Palaeoclimate reconstructions from Tierra Del Fuego to detect Land-Ocean-Atmosphere Interactions

Lead Research Organisation: Swansea University
Department Name: School of the Environment and Society

Abstract

The nature of future human induced climate change is highly uncertain with projected global temperature increases in 2100 spanning 0.3-6.4 Celsius (IPCC 2007, AR4). Part of this large uncertainty is due to the paucity of climate & proxy-climate data to validate climate models & constrain Earth System sensitivity to simulated forcing, particularly in the Southern Hemisphere (SH). A key component of variability of the SH atmosphere is the Southern Annular Mode (SAM), which is an oscillation of atmospheric mass that results in changes in the westerly winds over the Southern Ocean. The SH westerly winds modify the upwelling of carbon-rich deep water & therefore influence the global balance of carbon dioxide between the ocean and the atmosphere. It is uncertain whether the recently observed intensification of the southern westerlies will cause the Southern Ocean to be a net source or sink of atmospheric carbon dioxide. Little is known about the long-term past variability of the southern westerlies & atmospheric carbon dioxide, making it difficult to separate internally & externally-forced fluctuations. It is imperative to rectify this deficiency in order to generate & test hypotheses to explain the processes of change in the strength of the southern westerlies & how these are related to (inter-)hemispheric climate change during known periods of contrasting climate change, for example the Medieval Climatic Anomaly & the Little Ice Age.
This project will investigate four new sites located in southern South America (SSA). This region is located in the core of the southern westerlies and is ideally located to capture changes in their intensity. SSA terrestrial peatland-based palaeoclimate archives are capable of recording long-term changes in the westerlies, given that wind intensity affects precipitation mainly produced in winter by fronts & low-pressure systems embedded in the prevailing westerly circulation. The selected sites are all rain-fed peat bogs, which provide excellent climate archives. Plant & protozoan (testate amoebae) fossils preserved in well-dated cores extracted from these bogs will be used to reconstruct past changes in Bog Surface Wetness (BSW, an index of surface water balance) over the last ~2000 years, at a time resolution of 10-100 years. The same core samples will be analysed for stable isotopes of oxygen & hydrogen. The spatial & temporal distribution of the heavy isotopes of these elements in precipitation is related to air temperature, & hence to atmospheric circulation. The isotope signal captured in the cellulose fraction of Sphagnum moss closely tracks that of the precipitation used by the plant for cellulose synthesis. Hence, fossil Sphagnum from raised peat preserves a clear signal of past changes in climate & atmospheric circulation. The stable isotope data will be compared with isotope measurements from moss banks & ice cores from the maritime Antarctic and Antarctic Peninsula, in addition to stable water isotope data & BSW reconstructions from eastern North America. Analyses of fossils & stable isotopes from the same core levels will allow us to reconstruct the timing, magnitude & spatial pattern of the regional terrestrial response, as well as exploring the impact of different causal factors such as changes in atmospheric & ocean circulation & solar variability on the climate of the study area. In this way, insight will be gained into the mechanisms that have driven climate change over the last ~2000 years.
Hypotheses to be tested:
1 Climate changes during the last ~2000 years in SSA are in phase with climate changes identified in eastern North America & NW Europe, & represent inter-hemispheric teleconnections.
2 Climate changes in SSA during the last ~2000 years are in antiphase with Northern Hemisphere climate changes & represent a bipolar seesaw.
3 Climate changes in SSA during the last ~2000 years are uncorrelated with Northern Hemisphere climate changes.

Planned Impact

Who will benefit from this research?
1. Palaeoclimate scientists and Earth System modellers interested in the nature and causes of long-term climate change. 2. Peatland scientists and conservation agencies interested in the long-term record of peat forming plants, in terms of stability and response to former periods of climate change. 3. Peatland scientists and Earth System modellers interested in the interplay between long-term climate change and carbon sequestration in peatlands, given that these ecosystems represent a significant component of the global terrestrial carbon cycle. 4. The media and the wider public, students and school-level audiences. 5. Training and development of project PDRA staff with specialist, media, presentation and oral communication skills.

