measure for measure: female responses to the social and sexual environment.

Lead Research Organisation: University of East Anglia
Department Name: Biological Sciences

Abstract

We respond to our environments in all sorts of ways, generally to fit in or become more competitive - such responses are usually beneficial, though can also be expressed in a pathological manner as so-called 'gang' or 'lad' culture. As an example of a social / sexual response, we may often adopt the speech patterns or mannerisms of the people we are talking to in an unknowing effort to ease communication. The animal world is full of analogous examples. Males in groups perceive that they are under a potentially elevated risk of competition for mates and matings. Hence such males may compete more strongly for matings, elevate their courtship rituals, mate for longer and transfer more sperm and ejaculate proteins when they do mate. These effects have been shown to benefit males that are subject to reproductive competition by allowing them to increase their investment in reproduction when it is relevant to do so.

Our work shows that females also show substantial variation in responses to males, mating and sexual context. However, virtually nothing is yet known about the significance of these responses. Unlike for males, we do not know the benefits of responding to the sexual environment, nor what the consequences are for the female's offspring. This is especially important as parental social experience can influence offspring performance through non-genetic effects. Hence mothers may be able to 'prepare' their offspring for the prevailing competitive environment.

Hence, we conclude that both sexes can express considerable plasticity in responses to the environment, which offers much raw material upon which natural selection can act. Yet the significance of all this genetic variation remains a mystery.

In addition, given that both sexes can exhibit reproductive plasticity (e.g. in how much investment to make in each reproductive episode) it is surprising that we don't yet know what the sum contribution of these effects is to an individual's overall reproductive success. When both mating partners are in agreement with one another over reproductive decisions, then '2 partner plasticity' should increase overall reproductive success. However, if there is conflict, as there often is, then the benefits of plasticity expressed by each partner may cancel each other out.

All these ideas have never previously been tested.

We propose here a highly novel research programme to tackle big gaps in our understanding of sexual plasticity in females. We will use fully genome-sequenced 'iso-female' lines. These offer the potential to measure the extent of genetic variation in each of the experiments we will conduct and, in the future, to pin down the genome regions associated with each reproductive character in much the same way as tests of genes 'for' specific diseases are conducted by medical researchers.

We have 3 broad aims:

1. To measure the benefits for females of expressing reproductive plasticity.
2. To discover whether females can signal the likely competitive environment into which their male and female offspring will emerge.
3. To discover how the plastic responses of male and females interact.

The results will contribute significantly to our fundamental understanding of reproductive decisions made by males and females. They will also reveal the mechanisms by which females can sense competition and signal competitiveness to future generations.

Planned Impact

The proposed work is expected to generate significant impacts - we describe below who will benefit and the mechanisms in place to show how that impact will be achieved.

1. DISSEMINATION OF FUNDAMENTAL SCIENCE ACROSS ACADEMIC AND PUBLIC DOMAINS: A wealth of data on the different facets of plasticity in different environments will be generated. These data are expected to be the springboard for further future studies by us and by other researchers. These impacts will be delivered by the PI, Researcher Co-I and Co-I through published papers, press releases, science blogs, twitter, conferences and reports. Public dissemination will be achieved through the whole team via the diverse outreach and engagement activities specified in the pathways plan. Collectively we have a strong record in such activities (local and national public exhibitions such as at the Royal Society, Norwich Forum, Sainsbury Centre for Visual Arts, blogging and twitter). We see several possibilities for research outcomes to gain the attention of a broad audience:

(i) Sexual plasticity: there are strong potential impacts arising from understanding basic processes such as who mates with who, why and the resulting consequences. This impact will be disseminated to researchers in this field using the research expertise and research links of the whole team.

