Hypogene karst: genesis and implications to optimisation of low enthalpy energy resources
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Manchester
Department Name: Earth Atmospheric and Env Sciences
Abstract
Karst is the term used to describe a suite of features formed by dissolution of limestone. It includes surface features such as limestone pavements, dolines (sink holes) and tower karst, as well as subterranean caverns and chemical (carbonate) precipitates. Karst forms by dissolution of limestone and can create well connected caverns, fissures and passages that control the subterranean flow of groundwater. Caves form through geological time as a result of dissolution above, at and below the water table from mildly acidic groundwater and mixing of waters of different chemistry (e.g. at the marine - meteoric mixing zone). The most common, and best understood, subterranean caverns are epigenetic - they form in the near surface due to dissolution by groundwater and include caves that are horizontal or sub-horizontal and broadly conformable with limestone strata. The genesis of this epigene karst, is fairly well understood. Hypogene karst is another type of subterranean cavern which is less well studied, even though it is a component of many of Earth's largest cavern networks. It is characterised by vertical or sub-vertical caverns that cross-cut strata and can connect stratabound caverns to form maze cave systems. They are interpreted to form by dissolution from upward-flowing fluids and may also be associated with chemical reactions such as oxidation and/or dissolution associated with CO2 or H2S- rich water. They are potentially significant because:
1) They can control the direction and rate of groundwater flow, as well as the supply of thermal waters (e.g. to hot springs or for geothermal heat production)
2) They might result in high rates of fluid loss, and pressure perturbations, during drilling for geothermal energy and hydrocarbon production
3) They can create zones of geomechanical instability in the subsurface, which could lead to ground instability and collapse (i.e. formation of sinkholes).
This project is concerned with the characterization of a range of non-stratabound, vertical and sub-vertical caverns within Carboniferous (mid-Mississippian) limestone of the Derbyshire Platform, UK, and an assessment of the factors governing their genesis. Since at least four types of non-stratabound cavern occur in the study area, they potentially serve as an exemplar for a range of hypogene processes. They are variably open, calcite-cemented, mineralised by a galena-fluorite-barite-calcite assemblage and/or sediment filled, but it is unclear if they were formed at the same time and by the same process. The project will use field mapping, low temperature geochemistry and reactive transport modelling to determine how and when the different types of caverns formed, in order to improve prediction of their distribution. The project brings together communities who do not commonly interact by coupling a) expertise in carbonate sedimentology and geochemistry with b) a deep knowledge of speleology, hydrogeology and modelling, and c) extensive geoscience databases held at the British Geological Survey. It will deliver databases of cavern morphology and fill and a suite of models to explain their formation. This is of particular relevance because Mississippian limestone is a primary target for geothermal energy production within the UK and northern Europe. The results will also be widely applicable to hydrogeologists and speleologists globally, who are interested in physical and chemical groundwater modelling and ground stability, as well as to subsurface geoscientists interested in hydrocarbon production, gas storage and carbon sequestration in carbonate reservoirs.
1) They can control the direction and rate of groundwater flow, as well as the supply of thermal waters (e.g. to hot springs or for geothermal heat production)
2) They might result in high rates of fluid loss, and pressure perturbations, during drilling for geothermal energy and hydrocarbon production
3) They can create zones of geomechanical instability in the subsurface, which could lead to ground instability and collapse (i.e. formation of sinkholes).
This project is concerned with the characterization of a range of non-stratabound, vertical and sub-vertical caverns within Carboniferous (mid-Mississippian) limestone of the Derbyshire Platform, UK, and an assessment of the factors governing their genesis. Since at least four types of non-stratabound cavern occur in the study area, they potentially serve as an exemplar for a range of hypogene processes. They are variably open, calcite-cemented, mineralised by a galena-fluorite-barite-calcite assemblage and/or sediment filled, but it is unclear if they were formed at the same time and by the same process. The project will use field mapping, low temperature geochemistry and reactive transport modelling to determine how and when the different types of caverns formed, in order to improve prediction of their distribution. The project brings together communities who do not commonly interact by coupling a) expertise in carbonate sedimentology and geochemistry with b) a deep knowledge of speleology, hydrogeology and modelling, and c) extensive geoscience databases held at the British Geological Survey. It will deliver databases of cavern morphology and fill and a suite of models to explain their formation. This is of particular relevance because Mississippian limestone is a primary target for geothermal energy production within the UK and northern Europe. The results will also be widely applicable to hydrogeologists and speleologists globally, who are interested in physical and chemical groundwater modelling and ground stability, as well as to subsurface geoscientists interested in hydrocarbon production, gas storage and carbon sequestration in carbonate reservoirs.
