Piloting Zooniverse for food, health and sustainability citizen science
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Sheffield
Department Name: Geography
Abstract
There is a food knowledge disconnect between food and nutrition researcher community, and general population. Likewise, policy makers have detailed information about food, but cannot measure easily what citizens understand or perceive to know about food, or how large the disconnect is between these two knowledge bases. This information disconnect has implications for how to address a wide range of food related subjects from food safety, and health education, as well as how to communicate complex issues ranging from environmental sustainability, and animal welfare and human rights.
The STFC funded Zooniverse platform is a proven method of engaging citizens with complex scientific issues. A recent STFC food network + Collaborative Scoping Project "Piloting Zooniverse to help us understand citizen food perceptions" (2018) has shown that the Zooniverse citizen science platform can be a solution to the measurement of citizens perception of food information (and might also act as a way to inform and discuss food information with citizens). As a result of this pilot government departments (FSA and DEFRA) are now interested in working with a multidisciplinary research team to co-develop a publicly facing citizen science pilot using Zooniverse.
The previous pilot tested the Zooniverse interface, and refined the citizen science methodology for food related questions. It relied on a small private sample of participants, asking questions on 10 food types and 2 variables (greenhouse gas emissions and energy density). Before a large citizen science campaign can take place, an additional phase of piloting to further refine the methodology needs to occur.
This pilot will be publicly facing, engaging and educating a minimum of 400+ UK citizens over 3 month operational period. It will extend the prior research, measuring citizen perceptions of 30+ foods on topics of sustainability (including geographically and technology associated impacts) and healthiness; risk and trust in the food system; food habits (such as shopping cooking, preparation and storage); and animal welfare and human rights.
In addition, this pilot will provide methodological benefits for Zooniverse as it will 1) Compare Zooniverse to traditional survey methods. 2) Measure behaviour and dietary change of engaged citizens over the 3 month period. These two factors have not been measured previously and will benefit the larger research community.
The STFC funded Zooniverse platform is a proven method of engaging citizens with complex scientific issues. A recent STFC food network + Collaborative Scoping Project "Piloting Zooniverse to help us understand citizen food perceptions" (2018) has shown that the Zooniverse citizen science platform can be a solution to the measurement of citizens perception of food information (and might also act as a way to inform and discuss food information with citizens). As a result of this pilot government departments (FSA and DEFRA) are now interested in working with a multidisciplinary research team to co-develop a publicly facing citizen science pilot using Zooniverse.
The previous pilot tested the Zooniverse interface, and refined the citizen science methodology for food related questions. It relied on a small private sample of participants, asking questions on 10 food types and 2 variables (greenhouse gas emissions and energy density). Before a large citizen science campaign can take place, an additional phase of piloting to further refine the methodology needs to occur.
This pilot will be publicly facing, engaging and educating a minimum of 400+ UK citizens over 3 month operational period. It will extend the prior research, measuring citizen perceptions of 30+ foods on topics of sustainability (including geographically and technology associated impacts) and healthiness; risk and trust in the food system; food habits (such as shopping cooking, preparation and storage); and animal welfare and human rights.
In addition, this pilot will provide methodological benefits for Zooniverse as it will 1) Compare Zooniverse to traditional survey methods. 2) Measure behaviour and dietary change of engaged citizens over the 3 month period. These two factors have not been measured previously and will benefit the larger research community.
Planned Impact
IMPACT OBJECTIVES are directly linked to each research objective:
Ob1) A uptake of DEFRA and FSA use of citizen science to monitor citizen perceptions, with data collected by these methods used to inform policy.
Ob2) A measured positive dietary shift occurring in occurring in citizens who engage with the pilot: a) shifting towards diets aligned with the Eatwell guide, b) shifting towards plant forward diets,
Ob3) A measured shift of food preparation and cooking methods (to reduce the use phase of foods' environmental impact).
Ob4) A measured shift to consumption of lower risk foods and greater positive food safety practices outcomes.
Together these shifts increase food security and positive health outcomes, while reducing food related carbon emissions, food waste, and water, land, and energy use. These outcomes can also be used as impact measures.
