The Distribution of Oxygen in Earth's mantle

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Earth Sciences

Abstract

The exchange of oxygen between the mantle and surface environment is a key component of Earth's geochemical cycle. Oxygen plays a role in generation of magma within the earth and the transfer of volatile elements like sulfur, carbon and hydrogen from the solid earth into molten rock. When such magma rises towards the surface, volcanic gases are released, driving or regulating the composition of Earth's atmosphere. It is therefore increasingly accepted that variation in the oxygen content of Earth's mantle is closely linked to Earth's habitability as a planet.

Basaltic magma is generated by melting the mantle. Therefore, the composition of samples of basaltic volcanoes carries information about the composition of the underlying mantle. However, many processes modify the magma's composition from the point of generation at depth to eruption at the surface. The generation of the melt itself, its crystallisation in the shallow crust and the loss of volcanic gases near the surface all change the composition of magma. It is therefore necessary to account for these processes in order to understand the chemical characteristics of the mantle. Previous attempts to study variation in the oxygen content of the mantle have made simplifying assumptions about these processes. However, progress in theoretical understanding of elemental behaviour indicates that the correcting assumptions need to be revisited. One startling feature of the previous studies is that they come to very different conclusions about the distribution of oxygen in the mantle. The current uncertainty in the oxygen content of the upper mantle corresponds to a number of oxygen atoms that is about 100 times that present in the atmosphere!

We think that part of this discrepancy is caused by the sets of assumptions that previous investigators have made. A crucial component of our project is therefore to use new theoretical and observational constraints to understand how the processes in magmatic systems modify the chemistry of basalt. We have carefully chosen our target geologic setting: Iceland has plentiful basalts that are well studied in terms of traditional chemical compositions and therefore provide us with the extensive background information we need to underpin our models. Once we have improved models by adding our new observations, we can better focus our map of the variation in the oxidation state of the Earth's mantle.

In detail, our research will involve a great deal of painstaking geochemical work. We aim to use the isotopic composition of the element vanadium, because theoretical work and preliminary experimental studies indicate that the behaviour of vanadium and its isotopes is strongly controlled by mantle oxidation state. By combining new constraints from vanadium isotopes with other geochemical measurements that are thought to be sensitive to mantle oxygen, we can construct a model of oxidation state across the Iceland. The combination of several independent chemical constraints allows us to determine just how much variation in oxygen there is beneath this classic locality. Furthermore, it equips the community with a precise tool to extract global variations in mantle oxidation.

Planned Impact

Industrial Beneficiaries:
-FEI (high performance microscopy company) - Direct benefit;
-Mineral Resource and Energy companies - Indirect benefit.

FEI sells many QEMSCAN imaging systems to industry every year. The importance of quantifying the mineral compositions in ore rocks is clear for mining companies, and hydrocarbon companies use QEMSCAN for understanding reservoir quality. QEMSCAN converts EDS data into mineral-composition maps using a SIP file. We will develop a SIP file for mafic/ultramafic rocks and will share this with FEI. They may then use this file in combination with other companies to improve characteristion of ore-bearing rocks, with crucial global economic influence. We will also generate beautiful high resolution images that FEI may use in their marketing of the QEMSCAN system. The project PDRA and the summer students on the project will develop experience with QEMSCAN - a skill that will be very attractive to mining and hydrocarbon companies that use the software.

Educational Beneficiaries:
-Public/undergraduates/postgraduates via Imperial Rock Library -Direct;
-Industries requiring petrographic ability - Indirect.
-UK education via promotion of STEM subjects - Direct

The Imperial College London Rock Library is a database of rocks and minerals specifically designed as a university level training, evaluation and reference resource. Through easy access to thousands of examples of minerals, textures and rock types, straightforward online identification tools, training activities and evaluation tests the Rock Library provides a unique set of tools to ensure Earth Scientists obtain and maintain a high level of practical ability without requiring direct access to microscopes and hand specimens. The Rock Library and currently attracts 400,000 users per year from almost every country, most of which are undergraduates, postgraduates and industry geologists. However, there is a lack of basaltic examples in general and Icelandic examples specifically. Our work will address this by making high quality QEMSCAN images available to the Rock Library, thus expanding its technologic repertoire.

