Droned Life: Data, Narrative, and the Aesthetics of Worldmaking

Lead Research Organisation: UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE
Department Name: Arts and Humanities

Abstract

Critics have noted the 'worldmaking' power of drones (Stubblefield 2020), but the political implications of that philosophical term for this emerging technology, and for the way figures from the creative economy are responding to and shaping its development, have yet to be scrutinized in depth. 'Droned Life' sits at the cross-section of interdisciplinary scholarship, with a team situated across English, Politics, Computer Science, and Digital Media. It investigates how drones and their physical and digital infrastructures produce new ways of interpreting and experiencing the world, and how imaginaries and aesthetics facilitate the widespread and increasing use of intrusive technologies.

It is driven by an overarching research question--what are the aesthetics of drones?--with aesthetics defined as art, embodiment (aisthesis), and as what makes politics perceptible and normalized (Rancière 2004). How do aesthetics inform the politics of prosthesis in relation to drones--seen, for instance, in the 'targeted killings' in the War on Terror, or in the security breaches made by domestic drones at Heathrow airport? In light of the increasingly common use of drones in law enforcement and surveillance, how do the aesthetic dimensions of drones serve to facilitate more nefarious purposes, such as the objectification of human bodies into things to photograph, track, and target in the name of safety and convenience; or the transformation of human lives into data to monitor and aggregate for anticipating trends and collective behaviour? How have drone aesthetics helped to dissolve military and civilian boundaries to help establish the 'world' as we currently know it--where data, algorithm, and artificial intelligence have become endemic to private and public security, and increasingly, to everyday life?

To answer this research question, this FLF programme draws from theories of worldmaking (Goodman 1978, Nunning 2015) to examine what new perceptual, legal, and geopolitical worlds drones create. On the one hand, drones make new worlds because they mediatize and create uniquely embodied, virtual experiences. An unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) can be operated thousands of miles away from the drone pilot, creating new aerial views and functioning as a prosthesis for perceptual experience through the digital screen. On the other hand, drones make worlds because they establish, even while reinforcing, their own political justifications. Military drones, for instance, employ the real-time circulation of diagrammatic signs to establish a possible, rather than pre-identified, target; this logic of pre-emption has profound consequences for international law. High-street drones, meanwhile, occupy a liminal space between aircraft and plaything, and they continue to disrupt straightforward boundaries in relation to privacy, security, and civil liberties.

Because drones involve manipulations in narrative, perspective, visual framing, and the reading of multimedia, and because they create intersections between human and machinic agency, there is a complicity between the drone object and the cultural and interpretive practices undergirding it. This FLF will examine the worldmaking dimensions of drones through: 1. the empirical study of four areas of the aesthetic arts--literature, film, visual arts, and game design concerned with drones, and 2. through a series of co-designed knowledge exchange activities with non-academic partners to examine how drones have become a part of our world. It focuses on three collaborators and their respective methodologies: data activism (with the NGO Drone Wars UK), virtual and immersive technologies (with the graphics firm Human Studio), and museum curation (with the Imperial War Museum). With drones, sensors, AI, and simulation all combining to produce new modes of worldmaking over the past decade, it is important to reflect on what worlds are being created, and to stage interventions around them.
 
Description In the first year of this award, in my research and public engagement and knowledge exchange events, I have explored how and why drone use in four different sectors and industries--war, humanitarianism, art, and the study of the environment--have different narratives about what constitutes ethical uses of this technology. My research is also finding that drones and AI are increasingly linked, and a normative approach to drone ethics, as drone technology proliferates, is also a way for us to think about AI ethics.

