Exploring the feasibility of school based interventions to reduce sugar sweetened beverage consumption in India

Lead Research Organisation: Public Health Foundation of India
Department Name: Research

Abstract

The increased consumption of Sugar and Sweetened Beverages (SSBs) is one of the most important reasons for obesity and overweight, dental caries and Type II diabetes. The consumption of SSBs is rapidly increasing among children and adolescents especially in developing countries. This is an important public health issue as majority of the population in developing countries is very young. Governmental bodies around the world are taking increasing action to address the availability of soft drinks in schools through increased taxation on soft drinks or banning their sale in schools. However, the evidence around effects of restricting availability or increasing taxes on SSBs on their consumption and health is still unclear and emerging, it is likely that these actions are being driven by the belief that high-calorie, nutrient-poor drinks no longer have a place in schools, and, moreover, that schools are an appropriate starting point to reduce total consumption of SSBs among youth. In the absence of robust evidence, an intervention cannot be delivered to test the effectiveness of various fiscal policies in reducing SSB consumption among youth. This study will test the acceptability and feasibility of a fiscal intervention delivered through schools to reduce SSB consumption among children and adolescents.

Technical Summary

Sugar-sweetened beverage (SSB) consumption is established as a major risk factor for overweight and obesity, as well as an array of cardio-metabolic conditions, especially type 2 diabetes and dental caries. SSB consumption is particularly popular in school going children. In the past few decades, sources of energy intake among youth have shifted toward greater consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs), such as soda, sports drinks, and high calorie fruit drinks. This shift has important public health implications given that SSB consumption has been associated with youth obesity and weight gain, which have several physical and psychosocial consequences. This becomes a very serious problem especially for Low and middle Income Countries (LMICs) which are demographically very young. In certain countries including India national taxation policies have been introduced to promote healthy diet such as a tax on sugary soft drinks but these policies have focussed primarily on soda while not taxing other SSBs. As an alternative to a national tax policy, there is the option of implementing pricing policy at a more local level through a settings approach. Some schools have also taken voluntary action restricting the sales of soda but have left out other SSBs and have shown a mixed bag of results providing no clear evidence on the best set of interventions which can lead to reduction in SSB consumption among youth. The development, implementation and evaluation of a fiscal and policy intervention to reduce SSB consumption amongst school going children is a complex and challenging task. Before a full scale randomised controlled trial can be undertaken detailed preliminary research is needed. This study therefore proposes to undertake a two-phased investigation to inform and test the acceptability and feasibility of a SSB fiscal and policy intervention delivered in the setting of recognised non-aided public schools of New Delhi.

Planned Impact

Sugar-sweetened beverage (SSB) consumption is established as a major risk factor for overweight and obesity, as well as an array of cardio-metabolic conditions, especially type 2 diabetes and dental caries. SSB consumption is particularly rising in school going children. The variation of policies on soft drink availability and taxation presents an opportunity to examine the effects of various policy options, especially with regard to the effects of different levels of restrictions in schools. Such research could help identify policies that are most likely to succeed, information that is currently lacking for obesity and other NCD prevention in general. No study from India and very few from other LMICs have studied the effect of increased taxation or banning of sales of SSBs in schools on consumption among children and adolescents. This study is innovative as we would adopt a mixed methods approach to guide our intervention. The qualitative approach will help us to undertake an in-depth analysis on who is affected, what factors are involved, do individuals react or respond differently. Immediate academic beneficiaries will be the named Indian researchers who are likely to exploit this to set up their own independent research teams, and become more involved in designing and implementing complex intervention to answer some of the very difficult questions. The Indian researchers will get an opportunity to work in a multi-disciplinary team which will aid in building their research acumen by learning from the experience of UK based experts. The global public health community will also be benefited as the study will help pave the way to stimulate similar research work in other countries of the world and contribute to the global evidence. The proposed project may lead in the longer term to the development of new upstream interventions to reduce the burden of obesity and other chronic diseases, enhancing quality of life worldwide. We believe that the time scales for the benefits to be realised are not too distant. In the academic context, impact will be within the time frame of the grant proposal. All our research staff are in place, allowing us to progress at a fast pace. The research and professional skills that the staff on this project will develop are very broad. Other than being involved in high profile and cross-discipline research through an India-UK consortium, staff will also be trained in project management and communicating their science in the broadest sense, providing them with transferable skills beyond pure academic research. The research outputs will be communicated to the academic community through traditional scientific communication routes including high-profile peer-reviewed publications and international scientific conferences. All applicants will also actively engage in efforts to promote the public understanding of the science underlying the proposed project. We see the potential direct and indirect impacts of this study as considerable, particularly in terms of its relevance to current and future policy initiatives in India and other low and middle income countries. It will be a key role for each of the investigators to focus on ensuring this impact occurs. It will be an on-going agenda item for all group meetings. The press office will be regularly updated, and items for dissemination will be strategically considered to maximise impacts. The research team on this grant have considerable experience of maximising the impact of their research. We have very strong linkages with the federal government and many international organizations. We will use this platform to stimulate wider interest on this topic and the importance of undertaking policy relevant research. Context specific communication materials for the websites, newsletters, brochures, and events will be produced with the goal of promulgating the research findings and their impact towards a healthier, sustainable and an equitable future.
 
