Gestational diabetes in Uganda and India: Design and Evaluation of Educational Films for improving Screening and Self-management (GUIDES)

Lead Research Organisation: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Department Name: Epidemiology and Population Health

Abstract

Gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) is a condition in which the body of pregnant women cannot control the levels of blood sugar. This can result in a number of short- and long-term health problems for both the mother and her child. This condition is now becoming much more common in developing countries, yet most women are not diagnosed on time, and those who are diagnosed do not usually receive appropriate care. This is because the doctors and pregnant women in these countries don't know enough about this condition, as it is a relatively new experience for these societies.

The aim of our research is to assess whether an educational and behavioural intervention, delivered primarily through film, can improve the care of women with GDM. Films are a simple and low-cost way of delivering health interventions, and they are particularly suitable for people who are not very literate. So far, films have been shown to be useful in imparting health education and changing health-related behaviours in developed countries, but not in developing countries, which is a primary motivation for our research.

We will develop and evaluate an intervention with three different components. The first will be a training programme for doctors and nurses. Films will cover how to identify and treat GDM, and how to support women to make changes to their lifestyle (healthy eating, more physical activity). Secondly, a short film for pregnant women and their families, designed to raise awareness of GDM, will be shown in the waiting areas where women receive antenatal care (routine health care in pregnancy). Thirdly, a programme for women diagnosed with GDM to help them manage their condition. These films will educate them about treatment, and will support them to make changes for a healthier lifestyle. Films will be supplemented by Q&A sessions run by a trained nurse.

We will carry out our research in Uganda (Entebbe) and India (Bengaluru) because they are at different stage of economic development. First, we will carry out research to understand people's daily lives in these countries to develop an intervention that is suitable for their culture. Then we will test and refine it further until it is fit-for-purpose. We will then assess whether the intervention improves care for women with GDM in independent studies in both sites. In each site, thirty maternity units will be selected, from which half will be randomly chosen to receive the new intervention. Women visiting the participating clinics during pregnancy will be invited to join the study. To evaluate whether the interventions are successful, we will measure three things. Firstly, whether women have been screened for and/or diagnosed with GDM. Secondly, we will invite women who tell us that have been diagnosed with GDM to visit clinics so we can take a blood sample. We will test this blood to see how well their blood sugar is being controlled. Thirdly, we will calculate how many women have experienced a negative birth outcome which could be because of GDM (for example, having a baby who is larger than average, or giving birth by caesarean section). We will also conduct interviews with women and health providers to help us understand how and why the intervention may be (or may not be) successful.

If the intervention is successful in improving the detection and management of GDM, we expect there to be financial savings from a reduction in maternal and infant complications associated with GDM. We also think that the intervention may reduce the number of women who are diagnosed with type 2 diabetes later in life. In the longer term, it is hoped that the intervention will encourage the provision and quality of GDM screening and care across all LMICs.

Technical Summary

The prevalence of gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) is rising rapidly in many low-middle income countries (LMICs). It is associated with adverse short-term and longer-term consequences for the mother and child. Most women with GDM in LMICs are undiagnosed and/or inadequately managed due to a lack of knowledge and skills about GDM on the part of both providers and patients. Therefore, we propose to develop and evaluate a package of three interconnected educational/behavioural interventions aimed at: a) improving knowledge and skills of GDM guidelines and skills of health providers; b) raising awareness of importance of GDM screening among pregnant women and their families; and c) improving confidence and skills in self-management among those diagnosed with GDM. We plan to deliver the intervention through the medium of film as they are low-cost and scalable, and can transcend barriers of literacy, making them ideal for LMICs. Evidence on effectiveness of films in changing behaviours is currently limited to high-income countries.

The research will be carried out in Uganda (Entebbe) and India (Bengaluru). A careful contextual analysis will precede the development of a culturally-tailored film-based intervention for each setting, which will be iteratively refined using qualitative research methods till it is fit for purpose. Then the effectiveness of the intervention will be evaluated in independent cluster randomised trials, involving ~10,000 pregnant women across 30 maternity units at each site. Our principal research question is whether a low-cost educational/behavioural intervention delivered through a package of culturally-tailored films can provide scalable improvements in timely detection and management of GDM. The ultimate aim of the project is to contribute to scientific evidence underpinning the use of films in cost-effectively scaling up behavioural interventions in low-literacy settings.