My research team and I will be substantiating this with two public perception studies--one related to drones specifically, the other related to evolving understandings of the future of warfare--to examine how dual-use technologies become integrated into broader cultural life and the decisions people make in that integration. These findings will be of interest to those working in policy, to companies and purveyors of drone technology, to academics, and to the general public. The objective is to cultivate drone literacy and to help pave ethical drone futures.
Exploitation Route Outcomes of this funding may be used to support regulatory recommendations on how drones are deployed in service of war, art, humanitarianism, and environmentalism, and what constitutes ethical and appropriate use.
Sectors Creative Economy

Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software)

Education

Environment

Government

Democracy and Justice

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

Security and Diplomacy

 
Description In the first year of my fellowship, part of my research into drone use on war and conflict was parlayed into non-academic areas through public engagement and non-academic partners. After the Hybrid Warfare symposium, 100% of those who responded to the survey question, "Did the event help with your understanding of 21st century war and conflict?" replied yes.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Electronics,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Societal

 
Description House of Lords Select Committee on AI in Weapons Systems
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
Impact Part of the report "Proceed with Caution: AI in Weapons Systems" which comes with a series of 36 recommendations regarding the improved understanding and regulation of AI in Weapons Systems. Whether these will be implemented admittedly remain to be seen. (Report published in December 2023)
URL https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/646/ai-in-weapon-systems-committee/
 
Description Bridging Responsible AI Divides (BRAID) Grant - Scoping to Embed Responsible AI in Context
Amount £161,530 (GBP)
Funding ID APP17938 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2024 
End 07/2024
 
Description FLF collaborator (Human) 
Organisation Human Studio
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Research and design towards a creative commission involving the use of immersive technologies for the topic of "War and the Mind" (exhibition at IWM)
Collaborator Contribution Storyboarding, design, creation and production of creative commission to be shown at the IWM
Impact The creative commission will be an immersive installation related to the experience of drone warfare which will be launched in September 2024. Multi-disciplinary: Digital Media, Politics and International Relations, Computer Science, English, Museum Studies
Start Year 2023
 
Description FLF collaborator (Imperial War Museum) 
Organisation Imperial War Museum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We are collaborating on a number of initiatives, including an annual public engagement symposium, a creative commission shown as part of the museum's exhibition programming, and an annual YouGov survey on the "Public Understanding of War and Conflict". I am also contributing to programming and research related to the future of war for the IWM Institute.
Collaborator Contribution The partner is providing the venue for the fellowship's annual public engagement events and creative commission, as well as in-kind support from museum staff and experts. They are providing and facilitating the annual survey to be run.
Impact Interdisciplinary collaboration: Politics and International Relations, Arts and Humanities, Museum Studies, History, English, Computer Science, Digital Media Outputs: 1) "From Sniper to Smartphone: Hybrid Warfare and the New Face of Conflict" symposium (November 2023); 2) "Beware Blue Skies" (Title TBC) War and the Mind Creative Commission (Sep 2024 - Apr 2025); 3) "Public Understanding of War and Conflict" IWM Institute YouGov Survey (2024-2025)
Start Year 2023
 
Description Bloomberg Media Interview 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact I was interviewed by Bloomberg News for news piece on drone warfare on the Korean Peninsula. Bloomberg News has over 325,000 Terminal subscribers. The news piece is significant because of escalating tensions in Korea and the normalization of drone use for "spooking" without engaging in full-out conflict.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-06-22/two-koreas-speed-up-drone-race-after-unprecedente...
 
Description Engagement focused media channel for Centre for Drones and Culture 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I've put together a suite of public engagement platforms related to the Centre for Drones and Culture, which I've established as part of the FLF. This includes a website with updates and blogposts (with 1800 visits since the website was set up in March 2023), and social media accounts including Twitter and Instagram.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023,2024
URL http://centrefordronesandculture.com
 
Description Hybrid Warfare public symposium 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I collaborated with the Imperial War Museum on a public symposium, "From Sniper to Smartphone: Hybrid Warfare and the New Face of Conflict" in November 2023. Speakers included 11 academics, journalists, and policy experts related to the concept of hybrid warfare, and what electronic war looks like currently. Over 100 tickets were sold for the event, which offered a significant and public-facing forum for thinking through a difficult concept.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://www.iwm.org.uk/events/from-sniper-to-smartphone
 
Description Magazine article on Centre for Drones and Culture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I wrote an article, "Narratives of Hybrid Warfare", with my research associate which introduces some of the themes of the fellowship and its aims, alongside a recap of the first major public engagement activity (a public symposium at the IWM). This is appearing in the Faculty of English's alumni magazine, 9 West Road, at the University of Cambridge, a publication that goes out electronically to all alumni of the faculty.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024