South-South collaboration in realising the impacts of Peer-to-Peer Deaf Multiliteracies research in India, Uganda, and Nepal

Lead Research Organisation: University of Central Lancashire
Department Name: Sch of Humanities, Lang and Global Stud

Abstract

This project arises from research on "Peer to Peer Deaf Multiliteracies" - the idea that deaf sign language users can learn language, literacy and allied skills by working with deaf tutors in real-life relevant and self-generated ways. This previous research has shown that new ecosystems of learning can be developed and adapted to be used with different groups of deaf children and deaf youth in countries of the Global South.

With this project, we go a step further towards introducing key elements from Peer to Peer Deaf Multiliteracies research into concrete educational contexts, working with partners in India, Uganda, and Nepal. Crucial elements in pursuing this work are capacity building with young deaf professionals, multi-stakeholder engagement with key players in the relevant educational sub-systems, and effective South-South collaboration. To this effect, our work will create a range of materials (curricula, teachers' handbook materials, teaching/learning materials, and best practice examples) underpinning newly arising roles for deaf professionals for use in each partner country.

This work takes place in the context of increasing calls for people with disabilities to take an active role in all matters that concern them, e.g. in the "Charter for Change" that resulted from the 2018 Global Disability Summit in the UK. This project therefore moves from a "deaf-led research" agenda further towards enabling "deaf-led practice" in deaf education. We do this by following a common impact pathway for the three partner countries, at the end of which training options, human resources, and bilingual teaching/learning materials are developed to a point where a further roll-out of innovative ecosystems of learning for deaf sign language users becomes possible.

Planned Impact

In terms of immediate benefits, 14 deaf trainees from India, Uganda, and Nepal participating in the capacity building programme constitute the first group of beneficiaries from this research. They will build their capacities as master trainers and implementers of multiliteracies provisions, increasing their employability in this context. A second group of beneficiaries are members of the national agencies that need to conduct work allied to this project, but have expertise and manpower shortages to do so, namely the National Curriculum Development Centre in Uganda and the National Institute of Open Schooling in India. They will be enabled to pursue their objectives, particularly with respect to work on sign languages. Similarly, the schools for the deaf in India who are participating in the project will benefit from trained human resources, as they also face shortages of skilled personnel. This then impacts several hundred deaf children and youth who are taught in these schools and constitute the secondary group of beneficiaries, along with some of the teachers who will be exposed to new teaching approaches. Ca. 150 of these secondary beneficiaries can insights into improved teaching and learning methods via working our 10 Indian trainees on field placements.

This study has capacity-building, instrumental, conceptual, and connectivity impacts. These impacts are achieved by taking key educational actors from three partner countries, namely India, Uganda, and Nepal, through a common impact pathway. The capacity building impact is that deaf sign language users will be trained in the implementation of multiliteracies work with deaf children and adults, so that they can become conduits for the uptake of multiliteracies research in contexts of deaf education. The 14 participants will become master trainers in the deaf language and literacy area through this programme.

The instrumental impacts are in the form of three curricula that, if formally accredited, serve to institutionalise deaf sign language users' role in deaf education. If accreditation is not achieved during this project's lifetime, the curricula will be used in informal contexts. Secondly, multiliteracies work will be supported in the deaf education context with three sets of bilingual teaching and learning resource materials, in English and the sign language of the target country.

In terms of conceptual impact, our activities serve to reduce prejudice against and marginalisation of deaf people in educational systems, and to raise awareness among practitioners and policymakers about the capacity of deaf sign language users for contributing crucial skills to multiliteracies provisions for deaf children and adults. Finally, this project is an example of South-South collaboration between minorities who are educationally disadvantaged, and therefore has a unique connectivity and networking impact, where international deaf actors support and learn from each other.
 
