Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia: uncovering immunity during first-line treatment
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Leeds
Department Name: School of Medicine
Abstract
B cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia (CLL) is the most common haematological cancer in Western countries. In health B cells rearrange immunoglobulin genes to make specific antibodies to fight an infection, and some change into memory B cells that can recall the antibody on re-exposure. This function gives B cells a central role in our learnt 'humoral' immunity. We are exposed to many different infections, so our bodies generate a 'repertoire' of different antibody-producing B cells. When CLL develops, the genes in one of these B cells become mutated and the cell proliferates often producing little or no functional antibody. This results in impaired humoral immunity, alongside cancer symptoms.
Recently new drugs called 'small molecule inhibitors' that fight CLL have lengthened responses compared to traditional 'cytotoxic' chemotherapy. They target molecules in CLL cells that make them proliferate for example BTK and BCL-2 (the targets of ibrutinib and venetoclax respectively). Inhibition of these molecules causes the CLL cells to die, and healthy B cells grow back ('reconstitute'). However, patients on prolonged small molecule inhibitor treatment have fewer B cells than normal and remain susceptible to infection and poor vaccination response. The importance of this has been highlighted by the recent pandemic: patients on ibrutinib and venetoclax have been shown to have lower rates of response to COVID-19 vaccination alongside lower antibody levels.
I aim to uncover how modern CLL treatment affect reconstituted B cells, and therefore how on or post-treatment humoral immunity is impacted by analysing differences in expressed DNA (RNA) in normal individuals and pre-treatment CLL cases, compared to treated cases. I will do this in the context of the FLAIR (Front-Line therapy in CLL: Assessment of Ibrutinib-containing Regimes) trial, the largest UK trial of modern CLL treatment (1576 patients). Ibrutinib regimens are compared to traditional chemotherapy: fludarabine, cyclophosphamide and rituximab; ibrutinib alone; ibrutinib and venetoclax. Although ibrutinib and venetoclax increase treatment efficacy, the pathways they target are active in healthy B cells, resulting in fewer B cells and immunity impairment. This is important because ibrutinib is efficacious and well tolerated as monotherapy or in combinations and venetoclax is now included in front-line and relapse treatment regimens. Therefore, to maintain a healthy remission while on treatment we need to understand how the normal reconstituting B cells are surviving, if the repertoire is affected by treatment, and whether we can optimise their function to enhance humoral immunity including vaccine responses.
I will use targeted single cell RNA sequencing (scRNAseq) to determine the effect of treatment on humoral immunity. I will identify the important RNAs using a bioinformatic method called parsimonious gene correlation network analysis (PGCNA) and apply it to both CLL and B cell RNA databases to build an evidence-based panel. I will perform scRNAseq on age-matched healthy controls and CLL pre-treatment samples and the FLAIR ibrutinib and ibrutinib-venetoclax treatment groups. I have already devised a cell separation strategy to separate and quantify small populations of normal B cells and will then use scRNAseq to perform targeted sequencing. I will then overlay single-cell B cell repertoire sequences and the panel results to demonstrate how repertoire is linked to RNA expression changes, and use bioinformatic analysis to uncover whether B cell reconstitution post treatment shows the same patterns of immune as normal age-matched or pre-treatment cases. I will overlay these results alongside FLAIR trial clinical data, to show whether reconstituting B cells are performing normal humoral immune functions and how these can be enhanced.
Recently new drugs called 'small molecule inhibitors' that fight CLL have lengthened responses compared to traditional 'cytotoxic' chemotherapy. They target molecules in CLL cells that make them proliferate for example BTK and BCL-2 (the targets of ibrutinib and venetoclax respectively). Inhibition of these molecules causes the CLL cells to die, and healthy B cells grow back ('reconstitute'). However, patients on prolonged small molecule inhibitor treatment have fewer B cells than normal and remain susceptible to infection and poor vaccination response. The importance of this has been highlighted by the recent pandemic: patients on ibrutinib and venetoclax have been shown to have lower rates of response to COVID-19 vaccination alongside lower antibody levels.
I aim to uncover how modern CLL treatment affect reconstituted B cells, and therefore how on or post-treatment humoral immunity is impacted by analysing differences in expressed DNA (RNA) in normal individuals and pre-treatment CLL cases, compared to treated cases. I will do this in the context of the FLAIR (Front-Line therapy in CLL: Assessment of Ibrutinib-containing Regimes) trial, the largest UK trial of modern CLL treatment (1576 patients). Ibrutinib regimens are compared to traditional chemotherapy: fludarabine, cyclophosphamide and rituximab; ibrutinib alone; ibrutinib and venetoclax. Although ibrutinib and venetoclax increase treatment efficacy, the pathways they target are active in healthy B cells, resulting in fewer B cells and immunity impairment. This is important because ibrutinib is efficacious and well tolerated as monotherapy or in combinations and venetoclax is now included in front-line and relapse treatment regimens. Therefore, to maintain a healthy remission while on treatment we need to understand how the normal reconstituting B cells are surviving, if the repertoire is affected by treatment, and whether we can optimise their function to enhance humoral immunity including vaccine responses.
