The RTrT Partnership: Reducing Traffic-related TraumA - A community-based prevention and first-response programme intervention for Malawi and beyond.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Stirling
Department Name: Health Sciences

Abstract

Injuries resulting from road traffic collisions are a major and growing cause of preventable death in sub-Saharan Africa. Road traffic collisions in low and middle income African countries account for approximately 169,000 deaths and about 6 million healthy years of life lost due to disabilities people are left with. Road traffic collisions also impact on people's ability to work and on community wellbeing. As working aged men are three times more likely than women to be involved in a road traffic collision low and middle income countries lose up to 3% of their earning potential. As a result improving outcomes from road traffic collisions will contribute to the delivery of four of the United National Sustainable Development Goals: no poverty; health and well-being; sustaining cities and communities and partnership working.

Malawi has one of the highest rates of road traffic related death, lowest rates of vehicle ownership, and lowest income levels per person in the world. Consequently the Malawian Government have identified road traffic related trauma as a major barrier to improving the health and finances of the nation. However it faces considerable challenges in making improvements. Malawi has no formal prehospital care system, no universal emergency telephone number, and almost no ambulance service. Care of injured people is haphazard and often provided by passers-by who have very little or no training in basic first aid. As a result people who have survivable injuries often die. This has led to doctors from the largest Malawian hospitals recently publishing a Call to Action that highlighted the need to improve trauma care. All of trauma care would benefit from further research and development. However the Call to Action says that research to improve pre-hospital trauma care should be a specific priority. So pre-hospital trauma care is the Partnership's specific focus. This proposal was developed following a 9 day study visit to Malawi by Dr's Duncan and Uny in September 2017, at the invitation of Dr's Chokotho and Mulwafu. During this visit local challenges of road traffic related trauma were discussed with a wide range of different organisations, academics and community members. There was a broad consensus that the first step should be the development of community based programme intervention that is made up of different, but linked, interventions to prevent and respond to collisions. Tackling prevention and response together is likely to lead to bigger improvements in communities than dealing with either separately.

Our Road Traffic Related Trauma (RTrT) Partnership brings together experts in applied health science, public health, global health, arts and humanities, pre-hospital and emergency healthcare delivery, community engagement, and local community members. We will use a variety of methods from the different disciplines we represent. These are likely to include creative ways of gathering, sharing and discussing different people's views and ideas on the challenge of road collision, including the use of visual methods and theatre to engage and communicate within the research team, wider stakeholders and the public. Working in Malawi and at a distance between meetings we will develop an intervention to improve community prevention and first-response within local communities highly affected by road traffic collisions. Towards the end of the project we will will look at ways our work can be transferred to other sub-Saharan countries. We will then apply for funding to implement and test our interventions.

We will share our work locally, nationally and internationally. We will ensure that our findings are shared with with academics, Government policy makers, organisations involved in road traffic and trauma care, and local community members. Where appropriate these outputs will be developed with local residents and translated into key local languages.

Planned Impact

In the long-term our interdisciplinary Partnership will deliver innovative inter-sectoral solutions to the problem of road traffic related trauma (RTrT) in Malawi and across sub-Saharan Africa. These solutions are likely to lead to:- 1) improved health outcomes, as people who are involved in RTrT will be more likely to receive timely lifesaving interventions; 2) safer communities, through a reduction in the frequency of road traffic collisions; 3) improved economic productivity, by reducing the number of people unable to work due to trauma resulting from a road traffic collision which usually affect the economically productive age group; and 4) less resources used in the hospitals due to reduction in the burden of RTrT. Within the period of this project there will be academic, civil, policy, and public impacts.

Academically our Partnership will result in an increased focus on generating solutions to the problem of RTrT in Malawi and across sub-Saharan Africa. This will be achieved through a series of Labs and working groups that will take an interdisciplinary and inter-sectoral approach to developing a community-based programme intervention to prevent and respond to RTrT. The increased focus on RTrT in Malawi will lead to members of the Partnership considering potential future projects to improve other aspects of the Malawian trauma care pathway, and the applicability of our interventions across other sub-Saharan African countries. Our academic outputs will raise the profile and importance of addressing RTrT in Malawi and across sub-Saharan Africa.

Malawian civil society will directly benefit from the our exchange of knowledge, as several key services (e.g. Malawian Road Traffic Police, Malawian Red Cross, Malawi Fire Service, Malawian Road Traffic Authority) will be brought together to participate in Partnership activities. The study visit of co-applicants ED & IU to Malawi in September 2017, combined with the existing relationships that co-applicants LC & WM have with these key civil society services ensures their engagement and active participation in our Partnership. During the Partnership these organisations will learn about the challenges of preventing or responding to RTrT from the differing perspectives of each other's organisations and learn about arts and applied healthcare approaches to improving outcomes. It is anticipated that this innovate inter-sectoral approach to RTrT will result in the identification of quick wins that do not require further evaluation and can be implemented without delay.