Planned Impact

The scientific outputs of this research are to a) contribute robust evidence regarding the use of film in health interventions in low- and middle-income country (LMIC) settings, and b) to evaluate whether an educational/behavioural film-based intervention can improve the care of women with gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM). The proposed research has the potential to realise a number of impacts:

- We expect an impact on economic productivity in Uganda and India. GDM is a risk factor for type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM), and encouraging healthy lifestyles in pregnant women will help to prevent progression to T2DM. In India there are 60 million people with diabetes. Sub-Saharan Africa is witnessing an 'epidemic' of T2DM, with 6% of total mortality attributable to diabetes. In LMICs, diabetes-associated morbidity and mortality is highest in the most economically active age groups. A reduction in prevalence will improve economic productivity through increased contribution to the labour force. Women tend to be gatekeepers to health services for the whole family. Improving their relationship with health providers will impact on the health of other family members, including the future labour force (children).

- Another impact of the study will be changes in healthcare and related industries. Many of the benefits of staff training provided through the intervention will not be restricted to GDM care (e.g. improved communication skills). Although our study does not provide financial support for GDM screening, we anticipate that increasing awareness and demand for screening will have an indirect impact on stimulating and strengthening screening capacity in both the public and private health sector. The intervention may also stimulate the growth of other wellness and counselling industries, for example by increasing demand for fitness centres and gyms.

- The proposed intervention has the potential to reduce gender inequality. The International Diabetes Federation describes GDM as "a severe and neglected threat to maternal and child health". One key component of our planned intervention is improving women's self-efficacy and their confidence in managing their own health. This - in conjunction with training in communication skills for health providers - should result in improved patient-provider relationships and more timely care-seeking. There will be additional benefits for peer supporters, as this role may act as a springboard to other training and employment opportunities, improving the material circumstances of women.

- Our study will strengthen the role of film in public health, and therefore expand the growth of the film industries in the two countries. In the short-term, there will be opportunities for local film professionals to be involved in the production of intervention films. In the longer-term, this will contribute to a new stream of income for film industries. India has a highly developed film industry and the largest film market in the world. There is great potential for knowledge and skills exchanges between the two countries; we anticipate a particular benefit for Uganda, which has a small but growing film industry.

- A reduction in diabetes-associated complications may also result in benefits to other aspects of society. Public expenditure savings from treating and managing health complications could be diverted to other areas of need, for example, education. Better health will improve quality of life, and will lead to an increase in other activities (e.g. sport). Benefits to families and households will include freeing up of income, as many healthcare costs are borne by individuals and their families, with this burden disproportionately felt by the most disadvantaged.

Although the immediate impact of this research will be most obvious in India and Uganda, our choice of two country settings at different stages of the economic transition will mean that impacts should be generalisable to all LMICs.
 
Title Professional development films about GDM: films for doctors and nurses in India 
Description Following formative research activities, we worked with Medical Aids Films and local stakeholders to script two short films (~7 minutes) about GDM which can be used for professional development (one for nurses, one for doctors). Filming was carried out on location by a local team of film makers, and involved interviews with local healthcare professionals. The films cover knowledge of GDM and relevant national clinical guidelines, skills for blood glucose monitoring and managing medication including insulin administration, specialist obstetric and neonatal care, and GDM and lifestyle counselling. The films are available in English and Kannada audio with subtitles. The films are designed to be shown during routine professional development meetings. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This film forms part of the educational-behavioural intervention for the GUIDES study and so is not yet available outside the study. Once the trial is completed, the film will be made freely available worldwide via Medical Aid Films usual distribution avenues (https://www.medicalaidfilms.org/watch-2/). 
 
Title Professional development films about GDM: films for doctors and nurses in Uganda 
Description Following formative research activities, we worked with Medical Aids Films and local stakeholders to script two short films (~7 minutes) about GDM which can be used for professional development (one for nurses, one for doctors). Filming was carried out on location by a local team of film makers, and involved interviews with local healthcare professionals. The films cover knowledge of GDM and relevant national clinical guidelines, skills for blood glucose monitoring and managing medication including insulin administration, specialist obstetric and neonatal care, and GDM and lifestyle counselling. The films are available in English and Luganda audio with subtitles. The films are designed to be shown during routine professional development meetings. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This film forms part of the educational-behavioural intervention for the GUIDES study and so is not yet available outside the study. Once the trial is completed, the film will be made freely available worldwide via Medical Aid Films usual distribution avenues (https://www.medicalaidfilms.org/watch-2/). 
 
