The CARE Project: Building Sexual Violence Survivors' Capacity to Evidence and Research (C)rimes and (A)dvocate for Effective (Re)sponses

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: School of Psychology

Abstract

Sexual violence is an enduring human rights violation, and its effects are major obstacles to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG), particularly SDG5, which concerns gender equality and the empowerment of women. Survivors struggle to access post rape care services and prosecutions are extremely rare, particularly in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs). The lack of data, and weak statistical and technical capacity, pose major obstacles to sustainable development in LMICs. The proposed secondary data analysis will inform policy makers about barriers to service access and case attrition. The dataset provides urgently needed information about the experiences of adult and child survivors in Nairobi who attempted to access post rape care services from 2016 to present day. The results will enable rape survivors in Kenya to use the insights from the research to advocate for policy change while providing generalisable insights for other LMICs. Our vision is to show, via this project, how secondary data analysis can be creatively used to help Kenya and other countries address the global issue of sexual violence. Our ESRC GCRF IAA grant has prepared us to undertake this research and it culminated in a series of co-developed research objectives and questions. Our objectives are to conduct the secondary data analysis to deliver high-quality impactful data research on the nature of sexual violence, post rape care service gaps, and case attrition patterns, and to study sexual violence health and well-being impacts. Our research questions focus on understanding the nature of sexual violence, the barriers survivors face in accessing post rape care services (medical, police, legal), and the reasons why so few cases are prosecuted. We will also build the capacity of the WKF to update their results as new data are collected. The findings of the secondary data analysis will be discussed with policy makers and other stakeholders. Further, the secondary data analysis project will develop a capacity building research agenda that improves the ability of the Survivors' Network to research and document sexual violence cases. The project will engage and partner with rape survivors' networks in other LMICs to share results and demonstrate the value of secondary data analysis in delivering important insights to effectively prevent and respond to sexual violence, helping to achieve SDG5.

Planned Impact

Our secondary data analysis project addresses urgent knowledge gaps about post rape care services and case attrition, and maximises the value and use of data held by the Wangu Kanja Foundation (WKF). The project builds the capacity of the Rape Survivors' Network in Kenya (founded by the WKF) to use the new understandings and insights from the secondary data analysis to achieve policy and practice impact. The project will provide generalisable insights that can be used to address sexual violence in other LMICs. Short-term impacts will develop from engaging survivor beneficiaries and stakeholders in project activities, while medium term effects will occur through reaching out to a wider range of stakeholders, such as rape survivors' networks in other LMICs (e.g., the Phephisa Survivors Movement in South Africa).

The timing of the application around the recent launch of MobApp, an innovative tool that has been developed for documenting sexual violence cases across Kenya, is important for survivors, and other stakeholders within and beyond Kenya.

The project impacts Sustainable Development Goal 5: Achieve Gender Equality and empower all women and girls. This innovative data research will deliver a co-produced, substantive, and critical mass of knowledge regarding the accessibility of post rape case services and case attrition in Kenya.

We will build on the partnerships developed and the workshops delivered through our recent ESRC GCRF IAA funding by opening our events to survivors, policymakers, politicians and practitioners, eliciting their feedback and help in disseminating the findings to achieve the greatest potential impact. Events include stakeholder workshops and a residential end of project conference.

We will also establish a project website and a social media presence to disseminate news about the project and project outputs. We will also engage with survivors' networks in other LMICs to share the insights we have learned through the secondary data analysis. Toward this end, we will leverage our existing connections (e.g., the Preventing Sexual Violence Initiative team), and rape survivors' networks in other countries.

Through the knowledge gained via the secondary data analysis and stakeholder engagement, the project has strong potential to provide generalisable insights for other LMICs to effectively respond to and prevent sexual violence around the world, and tackle SDG5.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We found in our secondary data analysis that 1) emergency measures during Covid-19 exacerbated the vulnerability of children and women to sexual and gender based violence; 2) the socio-economic impact of Covid-19 increased tensions within households, with reports of physical violence and increased homelessness for women; 3) vulnerability to violence was amplified across the population as a whole according to reports by human rights actors, with there being numerous incidents of death and injuries caused by the police while enforcing the COVID-19 emergency measures put into place.

The project website is here: https://www.careresearchproject.com

Work package 1: This package quantitatively analysed data held by the WKF (N=1,162 cases, 150 of which were collected using MobApp), and shared the preliminary findings with policymakers and stakeholders at a workshop in Nairobi, which was held remotely via Zoom because of the pandemic.
Survival analyses and logistic regression models were used to study the characteristics of cases involving adults and children both before and after the pandemic. The results are currently under review at a journal. The findings illustrate when cases are particularly vulnerable to attrition along the case referral pathway (i.e., survivor should be referred from medical services to the police and then to the judiciary) as a function of key case characteristics (i.e., offense, victim, perpetrator, and evidentiary factors).

Work package 2: This package produced an academic working paper, a brief project report and a policy brief presenting WP1 findings and implications. The working paper, brief project report, and policy brief have been produced and are available open access. They have been viewed over 3600 times and downloaded over 1100 times. https://zenodo.org/record/3964124#.YQu- Dy1Q2NI and https://zenodo.org/record/3964162#.YQu-BS1Q2NI

Work package 3: We used statistical package R to create a bespoke data analysis software and an attendant user manual to enable WKF staff to periodically and automatically update the results as new data are collected.