To achieve these impact objectives Dr Reynolds will
Work with stakeholders to co-create citizen science interventions that deliver measurable improvements in environmental sustainability and dietary shifts.
Engage will innovators and influencers from business, government, and the third sector to support the transformation of the UK diet towards resilient, sustainable, and healthy outcomes.
Work with the devolved administrations, Defra, FSA, PHE, and the third sector to inform the development of health, food, farming, and environmental policy.
ENGAGEMENT WITH GOVERNMENT. This research has been designed in part to complement the UK Government's Clean Growth Strategy commitment for Defra (to "20% reduction in the greenhouse gas intensity of food and drink consumed in the UK" by 2025 (p135), and PHEs 2018 calorie reduction strategy (20% reduction by 2024). Impact will be measured via integration of findings and harmonised data into DEFRA and FSA policy.
ENGAGEMENT WITH UKRI. Dr Reynolds is engaged in the NERC and N8 Agrifood KE programmes, and is a research champion for STFC food network+. He has also been involved with GFS events, and has spoken at UKRI as part of Green Week. These links will ensure effective two-way knowledge exchange with UKRI.
PLANNED ENGAGEMENT WITH OTHER STAKEHOLDERS via WRAP, N8Agrifood, FCRN and FRC partnerships these include the Sustainable Restaurant Association, WRI, WWF, and the Food Foundation.
Ob1) A uptake of DEFRA and FSA use of citizen science to monitor citizen perceptions, with data collected by these methods used to inform policy.
Ob2) A measured positive dietary shift occurring in occurring in citizens who engage with the pilot: a) shifting towards diets aligned with the Eatwell guide, b) shifting towards plant forward diets,
Ob3) A measured shift of food preparation and cooking methods (to reduce the use phase of foods' environmental impact).
Ob4) A measured shift to consumption of lower risk foods and greater positive food safety practices outcomes.
Together these shifts increase food security and positive health outcomes, while reducing food related carbon emissions, food waste, and water, land, and energy use. These outcomes can also be used as impact measures.
To achieve these impact objectives Dr Reynolds will
Work with stakeholders to co-create citizen science interventions that deliver measurable improvements in environmental sustainability and dietary shifts.
Engage will innovators and influencers from business, government, and the third sector to support the transformation of the UK diet towards resilient, sustainable, and healthy outcomes.
Work with the devolved administrations, Defra, FSA, PHE, and the third sector to inform the development of health, food, farming, and environmental policy.
ENGAGEMENT WITH GOVERNMENT. This research has been designed in part to complement the UK Government's Clean Growth Strategy commitment for Defra (to "20% reduction in the greenhouse gas intensity of food and drink consumed in the UK" by 2025 (p135), and PHEs 2018 calorie reduction strategy (20% reduction by 2024). Impact will be measured via integration of findings and harmonised data into DEFRA and FSA policy.
ENGAGEMENT WITH UKRI. Dr Reynolds is engaged in the NERC and N8 Agrifood KE programmes, and is a research champion for STFC food network+. He has also been involved with GFS events, and has spoken at UKRI as part of Green Week. These links will ensure effective two-way knowledge exchange with UKRI.
PLANNED ENGAGEMENT WITH OTHER STAKEHOLDERS via WRAP, N8Agrifood, FCRN and FRC partnerships these include the Sustainable Restaurant Association, WRI, WWF, and the Food Foundation.
Publications
Armstrong B
(2020)
Piloting Citizen Science Methods to Measure Perceptions of Carbon Footprint and Energy Content of Food
in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Armstrong B
(2021)
How Does Citizen Science Compare to Online Survey Panels? A Comparison of Food Knowledge and Perceptions Between the Zooniverse, Prolific and Qualtrics UK Panels
in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Armstrong B
(2021)
Food insecurity, food waste, food behaviours and cooking confidence of UK citizens at the start of the COVID-19 lockdown
in British Food Journal
Bridge G
(2021)
Engaging citizens in sustainability research: comparing survey recruitment and responses between Facebook, Twitter and qualtrics
in British Food Journal
Frankowska A
(2020)
Impacts of home cooking methods and appliances on the GHG emissions of food.