| Description | This project was focused on a particular type of karst (cave system) that forms in limestone from fluids that move upwards within the Earth's crust, rather than from rainfall that normally drains from the surface. The project found abundant evidence for these caves within Carboniferous Limestone on the Derbyshire Platform, Pennines, UK. Hypogene karst is interpreted to have formed over at least two key time periods; a) during the Upper Carboniferous to Permian, forming stratabound mineralized pipes and calcite cemented cavities, as well as some cemented vertical karst conduits and vertical rising chimneys. Calcite from two localities was dated for the first time using U-Pb geochronology and b) open, uncemented conduits are interpreted to form more recently, in the Cenozoic. The presence of hypogene caves containing Miocene Brassington Formation suggests either pre-Miocene cave formation or post-Miocene dissolution and collapse. Very coarsely crystalline calcite crystals within the cave formed from warm water (60-100oC) that had flowed deep beneath the surface and risen towards the surface. They are homogeneous (microscopically and geochemically). Combined with their coarse crystal size and euhedral morphology this suggests slow rates of continuous precipitation under sub-oxic to anoxic conditions. Stable isotope analysis suggests precipitation from meteoric fluids that have evolved by reaction with the limestone. Overall, the project has generated a new conceptual model for fluid-rock reactions from upward-rising meteoric fluids within the Carboniferous Limestone, and opened up new questions on how dissolution takes place. Some of these findings will be interrogated within the ongoing modelling programme (NE/W000733/1). The characterisation of hypogene karst morphology and fill opens new research questions on basin evolution, fluid flow and mineralization with implications to geothermal development and exploration for critical minerals. |
| Exploitation Route | These results comprise the outcome from the first part of an ongoing study which could be taken forward in the following ways: Predicting the distribution of caves in the subsurface, which form a drilling hazard (e.g. during hydrocarbon or geothermal drilling) and could compromise storage security during CCS. The process of dissolution and precipitation of calcite in lithified carbonate strata also has implications for understanding in situ mineralization (e.g. during CCS). These questions are of significance to energy companies seeking to exploit the subsurface. Constraint on the timing of mineralization and fluid properties adds to data on the genesis of Pb-Zn-F-Ba mineralization within the study area and analogue areas. There is renewed interest in these sediment hosted mineral deposits for critical mineral exploitation. The presence of hypogene caves, which have no surface expression, is a potential geohazard since large caverns exist just beneath the surface within limestone bedrock. This is of public interest and will also be important to local government departments and companies planning infrastructure projects (e.g. windfarms). Finally, caves in the study area are an important source of income from tourism. There is the potential to adapt some of the findings from this study to expand the explanation of geological processes provided by some of these caves. |
| Sectors | Energy Environment |
| Description | Consultation on deep geothermal in the UK |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Policy Influence Type | Contribution to a national consultation/review |
| Title | Field, petrographical and geochemical data collected from Asbian and Brigantian strata from the Derbyshire Platform, UK |
| Description | Field, petrographical and geochemical data collected from Asbian and Brigantian strata from the Derbyshire Platform, UK. Derbyshire Platform, ranging from Castleton (SK15106 83079) - Buxton (SK 05781 73182) - Matlock Bath (SK 29454 57924) / Wirksworth (SK28696 53997) area Data includes: Cavern size and morphometrics Transmitted light, cathodoluminescence and SEM images of calcite cements filling hypogene voids Geochemical data (stable and clumped isotopes, trace element concentrations) of calcite cements filling hypogene voids Data collected as part of NERC project NE/W000970/1, Hypogene karst: genesis and implications to optimisation of low enthalpy energy resources. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2025 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | Impacts are emerging |
| URL | https://www2.bgs.ac.uk/nationalgeosciencedatacentre/citedData/catalogue/b15d7894-f97d-487a-9943-a792... |
| Description | British Cave Research Association |
| Organisation | British Cave Research Association |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Charity/Non Profit |
| PI Contribution | Organisation of the 2022 Annual General Meeting of the British Cave Research Association Presentation at the 2023 Annual General Meeting of the British Cave Research Association |
| Collaborator Contribution | BCRA are facilitating access to caves and ensuring safety during cave visits |
| Impact | No outputs as yet BCRA as co-ordinated cave access UoM organised and hosted the BCRA AGM in 2022 |
| Start Year | 2022 |
| Description | Geochemical analysis, Penn State University |
| Organisation | Penn State University |
| Country | United States |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Analysis of trace element and clumped isotopes composition of calcite cements and collaboration to interpret data |
| Collaborator Contribution | Data analysis and interpretation of data |
| Impact | None as yet, but publications in preparation |
| Start Year | 2024 |
| Description | Blog for Policy@manchester |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
| Results and Impact | Blog post for Policy@Manchester entitled 'Can geothermal energy provide a sustainable source of renewable heat in the UK?', including reference to research into geothermal energy from the Lower Carboniferous Limestone. Published online in Jan 2023. Too early to assess impact |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://blog.policy.manchester.ac.uk/posts/2023/01/can-geothermal-energy-provide-a-sustainable-sourc... |
| Description | Fieldtrip for Shell International Exploration and Production |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
| Results and Impact | 1 day field trip to the Derbyshire Platform, including a visit to look at hypogene karstification at Treak Cliff cavern |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| Description | Visit to Pen Park Hole, Bristol |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A magazine, newsletter or online publication |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | Local |
| Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
| Results and Impact | British Cave Research Association members in Bristol facilitated a visit to Pen Park Hole cave in Bristol, and the team provided a write-up of the event for the local speleological magazine published in October 2023 |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://www.ubss.org.uk/resources/newsletter/online/UBSS%20Monthly%20Newsletter%20-%20October%202023... |