Work package 4: This package disseminated findings and obtains stakeholder feedback throughout the project. Since travel to Kenya was not possible, the UK project team joined discussions via Zoom, which enabled us to finalise and disseminate the working paper, brief project report, and policy brief in view of stakeholder feedback. Research concept notes were also developed, and a grant application was submitted to the Sexual Violence Research Initiative, and , but UKRI submissions have not been made owing to the end of the GCRF programme.
Exploitation Route The outcomes highlight the needs and benefits of implementing real time data collection systems to monitor crime hotspots and to help the police, policymakers, and communities understand the nature and consequences of sexual and gender based violence. The outcomes also call on governments to revise and enact policies that are survivor-centred and ensure that vital services are accessible and better serve the needs of survivors in the aftermath of SGBV. The outcomes of the research also highlight the need for innovative investigation tools that are cost-effective, such as crime linkage and perpetrator behavioural analysis, to link serial offences.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Government, Democracy and Justice

URL https://www.careresearchproject.com
 
Description As a result of this project, we developed a capacity building programme that trains members of the Wangu Kanja Foundation and the Survivors Network to use evidence-based interviewing techniques to document cases using best practices. Whilst the question format on MobApp adheres to best practice guidelines, members of the Network ask interviewees the questions and input answers onto MobApp. Numerous studies have found that it is difficult for interviewers, even trained professionals such as the police, to complete these interviews effectively without special training. We co-created a training programme with the Wangu Kanja Foundation, and have piloted and evaluated it, training members of the Network, police forces, and first responders in 7 counties in Kenya. The training is delivered by the Wangu Kanja Foundation. We have conducted two evaluation studies of to assess skills pre versus post training. The methodology included paper and pencil assessments, and as well as assessing members of the Network conducting mock interviews pre and post training. We are currently writing up these results. Our preliminary analysis of the data shows that the programme attendees gained knowledge and improved their practice, though we would like to see that the gains are even larger. Therefore, we recently received funding from the ESRC IAA to revise and validate the training manual and attendant resources, as well as to develop 3 short training videos modelling best practices in 1) rapport building, 2) asking open questions, and 3) documenting a survivor's independent voice, a written toolkit in English and Swahili (which will be particularly useful for circumstances in which Internet and mobile devices are not available). These training resources will be evidence-based. The training resources will be housed on our project website (https://www.careresearchproject.com), with the aim of completing the work by summer 2023. Through this educational programme we hope to: 1) increase the skills of the Network, and human rights defenders in documenting cases as assessed through pre-and post-training mock-interviews; 2) increase the strength of the evidence base that can be used to investigate and prosecute cases measured through an analysis of MobApp data collected pre-and post-training; 3) minimise secondary victimisation of interviewers documenting cases as well as re-traumatisation of the survivor established via interviews, questionnaires and focus groups; 4) continue to strengthen the working relationship between the Wangu Kanja Foundation and University of Birmingham and 5) build the capacity of our PGR (Laura Stevens) who will aid in the formation and evaluation of the educational resources. We have also disseminated our work to the Murad Code developers, as well as with survivors networks from around the globe via the PSVI Conference November 2023, wherein we were invited to deliver a panel on survivor-centred research.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Government, Democracy and Justice
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description ESRC Impact Acceleration Account Covid-19 Urgency grant
Amount £5,000 (GBP)
Organisation Economic and Social Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2020 
End 01/2021
 
Description Time for Rights/Rights for Time: Responding to the times of violence, conflict, and displacement
Amount £1,867,627 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/T008091/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2020 
End 03/2024
 
Description Visualising Justice on Sexual Violence in Kenya: Stimulating inclusion, Peace and Public Engagement through the Creative Economy
Amount £130,862 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/W006510/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2021 
End 10/2022
 
Description USIU, Nairobi, Kenya 
Organisation United States International University
Country Kenya 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Statistical analysis, report writing, and publication dissemintation.
Collaborator Contribution Contribution to the research design and dissemination plan, authoring of papers.
Impact In progress: An academic paper is in preparation.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Wangu Kanja Foundation, Kenya 
Organisation Wangu Kanja Foundation
Country Kenya 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Thsi project was conducted in collaboration with partners in Kenya, including the Wangu Kanja Foundation.
Collaborator Contribution This Kenyan partner contributed to the design of the study, data analysis, and dissemination, which has included written outputs and workshops.
Impact *1 policy brief (see publications section of form) *1 research report (see publication section of form) *3 research articles (see publication section of form) *2 webinars
Start Year 2019
 
Description Effective Case Documentation Training, Kenya 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This event delivered a bespoke co-deleloped training programme to the Survivors of Sexual Violence in Kenya Network
•This activity occurred in-country and was delivered in person in Nairobi, Kisumu, Vihiga and Bungoma and Mount Elgon counties
• The Wangu Kanja Foundation, the Survivors of Sexual Violence Network in Kenya, and ADSOCK, all of which are Kenyan organisations co-developed and delivered the training
• Identify networking activities and workshops. Ensure the following information is provided:
o 78 survivors, 46 duty bearers (healthcare workers and police) attended these training sessions, and 3 people delivered the training sessions. All of these individuals were Kenyan.
from the DAC list country/countries)

To date our evidence is that the training programme is improving participants' knowledge of interviewing skills and we have found that the training significantly increases their understanding of interviewing best practice e.g. ground rules, rapport and independent voice. This will increase attendees their case documentation and employability skills, and increase the GBV evidence base, leading to more resources to combate GBV in Kenya.

The FCDO and the IICI have asked for further information and results, increasing the potential for wider dissemination beyond Kenya.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021