Encouraging the next generation of scientists is a fundamental responsibility of academia. We approach this by using 'student reporters' who will document the course of the work by participation in field work and subsequently following the samples they have witnessed being collected as they are converted into high quality, meaningful chemical data. Student reporters will inform both their peers and the general public through outreach including, but not limited to, the Imperial Festival, blogs, vlogs, and Imperial's Earth Class. Earth Class is specifically aimed at year 9 and 10 students who will be considering further education. We hope to generate excitement and enthusiams for STEM subjects in general, and our work in particular by portraying the journey of the work through the eyes of the young student reporters.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Novella D (2020) A multi-proxy investigation of mantle oxygen fugacity along the Reykjanes Ridge in Earth and Planetary Science Letters

 
Description Reliable method for high-precision analysis of V-isotope composition of basalts. We have also found a way of exploring how oxygen is recycled by plate tectonic and mantle convection processes. We found that V-isotopes are remarkably invariant in young volcanic rocks from the sea-floor south of Iceland. We developed a method to link these observations, along with trace element and iron oxidation state measurements, to the composition and extent of oxidation of the solid Earth under Iceland. We found that recycling of ancient oceanic crust may play a key role in defining the mantle composition under Iceland and investigated the consequences of this finding for elemental cycling I the Earth System.
Exploitation Route Methods used by other geochemistry labs. The V-isotope dataset is being acquired from samples that are also being studied for other isotopic and geochemical quantities in other labs - this will lead to collaborative synthesis of the results.
Sectors Energy,Environment,Other

 
Description BGI research grant
Amount € 2,000 (EUR)
Organisation University of Bayreuth 
Sector Academic/University
Country Germany
Start 02/2018 
End 02/2018
 
Description Deep Carbon Observatory (DCO) Early Career Scientist Workshop Travel Grant (to Novella - PDRA)
Amount € 500 (EUR)
Organisation Deep Carbon Observatory 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United States
Start 07/2017 
End 11/2017
 
Description Italian Society of Mineralogy and Petrology (SIMP) Conference Grant - (PDRA Novella)
Amount € 150 (EUR)
Organisation Italian Society of Mineralogy and Petrology 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Italy
Start 07/2017 
End 12/2017
 
Description Unlocking the C and N budget of the Earth
Amount £437,287 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/V011383/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2021 
End 04/2024
 
Title A multi-proxy investigation of mantle oxygen fugacity along the Reykjanes Ridge 
Description Mantle oxygen fugacity (fO2) governs the physico-chemical evolution of the Earth, however current estimates from commonly used basalt redox proxies are often in disagreement. In this study we compare three different potential basalt fO2 proxies: Fe3+/Fetot, V/Sc and V isotopes, determined on the same submarine lavas from a 700 km section of the Reykjanes Ridge, near Iceland. These samples provide a valuable test of the sensitivities of fO2 proxies to basalt petrogenesis, as they formed at different melting conditions and from a mantle that towards Iceland exhibits increasing long-term enrichment of incompatible elements. New trace element data were determined for 63 basalts with known Fe3+/Fetot. A subset of 19 lavas, covering the geographical spread of the ridge transect, was selected for vanadium isotope analyses. Vanadium is a multi-valence element whose isotopic fractionation is theoretically susceptible to redox conditions. Yet, the d51VAA composition of basaltic glasses along the Reykjanes Ridge covers only a narrow range (d51VAA= -1.09 to -0.86‰; 1SD= 0.02-0.09) and does not co-vary with fractionation-corrected Fe3+/Fetot (0.134-0.151; 1SD= 0.005) or V/Sc (6.6-8.5; 1SD= 0.1-1.3) ratios. However, on a global scale, basaltic d51VAA may be controlled by the extent of melting. The V/Sc compositions of primitive (MgO > 7.5 wt%) basalts show no systematic change along the entire length of the Reykjanes Ridge. Typical peridotite melting models in which source Fe3+/Fetot is constant at 5% and that account for the increased mantle potential temperature nearer the plume center and the fO2 dependent partitioning of V, can reproduce the V/Sc data. However, while these melting models predict that basalt Fe3+/Fetot ratios should decrease with increasing mantle potential temperature towards Iceland, fractionation-corrected Fe3+/Fetot of Reykjanes Ridge lavas remain nearly constant over the ridge length. This discrepancy is explained by source heterogeneity, where an oxidized mantle pyroxenite component contributes to melting with increasing proximity to Iceland. Comparison of observed and modeled Fe3+/Fetot indicate that source variation in fO2 is present under the Reykjanes Ridge, with higher Fe3+/Fetot closer to Iceland. This source variability in fO2 cannot be resolved by V isotopes and redox-sensitive trace element ratios, which instead appear to record magmatic processes. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This dataset is an an important contribution to the development of a global model of the stable isotope composition of basalts. This is a rapidly expanding field and new models and datasets and revealing the relative importance of process (e.g. mantle melting) and source in controlling these compositions. 
URL https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/299149
 
Description Cheltenham Science Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact PDRA Novella accompanied GeoBus activties at Cheltenham festival
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.cheltenhamfestivals.com/science/
 
Description Fieldwork twitter account and blog 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This was a fieldwork blog that was generated by two undergraduate students that accompanied us on fieldwork.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018
URL https://lavatolab.wordpress.com/author/xenia268/