GOAL: Supporting government and partners in strengthening health systems for better mental health of Syrian refugees and host communities in Lebanon

Lead Research Organisation: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Department Name: Public Health and Policy

Abstract

GOAL focuses on the challenge of supporting health systems providing for the mental health needs of people affected by protracted displacement, focusing on Lebanon. Poor mental health causes long-term suffering and disability, is a barrier to realising full potential of individuals and society, and impedes progress in achieving the SDGs. Poor mental health is often more common among protracted refugee populations than non-crisis affected populations. Effective mental health services exist, but there are major gaps in access to them, especially among refugee populations. The challenge is how to best deliver such services, including the design of health systems required to support this delivery. This is particularly challenging in protracted displacement settings which can place substantial additional pressure on already strained health systems and where an influx of international aid and actors can risk weakening national government-led responses.
GOAL is a partnership between universities, the National Mental Health Programme at the Ministry of Public Health and civil society organisations in Lebanon. It addresses the following questions in the UKRI-GCRF Protracted Displacement call: (i) what should governments at every level do in order to anticipate and efficiently manage protracted stays, reduce refugees' dependence on humanitarian aid and implement systems that facilitate refugee /IDP integration, inclusion and social wellbeing? (ii) How can health care systems for the displaced be expanded to cover areas that are usually neglected in refugee/IDP settings such as (though not limited to) treatment of chronic illnesses, disability and mental health? (iii) How does gendered access to services, economic and cultural opportunities and levels of power influence differently the experiences, opportunities and limitations of men and women?
The overall aim of GOAL to support government and partners in strengthening the ability of health systems to meet the mental health needs of refugee and host communities affected by protracted displacement, focusing on Lebanon as it is home to over one million Syrian refugees. It addresses two health system topics, governance and financing, identified as priority areas by key stakeholders in Lebanon and by external independent experts. GOAL's research is framed by the use of Transition Theory and gender is addressed as a cross-cutting issue informing all aspects of the project research. It follow a co-production approach, working closely with key stakeholders - particularly mental health service users. Quantitative and qualitative methods will be used and interdisciplinarity fostered. We also work with mental health service users to produce innovative materials (e.g. animations and augmented reality digital images) communicating the benefits of participation from people with lived experience of mental disorders in research and policy-making processes, and for advocacy and teaching. GOAL has capacity strengthening activities to provide technical training to project partners and key stakeholders, and to support institutional capacity and individual career progression.
The main immediate beneficiary will be the National Mental Health Programme at the Ministry of Public Health in Lebanon. Other beneficiaries will include key stakeholders including mental health service users, NGOs, and UN agencies, both in Lebanon and other countries responding to protracted displacement situations. The proposal responds to SDG 3 (good health and well-being) and DFID's strategic objectives of strengthening resilience and response to crises, and tackling extreme poverty and helping the world's most vulnerable.

Planned Impact

Poor mental health causes long-term suffering and disability and it is often more common among protracted refugee populations than non-crisis affected populations. Effective, feasible and scalable mental health services exist, but there are major gaps in access to appropriate mental health care globally, especially among forcibly displaced populations. The challenge is how to best deliver such services equitably and effectively, including the design of systems required to support this delivery. This is particularly challenging in protracted displacement settings which can place substantial additional pressure on already strained health systems as they face increasing demand for services without an increase in resources. The GOAL project seeks strengthen health system responses for the mental health needs of Syrian refugees and host population in Lebanon, focusing particularly on governance and financing as these are two key areas requiring support in Lebanon. Importantly, GOAL works closely with the government of Lebanon and key partners including mental health service users, civil society organisations, and UN agencies. The research findings and capacity strengthening activities will help strengthen mental health care provision in Lebanon to refugee and host populations, thereby improving their health, functioning and well-being. The findings and approaches used in the study will also be shared with other key stakeholders involved in mental health care in other protracted displacement settings which will support their work in improving mental health outcomes globally. The following stakeholders would be expected to be positively impacted by GOAL:
1. Individuals and communities affected by protracted displacement would benefit through improved mental health services and care which would lead to improved health and related development outcomes (e.g. economic benefits among crisis-affected individuals through improved productivity and earnings and reduced health care expenditure).
2. Government partners in Lebanon would benefit through the findings being used to support improved governance and financing arrangements for mental health in Lebanon; and the capacity strengthening activities in GOAL.
3. Universities would be positively impacted through the development of new networks and the sharing of new ideas, approaches, methods and skills; and the capacity strengthening activities included in GOAL.
4. Civil society organisations and individuals would benefit from the new networks, knowledge, and strengthened capacity.
5. Humanitarian and development funding and policy-making agencies (e.g. donor agencies and UN agencies) would benefit from the findings and guidance generated by the study.

