The intrauterine environment and human early placental development; a new paradigm for the pathophysiology of complications of pregnancy

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Physiology Development and Neuroscience

Abstract

Adverse outcomes of pregnancy, such as growth restriction, stillbirth, pre-eclampsia and prematurity, place considerable economic and emotional burdens on society. They cause significant morbidity and mortality; in the UK 10-12% of pregnancies miscarry and there are approximately 4,000 stillbirths each year. A further 10-12% suffer growth restriction, which predisposes to an increased risk of cardiovascular and other diseases in adult life. The causes of these complications are complex, and despite much research their incidence has not changed substantially over the last 50 years; indeed, the incidence of low birth weight is increasing in the USA. This research programme takes a fresh and innovative approach to understanding their cause by focusing on a key unifying feature, impaired early development of the placenta. The placenta nourishes and protects the embryo, and so needs to develop rapidly after fertilisation. The overall aim is to investigate how that early development is stimulated, and how perturbations in the uterine environment lead to aberrant placentation. A more complete understanding of these critical events will ultimately facilitate interventions being devised that prevent complications being initiated, rather than attempting to treat them once established.
Our previous research supported by the MRC, transformed our understanding of the environment inside the uterus in early pregnancy. For many years it had been assumed that placental development was a continuum across gestation, but we demonstrated that it occurs in two very distinct phases. During the first 10-12 weeks, the placenta receives nutritional support from the glands lining the uterus, rather than from the maternal circulation as it does later. The glands provide essential nutrients, but also secrete proteins that can act as powerful stimulants to growth. Indeed, in some species, such as the sheep, the placenta sends signals to the glands to produce more of these proteins, and so enhances its own growth. The uterus therefore plays a much more dynamic role in supporting the first third of pregnancy than previously anticipated, creating a unique highly stimulatory microenvironment.

Our goal is to fully characterise that environment in the human, understand how it is regulated and investigate its impact on proliferation and differentiation of placental cells. The first aim is to identify the range of proteins secreted by the uterus using the latest sequencing techniques to analyse gene expression in samples of the lining of the uterus. We have recently applied the same technique to progenitor cells isolated from the early placenta, and so will able to identify potential growth factor/receptor interactions. The impact of these interactions on progenitor cell behaviour will then be tested in vitro. The second aim is to explore the signals coming from the placenta that might increase or alter the secretions. The third aim is to investigate using genetically modified mice whether metabolic stress alters secretions and impairs fetal growth. We will also determine whether stresses in humans such as obesity and diabetes, that are associated with adverse obstetric outcomes, reduce the effectiveness of these mechanisms and impair placental development. Finally, we will determine whether development of the uterus is compromised in offspring who are born growth restricted, resulting in intergenerational effects on birth weight.
It is anticipated that the results will have major implications for reproductive and public health medicine. Understanding the fetal-maternal dialogue during early pregnancy will help to develop novel interventions to optimise placental development. Equally, an appreciation of the impact of metabolic and other stresses on uterine function during early pregnancy may lead to improved peri-conceptional care. In the longer term, having healthier normal birth weight babies will help to reduce the burden of chronic disease in adulthood.

Technical Summary

This programme investigates the initiation of the pathophysiology of common complications of pregnancy that have profound effects on neonatal and long-term health. There is strong evidence that poor placental development is a unifying feature, but virtually nothing is known regarding how early placental growth is regulated. Our previous research showed that contrary to textbook accounts, the maternal blood supply to the placenta is not established until 10-12 weeks gestation, and that until then the conceptus is supported by secretions from the endometrial glands. Extending data from domestic species, we hypothesise the conceptus signals to the glands to up-regulate secretion of nutrients and mitogenic growth factors that stimulate proliferation of the placental tissues through a feed-forward mechanism. To test this, we will first identify the transcriptional networks that maintain stemness within a proliferative trophoblast progenitor niche we have identified. Secondly, we will use RNA-Seq to generate a comprehensive catalogue of the potential gland secretome in early pregnancy. The importance of specific growth factor-receptor pairings will be tested in vitro using co-cultures and in vivo using temporally regulated tissue-specific knock-out mice. Clinical correlates will be sought by assessing gland function in pre-conception endometrial biopsies from a high-risk population and linking to pregnancy outcome. Having identified the relevant pathways, we will test susceptibility to perturbation by metabolic stresses known to increase risk of the complications. This will be achieved by a combination of cell cultures in vitro, mouse models in vivo, and human clinical correlates. Finally, we will test whether uterine architecture is affected by developmental programming, leading to intergenerational effects. By elucidating these regulatory pathways, we aim to identify new approaches for the development of therapeutic interventions to optimise early placental development.

