SAGES: Systems Approach for Greener, Eco-efficient and Sustainable mineral resource management

Lead Research Organisation: Imperial College London
Department Name: Earth Science and Engineering

Abstract

Sustainable management of mineral resources requires a balance of economic development and responsible governance on the one side and community benefits together with environmental protection on the other. The Philippines is the world's fifth most mineral-rich country with metal resource assets valued over USD 1 trillion, but their exploitation has not been maximised. Benefits to the country by the resource sector remain <1.4% of GDP since 2006 and mining is perceived negatively by the public.

We propose to develop the Systems Approach for Greener, Eco-efficient and Sustainable (SAGES) mineral resource management framework as a unifying framework that will support Philippine mining in its transition into an economically sustainable, socially responsible and environmentally sensitive industry. The core idea behind SAGES is that transforming legacy mines into future mines and mine wastes into secondary resources can simultaneously reduce waste generation, provide additional economic benefits to stakeholders, empower host communities and improve rehabilitation programmes and therefore provide the paradigm shift necessary to stimulate growth of the resource extraction sector in the Philippines.

The partnership and project development (PPD) stage is initially organized in six themes: (i) advanced waste characterization; (ii) reprocessing of wastes; (iii) repurposing of by-products; (iv) treatment/remediation of wastewater, mine drainage and polluted soils; (v) rehabilitation and monitoring via bioindicators; and (vi) multi-criteria systems analysis across the mining value chain. These themes will be further streamlined based on the needs and expectations of all stakeholders (mining companies, national and local government units, civil society organisations and host communities), as informed by the PPD process. Stakeholder engagements during PPD will ensure that the SAGES framework i) is customisable and scalable to local contexts; ii) accounts for waste heterogeneity; iii) creates new markets and socio-economic-cultural opportunities; and iv) transforms mining-related activities into reliable tax revenue streams.

The SAGES mineral resource management framework also envisions post-mining land uses that are climate- and culture-sensitive instead of traditional "replanting" strategies, an approach that creates value to host communities even after mine closure. The multifaceted problems of the mining and resource sectors can be addressed effectively by pooling together industry leaders, socio-environmental scientists and technology experts and developing an overarching framework capable of integrating, translating and communicating data across various disciplines.

The PPD process and refinement of the SAGES mineral resource management framework will be delivered by an international consortium including geology, mineral processing and climate experts from Imperial College London, the Grantham Institute for climate change and the environment and the London Natural History Museum, chemical and systems engineers from De La Salle University, waste management and socio-environmental scientists from Mindanao State University-Iligan Institute of Technology and Central Mindanao University, multiple mining companies (Agatha Mining Ventures Inc. and Carmen Copper Corporation) and hydrometallurgists and environmental geochemists from Australia (University of New South Wales and Curtin University).

The outcome from the partnership and project development (PPD) stage will be a streamlined SAGES framework specialized for the Philippines, addressing the needs and constraints of all stakeholders. The PPD process will strengthen and further establish partnerships through networking and stakeholder engagements, identify and characterize the decision support tools needed in light of emerging technologies available, and recognize community, government and industry needs and expectations explicitly.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This Partnership and Project Development (PPD) funding allowed the team to refine the SAGES framework and strengthen the capabilities within the team, expanding the areas of expertise to be covered in the project that was proposed for a Strategic Large Grant. The team identified the needs and expectations of stakeholders, strengthened partnerships and fine-tuned key research questions to be explored. As a result, not only a detailed proposal for a Strategic Large Grant was developed and submitted but a number of knowledge exchange activities took place. The achievements listed below are a good indication of the successful synergies created between the UK and Philippines project teams.

- A key outcome from the SAGES PPD was the development of a characterisation analytical workflow to produce a reconciled chemical and mineralogical audit of mine site materials. A proof-of-concept of this analytical workflow was carried out. A critical finding of this PPD analytical flow development is that the reconciliation process is increasingly difficult for elemental budgets as they become increasingly dilute. This is compounded when trace phases (<2 volume %) become less crystalline. Full reconciliation with micro-scale analyses was proposed to minimise this effect.
- A conceptual framework for a holistic metric to assess eco-efficiency in mining operations was developed
- Stakeholder engagement meetings took place with mining companies in the Philippines, industry practitioners and the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB). Access to material from the mines enabled the analysis of chemical compositions of ores, tailings and acid mine drainage, as well as silt and low-grade ores. A highlight from the discussions was that while some rehabilitation programmes are based on leading practices from other countries, these are often challenging to apply because of differences in climate, soil properties, flora and fauna, and other environmental factors.
- An internal workshop on social aspects of mining in the Philippines was organised to identify how the activities planned as part of the project proposal would support changes beneficial for the local communities. Notably, the need for a programme logic model that linked the social and technical aspects of the projects was identified.
- Through engagement events with the host community and via focus group discussions, initial data were acquired on their beliefs, perceptions, knowledge base, and aspirations towards the mining sector. These data would be useful to develop a survey tool for wider data collection.
- A series of dissemination webinars were organised, open to the public and particularly aimed at senior high school and university students, researchers, and project partners in industry and government in the Philippines. These covered mineral resources management, sustainability and the role of social sciences in a sustainable future, biotechnology, Earth observation, and the potential of nickel laterites.
Exploitation Route The research ideas that were generated as a result of this PPD grant will be taken forward by the project team members for future projects.
In particular, engagement with mining companies during the project helped identify key challenges for the analysis of samples of ores, tailings and acid mine drainage. Similarly, silt was identified as a priority for one of the companies, for the development of products that could be used by local communities.
Stakeholder engagement meetings with the Philippines Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) highlighted the need for rehabilitation strategies tailored to the Philippines context. It also allowed the team to identify a mining legacy site of key importance to MGB for future studies.
Engagement events with host communities via focus group discussions allowed the incorporation of a social component to the SAGES framework, thus contributing to a holistic approach to sustainable mining.
The framework is expected to be useful for further research and education activities, as well as for the planning of activities by mining companies.
Sectors Education,Environment,Other

 
Description Dissemination webinar on sustainability and the role of social sciences in a sustainable future 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A dissemination webinar on sustainability and the role of social sciences in a sustainable future that was open to the public and particularly aimed at senior high school and university students, researchers, and project partners in industry and government in the Philippines.
It was held on 17 September 2021, with almost 100 participants and with speakers from University of New South Wales and Curtin University.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Dissemination webinar on biotechnology, Earth observation, and the potential of nickel laterites 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact A dissemination webinar on 22 September 2021, with speakers from Bangor University, Imperial College London and the Natural History Museum, and covering biotechnology, Earth observation, and the potential of nickel laterites. It gathered over 100 participants. It was open to the public and particularly aimed at senior high school and university students, researchers, and project partners in industry and government in the Philippines.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Dissemination webinar on mineral resources management 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A dissemination webinar on mineral resources management that was open to the public and particularly aimed at senior high school and university students, researchers, and project partners in industry and government in the Philippines. It took place on 13 September 2021, with over 300 participants and with speakers from the De La Salle University, Mindanao State University - IIT and Central Mindanao University.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021