Poor mental health is a barrier to realising full potential of individuals and society, and impedes progress in achieving the SDGs. We believe the proposal responds to SDG 3 (good health and well-being) and DFID's strategic objectives of strengthening resilience and response to crises, and tackling extreme poverty and helping the world's most vulnerable. It support's DFID's approaches of: developing and using partnerships to promote greater accountability; supporting partnerships to encourage advocacy for change; strengthening the ability of existing and new advocacy actors to enable decision makers to be held to account; improving access, supply and quality of basic services; and strengthening the response to conflict and local-level crisis to improve resilience in fragile and conflict-affected states.
The separate 'Pathways to Impact' document describes the plan to achieving this impact. This will be supported by the Theory of Change process that will guide the project in achieving impact.
 
Description We present the key findings from the research on research co-production in humanitarian settings (published as a best practice guide reports), the systematic review on participation by conflict-affected communities in humanitarian healthcare responses (published in the journal Migration and Health) and the systematic review on health system governance in conflict-affected settings (published in the journal Health Policy and Planning).

The key findings from the research on co-production in humanitarian settings (published as a best practice guide report and the paper in the journal 'Disasters') were as follows. It highlights the problems with "research as usual" partnerships in humanitarian settings, specifically: the burden on communities as merely sources of data, certain forms of knowledge being valued over others, lack of reflection on the power hierarchies structuring research partnerships, top-down decision-making and lack of transparency, one-way "capacity-building", lack of mutual benefit, and rigid research processes and timeframes. The paper also identifies seven key principles of co-production that can be helpful in attempting to equalise power dynamics within research partnerships, specifically in conflict-affected and humanitarian settings and these are: tackling unequal power dynamics, challenging knowledge production hierarchies, ensuring more equitable partnerships and shared decision-making, emphasising reciprocity, promoting mutual capacity strengthening, ensuring greater reflexivity, and enabling flexible ways of interacting and working.

The key findings from the systematic review on participation by conflict-affected communities in humanitarian healthcare responses (Migration and Health journal) were as follows. Participation mostly involved in implementing interventions rather than framing problems or designing solutions. Most studies on community participation focused on changes in health services (access, utilisation, quality), community acceptability and awareness, and ownership and sustainability. Key barriers and facilitators to community participation included political will at national and local level, ongoing armed conflict, financial and economic factors, socio-cultural dynamics of communities, design of humanitarian responses, health system factors, and health knowledge and beliefs. The eligible studies were of mixed quality and the overall strength of evidence was weak. More generally there was limited critical engagement with concepts of participation.

The key findings from the systematic review on health system governance in conflict-affected (Health Policy and Planning journal) were as follows. the most frequently identifiable governance principles related to participation and coordination, followed by equity and inclusiveness and intelligence and information. The least frequently identifiable governance principles related to rule of law, ethics and responsiveness. Across studies, the most common facilitators of governance were collaboration between stakeholders, bottom-up and community-based governance structures, inclusive policies, and longer-term vision. The most common barriers related to poor coordination, mistrust, lack of a harmonised health response, lack of clarity on stakeholder responsibilities, financial support, and donor influence. Few studies provided a theoretical framework or definition for governance. In summary, the review highlights the need for more theoretically informed empirical research on health system governance in settings with conflict-affected populations that draws on existing frameworks for governance.

We have also published a paper on collaborative data coding as part of our work on research co-production in GOAL (published in the journal of International Journal of Qualitative Methods). This paper explored the value and benefit of collaborative data coding used in the GOAL project, reflecting on how coding together enabled greater inclusion, teamwork, improved analysis as well as improved future data collection. It also discussed the technical and logistical challenges faced in coding within a team and using internet-based software, including the complications involved in navigating power dynamics between researchers and coming to final decisions about codes. The paper contributes a reflexive analysis on the power dynamics and decision-making complexities involved in collaborative coding. It emphasizes the importance of investing in interpersonal relationships over time and prioritizing less-centralized decision-making within research collaborations

We also have at least six papers currently being drafted based on the analysis of work on health system governance in Lebanon. These are expected to be submitted in the second and third quarters of 2023.
Exploitation Route The findings from the co-production work have been disseminated through public seminars, conferences and training activities and have been used by researchers in their projects to strengthen co-production and more equitable ways of conducting research projects. The findings from the systematic reviews provide the first systematic investigation into the current evidence and so provide a strong empirical basis from improving both practice of community participation and health system governance with conflict-affected populations as well as supporting improved research on these topics.
Sectors Healthcare

URL https://www.lshtm.ac.uk/research/centres-projects-groups/goal
 
Description Introduction: We received a no-cost extension for GOAL to December 2023. Despite all the ongoing challenges in Lebanon due to the political and financial crisis, we are on track for the key research and capacity strengthening deliverables to be achieved by the end of the project. We list below the key contributions in the research and capacity strengthening activities from GOAL in this last reporting year. Knowledge generation: For the Governance Work Package, the data collection been completed for all the case studies, with the exception of the one on collaborative governance models (ongoing). The data analysis and write-up of publications is ongoing. This work has also led to a publication reflecting on the process of collaborative data coding. A number of conference presentations have also been made staff members on the governance research. For the finance work package, the qualitative data collection is complete and the analysis and write-up ongoing. The quantitative survey with mental health service users is ongoing, as is the collection of facility-based data on costs of delivering mental health services. The capacity strengthening activities have continued, and include the completion of research capacity strengthening needs assessment with University of St. Josephs Beirut and finalisation of plans to enact a phase 2 of this. We have also continued to run individual training courses - focusing particularly on qualitative data analysis and write-up.
Sector Education,Healthcare
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Co-production Workshop
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Co-production Workshop led by GOAL staff, 14th January 2021. 25+ participants Participants mainly from Lebanon, with some from UK.
 