I will use targeted single cell RNA sequencing (scRNAseq) to determine the effect of treatment on humoral immunity. I will identify the important RNAs using a bioinformatic method called parsimonious gene correlation network analysis (PGCNA) and apply it to both CLL and B cell RNA databases to build an evidence-based panel. I will perform scRNAseq on age-matched healthy controls and CLL pre-treatment samples and the FLAIR ibrutinib and ibrutinib-venetoclax treatment groups. I have already devised a cell separation strategy to separate and quantify small populations of normal B cells and will then use scRNAseq to perform targeted sequencing. I will then overlay single-cell B cell repertoire sequences and the panel results to demonstrate how repertoire is linked to RNA expression changes, and use bioinformatic analysis to uncover whether B cell reconstitution post treatment shows the same patterns of immune as normal age-matched or pre-treatment cases. I will overlay these results alongside FLAIR trial clinical data, to show whether reconstituting B cells are performing normal humoral immune functions and how these can be enhanced.
Technical Summary
B cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia (CLL) is the most common leukaemia in Western countries. In the UK FLAIR is the largest trial of contemporary first-line therapy for CLL (n=1576); comparing venetoclax and ibrutinib, ibrutinib monotherapy and traditional chemoimmunotherapy (FCR). I aim to evaluate the effects of FLAIR trial treatments on reconstituted B cells to explore the impact of treatment on humoral immunocompetence. To achieve this, I will develop a targeted single-cell RNA sequencing panel (scRNAseq) using parsimonious gene correlation network analysis, a method that selects highest information content gene nodes across multiple networks. I will input bulk RNA and scRNAseq data to develop models of CLL alongside established B cell PGCNA networks, and identify up to 600 genes for the panel. Targeted scRNAseq has an advantage over agnostic scRNAseq because it reduces the risk of gene drop-out, so each relevant gene can be assessed at adequate depth. CD19+, ROR1 negative cells will be selected and run simultaneously with BCR and Abseq on the BD Rhapsody system. Novaseq6000 (20x10^9 reads, illumina) will be used for sequencing the libraries achieving a read-depth of at least 30,000 reads-per-cell, which is adequate to assess all expression features. Abseq will allow comparison of bioinformatically derived clusters with conventional flow-cytometry subsets to enable comparison of results with published data for validation, and each sample will have linked data from minimal residual disease analysis and mature clinical outcomes from the FLAIR trial. I will run normal age-matched and pre-treatment controls, as well as samples from ibrutinib and ibrutinib-venetoclax treatment groups. Samples will be taken 2 years or more into treatment to reflect stabilised B cell reconstitution. scRNAseq data will be analysed using t-SNE or UMAP clustering, compositional analysis including for graphical representation (scDC) and trajectory/pseudotime analysis (slingshot).
Publications
Fisher A
(2023)
The evolving use of measurable residual disease in chronic lymphocytic leukemia clinical trials.
in Frontiers in oncology
| Description | UNCOVERplus CLL |
| Organisation | The Clatterbridge Cancer Centre NHS Foundation Trust |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Public |
| PI Contribution | Work package 1 (CLL) of the UNCOVERplus project. This is a national retrospective study across multiple national clinical datasets for example, Systemic Anti-cancer therapy and HES (hospital episode statistics) Outpatient Care, which reports on general data (demographic, socioeconomic etc), treatment sequencing and secondary malignancies. This provides new baselines for modern CLL patients, their treatment and their outcomes. I am the early career researcher on this team, and am working with a data scientist to provide clinical input into the data, for example which patients have transformed disease as shown by their chemotherapy prescriptions. I will work towards reporting the data in a clinical context and producing abstracts and publications with the team over the next few years. |
| Collaborator Contribution | The data scientist produces the bulk of the data from across the available databases, using a set of objectives defined by the clinicians and agreed upon as important by patient representatives. Data is then interpreted by collaboration of the group, both clinicians and scientists, and reviewed by patient representatives. |
| Impact | Multidisciplinary: clinicians, data scientists, patient group representatives. |
| Start Year | 2024 |
| Description | Filming for Leeds Hospitals Charity |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Supporters |
| Results and Impact | Filming of a short piece for Leeds Hospitals Charity outlining the purpose of an AutoMACS cell sorter purchased with funds donated by the Norman Hunter Golf day. The piece states how this equipment will enable our ongoing research. It includes myself and my post doctoral researcher colleague, who is also working on CLL samples from FLAIR and affiliated trials. The piece also thanks the donors, aiming to engage with them by demonstrating that the donations are of significant research value, to encourage their continued engagement with the Norman Hunter fundraising events. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d09X3FXEV-c&t=3s |
