Bringing sociological theories of care and care practices into understandings of, and intervention approaches for, women's alcohol use.

Lead Research Organisation: Durham University
Department Name: Sociology

Abstract

Patterns of heavy alcohol use that have the potential to cause health harms and social problems (such as difficulties in families and at work) have increased in British women aged over 25 years and affect women in the most socially deprived groups the most (Public Health England, 2016; NHS Digital, 2018). In Britain, some of the main approaches to supporting women to reduce heavy alcohol use are focused on individuals taking responsibility for changing their drinking themselves. For example, through guidance about how much alcohol women should drink to lower their risk of alcohol related harm. These approaches draw on the idea that telling people about health harms will change their behaviour and give little consideration to the positive roles that alcohol may play in some women's lives.
Research that focuses on what women tell us about their experiences of alcohol use can provide insights into what alcohol means to women in their everyday lives. Sociological ideas help us understand how the circumstances of women's lives such as their roles in families, or financial circumstances can alter; how they drink, and the appropriateness of different types of support to reduce their drinking. There is a distinct gap in research that places British women's drinking in the context of real lives and lived experiences, and practical approaches to reducing women's drinking which draw on these insights.
This fellowship will extend the findings from my PhD in which I carried out interviews with women with a range of different circumstances and drew on a number of sociological ideas (including feminist theories of care, and social practice theory) to develop our understanding of women's everyday alcohol use in relation to stress. I found that women's relationships and identities in relationships (e.g. as a good mother) are central to their drinking practices. There were gaps in receiving care in women's everyday lives and alcohol was one way in which women created spaces of care - or performed care practices in different relationships. For example, alcohol could be seen as a way of being caring/spending time together in couple relationships and drinking with friends could be used as an opportunity for women to gain support and talk about their problems. I also found that the opportunities women had to drink in practices of care was altered by their personal circumstances. Most of the time, the role alcohol plays in providing openings for care was more important to the women than the health harms of heavy drinking. The findings from this work suggest that ways of supporting women to reduce their drinking through recognising that alcohol is part of care practices could be more relevant to women than the main approaches which are currently used.
There are five objectives for the fellowship which seek to incorporate sociological ideas from my research into academic research and into the work of those who develop, fund and deliver support to reduce women's drinking. I also intend to engage with women themselves, policy makers and practitioners to develop ideas for future research on this topic. I retain a commitment to feminist approaches. I will:
1) pursue a programme of activity which is focused on sharing findings and considering the implications of the findings for future methods of support, with users who are women themselves and practitioners and policy makers who develop policy and work with women to reduce heavy drinking;
2) use the theoretical and conceptual work developed in the PhD research to publish three academic publications in high ranking journals;
3) present the findings from this work at one academic and one academic/ substance use conference;
4) plan and deliver teaching on the role of sociological theory in public health interventions;
5) build on 1-4 to develop future research projects collaboratively with women themselves.
 
Description This one-year fellowship project was undertaken during the COVID pandemic and I was able to meet some of the project objectives. This included: 'Building academic impact and research experience through academic publication'. I published three papers during the award, one of these contributed to the existing literature about ethics in practice for early career researchers, and to scholarship which critiques the wider health research context by considering the challenges it can pose for early career researchers when managing relational ethical spaces in qualitative interview studies. I also met the objective of 'Taking my research expertise and knowledge to future health practitioners through teaching'. I taught students, from a range of academic backgrounds, on the Masters in Research Methods at Durham University and received feedback from them that applying real life examples from my research roles to methodological and theoretical discussions was valued in the seminar teaching. At the end of the award, I was successful in gaining a research role on an NIHR funded project, on the topic of alcohol and depression which is closely related to the focus on this one-year fellowship.
Exploitation Route Through the work done during the fellowship, I have indicated the value of applying theories of ethics of care to different health contexts, as well as the difficulties of asking health practitioners to engage with critical theoretical ideas when they are extremely busy during an unprecedented national crisis. The methodological work resulting from one of the publications is useful for early career researchers working in a health care context.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare

 
Description My findings have been used indirectly to inform my input and feedback to the North East and North Cumbria Alcohol Needs Assessment led by the Alcohol strand of the North East and North Cumbria Integrated Care System. I have advised that it is important to think of people as interdependent and relational, and therefore to consider supported signposting and referral rather than self-referral. Also, the importance of considering how difficult it can be to ask for help around alcohol in families because of the social stigma associated with drinking for women, in particular.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Loneliness and Mental Health Network perinatal mental health researchers 
Organisation St George's University of London
Department Population Health Research Institute
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution We have recently submitted two small grant applications where as co-applicant I would provide expertise on sociological and feminist approaches to care.
Collaborator Contribution The collaborators have led on writing the research bids and forming the research teams.
Impact Lived experience, health services research, psychotherapy
Start Year 2019
 
Description Sociologists in Public Health 
Organisation University of Sheffield
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I have attended and contributed to a workshop (first meeting held at the University of Sheffield - 6th April 22) with public health practitioners and sociologists, which is focused on improving sociology's impact on local public health.
Collaborator Contribution Intellectual Input
Impact We are about to submit a a multi-authored editorial to communicate the learning from our event. The focus is how can sociologists better support public health and work together.
Start Year 2022