in Nature food
Oakden L
(2021)
The Importance of Citizen Scientists in the Move Towards Sustainable Diets and a Sustainable Food System
in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Pateman R
(2020)
Citizen Science for Quantifying and Reducing Food Loss and Food Waste
in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Reynolds C
Citizen Science and Food: A Review
Description | Citizen science is a useful tool for engaging with food, health and sustainability issues. Citizens have many different understandings of health and sustainability issues, and so using the correct approach and measurement methods is crucial. |
Exploitation Route | The FSA has created a joint UKRI funding call for food citizen science. Our findings have been made into multiple documents. http://doi.org/10.1108/BFJ-06-2020-0498 http://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2021.596594 http://doi.org/10.1108/BFJ-10-2020-0917 https://www.food.gov.uk/research/research-projects/citizen-science-and-food https://www.csap.cam.ac.uk/media/uploads/files/1/future-directions-for-citizen-science-and-public-policy-web-v6.pdf |
Sectors | Agriculture, Food and Drink |
Description | Building on this research project the Food Standards Agency UK, commissioned the research team to conduct a review of food citizen science, to allow the FSA to target and facilitate more systematic engagement with UK and global research communities, to help address key research priorities of the FSA. https://www.food.gov.uk/research/research-projects/citizen-science-and-food In 2021 the FSA then launched a UKRI joint funding call for citizen science projects https://www.ukri.org/opportunity/citizen-science-for-food-standards-challenges/ This resulted in new food citizens science projects being funded for 2022: https://www.food.gov.uk/news-alerts/news/fsa-and-ukri-join-forces-with-the-public-to-explore-food-safety https://www.bath.ac.uk/announcements/fsa-and-ukri-join-forces-with-the-public-to-explore-food-safety/ |
First Year Of Impact | 2021 |
Sector | Agriculture, Food and Drink,Government, Democracy and Justice |
Description | DEFRA and FSA briefings on Citizen Science and COVID-19 |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Implementation circular/rapid advice/letter to e.g. Ministry of Health |
Description | FSA - A rapid evidence review on consumer and industry understanding of sustainable food and its importance when making food choices |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Citation in other policy documents |
Impact | A Report has been commissioned by the FSA "A rapid evidence review on consumer and industry understanding of sustainable food and its importance when making food choices", our previous research in this area, allowed us to bid for this tender and win it successfully, likewise, the resulting report features citations of our work. I highlight this report helps set FSA food policy direction in terms of sustainable food in the UK. |
Description | FSA Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Implementation circular/rapid advice/letter to e.g. Ministry of Health |
Description | Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment |
Amount | £10,805 (GBP) |
Funding ID | FS900108 |
Organisation | Food Standards Agency (FSA) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 12/2020 |
End | 01/2021 |
Description | FSA Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment |
Organisation | Food Standards Agency (FSA) |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Public |
PI Contribution | The research team has worked upon a Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment for the FSA as a result of this project |
Collaborator Contribution | The research team has worked upon a Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment for the FSA as a result of this project |
Impact | There will be a report published in March 2021, and a UKRI/FSA joint funding call opening. |
Start Year | 2020 |
Description | FSA Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment |
Organisation | Queen's University Belfast |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | The research team has worked upon a Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment for the FSA as a result of this project |
Collaborator Contribution | The research team has worked upon a Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment for the FSA as a result of this project |
Impact | There will be a report published in March 2021, and a UKRI/FSA joint funding call opening. |
Start Year | 2020 |
Description | FSA Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment |
Organisation | University of York |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | The research team has worked upon a Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment for the FSA as a result of this project |
Collaborator Contribution | The research team has worked upon a Citizen Science and Food, Rapid Evidence Assessment for the FSA as a result of this project |
Impact | There will be a report published in March 2021, and a UKRI/FSA joint funding call opening. |
Start Year | 2020 |
Description | Food Standards Agency -seminar |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Policymakers/politicians |
Results and Impact | I presented on the findings of this study to the FSA as part of their Food for thought seminar series. Online presentation 2 hours 90+ participants. Led to invite to apply with FSA for further funding |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2020 |