Hydroscape:connectivity x stressor interactions in freshwater habitats

Lead Research Organisation: University of Stirling
Department Name: Biological and Environmental Sciences

Abstract

All types of ecosystems exhibit connectivity at some level. However, connectivity is the quintessential property of aquatic systems. Connectivity matters in freshwaters because it is the means by which energy, materials, organisms and genetic resources move within and between hydrological units of the landscape (the 'hydroscape'). Hydrological connectivity is a particularly effective vector for multiple climatic, biological, chemical and physical stressors, although other forms of connectivity also link freshwater ecosystems. Our proposal addresses the fundamental question of how connectivity and stressors interact to determine biodiversity and ecosystem function in freshwaters.
Connectivity is multifaceted. It may be tangible - water moves downhill or over floodplains, or more subtle - terrestrial organic matter is incorporated into aquatic food webs. Animals and people naturally gravitate to freshwaters, thus providing additional dispersal vectors that can carry propagules to isolated sites. Connectivity may be passive or active and occurs across scales from the local to the global. Freshwater scientists recognise the fundamental role of connectivity in key paradigms such as the river continuum and flood pulse concepts. Land-water connectivity is also the founding principle behind catchment management. However, in reality, a long tradition of focusing on individual stressors, sites, taxonomic groups or habitats, has led to a highly disjointed view of the most intrinsically interconnected resource on the planet. While the need for an integrated approach to water management is universally acknowledged, an understanding of this most fundamental part of the infrastructure of freshwaters is lacking. This is a serious obstacle to meeting critical societal challenges, namely the maintenance of environmental sustainability in the face of multiplying human-induced stresses. Without a more integrated view of the freshwater landscape we struggle to answer basic questions. These include (i) how do organisms, nutrients and energy move naturally within and between landscapes? (ii) how is this basic template altered by different stressors, singly or in combination? (iii) how has widespread alteration of land cover and of the basic infrastructure of freshwaters that largely drives connectivity, redistributed pressures and modified their effects? (iv) how should reductions in stressors and changes to connectivity, that are now widely implemented, be prioritised when seeking to restore biodiversity and ecosystem function?
Our primary aims are to (1) determine how hydrological, spatial and biological connectivity impact on freshwater ecosystem structure and function in contrasting landscape types, and (2) use this understanding to forecast how freshwaters nationally will respond to (i) multiple, interacting pressures and (ii) management actions designed to reduce pressures and/or alter connectivity. We will achieve these aims by working at different spatial (landscape vs national) and temporal (sub-annual to decadal vs centennial) scales and using a combination of complementary well established and more novel molecular and stable isotope techniques. We will combine existing data sources (e.g. archived sediment cores, biological surveys and the millions of records held in national databases) with targeted sampling to maximise cost effectiveness and achieve a cross habitat and ecosystem wide reach.
Landscape scale thinking has become the new mantra of nature conservation and environmental bodies but the knowledge needed to ensure resilience to climate change and to underpin large scale conservation and restoration of aquatic landscapes is currently lacking. In this regard an understanding of how biodiversity and ecosystem function respond to the changing connectivity x stressors arena in freshwaters is critical. The outputs of the proposed research will deliver the integrated understanding of the hydroscape that is now required urgently.

