UK:Development of a marketable nanoparticle-assisted high-throughput prototype system for chemical speciation measurements of trace elements (DIFFNAL)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Earth Sciences

Abstract

Polluted water, soil and air are responsible for the diseases that kill at least nine million people worldwide and cost trillions of dollars every year according to a recent research. Contamination with trace elements such as arsenic, mercury, and chromium of an increasing ecological and global public health concern and at the top of the list for environmental legislations. The mobility and toxicity of trace elements depends especially on their chemical forms (or species) rather than their total content. For example, while trivalent chromium (chromite) can be considered a dietary supplement, hexavalent chromium (chromate) is toxic and potentially carcinogenic.

Because different elemental species exhibit very different physiochemical properties and varying toxicities, it is becoming vital and increasingly demanded by many regulatory, health and safety organisations to measure and monitor these individual toxic elemental species in the environment. However, the current lacking in any robust speciation technique limits our ability to monitor and control environmental pollution. This lack of analytical ability also poses a challenge to many other branches of analytical chemistry. We have recently developed a novel device (termed DIFFNAL) that has the potential to provide rapid analysis of speciation of a wide variety of samples. This combines membrane technology with design of novel sortable active nanomaterials with special characteristics. This proposal seeks to build and commercialise a DIFFNAL device for chromium speciation. This project also seeks to form an Oxford University spin-out company that would build and commercialise new lines of the technology including single analyte and multi-analyte DIFFNAL instruments.

DIFFNAL is a completely novel technology for the following reasons:
1- Highly sensitive and selective ion separation technology
2- Single-step and fast separation (< 10 min) with no or minimum sample handling
3- No specialised user training required
4- An environmentally friendly technology as no harmful reagents or solvents required.
5- Capability to re-sample quickly and to process a large number of samples per day
6- Critically, it maintains the 'chemical character' and distribution of species and hence reflects the 'true' fractionation of species in a sample, making it the only available technology capable of analysing air-sensitive or unstable samples.

The Oxford-Teledyne consortium specific aims are to:
1. Develop a functional single analyte DIFFNAL alpha-prototype system for chromium speciation in different types of matrixes including environmental samples.

2. Preliminary coupling tests of the DIFFNAL device with an ICP-OES. This initial coupling with ICP-OES is favoured over ICP-MS because of it simplicity and potential commercialisation due to low cost.

3. Benchmark the performance of DIFFNAL against existing technologies including the coupled HPLC-ICP-MS. Our initial analytical testing will be carried out using our existing Voltammtery-DIFFNAL system vs HPLC-ICP-MS.

4. Upon evaluation of the performance parameters, to develop marketing material and an investment prospectus for DIFFNAL technology.

5. An Oxford University spin-out company (NanoMetalytics) with be formed. The new spin-out will be responsible for the development of single- and multi-analyte DIFFNAL speciation systems for priority contaminants.

The DIFFNAL system has already been patented as a speciation technology. As such this technology presents the instrumental analytical sector with a novel approach for a novel, effective and low-cost chemical speciation technology. Given the increasing global pressure on regulating environmental contaminants and environmental monitoring of trace elements and the associated costs for chemical speciation, innovation in this area is extremely timely.

Keywords: DIFFNAL, Chemical Speciation; trace elements; water pollution, Mass spectrometry, ICP-MS, ICP-OES

Planned Impact

The DIFFNAL instrument has a potential to dramatically increase the speed and flexibility of analysis of chemical speciation, and would be a 'game changing' in many applications of analytical chemistry. Besides the importance of DIFFNAL as a tool for facilitating toxicological studies and environmental monitoring, it is expected to play a major role in key industries such as mining. For example, understanding cyanide speciation would help reducing costs and waste by selecting the most appropriate form (free cyanide vs thiocyanate) in gold exploration. Speciation analysis also helps in assessing the risks posed by discharge or treatment process and help optimising the performance of technical processes.

This project has major potential impacts on the global analytical market, in environmental, economic and societal terms. Environmental and economic benefits that will accrue directly through the Oxford-Teledyne collaboration as a result of the proposed project include:

1- Commercialisation of an academic invention through a new collaboration with a private sector company;

2- Development of a novel technology for a diversity of chemical speciation measurements whilst offering significantly enhanced performance compared to that of existing technologies;

3- Establishment of a new spin-out company and technology for export;

4- Enhancement of existing toxic element regulations and standard methods through development of a "step-changing" technology;

5- Provision of significant cost savings to a wide range of analytical laboratories and a contribution to improving water treatment and risk assessment sectors.