(ii) Divergence: ultimately we wish to understand the role of plasticity in females and males in contributing to evolutionary change - in this project we will identify the processes underpinning such processes. This information should prove important in terms of both public impact and further research in this area, especially given the opportunity to manipulate different sets of genes in order to start to probe causality (and thus ultimately to identify the gene regions responsible). Theory reveals the likely role of both males and female plasticity in contributing to phenotypic variation. Our experiments should yield important additional anchoring data for those studies. The PI and Co-Is will drive this potential impact through public exhibitions and talks, with which they have a good level of experience.

(iii) Divergent reproductive strategies: we will gain much needed information on differences in female responses to their environments. This impact is expected to be realised in the public domain through its intrinsic interest and via our mechanisms for engagement.

2. NOVEL METHODS OF INSECT CONTROL. The proposed work is relevant to the potential for understanding, manipulating and improving the sexual performance of mass-reared insects subject to mass release programmes for control. Our data will highlight mechanisms by which individuals can respond their environments and identify new candidate loci that could be manipulated for control. We have strong links with the applied insect research community (PI in PhD projects with Oxitec, Pirbright and Ecospray Ltd). To elaborate: the PI has previously held 2 NERC iCASE PhD studentships with Oxford Insect technologies (Oxitec Ltd), two more CASE studentships started in Oct 2015 (Institute of Animal Health and a further industry-funded PhD studentship with Oxitec). Oxitec were also a Project Partner on a BBSRC grant BB/K000489/1. These active, ongoing relationships have cemented relevant industry contacts and strong research links to the applied community.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Dore AA (2018) The role of complex cues in social and reproductive plasticity. in Behavioral ecology and sociobiology

publication icon
Dore AA (2021) Plastic male mating behavior evolves in response to the competitive environment. in Evolution; international journal of organic evolution

publication icon
Hotzy C (2022) Evolutionary history of sexual selection affects microRNA profiles in Drosophila sperm. in Evolution; international journal of organic evolution

 
Description So far on this project we have discovered that females are every bit as responsive as are males to their social and sexual context. Females that exposed to other females prior to mating are slower to mate. We are currently testing whether this is an effect of exposure to females / males of the same / closely-related species, specifically. The results are interesting in the context of whether females respond to competition per se or to food / oviposition site availability.

We discovered that females secrete public goods on their eggs, leading to follow up funding NE/T007133/1 from NERC. We also now know the cues used by fermales to respond to each other and have submitted that research to ELife.

Fowler EK, Leigh SA, Rostant WG, Thomas A, Bretman A & Chapman T. Female fruitflies use gustatory cues to plastically alter fecundity in response to the social environment.

The following publications are arising:

Rostant WR, Fowler EK & Chapman T. (2020) Sexual conflict theory: concepts and empirical tests. The SAGE Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology, edited by Todd Shackelford.

Fowler EK, Bradbury T, Moxon S, Chapman T. (2019) Sex-specific transcriptional responses to mating in D. melanogaster. Scientific Reports published.

Dore AA, Bretman A & Chapman T. (2020) Fitness consequences of redundant cues of competition in male D. melanogaster. Ecology and Evolution, Published.

Dore AA, Rostrant WG, Bretman A & Chapman T. Plastic male mating behaviour evolves in response to the competitive environment. Evolution, published.

Dore AA*, Fowler EK*, Bretman A, Mohorianu I & Chapman T. Redundant networks and alternative expression pathways: a test case using conspecific competitive responses in male fruitflies. Ecology and Evolution in revision.

Fowler, E.K., Leigh, S., Bretman, A. and Chapman, T., 2021. Reproductive plasticity in both sexes interacts to determine mating behaviour and fecundity. bioRxiv.
Exploitation Route To improve insect husbandry for pest insect control, potentially. As a novel test of social evolution theory, as indicated by the successful award of follow up research grant funding.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

 
Description BBSRC DTP PhD studentship
Amount £100,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2022 
End 09/2026
 
Description BBSRC DTP studentship to T Chapman and W Haerty on sexual detection - social responses in fruitflies
Amount £100,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2019 
End 09/2023
 