The Partnership will impact on policy through the development of briefings that will be co-produced and shared with the Malawian Ministry of Health, The World Bank, The World Health Organisation and others. These briefings will provide clear summaries of the findings and recommendations of the Partnership in order to inform these key decision making bodies about the importance, challenges and potential solutions to the problem of RTrT, to stimulate discussion, and to encourage further action to be taken.

There will be a series of impacts on members of the Malawian public. These include:- increased awareness of the challenges; potential solutions; quick wins that each person can do to prevent collisions; guidance on how best to respond if they do happen; and key prevention and response messages to share with their family and friends. These impacts will be achieved through members of the public becoming involved in the activities of the Partnership as well as through attending a two day creative and interactive exhibition to communicate the work of the Partnership. We are aware that attendance at the exhibition will only be feasible for individuals living the Southern region of Malawi. We will therefore communicate the same messages through local and national media.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Safe Roads Africa Exhibition 
Description The artistic products are created by young people as a visaul medium to communicate the problem of poor road infrastrcuture in their surrounding school environments. These large scale portable murals were displayed at a public exhibition in Blantyre, Malawi and at a Semina in the same city that was attended by a range of national stakeholders. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact The exhibition and seminar led to a committed partnership between a multi-national corporation and a Mr Gerald Lipikwe, a local councillor. Together they committed to undertaking road safety infrastruture improvements surrounding two schools in Lambe, Blantyre. Within three months Councillor Lipikwe and Total Malawi had collaborated on several road infrastructure improvements around Limbe schools. Visual evidence of the murals, the exhibition and the imapct can be seen in our project blog on our Safe roads Africa Website - see url below. 
URL https://saferoadsafrica.com/chitetezo-preventing-young-people-dying-and-being-injured-through-road-t...
 
Description Chitetezo: Improving adolescent road safety and reducing traffic collisions
Amount £742,961 (GBP)
Funding ID MR/T026367/1 
Organisation Medical Research Council (MRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2021 
End 02/2024
 
Description Partnership development award to scale up the Safe Roads Africa community resilience intervention from Malawi to Zambia
Amount £2,300 (GBP)
Organisation University of Stirling 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2019 
End 08/2019
 
Description Using education for sustainable development to raise health awareness and prevent road traffic related trauma in Malawi. CHITETEZO Feasibility study
Amount £4,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Stirling 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2019 
End 09/2019
 
Description Safe Roads Africa Partnership 
Organisation First Aid Africa
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Our well established Safe Roads Africa (SRA) partnership (https://saferoadsafrica.com/), works to develop sustainable and scalable solutions to road traffic related trauma in sub-Saharan Africa. Safe Roads Africa began as a partnership between our interdisciplinary research team, the Malawian Road Traffic Authority (RTA), Road Traffic Police (RTP), the Malawian Fire Service, Traditional Leaders, The Minibus Drivers Association of Malawi, The Malawi Red Cross, and with over 100 members of two local communities in Southern Malawi (Bangwe West and Domasi). It later extended its reach to partner organisations in Zambia. Recognising the applicability of SRA to other sub-Saharan nations, I conducted a week long scoping visit to Lusaka, Chibombo and Kabwe in Zambia in March 2019, where I met with a similar range of stakeholders and local communities. A key collaboration developed during that visit was with First Aid Africa, an established provider of internationally recognised emergency first aid training to local communities, with established bases in Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania and beyond. First Aid Africa joined the SRA partnership for our final Lab in Malawi.
Collaborator Contribution Over the last two years the SRA partners have developed an in-depth understanding of the contextual challenges of delivering a first-aid response to road traffic collisions. A week-long capacity building event involving During September 2018 we held a week long capacity building event involving Scottish and Malawian members of the research team was held in 2018. This was followed by in Scotland. We then held three highky participatory and interdisciplinary week-long events (known as Labs), in December 2018 and and February and October 2019, in Southern Malawi (Blantyre region) with UK and Malawian partners. Each Lab lasted a week. During these Labs we collected large amounts of qualitative data from members of local communities, held participatory design workshops with our SRA partners and held research team meetings to develop our shared understanding of the problem and potential solutions.
Impact First Aid Africa ( a project partners) delivered in kind internationally accredited first aid training to 42 members of the local commuities (Bnagwe and Domasi) with whom we have an ongoing partnership. A project grant application to the MRC Applied Global Health Research Fund is under development. The collaboration is highly interdisciplinary and includes: applied health scientists, qualitative researchers, paramedic, emergency physician, Public and Population Health, Global Health, Health design, Trauma consultants (Scotland and Malawi), communication and behavioural change (Malawian context)
Start Year 2019
 
Description Safe Roads Africa partnership 
Organisation University of Malawi
Country Malawi 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution As a result of the RTrT award an interdisciplinary partnership entitles Safe Roads Africa was set up, led by Dr Edward Duncan and with academic and practice partners in the UK and Malawi.
Collaborator Contribution Partners engage in implementation activities with agencies in Malawi and grant funding applications to funders such as the MRC and NIHR
Impact Impact activities to improve road traffic safety in Blantyre, Malawi in which funding was gained form TOTAL Malawi to support improvements to the road infrastructure, following a study engagement event. Grant applications to the MRC (£746000, successful) and NIHR (c.£1.9million, submitted) for further work to manage and respond to road traffic related trauma.
Start Year 2018
 