Title Drink No Sugar Video Film 
Description Videos are an important tool for communication. It appeals to both sight and sound, it captures the attention of the viewer immediately and makes a lasting impression. The messaging is concise and easy to understand. We have developed an infographic video with a drink no sugar theme. The theme of the video is in sync with the other communication materials developed in this study.. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact We are in the process of assessing the impact of this infographic video and will notify about it's impact in April 2017. 
 
Title Mythbuster E Cards 
Description Leaflets and E- Cards are simple and easy to read, it has an advantage to pass information through simple and large fonts with few words appealing to the viewers. Leaflets and E- Cards will be communicated through social media via: 1. Snap Chat 2. Facebook 3. Instagram 4. E- mails 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2016 
Impact We are in the process of field testing these innovative communication aids and will upload our findings by April 2017. 
 
Title Posters for Schools 
Description Posters provide a logical and cost-effective way of communicating to a particular target market. Posters have the ability to stick to the viewers minds and can be used to increase brand awareness. Themes for the poster :- 1. Healthy Drinks/ Knowledge on what are SSBs (not just Colas) 2. Sugar Content of SSBs and its Health Effects 3. Water as an alternative for SSBs Tagline or Headline :- A headline/ Tagline provides a first impression to the audience. They attract the attention of the reader to the related material. Some of the suggested Taglines are : • Heavier the thirst lighter the drink • Be smart to choose the right drink • Play your part be sugar smart • Don't Be a Sugar Bin 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact We are in the process of field testing the imp[act of the posters and will notify our results by April 2017 
 
Description We were able to successfully complete the qualitative component of the study (Phase I) where we assessed a) experience of food and drink purchases in school canteens, b) views on diet related health problems, c) views and attitudes of different local policy options to improve diet, d) views of different options in pricing policy on sugary drinks e) acceptability of introducing a comprehensive intervention in a school setting, f) barriers and facilitators to implementing a sugar control policy in a school setting. For the Phase II of the study we assessed a) Development of innovative, context specific Behaviour Change Communication (BCC) tools to accompany the intervention in the study schools b) Interventions tailored for use in school settings to reduce SSB consumption c) Through process evaluation the acceptability of the intervention to both children, their parents and school authorities d) Determination of the feasibility of the intervention in terms of recruitment and retention of study sample and the engagement with school authorities.
Exploitation Route To make future interventions easier and more effective, we need to find non SSBs options which are easily available, affordable by school children and should appeal to their taste. We need to create awareness among canteen owners, school authorities, parents and children regarding harmful effects of SSBs for better implementation. Creating awareness among parents will also help in limiting their SSBs consumption outside the school. Using BCC material which is informative as well as appealing to the children is crucial. Better marketing, packaging of the non SSBs and promotions of these drinks by influential public figures. Will make them more attractive to children.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare

URL https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/sugary-drinks-a-common-factor-for-oral-diseases-finds-lancet-study/story-V1nlNOOyUHs16NzgkfAH2M.html#:~:text=A%20250ml%20of%20sweetened%20beverage,co%2Dauthor%20of%20the%20study
 
Description Advisory Committee on Health Promotion and Non Communicable Diseases
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Description DST INSPIRE Fellowships
Amount ₹140,000 (INR)
Organisation Ministry of Science and Technology India 
Sector Public
Country India
Start 09/2015 
End 09/2017
 
Title SSB Audit Tool for Schools 
Description This is a tool devised by the research team of the project to capture the unit sales of SSBs in school canteens. The tool takes into account seasonal fluctuations as well as measure the qualitative aspects of SSB selling in schools. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This tool is an important value addition in order to develop a robust fiscal intervention for reducing the consumption of Sugar Sweetened Beverages in schools. 
 