Description Focused training on data coding of qualitative data analysis
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Improved skills in qualitative data coding
 
Description Focused training on qualitative research interviewing skills
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Improved capacity to collect qualitative research data
 
Description Gender Workshop
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Gender Workshop for GOAL staff on 22nd January 2021. 25+ participants (majority from Lebanon, others from UK)
 
Description Lecture on mental health, armed conflict and health systems
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Lecture by Professor Bayard Roberts (PI of GOAL) to students in the MSc for Public Health at the University of St. Joseph's Beirut. The topic was mental health, armed conflict and health systems. There were approximately 25 students attending and all are public heath or medical practitioners.
 
Description Mental health policies and laws in Lebanon, 11th March 2021
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Mental health policies and laws in Lebanon, 11th March 2021, 1.5 hours, 12 participants from Lebanon and the United Kingdom
 
Description Qualitative research methods training programme
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Qualitative research methods training programme. This was a series of qualitative research workshops with GOAL research staff from Lebanon that were facilitated by LSHTM staff. The workshops were as follows: Introduction to Qualitative Methods, 23rd February 2021, 2 hours, 9 participants. Research ethics, confidentiality, consent and data management, 23rd February 2021, 3 hours, 9 participants. Safety, safeguarding, child protection and referrals, 24th February 2021, 3 hours, 9 participants. Participant observation (part 1 - basics), 2nd March 2021, 3 hours, 6 participants Translation and transcription, 3rd March 2021, 7 participants. Participant observation (part 2 - fieldnotes and coding after homework), 5th March 2021, 3 hours, 6 participants
 
Description Training on introduction to health financing for GOAL staff from NMHP, ABAAD, War Child and LSHTM
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Improved knowledge and capacity on health financing.
 
Description Training on writing up qualitative data for GOAL's War Child staff
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description ABAAD 
Organisation ABAAD Resource Center for Gender Equality
Country Lebanon 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution As a key project partner, ABAAD are supporting the implementation of the GOAL research and capacity strengthening activities
Collaborator Contribution As a key project partner, ABAAD are supporting the implementation of the GOAL research and capacity strengthening activities
Impact None yet
Start Year 2020
 
Description National Mental Health Programme at Ministry of Public Health in Lebanon 
Organisation Ministry of Public Health
Country Lebanon 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We are collaborating with staff from the National Mental Health Programme as key partners in the project. This included in the project design, proposal, implementation, outputs, dissemination and pathways to impact.
Collaborator Contribution Contributions by the National Mental Health Programme have included inputting on the overall project design, proposal, specific research protocols, their implementation, outputs (e.g. papers and blogs to date), and capacity strengthening activities.
Impact Please see outputs listed as part of the GOAL project
Start Year 2020
 
Description University of Saint Josephs, Beirut 
Organisation Saint Joseph University
Country Lebanon 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution One of the main partner in the project. USJ were involved in the study design, proposal development, protocol development, research outputs, and capacity strengthening plans.
Collaborator Contribution One of the main partner in the project. USJ were involved in the study design, proposal development, protocol development, research outputs, and capacity strengthening plans.
Impact None yet
Start Year 2020
 
Description War Child 
Organisation War Child
Country Netherlands 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Key partner involved in the project (including design, implementation, outputs and capacity strengthening activities)
Collaborator Contribution Key partner involved in the project (including design, implementation, outputs and capacity strengthening activities)
Impact Not yet
Start Year 2020
 
Description BLOG: COVID-19 and mental health among displaced Syrians in Lebanon 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A blog on COVID-19 and mental health among displaced Syrians in Lebanon. Further details can be found at https://www.lshtm.ac.uk/research/centres-projects-groups/goal#news-and-blogs
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.lshtm.ac.uk/research/centres-projects-groups/goal#news-and-blogs
 
Description Co-production Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Co-production Workshop led by GOAL staff, 14th January 2021.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Conference Presentation by Thurayya Zreik: 'Co-production in Global Mental Health Research: Reflections from the GOAL project in Lebanon' at CARFMS22 Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Presentation at CARFMS22 Conference: Crisis and Forced Migration: Manifestations of power in a changing world (Canadian Association for Refugee and Forced Migration Studies), November 2022.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Conference Presentation: Barriers in participation in decision-making processes related to mental health services in Lebanon' at CARFMS22 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Conference Presentation at the CARFMS22 Conference: Crisis and Forced Migration: Manifestations of power in a changing world (Canadian Association for Refugee and Forced Migration Studies), November 2022.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Conference presentation by Rozane Al Masri: 'Responding to MHPSS needs - the case of the MHPSS Taskforce in Lebanon' at CARFMS22 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Presentation for the Canadian Association for Refugee and Forced Migration Studies, November 2022.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022