Modelling the dynamics of viral load to reveal mechanisms of protection in COVID-19

Lead Research Organisation: Imperial College London
Department Name: Infectious Disease

Abstract

Variation in the severity of COVID-19 may be due to differences in how well the immune system fights the virus. The most severe cases have the highest levels of virus, which may be driving such a strong immune response that it damages the body. The virus may have reached high levels because it grew very fast or because the immune system did not respond fast enough or in the right way. We can only find out which parts of the immune response are protective if we know how the levels of virus and immune response influence each other over time. We have previously shown that we can use data from lots of patients to develop a model of how the levels of virus and the immune response interact, and then use this as a framework to estimate how effectively the immune response of each individual is controlling the virus. This then allows us to identify which of the thousands of molecules involved of the immune response are actually responsible for protection. Using data which has already been collected in other studies to develop a similar model for COVID-19, we will identify the protective immune response, leading better treatments and vaccines.

Technical Summary

Characterising the protective host-response in COVID-19 is a critical step towards developing effective treatments and vaccines. Increasing pathogen load stimulates the host response to infection, but identifying the protective components of the response in humans is challenging in cross-sectional studies. Variation occurs between individuals in both the dynamics of pathogen load over time and the relationship between pathogen load and magnitude of the host response, and this variation can be harnessed to identify correlates of protection. A mathematical model of the relationships between pathogen load and host response can be developed using population data and then used to make quantitative estimates of the model parameters determining pathogen load for individual subjects. Importantly, we have shown that parameter estimates in individuals can then be correlated with measured host factors, to identify biological mechanisms controlling pathogen load. We propose to develop a within-host model of viral load dynamics in COVID-19 and use it to: i) quantify parameters of viral load control for individuals; ii) predict clinical outcome; iii) identify constitutive host characteristics associated with control of viral load; iv) identify components of the blood and mucosal immune responses which control viral load. We build on extensive clinical and biological data generated by ongoing studies, adding value to these projects and expediting their public health impact. Our approach will deliver a prioritized list of host factors which control viral load dynamics, underpinning development of more effective, and potentially personalised, treatment and vaccine strategies.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description One of the most important measures to tackle the COVID-19 pandemic was reducing transmission of the virus from infected people to uninfected people. Early in the pandemic, it became clear that if a large amount of virus was present in someone's nose and throat it increased the likelihood that they would spread it to others. It was also clear that there was a lot of variation between people in how much virus they had in the nose and throat, but we did not understand why. Our research investigated the variation between individuals in this "viral load" and tried to identify what determines the viral load in the nose and throat. Our aim was to identify factors which might reduce viral load and therefore reduce the spread of the virus.
We first collated data from many published studies around the world in which viral load was measured, and combined these to characterize how the viral load changes over time from the start of illness, how it is related to factors like age and sex, and how much is explained by "unknown" differences between individuals. We made a mathematical model to describe these relationships with viral load and allow us to classify how well individuals were controlling viral load. Next, we used samples from a smaller group of patients with COVID-19 to relate their ability to control viral load to their body's immune response. We measured which genes were turned on and off in their blood and in the lining of their noses, to help us to understand this.
We found that viral load in the nose and throat is not associated with severity of illness, age or sex, but was strongly associated with the time from onset of illness. We found that antibodies to the virus, an important part of the immune response, were associated with control of viral load. We also found evidence that certain immune cells which can kill virus infected cells are important, and we identified a particular "anti-viral" molecule produced by immune cells which was strongly associated with control of viral load. This molecule might be tested as treatment to reduce viral load and help to reduce transmissibility of the virus. Further work would be needed to test this in patients to see if it works when used in this way, is safe and well-tolerated. Our work demonstrates that this approach can be applied to understand how viral load is controlled in a new infectious disease, and could pave the way to accelerate the discovery of treatments for any new infectious disease.
Exploitation Route We are just about to submit the second paper from this project, describing mechanistic correlates of control of viral load. This paper reveals many mechanisms which are potential leads for development of prophylactic and transmission-blocking therapeutic drug and vaccine development . We anticipate that this will be of interest to the pharmaceutical industry and may be taken forward to clinical trials
Sectors Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Title Modelling upper respiratory viral load dynamics of SARS-CoV-2 
Description We developed a mechanistic model to describe upper respiratory tract viral load dynamics and host response in SARS CoV-2 infection 
Type Of Material Model of mechanisms or symptoms - human 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact No impact yet (model is being used in further discovery of mechanistic correlates of protection) 
URL https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12916-021-02220-0
 
Description Spanish COVID 
Organisation University of Santiago de Compostela
Department Department of Paediatrics
Country Spain 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Collaboration on analysis of RNA-Sequencing data from Spanish patients with COVID and integration with results of COVID viral load z-scores
Collaborator Contribution Contribution of samples and upper respiratory tract gene expression data
Impact None yet
Start Year 2021