Reducing Global Catastrophic Risks from Unseen Climate Extremes
Lead Research Organisation:
King's College London
Department Name: Geography
Abstract
Climate extremes can cause devastation. The most severe events have killed millions and, through complex cascades, resulted in profound additional impacts, for example the collapse of East Pakistan following the 0.5 million deaths from the 1970 Bhola Cyclone. As the climate warms to a level not experienced in human history, the potential for unprecedented extremes is also growing, either from familiar hazards like heatwaves reaching unfamiliar intensities, or the arrival of events that are new in character -- for example the first time a powerful tropical cyclone ravages the highly-developed shorelines of the Persian Gulf. Such novel threats are 'unseen': they sit outside all human experience, and their potential impacts are, therefore, highly uncertain. Upward extrapolation of the consequences from the most similar events in history may provide a very conservative estimate of what to expect, as the element of surprise could cause even greater impacts on a society that is unprepared. The potential for novel climate extremes to manifest as Global Catastrophic Risks (GCRs) -- with world-wide impacts, killing at least 10 million people or causing at least $10 trillion of damages -- therefore deserves urgent attention.
The most concerning unseen extreme on the horizon is the emergence of heatwaves so severe that, for the first time in human history, the atmosphere becomes a heat source rather than a sink over large, well-populated regions. Such conditions mean that regardless of fitness, levels of hydration, or access to fans, prolonged exposure (in the order of hours) would be deadly. We do know that these events will occur given sufficient global warming, and that they may become widespread as early as this century; but precisely where is at risk and how soon the threat may emerge is not well understood. The potential societal impacts of such an event are almost completely unknown. For example, is unprecedented mortality inevitable if the atmosphere becomes a heat sink? If so, might it trigger mass migration due to place abandonment? Or could the most at-risk communities become resilient to such extreme heat?
The Fellowship will address these critical research gaps in our understanding of unseen heatwaves. Through an ambitious program of physical science it will provide new insight into how much warming is required for regions to experience heat beyond human tolerance. Focussing on one of the hottest cities in the world (Jacobabad, Pakistan), it will grapple with the complexity of how heat at regional scales manifests within people's homes, finally joining up future climate model projections with the conditions that people are likely to experience within their community. Through an equally ambitious program of social science research, the Fellowship will also tackle the question of how resilient communities may be to these future heatwaves, and the extent to which that could be strengthened through adaptation.
At the same time, the interdisciplinary Fellowship team will also zoom out to explore what other unseen climate extremes most threaten our future, and which -- perhaps with GCR potential -- should be prioritised for urgent risk reduction efforts. This challenge of identifying novel threats is particularly difficult because it requires that we overcome the cognitive bias of history to identify the much wider set of extreme events that could have occurred, whilst also accounting for a changing climate. It will be overcome by the Fellowship using 'top-down' (hazard-centred) techniques, whereby historical events and climate model simulations are used together to map out the domain of physically-plausible threats. Bottom-up (vulnerability-centred) approaches will in turn inspire and narrow the search of this very large phase space. These perspectives, once refined, will constitute a new framework to systematically identify, and reduce risk, from the most dangerous unseen climate extremes.
The most concerning unseen extreme on the horizon is the emergence of heatwaves so severe that, for the first time in human history, the atmosphere becomes a heat source rather than a sink over large, well-populated regions. Such conditions mean that regardless of fitness, levels of hydration, or access to fans, prolonged exposure (in the order of hours) would be deadly. We do know that these events will occur given sufficient global warming, and that they may become widespread as early as this century; but precisely where is at risk and how soon the threat may emerge is not well understood. The potential societal impacts of such an event are almost completely unknown. For example, is unprecedented mortality inevitable if the atmosphere becomes a heat sink? If so, might it trigger mass migration due to place abandonment? Or could the most at-risk communities become resilient to such extreme heat?
The Fellowship will address these critical research gaps in our understanding of unseen heatwaves. Through an ambitious program of physical science it will provide new insight into how much warming is required for regions to experience heat beyond human tolerance. Focussing on one of the hottest cities in the world (Jacobabad, Pakistan), it will grapple with the complexity of how heat at regional scales manifests within people's homes, finally joining up future climate model projections with the conditions that people are likely to experience within their community. Through an equally ambitious program of social science research, the Fellowship will also tackle the question of how resilient communities may be to these future heatwaves, and the extent to which that could be strengthened through adaptation.
At the same time, the interdisciplinary Fellowship team will also zoom out to explore what other unseen climate extremes most threaten our future, and which -- perhaps with GCR potential -- should be prioritised for urgent risk reduction efforts. This challenge of identifying novel threats is particularly difficult because it requires that we overcome the cognitive bias of history to identify the much wider set of extreme events that could have occurred, whilst also accounting for a changing climate. It will be overcome by the Fellowship using 'top-down' (hazard-centred) techniques, whereby historical events and climate model simulations are used together to map out the domain of physically-plausible threats. Bottom-up (vulnerability-centred) approaches will in turn inspire and narrow the search of this very large phase space. These perspectives, once refined, will constitute a new framework to systematically identify, and reduce risk, from the most dangerous unseen climate extremes.
Publications