Title Socio-Environmental Model for Understanding Sugar and Sweetened Beverage Consumption Amongst Adolescents 
Description The consumption of SSB among children and adolescents is a complex behavioural trait influenced by many inter-related psychosocial and socio-environmental factors. We have developed an innovative, mixed methods socio-environmental model approach to guide our intervention. The qualitative approach will help us to undertake an in-depth analysis on who is affected, what factors are involved, do individuals react or respond differently. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact By using this approach, the intervention will give more recognition to individuals in the process, not just the observable effect of intervention upon children and adolescents. 
 
Title Baseline Assessment of SSB Consumption of Adolescents 
Description This is a database of about 744 adolescents from the four intervention schools (12-16 years of age) on whom we are testing the intervention. The database contains information on the volume of SSBs consumed by adolescents both in and out of school, the things which accompany SSB consumption and the factors affecting SSB consumption. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact We are undertaking an impact assessment and the results will be available by JUly 2017. 
 
Description PHFI-Imperial College MoU 
Organisation Imperial College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution - Collaboratively advocate for the public health implications of sugar consumption - Jointly working on academic publications - Identification of field sites in India to carry out research activities
Collaborator Contribution - Providing technical expertise to carry out research activities - Development of subsequent grant proposals - Capacity building of research team in India
Impact - Capacity building of research team in India in research methods and transferring evidence into effective policy arguments. - Formation of a core team analyzing data from the current study and working on two peer reviewed publications - Probability of a possible studentship for attending a short course on advanced analytic methods at Imperial College LOndon
Start Year 2015
 
Title A Fiscal Intervention to reduce SSB consumption among school going adolescents. 
Description An exploratory trial provides vital information on the feasibility, practicality and acceptability of key components of the trial design including engagement with study participants, sample recruitment and retention, measurement of outcomes and delivery of intervention. It also provides evidence on the effect of the intervention, which can then be used to inform sample size calculations for a future definitive large-scale trial. Informed by the findings from the initial exploratory study and the existing scientific literature, a feasibility trial will be designed and conducted in four schools different from those recruited in Phase I. The four schools would be randomly divided into intervention and control arms. Baseline and 6 month follow-up outcome measures will be collected. A process evaluation will also be undertaken to assess the acceptability of the intervention. A decision to proceed to the full scale study will be based on: recruitment of at least 85% of the planned sample within the allotted time; completion of primary outcome follow-up interviews with no less than 75% of participants; and receipt of intervention by at least 60% of those randomized to the intervention arm. Nature of intervention and controls We will assess the impact of two possible interventions to reduce SSB consumption among children. The first Intervention would be a complete ban of SSBs in one of the study schools and the second Intervention would be a subsidy on a non SSB drinks (Chaach) in one of the study schools to see the effect on SSB consumption. Chaach is a non-SSB beverage whose cost would be subsidised by 20%. Chaach is a low-calorie, low-carbohydrate, low-fat and low-protein content milk drink which is used as a thirst quencher in India and is readily available across the country. The following definition of SSB will be used: beverages containing added sugar, sweetened dairy products (e.g. chocolate milk), fruit juice (e.g. apple juice), soft drinks (e.g. cola) and energy drinks (e.g. sport energy drinks). To support and reinforce the intervention, appropriate information, education and communication leaflets will be prepared and circulated in the intervention schools detailing the harms of excessive SSB consumption and benefits of not consuming SSBs. Periodic health talks will also be organized in the intervention schools. The control group schools will continue selling SSBs as usual. No intervention will be provided in the control schools. 
Type Preventative Intervention - Behavioural risk modification
Current Stage Of Development Initial development
Year Development Stage Completed 2017
Development Status Under active development/distribution
Impact The intervention is still in it's nascent stages and we will have some initial impacts of the intervention by July 2017. 
 
Description Media Brief 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Manu Raj Mathur contributed to a cover story of how sugary drinks boosts morbidity and affects health status in India. The story got published in National Daily Newspapers and reached readers across the country as well as internationally. This has generated wider interest in the subject and have invited
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/health-fitness/health-news/How-one-sugary-drink-daily-...
 
Description Media Release 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Manu Mathur contributed to a story on the effects of sugary diseases on health and society. The story was published in a widely read international blog and generated further interst in this topic attracting requests for more media stories on this issue.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.indiaspend.com/cover-story/how-1-sugary-drink-daily-boosts-indias-death-rate-47373
 
Description School Sensitization Meetings 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact A sensitization workshop was organized at one of the schools in Delhi for teachers, parents and school childrens from 5 schools to sensitize them on the ill effects of SSB consumption and to understand the perceived barriers to reduce SSB consumption among adolescents.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Sensitization Workshop for Adolescents 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact We conducted a sensitization workshop in January 2017 by organizing a talk of a leading pediatrician of Delhi in one of the study schools. The talk was followed by an interaction with parents and adolescents and a short activity.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017