Planned Impact

Our project bridges the gap between policy/management needs and state-of-the-art scientific research on the impacts of connectivity and multiple stressors on freshwater ecosystems. Outputs will provide the scientific evidence base and regulatory guidance needed to support the future sustainable management of freshwater landscapes at the local, national and international scale.
Our results will be useful to organisations engaged in waterbody restoration, biological conservation, the control of invasive species and diseases of wildlife and humans. At the national scale, these include organisations such as Scottish Natural Heritage, Natural England, Natural Resources Wales, Environment Agency, Scottish Environment Protection Agency, GB Non-Native Species Secretariat (NNSS), water utility companies, Wildlife Trusts, National Trust, Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, Plantlife, Buglife and the Rivers Trusts, with all of whom we have long established working relationships. More locally, organisations such as the Norfolk Ponds Project, Norfolk Biodiversity Information Service, Norfolk Wildlife Trust, Norfolk Biodiversity Information Service, Norfolk Farming & Wildlife Advisory Group, Natural England, Norfolk Rivers Trust, Broads Authority (a project partner), River Glaven Conservation Group, Cumbria Wildlife Trust, Eden Rivers Trust, Cumbria Biodiversity Data Centre, Forth Fisheries Trust, Scottish Wildlife Trust, Buglife Scotland, and many other similar organisations will also benefit from a better understanding of the links between connectivity and environmental stressors. In particular, we expect the results of this work to challenge the widely held belief that re-connecting isolated waterbodies and removing obstructions to fish migration are essential features of restoration projects. For example, in highly impacted systems, the adverse effect of the spread of invasive species and/or pollution caused by such re-connections may be greater than any benefit provided by links to refugia that can provide biological source material for recolonisation.
At the local level, our research outputs will help water managers improve biodiversity and habitat quality in a sustainable way. This will result in greater amenity value, with local businesses benefitting from more visitors and increased income, and increases in native biodiversity and water quality, which will help meet conservation objectives. Residents, visitors and local schools will gain a better understanding of the links between environmental stressors, connectivity, biodiversity and ecosystem function, especially through their combined impact on ecosystem service provision.
At the UK level, the results will provide environmental and conservation agencies (e.g. EA, SEPA, SNH, NRW, NE, Defra, RSPB) and policy makers with a better understanding of the processes involved in achieving the sustainable management of freshwaters and their catchments. In particular, appreciating that measures aimed at restoring a particular site may be impacted by connectivity across the freshwater landscape.
At an international level, the results are expected to inform the implementation of the 2020 EU Biodiversity Strategy, which aims to "halt the loss of biodiversity and ecosystem services". More specific international beneficiaries are the Directorate General for the Environment (DG Environment) in relation to informing Water Policy (Water Framework Directive) and Biodiversity Policy (Europe 2020). The proposed work on heavy metals pollution links directly to the EU Environmental Quality Standards Directive (2008/105/EC), which has the "aim of ensuring that existing levels of contamination in biota and sediments will not significantly increase....". We are also focusing on trace metals that are currently listed as 'Priority Substances' or 'Priority Hazardous Substances' under the Water Framework Directive.
 
Description The following are among the most significant achievements to date of the Hydroscape project.
• We have developed a novel spatially-explicit suite of within- and between-catchment connectivity measures for all of Britain's lakes. This stretches beyond conventional perspectives on hydrological connectivity to include connectivity driven by human movements and water birds.

• Based on stratified sampling across biota, habitats and landscapes we have evaluated the relative roles of connectivity and stressors in driving freshwater biodiversity. Our findings show that effects may be generalisable across landscapes and broad water body types (e.g. ponds + lakes), but that taxa perceive connectivity differently depending on their mobility (linked to ease of dispersal) and that these effects can differ between native and non-native species. In this context we have demonstrated, in line with our original hypothesis, that some receptors, such as plant diversity, are influenced by the interactive effects of some stressors, such as nutrients and invasions, where interaction strength depends on the degree of isolation of the water body.

• Analyses of sediment and tissue heavy metal burdens across contrasting landscapes confirm that upstream water bodies tend to intercept downstream movement of pollutants but that there is a vast pollutant legacy that has the potential to be mobilised through changes to connectivity.

• Using national scale lake water chemistry monitoring data from the last 20 years we have shown that eutrophication signatures differ between shallow and deep lakes in terms of their sensitivity to indicators of water body connectivity and predation pressure, with such relationships being much better resolved in deep lakes. Drivers of such signatures in lakes from well-populated or more productive landscapes are surprisingly elusive.

• We have established the relative importance of different forms of connectivity in explaining the timing and pattern of invasion across mainland Britain of the120 most high profile non-native freshwater species. Many species are shown to have dispersed via the hydrological network but their developing distribution is the end product of a predictable interaction between human activity, hydrology and taxon mobility. As other recent studies have suggested transport related directly or indirectly to human activity can therefore often override the effect of static spatial measures of connectivity.

• By comparing the pre-1900 aquatic biota derived from sediment core macrofossils and historical archive records with the contemporary biota within the same landscape we challenge the notion of biological reference states; loss of connectivity to host populations post-restoration, coupled with climate-change scenarios is likely to lead to the emergence of novel ecosystems rather than replicas of the original, unless additional interventions are made.
Exploitation Route The importance of connectivity between populations and ecosystems is of interest to all scientists, irrespective of the realm in which they work, and is fundamental to the understanding of how communities are assembled and respond to change. The types of connectivity metrics we have successfully implemented will therefore interest ecologists in general. Our work also complements the rapidly growing awareness of the need to configure the role of connectivity within how society responds to the acute biodiversity crisis in freshwaters, which includes recognition of the importance of barriers to migration and changes in frequency of floods and drought in regulating connectivity between water bodies.

