Black Labour: African Migrant Networks and Informal Work in Southern Italy

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sussex
Department Name: Sch of Global Studies

Abstract

The research proposal is an analysis of the cultural and socio-economic impacts of undocumented labour migration from Africa to Europe. The aim of the research topic is to investigate and analyze the political and economic issues that the
illegal entry and stay of migrants produces on European local economies and labour standards. The case study takes into consideration the labour migration flows from Sub Saharan African countries to Europe with Italy as the first step in the migration project towards Northern European countries. The research topic focuses, more precisely, on seasonal Sub-Saharan African migrant labour in the agricultural sector in the South of Italy.
The research project analyzes the "caporalato", the migrant labour contracting system based on ethnic and kinship ties. The "caporalato" labour contracting system originated in the 1950s and spread throughout the Southern part of Italy among local Italian workers until it was fought back by trade unionist and slowly disappeared.
Since the 1970s however there has been an increase in migrant flows from Sub-Saharan Africa toward Italy, changing Italy's role in the migration patterns from solely a departure country to a destination country. The increase in Italy of low-skilled African migrant labour has coincided with the re-emergence of the phenomenon of the "caporalato", which has taken resurfaced since the 1980s, with undocumented migrants as its main target labour force, and rendering the agricultural sector in the South of Italy completely reliant on the migrant labour contracting system. The function of the "caporalato" is to offer high numbers of temporary seasonal workers in a very short time, sometimes even just overnight. In fact, most of the migrant workers are contracted on a daily basis and will offer their labour in the early hours of the day in the "kaliffo ground" (the contract worker's ground).
I will be conducting ethnographic field research in the province of Foggia in the "Ghetto di Rignano" shantytown in the outskirts of Borgo Mezzanone, in the Puglia Region, where there is a high density of migrant work force contracted in the agricultural sector. "Radio Ghetto" is a radio station based in the "Ghetto di Rignano" that has as one of its principal objectives to create a participated communication experience that gives voice to the undocumented workers in the agricultural lands in Puglia.The "Radio Ghetto" volunteers have agreed to enable my access to the field and will act as "gate-keepers" to the area of field research investigation. The access I have been granted is the result of preliminary field research conducted in Summer 2016.
While undergoing field research I will be investigating the legal and economic system that allows for the exploitation of the migrants' "illegal entry and stay" status in Italy and their reasons and willingness to leave Italy and its exploitative conditions and proceed "North" in order to better their lives. I will investigate the modes of action of systemic structural undocumented migrant exploitation in Italy and the reasons behind a South-North internal European migrant flow trajectory. In fact, throughout ethnographic participant observation and interviewing processes, I will address the rhetorical construction of migrant utopias and destination countries, such as England and in particular the London area.
I believe that understanding the dynamics and limits of this system of structural illegality represents the first step in bringing about a change in the ways in which migrants enter Europe, are subsequently "allowed" to remain, and are forced to contend with myriads of constraints and impediments along the way. This type of research is fundamental for the management of migration throughout Europe.

Publications

10 25 50

Studentship Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Student Name
ES/P00072X/1 01/10/2017 30/09/2027
1935989 Studentship ES/P00072X/1 01/10/2017 30/09/2019 Emilia Melossi
 
Description First achievement: The research is based on exceptional access to a marginalised, criminalised and "illegalised" population in the agricultural sector not just in Italy specifically, but also in other parts of Europe. The new knowledge generated from this exceptional access, gives detailed and specific information regarding the labour exploitation dynamic that lies at the basis of the agricultural sector in Europe.

Second achievement: "Giving back", a new methodology.
Generally, a young white woman in the shantytown, who isn't a prostitute, must be an NGO worker. Migrants would assume that I was a social worker or an active local Christian volunteer. Most of the time migrants would come to me asking for favours and information of all kinds, from more legal information to more personal health questions. They would explain their problem to me and hope to get some help. At the beginning, I felt quite uncomfortable with the situation but after a while, I realised that my presence could become a bridge between the two worlds, the shantytown and the city, so I started researching the local migrant support systems, for example the legal help desk, the national health centre for undocumented migrants and the various trade union offices, and I put the migrants in contact with the various offices. These small acts of kindness are radical in that context. I was always upfront about my reasons for being there but my small gestures always set the tone for the interaction. Most of the people I was able to help, given my own rather meagre resources, were very appreciative and willing to exchange the favour. I believe there is something very powerful in admitting that you need help too. And there is something quite exceptional that happens when a "less empowered" person realises that they actually have the power to help someone else - and that their help can be offered on their own terms and conditions.