Title Self-management education programme for diabetes in pregnancy: a set of four films for women in India 
Description Following formative research activities, we worked with Medical Aids Films and local stakeholders to script a set of four short culturally-appropriate film (~6 minutes each) to support pregnant women who have been diagnosed with GDM, and their family members. The four films cover i) information about GDM; ii) glucose monitoring and medication, including self-administration of insulin; and early identification and treatment of hypoglycaemia; iii) skills to make successful lifestyle (diet, activity) changes; and iv) problem solving and healthy coping strategies. Filming was carried out on location by a local team of film makers, and involved interviews with local healthcare professionals. The film has been designed to be incorporated into facility-based group sessions for women with GDM (nurse-led or peer-led), or alternatively can be provided for viewing on personal mobile devices. The films are available in Kannada and Dhakani audio with subtitles. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This set of films forms part of the educational-behavioural intervention for the GUIDES study and so is not yet available outside the study. Once the trial is completed, the film will be made freely available worldwide via Medical Aid Films usual distribution avenues (https://www.medicalaidfilms.org/watch-2/). In India, the Department of Biotechnology has already expressed interest in having the film translated into other community languages for wider use across the country. 
 
Title Self-management education programme for diabetes in pregnancy: a set of four films for women in Uganda 
Description Following formative research activities, we worked with Medical Aids Films and local stakeholders to script a set of four short culturally-appropriate film (~6 minutes each) to support pregnant women who have been diagnosed with GDM, and their family members. The four films cover i) information about GDM; ii) glucose monitoring and medication, including self-administration of insulin; and early identification and treatment of hypoglycaemia; iii) skills to make successful lifestyle (diet, activity) changes; and iv) problem solving and healthy coping strategies. Filming was carried out on location by a local team of film makers, and involved interviews with local healthcare professionals. The film has been designed to be incorporated into facility-based group sessions for women with GDM (nurse-led or peer-led), or alternatively can be provided for viewing on personal mobile devices. The films are available in English and Luganda audio with subtitles. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This film forms part of the educational-behavioural intervention for the GUIDES study and so is not yet available outside the study. Once the trial is completed, the film will be made freely available worldwide via Medical Aid Films usual distribution avenues (https://www.medicalaidfilms.org/watch-2/). 
 
Title What is Gestational Diabetes? A short film for pregnant women in India 
Description Following formative research activities, we worked with Medical Aids Films and local stakeholders to script a short culturally-appropriate film (~9 minutes) to raise awareness among pregnant women and their family members regarding GDM and the importance of GDM screening and healthy lifestyles. Filming was carried out on location by a local team of film makers, and involved interviews with local healthcare professionals. The film has been designed to be viewed in antenatal waiting rooms and also on mobile viewing devices. The film is available in Kannada and Dhakani audio with subtitles. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This film forms part of the educational-behavioural intervention for the GUIDES study and so is not yet available outside the study. Once the trial is completed, the film will be made freely available worldwide via Medical Aid Films usual distribution avenues (https://www.medicalaidfilms.org/watch-2/). In India, the Department of Biotechnology has already expressed interest in having the film translated into other community languages for wider use across the country. 
 
Title What is Gestational Diabetes? A short film for pregnant women in Uganda 
Description Following formative research activities, we worked with Medical Aids Films and local stakeholders to script a short culturally-appropriate film (~9 minutes) to raise awareness among pregnant women and their family members regarding GDM and the importance of GDM screening and healthy lifestyles. Filming was carried out on location by a local team of film makers, and involved interviews with local healthcare professionals. The film has been designed to be viewed in antenatal waiting rooms and also on mobile viewing devices. The film is available in English and Luganda audio with subtitles. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This film forms part of the educational-behavioural intervention for the GUIDES study and so is not yet available outside the study. Once the trial is completed, the film will be made freely available worldwide via Medical Aid Films usual distribution avenues (https://www.medicalaidfilms.org/watch-2/). 
 
Description Assessing the Transgenerational Association of Maternal Glucose and childhood Obesity, and the Role of Behavioural, and Environmental influencing factors (TAGORE)
Amount $596,121 (USD)
Organisation The Wellcome Trust/DBT India Alliance 
Sector Multiple
Country Global
Start  
 
Title Assessment of GDM-related dietary behaviour 
Description We have designed a set of 12 questions to assess dietary behaviour. In our large trial it would not be feasible to ask participants to complete a detailed FFQ or a 24 hour food recall. Instead, we required a brief set of questions that could assess dietary behaviour specifically associated with the risk of gestational diabetes. We drew on an existing tool - the UK Diabetes and Diet Questionnaire (UKDDQ) - and adapted this for our use, working in consultation with stakeholders and health professionals. We reduced the number of questions, introduced several new ones, and adapted the wording for our settings (Uganda and India). This tool will be piloted in the early stages of our cluster RCT. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Pending - this research tool is being assessed via a trial 
 