Practitioners are increasingly called upon to restore sites to some form of 'reference condition', in line with Water Framework Directive thinking. While targets such as lowered major nutrient concentrations have a robust underpinning, ecological recovery may lag behind. In particular, convergence with biological reference states used to gauge success may never be achieved if connectivity to source populations of desired species cannot also be re-established. This may require interventions such as translocation to 'bridge the gap' but more than likely we should anticipate novel ecosystems, even having 'done the right thing' environmentally, which may necessitate alternative measures of success.

Managing and responding to biological invasions is a serious and growing concern for freshwater site managers. Our work has highlighted specific pathways and spread mechanisms associated with particular invasive taxa which provides the evidence needed to support better prioritisation of surveillance and management for invasive non-native species.

Overall, our emphasises that connectivity is a double-edged sword whose influence cannot be easily generalised. The natural instinct in restoring freshwaters will be to increase connectivity in line with wider conservation thinking, which may bring benefits in terms of increasing richness, genetic exchange between populations and prospects for natural colonisation by declining species, alongside boosts to ecological resilience. However, the potentially adverse effects of mobilising legacy pollutants and promoting invasive species spread also require careful consideration, potentially on a case-by-case basis.
Sectors Environment,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism

 
Description Data from thousands of specimens of plants, beetles, molluscs and bryozoans has been submitted to national and regional recording networks accessible to the public and specialists, filling many knowledge gaps in the understanding of species distribution, contributing to enhanced awareness of the project and promoting a two way flow of data. This is used out-with the project for biodiversity mapping and assessing changes in population status of individual taxa. Conservation managers, regulators and policy makers have begun using provisional findings in relation to design of conservation networks, risk assessments of altered connectivity, prioritisation of sites for management, measurement of ecological status, design of monitoring networks, and in understanding risks of invasive species spread.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Advanced Training Short Course in Bioassesment
Geographic Reach Europe 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description DEFRA Biodiversity Targets
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Description Invasive Non-Native Species: Strategic Evidence Plan
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Description Presentation to UK Freshwater Task Team
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
 
Description eDNA-based lake fish classification tool for UK agencies
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
Impact Product allows efficient implementation of requirements of the EU Water Framework Directive in the UK around the assessment of fish in lakes using environmental DNA and is thereby directed towards assessing and maintaining ecological quality of water resources
 
Description Monitoring, Modelling And Mitigating Pollution Impacts In A Changing World: Science And Tools For Tomorrow's Rivers
Amount £1,324,471 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/X01620X/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2022 
End 04/2026
 
Title 210Pb-dated historical lake sediment metal concentrations from Greater Glasgow, Scotland (mid-19th century to 2016) 
Description Measurements of sediment properties (including organic and carbonate content), radionuclides (210Pb, 137Cs, 241Am) and elements (including mercury, nickel, copper, zinc, and lead) in lake sediment successions. Radionuclide dating provides a reliable chronology of sediment ages from the mid-19th century (sometimes only 20th century) to the present (2016). The dataset comprises a standardised matrix of multiple measured sediment variables (element values per mass) against stratigraphic depth for 8 lakes. In some water bodies multiple core datasets exist. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact None as yet. 
URL https://catalogue.ceh.ac.uk/id/4b4a2388-fea2-48e8-8d61-4b93ada479bb
 
Title High spatial resolution seasonal distributions of faecally-derived waterborne and sediment bacteria in standing waters, Glasgow, UK, 2016-2017 
Description This dataset contains information about water quality based on faecal indicators at 15 lakes in the Greater Glasgow conurbation, Scotland. Lakes were sampled in winter (2016/17) and summer (2017) with faecal indicators being quantified at high spatial resolution (up to 60 points per lake depending on water body size) in sediment and water from each lake. Faecal indicators were quantified based on standard dilution, membrane filtration and incubation for water, and incubation in bacteria-specific broth, followed by plating and incubation for sediment extracts. Contextual information about water quality, water bird densities, and land cover in different buffer sizes is also provided for each lake. The data were collected to investigate how connectivity and stressors interact to determine biodiversity and ecosystem function in freshwaters. The work was supported by the Natural Environment Research Council grant NE/N006437/1 (Hydroscape: connectivity x stressor interactions in freshwater habitats) 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact None as yet. 
URL https://catalogue.ceh.ac.uk/id/34df30f2-3163-4c11-8743-3732e49220fb
 