The third achievement is the recognition that the "Radio Ghetto" migrant recorded broadcasts, from the shantytown itself, represent a new research resource that has not previously been considered. The broadcasts represent a historical archive of the migrants' experiences working in the agricultural sector since 2012.

What has been achieved is the establishment of a new network devoted to investigating the nexus between agriculture and migration in both Northern and Southern Europe. The topic is developed in the Journal of Rural Studies, in a forthcoming special issue on: "Agricultural Regimes and Migrant Labour", with guest editors: Russell King, Aija Lulle, Ben Rogaly and myself. The ten papers in this special issue originate from a double panel convened by the guest-editors at the Annual Conference of IMISCOE in Malmö, 26-28 June 2019; four of the papers were also presented at the Annual RGS/IBG Conference in London, 28-30 August 2019.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of this research project can steer the direction and orientation of government policies at the local, national and European level by shedding light on the nexus between the agricultural sector and migrant labour.

The research outcomes may be taken forward by local organisations, for example NGOs, cultural associations and trade unions across Europe and other parts of the world, where migrant labour is taking place in the agricultural sector.

This research project could be taken forward and developed by integrating the migrant interviews with interviews conducted with landowners and employers.
It would also be useful to conduct similar research in other parts of Italy, as well as in other European countries, in order to construct a comparative study of the different migrant agricultural labour systems.

The research could inspire small alternative migrant production and branding of various consumer goods with specific fair-labour labels that guarantee equitable labour practices.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Environment,Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Retail,Security and Diplomacy

 
Description I have discussed information regarding my findings on national public Italian radio and on the website of the municipality of Bologna, Italy: -Interview with Radio 3 on the Zazà Radio Programme as representatives for Radio Ghetto Voci Libere (30 September 2018) https://www.raiplayradio.it/audio/2018/09/ZAZAapos-ARTE-MUSICA-SPETTACOLO---Gli-abbronzati-di-Riace-644a30cd-b18b-45eb-b01d-585693f8df09.html -Interview by the Municipality of Bologna, Youth Media Portal Codec.tv regarding the grass-root project: Mercatino Verde del Mondo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c5ZlojFvzMw The information presented in the interviews highlighted the complex problem of migrant labour in various parts of Italy and the similarities that have been found in other European nations as well as in other countries in the world. Topics presented included: fair-labour wages, environmental issues (use of pesticides), workers' health, discrimination and racialisation. Presenting these topics through a general public radio broadcast widens the audience significantly since it is no longer limited to a specific academic group. It is imperative to bring these topics to the attention of the general public in order to create support and understanding for new projects designed specifically to have a positive affect on the situation of migrant labour workers working in the agricultural sector, a sector which is extremely important in the daily lives of everyone given the consumption of fresh picked foods. There is evidence that attention is slowly moving towards consumer awareness of product traceability and fair-wage policies. ttp://www.agricolturaeambiente.it/coop-il-lavoro-nero-da-solo-pessimi-frutti-scegli-i-frutti-della-legalita/
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Environment,Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Retail,Security and Diplomacy
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Assistant to the director of the film festival 
Organisation Human Rights Nights
Country Italy 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Assistant Director in organising the 2019 festival programme, including films selected. Secured participation of film director of the documentary presented on opening night. The 2019 festival was dedicated to the topic of anthropocene, specifically reflecting on "women and water" and the environmental and challenges that women have to face everyday.
Collaborator Contribution The Human Rights Film Festival director decided to lend me the "film festival car" in order for me to complete my research and conduct interviews in the shantytowns in the the South of Italy for the summers of 2017 and 2018.
Impact Collaboration is ongoing and plans for Human Rights Nights Film Festival 2020 are underway.
Start Year 2017