Description This project is an impact enhancement project, so it does not generate data-based research results. Instead, this is a research and development project with practical aims. Its main objectives are around capacity building, and the development of curriculum and teaching/learning resources.
We have organised an international six-month capacity building programme, which has been co-created between hearing academics, deaf project staff, and other deaf participants. We are finding that not only is it possible to train people with quite different backgrounds within the same group, but this is also another context where peer-to-peer learning is very powerful. That is, those deaf trainees who are further along in their learning journey and have been project staff in the research are taking on peer mentoring and partial teaching roles with respect to the newcomers.
The development of curricula and teaching/learning materials for India, Uganda and Nepal is the second major objective. For India, the curriculum for a diploma in "Language and Literacy through Indian Sign Language" has eight modules, and bilingual materials in English and Indian Sign Language have been developed for all modules. In Uganda, the curriculum is a diploma in special education for language and literacy proficiency with deaf learners. It also has eight modules, but is structured differently; most teaching and learning materials have been developed. We also developed some materials for Nepal. In each case, materials are in the respective sign language of the country, with supporting documents in English for India and Uganda.
Several innovations connected to this project have been published in two volumes that cover both the underlying research project and this impact project. Impact-related chapters include topics around collaborative curriculum development, capacity building with deaf professionals, and gamified learning for language and literacy. In particular, we invented the "English Grammar Games" as a way to improve peer-to-peer learning of English grammar in deaf communities through sign language and gamification.
Exploitation Route We have created curricula and teaching/learning resources that can be used for training deaf sign language users as professionals in deaf education. Therefore, the outcomes can be taken forward by institutions of Higher Education that are responsible for teacher training. More widely, the teaching and learning materials can also be used to work with deaf people on language and literacy in informal contexts, for example in adult training centres run by NGOs.
Sectors Education

URL https://islandscentre.wordpress.com/2021/12/22/read-write-easy-two-new-academic-volumes-showcase-our-work-on-deaf-multiliteracies/
 
Description Curricula and teaching/learning materials have been developed through this project, and these are being used in several contexts. We supported the National Institute of Open Schooling to implement Indian Sign Language as a secondary school subject (10th standard) nationally. Three research team members served on the NIOS curriculum committee for this course, and our team created the theory materials, consisting of 17 lessons in sign language as well as a textbook in English for the course. The course initiative was launched by the Prime Minister of India in 2021, and the first 80 students enrolled in the autumn of 2022. This is the first time that Indian Sign Language has become available nationally as a school subject at par with spoken Indian languages. From 2022 onwards, three project members again joined the NIOS curriculum committee to develop an Indian Sign Language course at the next-higher level, that is senior secondary level (12th standard). Deaf professionals are an essential resource for this development, and one of the deaf Research Assistants was recruited to work at the NIOS in 2022. In Uganda, one of the project's deaf Research Assistants was recruited by a private university to teach inclusive deaf education in a teacher training programme. This is a direct result of the six-month training that we provided for research assistants and other participants in 2019/20. The skills gained through this training enables the RA to meet employment standards in spite of having a BA as the highest formal academic qualification instead of the usual postgraduate qualification. Findings and resources from our project are now passed on to these teachers in training. Our Indian partner school continues using the teaching and learning innovations created under this project with their 40 deaf children. In particular, use of the English Grammar Games is being expanded at the school, and cross-subject learning grounded in multiliteracies is being deployed. Through using these research-led approaches, the school has been gaining a national profile. It gained the "Best school for the deaf" award after selection by a jury panel at the biennial Deaf Leaders Foundation event in January 2023, where 2500 participants were present. Two of the school's children were awarded first and second prize at junior level in the national Indian Sign Language story competition in 2022, with the prize awarded to them in New Delhi by the Minister of Social Justice and Empowerment.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Developed learning materials to facilitate the launch of Indian Sign Language as a school subject
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Membership of a guideline committee
Impact The project team created learning materials (see https://www.youtube.com/playlist?app=desktop&list=PLUuOqp8QaNB0Gwfl1H9q-UvLUVhNvd9Z6) and collaborated with the National Institute of Open Schooling in India so that Indian Sign Language could be launched as a school subject across the nation for the first time. In July 2021, Prime Minister Narendra Modi marked the one-year anniversary of the National Education Policy 2020 by announcing: 'For the first time, Indian Sign Language has been given the status of a language subject [at secondary level]'.
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=YblvWBu2G1c&feature=youtu.be
 
Description Development of curriculum and multimedia teaching and learning materials for a diploma in "Language and Literacy through Indian Sign Language"
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description Development of curriculum and multimedia teaching and learning materials for a special education diploma on Language and Literacy Proficiency for the Deaf
Geographic Reach Africa 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description Membership in committe on Indian Sign Language as a school subject
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
 
Description Produced teaching materials for Indian Sign Language as a school subject, in collaboration with National Institute of Open Schooling in India; continued serving as a member of its curriculum development committee (including participating in a meeting in December 2020)
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Membership of a guideline committee
 
