The council are a major project partner, supporting the delivery of workstream 1. They facilitate access to social care staff, child and adult survivors, adult perpetrators and other stakeholders to enable the research for the Safe and Together workstream to proceed.
Impact Access to managers, frontline social care staff, children and young people and adult survivors of domestic abuse.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Manchester Council 
Organisation Manchester City Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We have worked with Manchester council to explore their implementation of Safe and Together. This has included discussions with senior managers and frontline staff. Initial findings have been fed back to the partner team.
Collaborator Contribution The council are a major project partner, supporting the delivery of workstream 1. They facilitate access to social care staff, child and adult survivors, adult perpetrators and other stakeholders to enable the research for the Safe and Together workstream to proceed.
Impact Access to managers, frontline social care staff, children and young people and adult survivors of domestic abuse.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Northamptonshire police 
Organisation Northamptonshire Police
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We offer a reflexive evaluation of the implementation of police notification and liaison system for children impacted by domestic abuse in Northamptonshire.
Collaborator Contribution Northants Police are a major project partner, supporting the delivery of workstream 3. They facilitate access to police staff for interview, and to police data to contribute to our evaluation of the implementation of a police notification and liaison system in the county.
Impact A written report of first phase findings (interviews and focus groups with professionals and stakeholders) was provided
Start Year 2020
 
Description Waltham Forest 
Organisation Waltham Forest Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We have worked with the council to explore their implementation of Safe and Together. This has included discussions with senior managers and frontline staff. Initial findings have been fed back to the partner team.
Collaborator Contribution The council are a major project partner, supporting the delivery of workstream 1. They facilitate access to social care staff, child and adult survivors, adult perpetrators and other stakeholders to enable the research for the Safe and Together workstream to proceed.
Impact Access to managers, frontline social care staff, children and young people and adult survivors of domestic abuse.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Being Safe and Well - training workshop for Barnardos Ireland, in partnership with Tusla DSGBV 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Barnardos Ireland, in partnership with TUSLA, facilitate a community of practice, the Childhood Domestic Abuse Project, which aims to increase the visibility of childhood domestic abuse; to support a collective and collaborative approach to identifying the needs of children; and to delivering effective services in response. Prof Jane Callaghan was invited to provide two workshops to this community of practice, in October 2022. One focused on the experience of domestic abuse for children, the importance of hearing children's voice and responding with appropriate and effective services and practice. In the second presentation "Safety and Connection", we considered the importance of subjective safety, its role when children are in contact with practitioners. At the end of the session, practitioners discussed ways that they could enhance their practice by talking to children and young people impacted by domestic abuse about ways to be and to feel safe.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description CAFADA website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The CAFADA website includes key information on the study, blog updates on the study, and information on how to participate. Videos on the various workstreams directed to study participants will appear here shortly. Interim reports will also be published here over the summer.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021,2022
URL https://cafada.stir.ac.uk/
 
Description CEDAR and EYDAR involvement activity - presented to the Violence Against Women and Girls: Strategic Review of Funding and Commissioning of Services (Scotland) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Early findings from our research with CEDAR and EYDAR in Fife were translated into visual form by a graphic artist. These were discussed with participants, whose feedback was integrated into the graphic. Together with a group of women and children supported by CEDAR and EYDAR, these were presented by Dr Fiona Morrison and Laura Reid to the chair of the Violence Against Women and Girls: Strategic Review of Funding and Commissioning of Services panel.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Children's Human Rights Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was a virtual zoom conference with over 50 speakers that is sponsored by the Center for Childhood & Youth Studies at Salem State University, with co-sponsors such as Human Rights Educators USA, the Hope for Children CRC Policy Center, UNICEF USA, Child Fund Alliance, Child Welfare League of America, and others. It provided an opportunity to share children's rights developments across countries, and to discuss priorities particularly for the USA.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://hreusa.org/2022/06/09/childrens-human-rights-in-the-usa-virtual-conference/
 
Description Children's Rights European Academic Network Online Webinar - Building Back Better? Learning from crises for children's human rights 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Crises have seemed ever-present globally over recent years, from the COVID-19 pandemic to climate change. Both of these crises show what can be done collectively to uphold children's rights, should there be global attention and will. They also highlight extreme inequalities, their impacts and the precarity of human rights in times of crisis. This webinar will explore how to learn from these and other crises, to 'build back better' in relation to children's human rights.

The webinar included presentations from Prof. Philip D. Jaffé, who is a member of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, and young people from #CovidUnder19, an initiative aimed to foster intergenerational partnerships between children, young people and adult members of the children's rights community to develop evidence-based advocacy to uphold children's rights in pandemic recovery and response. After the presentations, we hosted an interactive panel with the speakers and others, providing an opportunity for questions and discussion.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.ed.ac.uk/education/rke/our-research/children-young-people/cyp-events/cyp-crean-building-...
 