Matthews T
(2025)
Mortality impacts of the most extreme heat events
in Nature Reviews Earth & Environment

Matthews T
(2024)
Humid heat exceeds human tolerance limits and causes mass mortality
in Nature Climate Change

Raymond C
(2024)
Evening humid-heat maxima near the southern Persian/Arabian Gulf
in Communications Earth & Environment

Van Wyk De Vries M
(2024)
At-scale Model Output Statistics in mountain environments (AtsMOS v1.0)
in Geoscientific Model Development
Description | What were the most significant achievements from the award? To what extent were the award objectives met? If you can, briefly explain why any key objectives were not met. How might the findings be taken forward and by whom? As major investors of public funds, UKRI are accountable for large sums of public money; being able to demonstrate the extent to which expectations from awards have been met is an essential component of this accountability. The award is less than 25 % of the way through, but the first objective has already been met: "O1. Identify global hotspots of humid heat risk and their proximity to critical thresholds, now and under future scenarios of warming". The relevant findings were published in two Nature family journals: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-024-02215-8, and https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-024-00635-w (with the latter much more comprehensive). In brief, these papers identified to what extent putative 'tolerance' and 'survival' heat thresholds are being, or will be breached at different warming levels, as well as identifying the key uncertainties. Some of the key messages from this compendium are provided below. Intolerable heat thresholds (combinations of air temperature and humidity, which if exceeded, will cause the core body temperatures of even healthy adults to rise above 37C) have been breached rarely for younger adults in recent decades (across ~2.2% of land area over 1994-2023) but more widely for older adults (~21%). Unsurvivable thresholds (levels of heat leading to lethal core temperature rises within ~6h of exposure) were only exceeded for older adults (~1.8% of land area). Anthropogenic warming will lead to more frequent threshold crossings, including tripling of the intolerable land area for young adults if warming reaches 2 °C above preindustrial levels (see https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-024-00635-w). The lethal impacts of crossing this lower, 'intolerable' threshold were demonstrated vividly during the 2024 Hajj pilgrimage, in which over 1000 people died during a short-lived breach (see https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-024-02215-8). Together, the two articles listed above addressing this aim received coverage in 89 news outlets. |
Exploitation Route | First, they identify the challenges of further global warming: the extent of the threshold crossings (which can be used to identify areas/times in which regions are in principle 'deadly' for people to venture outside for prolonged periods) at different warming levels informs the conversation around climate change mitigation and warming limits. This is relevant for negotiators at the UNFCCC Conference of Parties (in which Nationally Determined (emissions) Contributions) are decided. That is, these findings have the potential to feed into international policy at the highest levels. Second, these outcomes inform climate change adaptation efforts. For example, the work we have published identifies the importance of land surface cover in influencing threshold crossing events. This body of work has already fed into an internal report for the Asian Development Bank (see Narrative section), and it has considerable potential to be used much more widely for adaptation planning -- shaping, for example, decisions around whether or not to plant vegetation or irrigate to reduce the lethal threat from extreme heat. In surveying global proximity to the critical heat thresholds, it also identifies key 'hotspot' regions in which pursuing adaptation efforts (such as improved early warning and the provision of heat shelters) should be an urgent priority. Note that, in the section below, 'Security and Diplomacy' is selected alongside 'Healthcare' because of concerns that large-scale displacements of people due to extreme heat (and the emergence of 'unliveable' regions) could have implications for security. |
Sectors | Healthcare Security and Diplomacy |
Description | The findings on the threat from heat beyond humans' physiological tolerance featured extensively in an internal report for the Asian Development Bank. I was an author of one chapter of this report, and I liaised heavily with the other authors -- passing on key findings from my Nature Reviews Earth and Environment paper (https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-024-00635-w). Note that the purpose of the internal report was to help guide future investments. I acknowledge, though, that the ultimate impacts of my research here cannot be identified. I include this here in the spirit of being comprehensive and transparent. |
First Year Of Impact | 2025 |
Sector | Financial Services, and Management Consultancy |
Impact Types | Economic Policy & public services |