Mesoscale Convective Systems: PRobabilistic forecasting and upscale IMpacts in the grey zonE (MCS:PRIME)

Lead Research Organisation: UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD
Department Name: Oxford Physics

Abstract

A Mesoscale Convective System (MCS) is an organisation of many convective thunderstorms, each a few km in scale, into a coherent entity on scales of hundreds of km. We use the term to encompass a range of organised convective phenomena, including squall lines, supercells, and mesoscale convective complexes.

MCS sit at the intersection between weather and climate. On weather timescales, these long-lived systems produce extreme precipitation and flash flooding. Through their coupling to the large-scale circulation, they play a key role in climate phenomena including the Madden Julian Oscillation (MJO), the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ), and the Monsoons. The dynamical coupling is two-way: large-scale environmental conditions dictate the likelihood of convective organisation occurring, while in turn the MCS strongly feedback on the dynamics and thermodynamics of the environment.

Global numerical weather prediction (NWP) models, with grids of 15-20 km, and climate models, with grids of 50-100 km, cannot represent MCS. Our models operate in the "grey zone" where the phenomenon occurs at scales similar to the grid scale. This means that MCS are not fully resolved, but cannot be parametrised using conventional approaches, which assume that the unresolved process occurs on scales much smaller than the grid scale. Biases in the representation of the MJO, Asian Monsoons and ITCZ, as well as too few strong precipitation events, have been linked to deficiencies in the representation of MCS in models. Furthermore, "forecast busts" over the UK, for which the five- to six-day lead time forecast skill drops to around zero across the world's leading NWP centres, have been linked to a poor representation of MCS upstream over North America. We must improve the representation of MCS in weather and climate models.

This project addresses the representation of MCS in the grey zone in a comprehensive and coordinated manner. We will first combine a new global satellite-derived database of MCS with analysis products to assess the predictability of MCS formation and evolution conditioned on the large scales, taking a novel, probabilistic approach. Secondly, several theoretical frameworks have recently been developed which describe the dynamical impact of MCS back onto the large scales. We will critically assess these frameworks, making innovative use of analysis increments from within the data assimilation cycle, to measure the upscale impacts of MCS that are missing from current models.

We will use the fundamental understanding gained to develop a new parametrisation of the dynamical coupling between MCS and the larger scales. We will couple our approach to the new CoMorph convection scheme, which is undergoing trials for operational implementation in the UK Met Office's model. While CoMorph shows substantial improvements in initiating organisation, coupling of MCS to the large scales remains a problem. The representation we develop will be stochastic: we will represent the probability of different MCS tendencies conditioned on the resolved scale flow. Stochastic schemes are well suited to the grey zone, where parametrised motions are poorly constrained by the grid-scale variables, and so are very uncertain.

Evaluating the new parametrisation will critically test the knowledge gained throughout the project. Having validated our knowledge, we will use the scheme to measure the importance of the dynamical impacts of MCS on climate phenomena including the ITCZ and the MJO.

This project will produce a new understanding of the dynamics of MCS formation and upscale impacts. Through close collaboration with the Met Office, we intend to translate this into improved probabilistic forecasts for the UK and wider world. Only with reliable probabilistic forecasts can industry, policy makers, and the humanitarian sector quantify the risks of natural hazards, and act appropriately to protect against those hazards.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The main achievements to date are:

- the implementation of a simple representation of convective organisation into the UK Met Office Unified Model. The scheme improves the representation of the Madden Julien Oscillation and the representation of precipitation in the model (Zhang et al, accepted, JAMES)

- the identification of environmental conditions that lead to convective organisation, including uncertainties associated with these environmental conditions (Muetzelfeldt et al, 2025, JAS)

- the implementation of an improved trigger for the convective organisation scheme, utilising observed predictive relationships between convective organisation and the large-scale state (Muetzelfeldt et al, in prep)
Exploitation Route We have an ongoing collaboration with the UK Met Office to implement the new MCS:PRIME scheme into the Met Office Unified Model. If beneficial, the scheme has the potential to be adopted into the core codebase of the model with positive impacts on all weather and climate predictions made by the Met Office, and associated benefits for users of weather and climate prediction data
Sectors Aerospace

Defence and Marine

Agriculture

Food and Drink

Energy

Environment

Leisure Activities

including Sports

Recreation and Tourism

Government

Democracy and Justice

Transport

 
Description We continue to collaborate closely with the UK Met Office. Our research is feeding directly into their operational weather and climate model. Improved weather and climate forecasts have numerous and varied impacts for all users of Met Office weather and climate information
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Agriculture, Food and Drink,Energy,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Retail,Transport
Impact Types Cultural

Societal

Economic

Policy & public services

 
Description MCS:PRIME Met Office collaboration 
Organisation Meteorological Office UK
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Implementation of Mesoscale Convective System parametrisation in UK Met Office global model. Analysis of UK Met Office "Analysis Increment" dataset. Visits and online meetings with the UK Met Office to update on progress
Collaborator Contribution Provision of proprietary "Analysis Increment" dataset and support with using UK Met Office global model. Scientific input into project.
Impact Mesoscale Convective System parametrisation implemented and tested in Met Office model. Several conference talks and papers relating to research.
Start Year 2022
 
Description MCS:PRIME NCAR collaboration 
Organisation National Center for Atmospheric Research
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Further development of Mesoscale Convection System Parametrisation (MCSP) scheme developed at NCAR, and testing in UKMO model
Collaborator Contribution Support with implementation of MCSP scheme into UKMO model. Scientific input
Impact Working implementation of MCSP scheme in UKMO model Manuscript accepted Zhang, Z., Christensen, H. M., Muetzelfeldt, M. R., Woollings, T., Plant, R. S., Stirling, A. J., Whitall, M. A., Moncrieff, M. W., Chen, C.-C., & Feng, Z. (2024). Advancing organized convection representation in the Unified Model: Implementing and enhancing multiscale coherent structure parameterization. Accepted in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems.
Start Year 2022
 
Description MCS:PRIME PNNL collaboration 
Organisation U.S. Department of Energy
Department Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Extensive analysis of Mesoscale convective system (MCS) dataset to assess observational drivers of MCSs using ERA5 reanalysis data
Collaborator Contribution Provision of MCS tracking dataset. Support using the data. Scientific input
Impact Manuscript published M. R. Muetzelfeldt, R. S. Plant, H. M. Christensen, Z. Zhang, T. Woollings, Z. Feng, and P. Li. Environmental Conditions Affecting Global Mesoscale Convective System Occurrence. J. Atmos. Sci., 82:391-407, 2025.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Oxford Workshop on Model Uncertainty 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The PI acted as lead organiser of the Oxford Workshop on Model Uncertainty, which was held in Oxford Physics from 23-26 September 2024. With over 100 participants from four continents, we enjoyed a week of lively talks, posters, and discussions about model uncertainty and what we should do about it!

Traditionally the weather and climate communities have had very distinct ways of dealing with model uncertainty - this workshop brought those two communities together to learn from each other. The workshop brought together academics, postdoctoral researchers and PhD students with representatives of modelling centres from around the world, as well as from different industries which use weather and climate data (e.g. reinsurance).

A paper detailing the outcomes of the workshop is in preparation
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://oxfordmodeluncertainty.web.ox.ac.uk