Description Contribution to Launch of World Visions Centre for Excellence on Children's Participation in Advocacy 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact World Vision International has established a Centre for Excellence on Children's Participation in Advocacy. This aims to nature collaborations and learning together, bringing together World Vision staff, policy-makers, children and young people and academia.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.wvi.org/our-work/child-participation
 
Description International Conference 'Rethinking vulnerability within a children's rights approach'. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This was a 3 day conference, organised by the Child law research group at the Law Faculty, UiT - The Arctic University of Norway, is working on a project on Children's Right to Health. This is a four-year project funded by the Norwegian Research Council. As part of the project, we would like to invite to a small conference focusing on the topic children and vulnerability theory.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://uit.no/tavla/artikkel/763508/rethinking_vulnerability_within_a_children_s_righ
 
Description International seminar 'Participation of children, adolescents and young people in public policies' 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact A three-day international seminar was organised in Santiago and Valparaíso, Chile, to help influence their constitutional and national policy changes. The seminar was jointly organised by World Vision Chile, Universidad Autonoma and Catedra UNESCO at the Universidad de Valparaíso. There were further meetings with relevant Minister and policy makers, strategy meetings and interviews.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.wvi.org/content/events/child-participation/children-and-young-peoples-participation-publ...
 
Description Interview for national news 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Prof Callaghan appeared on Scotland tonight to discuss the importance of services for perpetrators of domestic abuse. She argued these benefited child and adult survivors benefit from services that hold perpetrators accountable for the impact of domestic abuse, and that support their change. She also highlighted the importance of ensuring that these services are offered in partnership with child and adult survivors, to ensure that their needs are recognised and addressed.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Participation and Childhood Seminar Chile 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Organised by World Vision Chile, Kay Tisdall provided a key note speech as part of a seminar series aiming to raise children's rights up the political agenda in Chile and particularly for its constitution. In English, the seminar series was titled '"Constituent Childhood: Proposals and Challenges for children and young people's participation in Chile". Primarily aimed to a Chilean audience, it was also accessible internationally as it was online.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Public Event for Space, Bedford 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Supporters
Results and Impact Space is a youth work led service, providing sustained support to children and young people impacted by domestic abuse. In the past year, young people supported by space have worked with our project researchers (Belussi, Alexander and Callaghan) and creative practitioners to explore their experiences of Space and its impact. Together with a spoken word poet (Jasmine Plumpton), they wrote poetry, which was voiced by the young people, and then set to music, with the composition guided by the young people. Recordings of the song, together with written versions of the poems and other creative outputs from the workshops were shared at two events - one oriented to families, and the other to local politicians, trustees and interested practitioners. The young people were present at the event, and there was a facilitated discussion, which supported the adults and young people present to ask questions of each other.

A further daytime event is planned to better target policy makers and commissioners in the local area.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://cafada.stir.ac.uk/
 
Description Rejuvenate Dialogue - Panellist 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Lead by a team at IDS and UHI, the goal of the REJUVENATE project is to re-energise the field of child and youth rights in social justice processes through a growing networks of child rights actors and to further consolidate, evidence and develop the REJUVENATE principles.
Upon publishing our working paper Learning from a Living archive: Rejuvenating Child and Youth Rights and Participation in December 2020, we issued a call to action to academics, practitioners, decision makers, advocates, and programme implementers involved in working with children and young people to enter into critical dialogue with our work 'as the start of an inclusive process of contributing to and building up international dialogue about children's and youth participation and creating regional networks to share learning on concepts, rights, and goals'.
As part of this process, on 14 September we are hosting a virtual dialogue for thinkers and doers in the fields of child rights and children and youth participation. Panellists will share their work and respond and reflect on the REJUVENATE principles, leading to broader discussions with event participants.

This was a webinar event, with a diverse audience from different parts of the world including ODA countries.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://rejuvenate.global/rejuvenate-dialogue-on-14th-september/
 
Description Training Day - Sligo Leitrim Children and Young People's Services Committee, and Domestic Violence Advocacy Service 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Prof Jane Callaghan and Dr Lisa Fellin were invited to provide a day of training to support the development of the workforce in Sligo and Leitrim. This was convened by the Domestic Violence Advocacy Service, Sligo, Leitrim and West Cavan and Sligo Leitrim Children & Young People's Services Committee. In the whole day event, we explored children's experiences of domestic abuse and their impact, and discussed how frontline professionals in public sector and third sector organisations in social care, policing and health could respond more effectively. In particular, participants considered how they could embed discussion about subjective safety with children and young people, to support them to feel and be safe.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022