6- Through Teledyne and its sub-contractors, the UK will benefit from equipment sales and license of IP.

Specific benefits that will accrue outside the Oxford-Teledyne collaboration include:

1- An increase in economic activity, triggered through the use of the DIFFNAL product internationally in the private sector;
2- Enhanced activity throughout the technology manufacturing supply chain;
3- The international market will benefit from a new generation of chemical speciation technology;
4- Increased environmental quality standards will be achieved;
5- Security of clean water supply will be realised through enabling novel approaches for routine chemical speciation of trace elements in conjunction with appropriate contaminant control technologies.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description COVID - UKRI additional funds
Amount £92,951 (GBP)
Funding ID JTR00060 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2020 
End 09/2021
 
Title Chemical speciation device to enables onsite test for water toxicity 
Description We developed and patented a working benchtop prototype for metal speciation measurements, in which highly selective ligand-capped magnetic nano-composite materials are used to separate ionic species from solutions in a single step and in < 10 min. The primary innovation is to miniaturise this benchtop prototype and to create the world's first portable, handheld-sized and compact microfluidic electrochemical speciation sensor. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The new method has been patented (https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/07/6c/ff/340bb6fa71cacd/US20200158704A1.pdf), which has resulted in a University of Oxford spinout aiming to continue the R&D journey of the new technology. 
URL https://innovation.ox.ac.uk/licence-details/diffnal-element-separation-chemical-speciation-biologica...
 
Description Oxford-Teledyne partnership 
Organisation Teledyne Advanced Chemistry Systems
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Expertise in analytical instrumentation, nanochemistry and chemical speciation of elements.
Collaborator Contribution Engineering time, technical advice, engineering parts and small equipment.
Impact 1- Development of Technology Know-how 2- Development of a benchtop prototype system for chemical speciation in water 3- Increased understanding of engineering challenges, product development pathways and market needs.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Oxford-Teledyne partnership 
Organisation Teledyne Technologies International Corp
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Expertise in analytical instrumentation, nanochemistry and chemical speciation of elements.
Collaborator Contribution Engineering time, technical advice, engineering parts and small equipment.
Impact 1- Development of Technology Know-how 2- Development of a benchtop prototype system for chemical speciation in water 3- Increased understanding of engineering challenges, product development pathways and market needs.
Start Year 2019
 
Title SEPARATION METHOD USING AN ION EXCHANGER AND A DRAW SOLUTION COMPRISING ADSORBER PARTICLES 
Description A method for separating ionic species from an analyte solution to form a fractionated sample, the method comprising contacting the analyte solution with an ion-exchanger that is selectively permeable to ionic species of either a positive or negative charge, contacting an opposing side of the ion-exchanger with a draw solution, wherein the draw solution comprises adsorber particles dispersed in a liquid carrier, establishing a concentration gradient across the ion-exchanger to allow at least some ionic species from the analyte solution to permeate through the ion-exchanger to the draw solution, adsorbing ionic species that permeate from the analyte solution onto the adsorber particles, separating adsorber particles having the ionic species adsorbed thereto from at least part of the draw solution, and eluting the ionic species from the separated adsorber particles to form a fractionated analyte sample comprising eluted ionic species. 
IP Reference WO2018229031 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2018
Licensed Commercial In Confidence
Impact -Development of new know-how -New intellectual property (filed)
 
Company Name NANOLYSE TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED 
Description Nanolyse is creating miniaturised, portable and low cost chemical sensing capabilities to address global testing and monitoring needs across industries, from water, environmental and food to biomedical and healthcare industries. Nanolyse Technologies Ltd was founded in 2020, by an Oxford academic, Dr Imad Ahmed (Executive Director and CTO). The company Director is Dr Graham Hine, a highly successful technology entrepreneur with a track record in leading, growing and successfully exiting technology companies. Nanolyse's advisors and consultants are Professor Peter Dobson, former director of Oxford University's Begbroke Science Park and renowned expert and academic in nanotechnology and biosensors, and Gideon Henderson, Professor of Earth Sciences at the Department of Earth Sciences in the University of Oxford and Chief scientific advisor to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. 
Year Established 2020 
Impact Nanolyse is a young (< 12 month-old) company but the following impacts are notable: 1- Knowledge creation related to chemical separation and sensing of reactive molecules in water 2- Knowledge application: working with collaborators, partners and others to implement knowledge and learning in building new systems
Website https://nanolyse.com/