Description Collaboration with Medical Aid Films 
Organisation Medical Aid Films
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We have worked closely with this partner in the development of the film-based intervention, including providing editorial briefs, material to be incorporated in the films, and reviewing scripts and post-production rough cuts.
Collaborator Contribution Medical Aid Films are responsible for the overall supervision and production of the films which will form the main educational-behavioural intervention for our trial.
Impact The output from this collaboration will be a set of culturally-appropriate educational films for pregnant women and health professionals, to be evaluated in a large cluster RCT in Uganda and India.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Collaboration with film production company in Bangalore, India 
Organisation STOM productions
Country India 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We contributed scientific knowledge and educational materials which were used to develop a set of culturally-appropriate educational films to be used as the main component of our behavioural-educational intervention.
Collaborator Contribution STOM productions are a film production house in Bangalore, India. They worked closely with our UK-based partner Medical Aid Films and were responsible for filming the local footage needed for our film-based educational intervention. Local crew were employed to maximise the potential for capacity building.
Impact A set of culturally-appropriate educational films to be evaluated as part of our hospital-based educational-behavioural intervention designed to improve the detection and management of gestational diabetes in India.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Collaboration with mobile app developer in India 
Organisation Athenaeum Technologies
Country India 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We have contributed knowledge regarding the logistics of carrying out field research and supplied our collaborator with our research tools (questionnaires).
Collaborator Contribution Athenaeum Technologies are a company specialising in mobile application development. They are working with us to develop a mobile app which can be used to collect data in the field for our research trial, which is being conducted in Uganda and India.
Impact A custom-designed app for data collection (still in development).
Start Year 2019
 
Title Educational films for improving screening and self-management of gestational diabetes in India and Uganda 
Description The intervention is a low-cost educational/behavioural intervention delivered through a package of culturally-tailored films with the aim of improving the timely detection and management of gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM). The intervention will comprise of three interconnected educational/behavioural interventions aimed at: a) improving knowledge of GDM guidelines and skills of health providers; b) raising awareness of importance of GDM screening among pregnant women and their families; and c) improving confidence and skills in self-management among those diagnosed with GDM. Films for pregnant women and their families will be screened in antenatal clinics and made available for viewing on personal mobile devices. The films for health professionals will be screened at professional development meetings. The development of this intervention will be informed by desktop reviews, contextual analyses based on qualitative interviews with pregnant women and their families and health professionals, and participatory work with key stakeholders. Two separate packages will be developed, one for India, and one for Uganda. This film-based intervention will be evaluated through two cluster RCTs in India and Uganda. The films were finalised in February 2021. The funding for the intervention development is via the Newton Fund (UK/Uganda) and the DBT (India). 
Type Preventative Intervention - Behavioural risk modification
Current Stage Of Development Refinement. Non-clinical
Year Development Stage Completed 2021
Development Status Under active development/distribution
Impact Collaboration with local film production companies/local film crews (capacity-strengthening). Engagement with key stakeholders. 
 
Description GUIDES Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We have created a website for the general public, study participants, stakeholders and those interested in research partnerships. The content is still being finalised, once this is done we will circulate the url using appropriate media and other communication channels.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://guidesresearch.org/
 
Description Presentation to the DBT Technical Committee 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Supporters
Results and Impact The India research team presented a progress update to the DBT Technical Review Committee. Policymakers and practitioners were very enthusiastic about the possibility of using the GUIDES intervention films more widely after the study end. Committee representatives are making contact with our collaborator Medical Aid Films to find out about translating the films into other local and regional languages used in India.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Technical review meeting (Uganda) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This event was held on 14th January 2020 in Entebbe with an overall objective of reviewing the video scripts derived from the qualitative study to ensure that the content of films is appropriate to the medical and social context of Uganda and relevant to the needs of women of reproductive age at risk of developing Gestational Diabetes Mellitus (GMD).
The meeting was attended by high-ranking government officials (including the Manager of NCDs Program from the Ministry of Health), a Commissioner from the Health Education Department, a Senior Physiotherapist, two District Health Officers, and individuals from different professional backgrounds such as a nurse experienced in the management of GDM, a nutritionist, an experienced film maker, mothers with past experience of GDM and an obstetricians. All those attending were able to review the proposed content for the educational films and made recommendations about how they could be improved.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020