Description I see / smell / touch / hear and therefore I am: sex differences in perception alter survival and reproduction
Amount £643,797 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/W005174/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2022 
End 03/2025
 
Description NERC standard discovery research grant
Amount £800,000 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/T007133/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2020 
End 08/2023
 
Title A More Standardized Method for Imaging and Measuring Drosophila Thorax Length Using ImageJ 
Description Thorax measurements are important metrics of Drosophila fitness and are often correlated with key life history traits such as lifespan and fecundity. Therefore, thorax length is a widely used measure in studies of genetic variation and plasticity in response to environmental alterations. However, the lack of fixed landmarks means that thorax measurements can sometimes be inconsistent and highly variable. Here we outline a dorsal bristle-guided method of thorax measurements, which we could use to draw a reliable and repeatable line from the thorax scutellum to the anterior thorax edge. We analyzed and compared this bristle-guided marker method to a non-landmark based thorax measurement, in a set of measures of female and male D. melanogaster. We found that the bristle-guided method exhibited significantly less variation between technical replicates than did the non-landmark based measure. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://figshare.com/articles/dataset/A_More_Standardized_Method_for_Imaging_and_Measuring_Drosophil...
 
Title A More Standardized Method for Imaging and Measuring Drosophila Thorax Length Using ImageJ 
Description Thorax measurements are important metrics of Drosophila fitness and are often correlated with key life history traits such as lifespan and fecundity. Therefore, thorax length is a widely used measure in studies of genetic variation and plasticity in response to environmental alterations. However, the lack of fixed landmarks means that thorax measurements can sometimes be inconsistent and highly variable. Here we outline a dorsal bristle-guided method of thorax measurements, which we could use to draw a reliable and repeatable line from the thorax scutellum to the anterior thorax edge. We analyzed and compared this bristle-guided marker method to a non-landmark based thorax measurement, in a set of measures of female and male D. melanogaster. We found that the bristle-guided method exhibited significantly less variation between technical replicates than did the non-landmark based measure. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://figshare.com/articles/dataset/A_More_Standardized_Method_for_Imaging_and_Measuring_Drosophil...
 
Title Data from: Fitness consequences of redundant cues of competition in male D. melanogaster 
Description Phenotypic plasticity can allow animals to adapt their behaviour, such as their mating effort, to their social and sexual environment. However, this relies on the individual receiving accurate and reliable cues of the environmental conditions. This can be achieved via the receipt of multimodal cues, which may provide redundancy and robustness. Male Drosophila melanogaster detect presence of rivals via combinations of any two or more redundant cue components (sound, smell and touch) and respond by extending their subsequent mating duration, which is associated with higher reproductive success. Although alternative combinations of cues of rival presence have previously been found to elicit equivalent increases in mating duration and offspring production, their redundancy in securing success under sperm competition has not previously been tested. Here, we explicitly test this by exposing male D. melanogaster to alternative combinations of rival cues, and examine reproductive success in both the presence and absence of sperm competition. The results supported previous findings of redundancy of cues in terms of behavioural responses. However, there was no evidence of reproductive benefits accrued by extending mating duration in response to rivals. The lack of identifiable fitness benefits of longer mating under these conditions, both in the presence and absence of sperm competition, contrasted with some previous results, but could be explained by: 1) damage sustained from aggressive interactions with rivals leading to reduced ability to increase ejaculate investment, 2) presence of features of the social environment, such as male and female mating status, that obscured the fitness benefits of longer mating, 3) decoupling of behavioural investment with fitness benefits. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL http://datadryad.org/stash/dataset/doi:10.5061/dryad.v9s4mw6rt
 