Planned Impact

Who will benefit from this research?
Scientists and clinicians investigating complications of pregnancy will benefit directly through new knowledge arising from this research. The first trimester is a crucial but under-researched period of pregnancy during which the placenta is established. This period corresponds to the phases of embryogenesis and organogenesis. Hence, perturbations may have a profound impact on both pregnancy outcome and life-long health. Remarkably, we still do not know how early placental proliferation and differentiation is regulated, and whether there is a dialogue between the placenta and the endometrial glands that stimulates placental development.
Health services are likely to also benefit through a reduction in complications of pregnancy; in the UK around 10% of the 800,000 annual pregnancies miscarry and there are approximately 4,000 stillbirths each year, while worldwide approximately 14 million infants are born growth restricted and 50,000 women die from pre-eclampsia. Preventing even a small proportion of these complications would therefore have major societal and economic benefits. Good obstetric care means that many pregnancies complicated by poor placental development end in live births. However, babies whose intrauterine life was compromised are at risk for long-term chronic diseases, such as cardiovascular disease and diabetes. Hence the economic and societal impact of a poor intrauterine environment is considerable.
Public health policy makers may benefit through the identification of critical pre-or peri-conceptional windows when supplementation with micronutrients or other interventions may improve endometrial function and hence placental development.
Finally, pharma companies may benefit if novel therapeutic targets to improve endometrial function in early pregnancy are identified.

How will they benefit from this research?
For researchers, a detailed knowledge of the transcriptional networks maintaining trophoblast stem cells and stimulating differentiation will add greatly to our knowledge of early placental development, and provide new information on an as yet unexplored stem cell niche. Isolation of a genuine trophoblast stem/progenitor cell would be a major advance in the field, replacing choriocarcinoma cell lines as model systems and preventing the need to continually isolate non-replicating primary cells form termination material.
For clinicians and health services, understanding the two-way signalling dialogue between the placenta and endometrium in early pregnancy may open avenues for novel therapeutic interventions to prevent complications of pregnancy, the incidence of which has not changed substantially for over 50 years. If the stimuli causing the glands to synthesise and release growth factors critical for placental proliferation can be identified, then the opportunity exists to target these pathways therapeutically in women at high risk of pregnancy complications. Since the glands are continuous with the uterine epithelium, they are easily accessible with minimally invasive delivery techniques.
For public health policy makers, a detailed knowledge of the role of the endometrium during early pregnancy could justify public health programmes aimed at ensuring maximal endometrial function either pre- or peri-conceptionally. This may involve treatment of low-grade infections or inflammation, or dietary supplements to improve gland activity and secretions.
Finally, for pharma companies, knowledge of the key factors and signalling pathways involved in the regulation of early placental development could open new avenues for therapeutic intervention. Any IP with commercial potential will be protected first and then exploited through Cambridge Enterprise, a wholly owned company established by the University to promote translation of basic research.
 
Description Dorothy Hodgkin Fellowship for Dr Margherita Turco
Amount £480,788 (GBP)
Funding ID DH160216 
Organisation The Royal Society 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2017 
End 09/2022
 