Description Collaboration with National Institute of Open Schooling, India 
Organisation National Institute of Open Schooling
Country India 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We used our findings and skills developed from the research in order to support the initiative at the National Institute of Open Schooling for offering Indian Sign Language as a school subject at 9th-10th standard in their nation-wide programme. We developed lessons in multimedia format to match the curriculum. The project PI from the UK, the Indian consultant to the project, and a project Research Assistant are members of the curriculum development committee for the new course, which admitted its first 80 students in the autumn of 2022. From 2022 onwards, the PI and two project members have again joined an NIOS curriculum committee, this time for the Indian Sign Language course at senior secondary level (12th class).
Collaborator Contribution The NIOS owns advanced video production and dissemination facilities including studios, satellite TV, and online dissemination channels. Their technical resource base benefits dissemination of the practical application of our research. NIOS has employed two deaf staff members to work on Indian Sign Language development.
Impact Curriculum developed for Indian Sign Language as a school subject for 9th/10th standard. We developed 17 theory lessons in a bilingual format, as Indian Sign Language videos and an accompanying textbook. The first 80 students enrolled on the course in the autumn of 2022.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration with Ndejje University, Uganda, on a diploma course for deaf language and literacy teachers 
Organisation Ndejje University
Country Uganda 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Makerere University was engaged with Ndejje University on a diploma course at university level in Uganda to train deaf teachers so that they can acquire a professional status. This would mitigate the challenges of lack of trained and qualified language and literacy teachers as identified in different baseline surveys and research studies during the project.
Collaborator Contribution Makerere University was engaged with Ndejje University on a diploma course at university level in Uganda to train deaf teachers so that they can acquire a professional status. This would mitigate the challenges of lack of trained and qualified language and literacy teachers as identified in different baseline surveys and research studies during the project.
Impact Makerere University was engaged with Ndejje University on a diploma course at university level in Uganda to train deaf teachers so that they can acquire a professional status. This would mitigate the challenges of lack of trained and qualified language and literacy teachers as identified in different baseline surveys and research studies during the project. Implementation of such a course is pending.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Online workshop about language and literacy trainers' course - 22-23 January 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The project team organized an online workshop on Zoom for two days with 15 deaf participants, including deaf teachers, deaf organisations, and deaf school stakeholders and alumni. This workshop was focussed on the curriculum for progressing the accreditation for deaf language and literacy trainers, how to implement the course, and use of the Moodle platform to access visual materials. The participants offered suggestions and ideas for improving the curriculum and online platform. They said that they want to discuss the feedback and online platform further after the platform is updated.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.facebook.com/P2Pdeaf/videos/1080103719083173
 
Description Paper presented at the 2021 Humanities Conference at Makerere University, Uganda, in August 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Co-I Mugeere presented a paper entitled 'Challenges in the education system for deaf learners: lessons from the Peer to Peer Deaf Multiliteracies (P2PDL2) project' at the 2021 Humanities Conference which was held at Makerere University in Uganda from 11 to 13 August 2021 with the theme 'Humanities and Humanistic Social Sciences Scholarship for a New Era'.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://events.mak.ac.ug/events/2021/08/11/231
 
Description Presentation at the National Convention of Educators of the Deaf, New Delhi, India 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Project member Nirav Pal presented on "Cross-subject learning with deaf primary school children". Project lead Prof Ulrike Zeshan and Nirav Pal also held a workshop entitled "From linguistic enrichment to metalinguistic skills in deaf learners". The audience engaged in discussion during the workshop, and became familiar with new concepts arising from the research. Participants requested information material after the workshop session.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Second meeting to discuss the feasibility of starting a diploma course for the Deaf at Ndejje University, Uganda, 6 November 2020 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was the second meeting held to discuss the Ugandan launch of a diploma course for deaf Language and Literacy Trainers, which is already being implemented in India. The participants discussed the practicalities of offering this course, including admissions, pre-requisites and bridging, teaching staff, funding, and international students.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Third project advisory committee meeting on plans for the deaf "Language and Literacy Trainers" course to be launched in Uganda, held on 11 December 2020 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was the third meeting about launching a diploma course for deaf Language and Literacy Trainers at the university level. The objective of the meeting was to discuss issues surrounding the implementation of the curriculum and the prospect of offering the course through Ndejje university.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Two workshops in India on English Grammar Games - June and July 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Two online English Grammar Games (EGG) workshops for schoolteachers and NGOs were held in India in June and July 2021, organised by teams at the Happy Hands School for the Deaf, the Shikha Eco-Learning Village, and UCLan. Most of the participants were deaf teachers who are interested in teaching English. The teachers and NGO representatives learned about EGG from the project staff and then contributed to the subsequent discussions and feedback sessions. EGG are used as an alternative method for students to learn English grammar in a fun way.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.instagram.com/tv/CQapnVLDRMQ/?utm_medium=copy_link