Title Invasion of freshwater ecosystems is promoted by network connectivity to hotspots of human activity 
Description Aim: Hotspots of human activity are focal points for ecosystem disturbance and non-native introduction, from which invading populations disperse and spread. As such, connectivity to locations used by humans may influence the likelihood of invasion. Moreover, connectivity in freshwater ecosystems may follow the hydrological network. Here we tested whether multiple forms of connectivity to human recreational activities promotes biological invasion of freshwater ecosystems. Location: England, UK. Time period: 1990-2018. Major taxa studied: 126 non-native freshwater birds, crustaceans, fish, molluscs and plants. Methods: Machine learning was used to predict spatial gradients in human recreation and two high risk activities for invasion (fishing and water sports). Connectivity indices were developed for each activity, in which human influence decayed from activity hotspots according to Euclidean distance (spatial connectivity) or hydrological network distance (downstream, upstream and along-channel connectivity). Generalised linear mixed models identified the connectivity type most associated to invasive species richness of each group, while controlling for other anthropogenic and environmental drivers. Results: Connectivity to humans generally had stronger positive effects on invasion than all other drivers except recording effort. Recreation had stronger influence than urban land cover, and for most groups high risk activities had stronger effects than general recreation. Downstream human connectivity was most important for invasion by most of the groups, potentially reflecting predominantly hydrological dispersal. An exception was birds, for which spatial connectivity was most important, possibly because of overland dispersal capacity. Main conclusions: These findings support the hypothesis that freshwater invasion is partly determined by an interaction between human activity and species dispersal in the hydrological network. By comparing alternative connectivity types for different human activities, our approach could enable robust inference of specific pathways and spread mechanisms associated with particular taxa. This would provide evidence to support better prioritisation of surveillance and management for invasive non-native species. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL http://datadryad.org/stash/dataset/doi:10.5061/dryad.18931zcs6
 
Title List of UK Freshwater Taxa 
Description Provides comprehensive listing of freshwater biota in the UK Gunn, I.D.M.; Carvalho, L.; Davies, C.E.; Edwards, F.K.; Furse, M.T.; Maitland, P.S.; Raper, C.; Siriwardena, G.M.; Winfield, I.J. (2018). UK Checklist of freshwater species. NERC Environmental Information Data Centre. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Unknown as yet. Available from July 2018 and publicised via Twitter and CEH website. 
URL https://doi.org/10.5285/57653719-434b-4b11-9f0d-3bd76054d8bd
 
Description Lake fish eDNA classification tool development 
Organisation University of Hull
Department School of Biological, Biomedical and Environmental Sciences
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Modelling of fish eDNA distribution in relation to lake connectivity and other environmental data
Collaborator Contribution Lake sampling, eDNA extraction and metabarcoding and interpretation
Impact Water Framework Directive compliant tool for classifying ecological status of lakes using fish eDNA
Start Year 2018
 
Description Article in BTO News magazine 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Article in BTO News by Stirling and BTO staff on role of connectivity in shaping distribution of freshwater organisms (too recent to identify impact)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://hydroscapeblog.wordpress.com/2019/01/24/connectivity-too-much-of-a-good-thing/
 
Description Blogs on Hydroscape project web site 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Web site and associated blogs used to communicate non technical information on project background and activities being undertaken by project team, especially to report on work in the field. Approx 5000 web site hits.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016,2017
URL https://hydroscapeblog.wordpress.com/about/
 
Description Cumbria Biodiversity Centre Annual Mtg 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presentation and questions with 90 amateur and professional members of biological recording network in Cumbria to explain the project, importance of connectivity, and how data submitted by recorders was being used and how data generated within the project would contribute to enhanced coverage of key taxonomic groups within Cumbria
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Eco LIFE+ conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presentation and panel session on role of connectivity in conservation planning and network design discussing positive and negative aspects of connectivity with conservation practitioners
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description European Ponds Conservation Network 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presentation to large international audience of mainly European scientists and practitioners engaged in management of freshwater systems where the role of different forms of connectivity as a driving influence on isolated systems was emphasised
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description European Ponds Conservation Network 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presentation to large international audience of mainly European scientists and practitioners engaged in management of freshwater systems where the role of different forms of connectivity as a driving influence on isolated systems was emphasised
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Scottish Natural Heritage Freshwater and Wetland Specialist Group 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Talk and Q&A session on Hydroscape project and role of connectivity in freshwaters and opportunities to restore freshwater ecosystems via altered connectivity
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Water quality management meeting (Strathclyde) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Attended working group meeting on lake management to advise on outcomes of microbial monitoring and its implications. Engagement with industry professionals refined focus of interest and highlighted opportunities for collaborative working
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017