Title Endometrial organoids 
Description We have developed organoid cultures of human endometrial gland cells from both non-pregnant endometrium and from early pregnancy decidua. These organoids form spheres of polarised epithelial cells that remain proliferative and genetically stable for over 5 months, can be passaged, frozen and recultured. This represents a major breakthrough in endometrial research, and provides us with proliferative, primary gland cells for the first time. Developing the organoids has required painstaking attention to the culture conditions, and manipulation of key stem cell signalling pathways. We have also had to identify a panel of markers that clearly separate these cells from others at the maternal-fetal interface. We have further confirmed that the organoids are stable in culture by performing microarray studies on organoids after 1-2 months culture and glands cells frozen at the time of isolation. Genes that encode uterine milk proteins, such as MUC-1, glycodelin and osteopontin, are highly enriched in the organoids, and their transcriptome is virtually identical to that of primary gland isolates. We have also performed electron microscopy and observed that they display features characteristic of secretory cells. Finally, we have demonstrated that the organoids respond to oestrogen and progesterone, and to placental hormones, such as human chorionic gonadotropin and placental lactogen, by upregulating transcription of uterine milk proteins. We are therefore convinced that the organoids faithfully represent endometrial glands cells, opening new avenues for research into events during early pregnancy, but also into common gynaecological disorders, such as endometriosis. The results have been accepted for publication at Nature Cell Biology, but are not yet available on line. Gene databases associated with the study have been uploaded to public databases. 
Type Of Material Cell line 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Previously, only one immortalised gland cell line was available for research. The development of replicative and physiologically responsive organoids represents a major step forward. Our pilot data indicates the organoids respond to the hormones of early pregnancy by upregulating what are collectively known as uterine milk proteins. In other species these play a key role in supporting and stimulating the early development of the conceptus. The aim of our full application to the MRC is to investigate the signalling dialogue between the endometrium and the placenta during human early pregnancy, and the organoids represent an important research tool for this purpose. We expect the organoids will also be of great interest to researchers investigating cases of infertility and early pregnancy loss, as well as conditions such as endometriosis. In addition, we have shown that the same technique can be used to grow organoids of the ectocervix, and these may be valuable for investigating the role of papilloma virus in the pathophysiology of cervical carcinoma. The paper describing the technique has only just been accepted for publication, and is not yet online. There is a protocol paper associated with the publication which provides a detailed description of the stages involved. 
 
Title Human trophoblast organoids 
Description The feedback from the MRC's PSMB at the time of this award was that we should concentrate on isolating proliferative progenitors of trophoblast that would enable us to perform the experiments we proposed. We have done this by successfully employing the organoid technique. Refinement of the culture conditions, the use of a low oxygen atmosphere, and modulation of the WNT and BMP4 signalling pathways has enabled us to maintain proliferative trophoblast cells for at least 2 months. To avoid any potential contamination by, and confusion with, endometrial organoids, we only culture trophoblast cells that are SRY-positive. Using FACS we have obtained highly pure populations of first trimester trophoblast, and used these to devise a panel comprising 4 different types of markers (genes, HLA-antigens, methylation and microRNAs) that accurately characterise trophoblast. The organoids all show that same markers, confirming their stability in culture. 
Type Of Material Cell line 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The absence of a true human trophoblast stem cell has been a major block for placental research. Until now, we have had to rely on choriocarcinoma cell lines, or immortalised cell lines that bear little resemblance to trophoblast. These organoids there represent a major breakthrough; for the first time we have access to proliferative, primary trophoblast cells that can be used for co-cultures, genetic manipulations and a variety of other experimental techniques. They may be very attractive to the pharma industry for the testing of drugs, and we are currently discussing IP rights with Cambridge Enterprise. 
 
Title Transcriptomic analysis of the human yolk sac 
Description We have performed RNASeq analysis on human and murine yolk sacs from early in pregnancy, and compared the data to published data from the chicken. This comparison has revealed remarkable conservation of transcripts encoding transporter proteins and metabolic functions across these species. We cannot perform experimental assessments of yolk sac function in the human. However, the conservation among the mouse and chicken, where it is known the yolk sac plays a key role in transport of macro- and micro-nutrients during early development, strongly suggests that the human yolk sac may play an equivalent role. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The transcript database will provide evolutionary biologists with a powerful tool for investigating phylogenetic development of the extra embryonic membranes. The results have been submitted to PNAS for publication, and are currently under review. The data have been uploaded to a public database and will be released once the paper is accepted for publication. 
 
Title First trimester placenta microarray 
Description We have performed microarray analysis of placental villi obtained from normal first trimester pregnancies in order to compare with the trophoblast organoids. The array results have been deposited in a public database and will be released once the paper describing the organoids has been published. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact These data will be of interest to researchers investigating early placental development. 
 