How will they benefit from this research?
1. Better understanding of the rate and nature of climate change in southern South America and how this is related to changes in the Northern Hemisphere. 2. The creation of quantitative reconstructions of climate change and stable water isotope reconstructions in a data poor region will have an impact upon Earth System modellers. Rigorous AOGCM development is dependent upon the availability of high quality palaeodata to ensure meaningfull data/model comparisons.

What will be done to ensure that they benefit from this research?
1. A regularly updated website describing the project, with both technical and general sections and a choice of three languages (English, Spanish and Welsh), in order to target the wider global community and local communities in Chile and Argentina. 2. Press releases to regional, national and international conservation organisations. 3. Attendance at local and national events to promote the public's engagement with science, particularly school level audiences. We will incorporate 'hands-on' displays of real life sub-fossil samples and a moveable display of posters. 4. Routine dissemination activities through peer-reviewed journals, congress, academic newsletters and submission to specialist databases.
 
Description Two fieldwork seasons have been successfully completed and five peat profiles have been recovered from Southern Chile & Argentina. Surface samples (x100) have also been collected and work is currently in progress to produce a testate amoebae transfer function for the study region. This will be applied to the fossil testate amoebae assemblages identified in the peat profiles. Progress is also being made with macrofossil analyses (Southampton University Project Partner) and stable isotope analyses (Swansea and Plymouth University Project Partners).

Modern process-based studies have resulted in an improved understanding of isotope fractionation in mosses. This information will assist in interpretation of the resulting environmental records. It also appears that carbon isotopes record changes in moisture-status of the mire and may be used in conjunction with testate-amoeba measures of bog-hydrology to provide more robust reconstructions of hydroclimate. In addition to the stable isotope analyses, a pilot investigation into n-alkane indices derived from the modern calibration transect indicate that previously accepted measures of bog surface wetness based upon n-alkane indices may be unreliable.

Long (c.2,000-year) isotopic analyses from the three studied peat bogs at Andorra, Tierra Australis and Parillar have been completed. Interpretations are ongoing, but preliminary findings indicate that conditions similar to today have previously been experienced at these bogs during the last 2000-years and that the 21st century is not atypical, in terms of its stable isotopic composition.
Exploitation Route 1. Make stable isotope data available for evaluation of isotope enabled Earth system models (once data are finalised).
2. Make data available to PAGES-2k Lotred initiative (once data are finalised).
3. Make data available to PAGES-2k Isotope modelling initiatives (once data are finalised).
Sectors Environment

 
Title Simultaneous determination of COH stable isotopes in organic matter 
Description A technological development is developed through which the stable carbon-, oxygen- and non-exchangeable hydrogen-isotopic ratios (d13C, d18O, d2H) are determined on a single carbohydrate (cellulose) sample with precision equivalent to conventional techniques. This triple-isotope approach offers significant new research opportunities, most notably in physiology and medicine, isotope biogeochemistry, forensic science and palaeoclimatology, when isotopic analysis of a common sample is desirable or when sample material is limited 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2014 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The development of a triple-isotope method represents a significant improvement over existing methods. The system performs comparably with standard methods in terms of analytical precision and importantly, requires less than a third of the sample material needed for single determinations using standard techniques. Analysis time is comparable with that of a single isotope determination by continuous flow. As the samples do not require nitration prior to analysis, significant efficiencies arise in the development of multiple-isotope time series. A further benefit of running three isotopic measurements on a single common sample is the increased statistical confidence in the mean value resulting from replicate analyses in cases where sample material is limited. If the triple-isotope approach is routinely adopted, we anticipate that the added information provided by the hydrogen-isotope data from a-cellulose samples will greatly facilitate modelling of hydrogen-isotope fractionation in plants and lead to a more complete understanding of carbon-, oxygen- and hydrogen-isotopic variability in the Earth system 
 
Description Evaluating Isotope Enabled Earth System Models Using Stable Isotopes in Tree Rings 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact Inter-disciplinary meeting resulting in proposals for closer working, collaborative working groups and potential research funding applications.

The potential value of tree ring isotope data in evaluating isotope enabled models was highlighted along with the current limitations in isotope-enabled modelling.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Simultaneous determination of COH isotopes in organic matter 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact Talk led to questions and discussion.

Submitted for publication.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014