Title Raw data for Leigh et al 2020: Satyrization in Drosophila fruiflies 
Description The satyr of Greek mythology was half-man, half-goat, with an animal persona signifying immoderate sexual appetites. In biology, satyrization is the disruption of reproduction in matings between closely-related species. Interestingly, its effects are often reciprocally asymmetric, manifesting more strongly in one direction of heterospecific mating than the other. Heterospecific matings are well known to result in female fitness costs due to the production of sterile or inviable hybrid offspring and can also occur due to reduced female sexual receptivity, lowering the likelihood of any subsequent conspecific matings. Here we investigated the costs and mechanisms of satyrization in the Drosophila melanogaster species subgroup of fruitflies. The results showed that D. simulans females experienced higher fitness costs from a loss of remating opportunites due to significantly reduced post-mating sexual receptivity, than D. melanogaster females, as a result of reciprocal heterospecific matings. Reciprocal tests of the effects of male reproductive accessory gland protein (Acp) injections on female receptivity in pairwise comparisons between D. melanogaster and five other species within the melanogaster species subgroup revealed significant post-mating receptivity asymmetries. This was due to variation in the effects of heterospecific Acps within species with which D. melanogaster can mate heterospecifically, and significant but non-asymmetric Acp effects in species with which it cannot. We conclude that asymmetric satyrization due to post-mating effects of Acps may be common among diverging and hybridising species. The findings are of interest in understanding the evolution of reproductive isolation and species divergence. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL http://datadryad.org/stash/dataset/doi:10.5061/dryad.0zpc866wc
 
Title Raw data for: Plastic male mating behaviour evolves in response to the competitive environment 
Description Male reproductive phenotypes can evolve in response to the social and sexual environment. The expression of many such phenotypes may also be plastic within an individual's lifetime. For example, male Drosophila melanogaster show significantly extended mating duration following a period of exposure to conspecific male rivals. The costs and benefits of reproductive investment, and plasticity itself, can be shaped by the prevailing socio-sexual environment and by resource availability. We investigated these ideas using experimental evolution lines of D. melanogaster evolving under three fixed sex ratios (high, medium and low male-male competition) on either rich or poor adult diets. We found that males evolving in high-competition environments evolved longer mating durations overall. In addition, these males expressed a novel type of plastic behavioural response following exposure to rival males: they both significantly reduced and showed altered courtship delivery and exhibited significantly longer mating latencies. Plasticity in male mating duration in response to rivals was maintained in all of the lines, suggesting that the costs of plasticity were minimal. None of the evolutionary responses tested were consistently affected by dietary resource regimes. Collectively, the results show that fixed behavioural changes and new augmentations to the repertoire of reproductive behaviours can evolve rapidly. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL http://datadryad.org/stash/dataset/doi:10.5061/dryad.qz612jmcg
 
Title Raw data for: Plastic responses of males and females interact to determine mating behaviour 
Description Individuals can respond plastically to variation in their social environment. However, each sex may respond to different cues and contrasting aspects of competition. Theory suggests that the plastic phenotype expressed by one sex can influence evolutionary dynamics in the other, and that plasticity simultaneously expressed by both sexes can exert sex-specific effects on fitness. However, data are needed to test this theory base. Here, we examined whether the simultaneous expression of adaptive plasticity by both sexes of Drosophila melanogaster fruit flies in response to their respective social environments interacts to determine the value of key reproductive traits (mating latency, duration and fecundity). To vary social environments, males were kept alone, or with same sex rivals, and females were kept alone, in same-sex, or mixed-sex groups. Matings were then conducted between individuals from all of these 5 social treatments in all combinations, and the resulting reproductive traits measured in both 'choice' and 'no choice' assays. Mating latency was determined by an interaction between the plastic responses of both sexes to their social environments. Interestingly, the mating latency response occurred in opposing directions in the different assays. In females exposed to same-sex social treatments, mating latency was more rapid with rival treatment males in the choice assays, but slower with those same males in no choice assays. In contrast, mating duration was determined purely by responses of males to their social environments, and fecundity purely by responses of females. Collectively, the results show that plastic responses represent an important and novel facet of sexual interactions. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL http://datadryad.org/stash/dataset/doi:10.5061/dryad.3tx95x6jc