Title Chitetetzo is a multifaceted, arts-mediated, rights-based advocacy intervention designed to decrease the frequency of road traffic collisions. It is founded on evidence from three previously unconnected areas: rights-based youth work, road safety education, and intergenerational approaches to co-producing local development. There are good theoretical grounds for taking an intergenerational approach to learning and education in the co-production of community-based solutions. Our research seeks 
Description Chitetetzo is a multifaceted, arts-mediated, rights-based advocacy intervention designed to decrease the frequency of road traffic collisions. It is founded on evidence from three previously unconnected areas: rights-based youth work, road safety education, and intergenerational approaches to co-producing local development. There are good theoretical grounds for taking an intergenerational approach to learning and education in the co-production of community-based solutions. Our research seeks to draw on young people's own expertise to co-produce solutions to road safety. Further Funding has been sought through an application to teh GCRF Adolescant Health Programme (£713000). We were short listed and received very positive reviewers comments. Currently awaiting funding decision. 
Type Preventative Intervention - Behavioural risk modification
Current Stage Of Development Early clinical assessment
Year Development Stage Completed 2019
Development Status Actively seeking support
Impact As a result of our Feasibility study, the local Balntyre City Council and TOTAL Malawi entered a partnership to improve the ropad safety infrastructure surrounding two schools in Limbe, Blantyre. This resulted in improved road markings and repaired street lighting. The work evidenced that the causal mechanism of the intervention was feasible (that young people advocating for change could lead to direct road infrastructure improvements). This work also received national publicity thorgh a newspaper article that covered the work. https://twitter.com/easduncan/status/1187441139437228033?s=20 https://twitter.com/easduncan/status/1190321451104161794?s=20 https://twitter.com/easduncan/status/1193120146438664193?s=20 
 
Title Communty Response Intervention 
Description This intervention development project is exploring, co-developing and undertaking initial acceptability testing of a community first responder intervention that will train and equip community champions to attend road traffic collisions and provide lifesaving first aid to individuals that require it. These same individuals will also undertake prevention sessions, using a variety of arts-based approaches, to local community organisations (e.g. churches, schools, community groups etc), to increase pedestrian behaviour. We have undertaken a wide range of qualitative data collection, using both traditional and innovative design methodologies with community members in Bangwe and Domasi. We have also collected data from and co-constructed the intervention with a range of national stakeholders, including the Road Traffic Police, The Fire Brigade, Hospital staff, The Road Traffic Authority, community leaders and others. A grant application to test the implemetnation of the intervention is curerntly under development and will be submitted to the MRC Applied Global Health Research Board. 
Type Health and Social Care Services
Current Stage Of Development Refinement. Non-clinical
Year Development Stage Completed 2019
Development Status Actively seeking support
Impact As a consequence on engaging with First Aid Africa (one of our partners), at the end of the development process they agreed to invest in providing internationally accredited entry level training in first aid to 42 members of communities who had supported our co development. Some evidence of this training is available here: https://twitter.com/easduncan/status/1205041369108090880?s=20 https://twitter.com/easduncan/status/1189670732357349376?s=20 
 
Description Participation in launch of Scottish Malawi Partnership Academic Collaborators directory in wihich RTrT project (also known as Safe Roads Africa) is featured 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact The event enabled researchers and others to come togther ot hear about the resaerhc that is being undertaken from Scotland relating to Malawi. One direct outcome of teh meeting was theat the Scottish Malawi PArternship invited me to attend their Cross Party working group in the Scottish Parliament, at a date to be fixed, to present our work on the Safe Roadds Africa Partnerhip.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.scotland-malawipartnership.org/news-events/past-events/higher-and-further-education-foru...
 
Description Presentation of Safe Roads Africa work to Director of Scottish Government Chef Scientist Office 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact A seminar of research activity was held that was attended by Dr Euan Dick, Director of the Chief Scientist Office. Dr Dick was previously unaware of this Global Health Activity and reported he would take this knowledge back to Government.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Presentation to the Scottish Graduate School of Social Science 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Approximately 60 post graduate students attended an online seminar on participatory research methods. I presented on the use of participatory intervention development in global health contexts. There were several questions afterwards and considerable discussion on the use of participatory methods in global health, and some of the environmental challenges of undertaking global health research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Project Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact We developed a study website http://saferoadsafrica.com that provides an overview of our activites and proejcts that have devloped from the Safe Roads Africa Partnership. We also micro-blogged about all our activities on Twitter linking each post together using the hashtag #saferoadsafrica

Our wok has reached an internatioanl audience and as a consequence we have been appraoched by other groups who are intersted in collaborating with us in further related research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL http://saferoadsafrica.com
 
Description World Bank Meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Invited to attend a meeting organised by the World Bank in Lilongwe, Malawi to discuss our road traffic related trauma research in sub-Saharan Africa and its synergy with World Bank activities in Malawi. The meeting widened knoweledge about our research, enhanced existing collaborations, and developed new networks.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018