Title HLA profiling and STR analysis of endometrial organoids 
Description We performed full HLA typing and STR analysis on organoids derived form endometrium, and on matched samples of maternal blood. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact These data may be of interest to researchers interested in HLA expression in organoid cultures. The results will be made public once the paper describing the organoids is published. 
 
Title Microarray of decidual glands 
Description We have performed microarrays on glands isolated from early pregnancy decidua as part of the confirmation of the endometrial organoids. These represent a significant resource for researchers investigating the human endometrium and human pregnancy. They will be placed on a public database. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact These will be of value to researchers interested in how gland activity changes during early pregnancy. 
 
Title Microarray of endometrial glands 
Description The microarrays we have performed on glands isolated from normal non-pregnant endometrium as part of the confirmation of the endometrial organoids represent a significant resource for researchers investigating the human endometrium. They have been placed on a public database, and will be released once the paper describing the organoids has been published. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact These data on gene expression within the glands of the normal endometrium may be of value to researchers interested in common disorders of the endometrium, such as endometriosis. 
 
Title Proteomic analysis of exocoelomic fluid. 
Description The exocoelom is the cavity within the placental membranes in which the yolk sac lies. It is filled with fluid that is derived principally from maternal serum and the secretions of the endometrial glands. The fluid acts as a reservoir of nutrients that can be transported to the embryo by the yolk sac. We have performed mass-spec. proteomic analysis of the fluid in order determine its composition, and hence identify key nutrients and growth factors secreted by the glands. These results have been submitted to PNAS publication and are currently under review. The data have been uploaded to a public database, and will be released once the paper is published.. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The basic composition of the exocoelomic fluid is known from previous studies, but our findings provide a more detailed analysis. We imagine the database will be of considerable interest to fetal physiologists interested in transport across the early placenta. 
 
Title RNA-Seq human yolk sac 
Description We have performed RNA-Seq on 9 human yolk sacs collected at approximately 11 weeks of gestational age. We hypothesise that the yolk sac plays a key role in the transport of nutrients from the endometrial glands to the embryo during the first few weeks of pregnancy. We are therefore interested in what transporter proteins are present on the yolk sac, as this will provide information on the classes of nutrients being secreted by the glands. To assist in the analyses we also sequenced placental villi of the same gestational age, as substances will have to cross this barrier first, and yolk sacs from the mouse where there is compelling experimental data on its role in fetal nutrition. Analyses identified 50 genes that are uniquely expressed in the yolk sac compared to the liver, lungs and kidney. We chose these organs for comparison as many of their functions are performed by the yolk sac in early pregnancy. The results indicate remarkable conservation of transcripts across the three species, suggesting that the human yolk sac plays important roles in transport and handling of cholesterol in early pregnancy. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The yolk sac plays a critical role in the early development of the embryo in many species, both as the site of the first haematopoiesis and through the transport of nutrients. In the human it is largely considered vestigial, although there are data associating abnormal development of the yolk sac with early pregnancy losses that are chromosomally normal. Human yolk sacs are very hard to obtain, and we anticipate that the transcriptome will be of interest to many researchers interested in early development and also in the handling of toxins and drugs by the early embryo. We believe our findings will change people's views of the human yolk sac, and stimulate much interest in its role during early pregnancy. They will also be of use to evolutionary biologists interested in the phylogeny of the extra embryonic membranes. We have submitted the results for publication to PNAS where they are currently under review. We will be making the sequence data available on public databases once the manuscript is accepted. 
 
Description Cambridge Alumni Festival lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This lecture highlighted the importance of placental research for long-term health, and showcased some of the latest research taking place in Cambridge.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Cambridge Science Festival lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This lecture outlined the role of the placenta, its importance for complications of pregnancy and also for the long-term health of the mother and her offspring. It sparked a number of questions relating to maternal diet and behaviour during pregnancy.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Lecture, Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was a specialist lecture to medical practitioners undergoing specialist training in Obstetrics, regarding the development and pathology of the placenta. There was discussion afterwards of the mechanisms underlying complications of pregnancy.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016