Digital Multi-channel Tibial Implants in Orthopedic Medicine

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Institute of Orthopaedics

Abstract

Clinical and translational research to develop enhanced treatments for fractures would be greatly facilitated by the use of a valid and reliable measure of fracture healing. In preclinical studies, the gold standard is the measurement of bending or torsional stiffness; these are direct measures of the restitution of the key property of bone. This can only be performed in humans if the fracture is treated conservatively (without fixation) or by means of an external fixator. However the tibial shaft fracture (the fracture most likely to give problems clinically) is most often treated by intramedullary nailing. With an IM nail in situ, stiffness measurement is considered a waste of time, since it reflects the stiffness of the nail, as well as the bone, to an unknown extent. This project aims to overcome that problem by directly measuring strains in the nail in response to well-characterised loading of the bone-nail construct, thus allowing the stiffness of the bone itself to be deduced.The alternative approach to the monitoring of fracture healing is by radiographic imaging. With conventional radiographs this is apt to be misleading, though that is what clinicians use on a day-to-day basis. In this study, 3-D images from spiral CT will be processed by finite element analysis (FEA) to calculate the strength and stiffness of the healing fracture and this technique (which would not be realistic for routine use) will be used to validate the results obtained by the new telemetric method.We will take modified tibial nails, 11mm in diameter, supplied by our industrial partner and instrument them with 36 strain gauges distributed at three circumferential sites at three levels, together with the circuitry to read the strains and transmit them as radio waves. The electronics will be powered inductively through a coil enclosed in a ceramic ring on the end of the nail, preserving the cannulation of the whole nail which allows its insertion over a guide wire. Each instrumented nail will be calibrated to allow measurement of force with six degrees of freedom, and also bending deflection.Nails of several appropriate lengths will be instrumented for insertion into nine patients who are having surgery for delayed union of tibial shaft fractures, with a variety of fracture configurations at different levels in the tibia. The nails will be double-locked top and bottom with threaded screws so that the mechanical link between nail and bone will be rigid. At intervals following surgery we will examine the patients by gait analysis with simultaneous telemetric readings of strain from the nail. A 3D lower limb biomechanical model will be developed to allow the determination of forces acting on the tibia-nail construct, taking into account the forces generated in the construct by the patient's muscles. The forces and deflections experienced by the nail will be processed to yield the contribution of the bone to the whole construct. Simpler static loading protocols will also be explored. At the same time points, spiral CT images of 0.3mm slice thickness will be acquired and the datasets used to feed material properties of the bone and fracture callus into FEA software, excluding the nail, from which structural stiffness of the healing bone will be calculated. We will also apply validated scales of lower limb function.Using the FEA-derived structural properties of the bone as our comparator, we will validate the stiffness measurement based on analysis of the nail readout and loads. We will then use principal component analysis to determine the minimal strain gauge configuration and simplest loading protocols that yield sufficient information, in order to refine the system for commercialisation and clinical use. As well as providing an outcome measure for clinical trials, the system will be useful in routine treatment to guide rehabilitation and receive earlier warning of the need for secondary interventions such as bone graft.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have developed a non-invasive method of measuring strains in fracture fixing bone nails.
Exploitation Route Commercialisation of the system by implant manufacturer
Sectors Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description To help our commercial partner file a patent, initially
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
 
Description Smith & Nephew
Amount £226,500 (GBP)
Organisation Smith and Nephew 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2010 
End 12/2012
 
Description Smith & Nephew
Amount £53,000 (GBP)
Funding ID RC831 
Organisation Smith and Nephew 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2010 
End 12/2013
 
Description SMD 
Organisation Strain Measurement Devices Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Awareness of medical markets and relevant products.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of strain gauging facilities and clean rooms.
Impact Within the SmartNail project, the outcomes are covered by the overall project outcomes. We also collaborate with SMD on other projects.
 
Description Smith&Nephew 
Organisation Smith and Nephew
Department Smith & Nephew Orthopaedics Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution UCL brings expertise in designing instrumented implants. Technology know-how. S&N have gained valuable insight from UCL into the complexity of designing, developing and electrically testing off-the-shelf miniaturised wireless circuitry for orthopaedic applications.
Collaborator Contribution UCL have increased their internal capabilities for designing miniaturised electrical components and connections, which are suitable for integration into intramedullary nails. UCL have also gained valuable technical experience in the development of a pre-clinical ovine tibial nail model for monitoring fracture healing, which may be applicable to other research project conducted at their facilities. UCL post-graduate students contracted onto the project have also benefited from working with a commercial partner in terms of gaining a better understanding of the business environment.
Impact The consortium successfully designed two generations of instrumented biomechanical nails (Figure 1) for evaluation with an automated 6 degree of freedom calibration station in order to determine the following:- (a) suitable positions on the nail for attaching the wireless sensors, and (b) the most sensitive loading protocols and regenerate materials available for monitoring the early stage of fracture healing.
Start Year 2007
 
Title LOW TEMPERATURE ENCAPSULATE WELDING 
Description A load-bearing medical implant is disclosed that includes a load-bearing structure with a cavity extending into the outer surface of the structure. The cavity accommodates a sensor that is held in a fixed position within the cavity by an encapsulant. The cavity is covered by a plate that is welded over the cavity in close proximity to the sensor and encapsulant to provide a seal over the cavity and the electronic component without causing thermal damage to the encapsulant or sensor despite the close proximity of the encapsulant and sensor to the welded areas of the plate and structure. Methods for encapsulating the sensor in the cavity, methods for encapsulating a wire bus leading from the sensor through a channel in the implant and methods for pulsed laser welding of weld plate over the sensor and encapsulant with thermal damage to either are disclosed. 
IP Reference WO2010088531 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2010
Licensed No
Impact A method for hermetically sealing an electronic component in a load-bearing implant, the method comprising: providing a load-bearing implant with a cavity for accommodating the electronic component; providing a weld plate configured to cover the cavity with an offset margin extending around a periphery of the cavity; encapsulating the electronic component in the cavity within an encapsulant; curing the encapsulant at a first temperature; heat treating the cured encapsulant to a second temperatur
 
Title TELEMETIC ORTHOPAEDIC IMPLANT 
Description The invention relates generally to orthopaedic implants, and more particularly to orthopaedic implants having data acquisition capabilities and their use in monitoring and diagnosing fracture healing. RSA is also disclosed as a method for measuring inter-fragmentary movement in long bone fractures in order to confirm whether the fracture is reduced and for detecting changes in stiffness of the healing callus. 
IP Reference WO2011004151 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2011
Licensed No
Impact None as yet.