The American Who Electrified Russia

Lead Research Organisation: University of Roehampton
Department Name: Drama, Theatre and Performance

Abstract

THE AMERICAN WHO ELECTRIFIED RUSSIA is a project exploring the relationship between biography and history in the twentieth century through the discovery of an individual life / the real person behind a fictional character in a documentary novel of the 1930s. It takes the form of a documentary video-film supported by a website with background material, and is designed for both academic and aficionado audiences.
The book is Little Golden America, by the Russian satirists Ilf & Petrov, which is nowadays read in schools and colleges in the USA because it recounts a road trip across the country from New York to California and back. Their guide and interpreter on the trip, Mr Adams, is described as an engineer who had spent several years in the Soviet Union. The historical person on whom this character is based is Solomon Trone (1872-1969), Managing Director of General Electric Russia before the 1917 Revolution and then a leading figure in the electrification of the USSR / a name unrecorded in the history books whose biography, as the film discovers, was nonetheless intertwined with history. Indeed his life traversed major developments in Russia, Japan, Germany, China, India, and Israel. In 1918 he was in Siberia, dodging back and forth between the battling reds and whites. In 1932, he sat in the press gallery at the first of Stalin's show trials. In 1939 he helped arrange for the last boat of Jewish refugees to escape from Germany. In 1945 he attended the Potsdam Conference as a member of the Allied Reparations Committee. But the title of the film will reveal itself as ironic, since Trone was actually born in a small town in Latvia.
The film explores the vivid contrast between public imagery and private memory. The public imagery of the events and places are drawn from archives, while the private memories and photos are those of his family. Mediating between these two strands are two more threads. The first is the research of a Canadian university librarian, David Evans, following a trail which began when he discovered, from reading the letters of Ilf & Petrov, that Mr Adams was real. Evans writes that researching Solomon Trone 'is a delight':
He becomes more and more remarkable as a guide through so much of history that
we had thought we had known. That so much of history now turns out to be a fiction,
because of uncovering the life of a man we had previously thought of as fictitious, is
of course ironic. Contrasting Solomon Trone's life between 1905 and 1953 and the
known history of this period there are many inconsistencies that suggest a different
version of events. Some of those differences, if they hold up to scrutiny, do not
appear to be minor.
But the result is that Mr Evans is now searching for material in archives in various countries across the globe.
The final thread is a series of comments from a range of scholars, professionals, archivists etc., which address the wider questions which the film raises about public and private versions of history.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title The American Who Electrified Russia 
Description A film about the role of the individual in history, and of history in the individual. Solomon Trone (1872-1969), a cousin of the film-maker's grandmother, is a figure unrecorded in the history books, whose life was nonetheless intertwined with History, but in paradoxical fashion: as a communist revolutionary and a director of General Electric. Drawing on archives both public and private, this is also a film about the gap between family memory and public knowledge of history - not the history we think we know, but another history, lived in another way. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2009 
Impact Selected for Punto de Vista International Documentary Festival, Pamplona, Spain, 5-13 February 2010; and Official International Selection at the Cali International Film Festival, Colombia 29 Oct-7 Nov 2010. 
URL http://www.americanwhoelectrifiedrussia.co.uk
 
Description 'The American Who Electrified Russia' is a documentary film exploring the relationship between history and family memory through the biography of an individual unrecorded in the history books whose life was nonetheless intertwined with history: Solomon Trone (1872-1969), Latvian-born first cousin of the filmmaker's maternal grandmother, a revolutionary in Russia in 1905 who became a director of General Electric and played a leading role in the electrification of the USSR. A film about the gap between family memory and public knowledge of history, interweaving reminiscence with photos, films, documents and memorabilia both public and private in a manner uniquely available to the documentary form, it addresses what Walter Benjamin called 'the enigmatic question of the biographical historicity of the individual as such'. The archive comes in many forms: family photos, documents and memorabilia; a huge amount of archived documentation like the photos, films and documents of the General Electric archives at Schenectady; a major find in a London film archive-Esfir Shub's K.Sh.E. (???, or Komsomol Patron of Electrification, 1932). Mediating between reminiscence and archive are two more threads: the research of a university archivist, and a series of comments from historians who address the wider questions which the film raises about public and private versions of history. While these are all familiar elements of documentary film language, the subject of the film is thus seen simultaneously in different perspectives - father, friend, family elder, and the real person behind a fictional character in a Soviet documentary novel of the 1930s. However, seeking to locate the biographical subject in historical space, the film is forced to negotiate the recalcitrance of the archival image, the elusiveness of the immediate context that always lies off-camera, outside the frame. Approaching the problem by making the process of investigation part of the story, the film tests the capacity of the documentary form to make sense of this diversity of evidence by foregrounding uncertainties, ambiguities, unanswered questions, instead of presenting a neat and rounded narrative. Nonetheless the effect of telling this story of an individual life is much more than the celebration of an extraordinary career, but to decentre our sense of twentieth century history, to recover a lost perspective, because this is not the history that we think we know, but another history, lived in another way.
Exploitation Route Feedback from early screenings indicated that the film could have an appeal across several areas. Considered in terms of research-as-practice it contributes to documentary and archive film studies as a solution to the problematic of historical representation. But it also holds interest in fields such as twentieth century history, politics, geography, industrial development, and postcolonial studies. The film has been made available on DVD for purchase or streaming through an independent web distributor, and is supported by an informative website.
Sectors Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other

URL http://www.americanwhoelectrifiedrussia.co.uk
 
Description 'The American Who Electrified Russia' was selected for the Punto de Vista International Documentary Festival, Pamplona, Spain, 5-13 February 2010; and Official International Selection at the Cali International Film Festival, Colombia 29 Oct-7 Nov 2010. It has been screened on several occasions since both in the UK and abroad including most recently (October 2014) in Mexico. It was the subject of presentations at seminars at universities in the UK including Sussex and Luton. I have received several private inquiries from scholars in different countries working in the field. In the process of making the film, I also prepared a subtitled edition of the film 'KShE' (Komsomol Patron of Electrification)' by Esfir Shub, and have given several presentations on it, including: ¶ 'No Apologies for Firstism: KShE (Komsomol Patron of Electrification)' Screening of the film by Esfir Shub, Visible Evidence XV, Lincoln University, 7 August 2008; repeated at CRFAC Seminar, Roehampton University, 22 October 2008. ¶ 'An Archival Find - Esfir Shub's Komsomol Patron of Electrification (1932)', Paper presented at 'The Visual Archive: The Moving Image and Memory', 28th-29th May 2009, Open University
First Year Of Impact 2009
Sector Education
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Conference Screening (Stirling) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Screening followed by rich discussion

Useful feedback and requests for a copy of the film.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2009
 
Description Presentation of KSheE (Open University) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Talk with film extracts stimulated useful discussion and interest.

Requests for copies of the complete film.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2009
 
Description Screening (Pamplona) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Screening followed by Q&A. Interviews with journalists.

There were several reviews of the film following the screening.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
 
Description Screening of KShE (Lincoln) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was a screening of a film from 1932 newly discovered in a London archive, which changes our knowledge of documentary history and accordingly provoked considerable interest.

I subsequently received requests for copies of the film for further screening.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2008
 
Description Symposium (Sussex) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Prompted useful and interesting discussion

General feedback and requests about the availability of the film.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2009