Communication, language and power in the Achaemenid Empire: the correspondence of the satrap Arshama

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Classics Faculty

Abstract

The Achaemenid Persian Empire (550-330 BC) was the largest state-formation in Europe or Western Asia before the Roman Empire and at greatest extent stretched from Greece to western India and from Central Asia to the northern Sudan. Multi- and cross-disciplinary study of its history through written and material evidence from a great variety of cultural settings has developed remarkably since the late 1970s (characteristically through collaborative enterprises) and it is this that provides the network's over-arching academic context: its root purpose is to advance understanding of Persian imperial culture.

The network plan starts from 34 documents (33 in Aramaic, one in Egyptian demotic) either written by Arshama or his officials or addressed to him or alluding to his official activities. 26 form a single archive from an unknown Egyptian site, 7 come from a Jewish archive at Elephantine and one from Saqqara. The specific aim is to use the documents as the focus for (a) investigating how the Persian imperial state ruled and exploited its subjects and (b) drawing scholars from several UK HEIs into a conscious Achaemenid Studies network. The documents fit the purpose perfectly since
- they provide primary evidence from the heart of the imperial bureaucracy and the entourage of one its most powerful figures
- they have never received in their own right the systematic historical and linguistic study they deserve
- as (predominantly) Semitic documents from the circle of an Iranian governor in Egypt (the empire's second-wealthiest province and a region with an exceptional cultural and historical identity) their study is of interest to and requires the expertise of a wide range of philological and historical specialisms

We shall pursue this aim by four means

Close reading of texts. 24 sessions in Oxford will provide a basic introduction to Achaemenid Aramaic and the opportunity to read through the documents in detail. The actual parchments will be available for examination.
Objectives
- acquisition of language skills and an ability to engage with the linguistic aspect of problems in historical interpretation
- new readings of parts of documents that survive in damaged or fragmentary form
- informed contribution to workshops and conference

Workshops and conference. 5 workshops will address major issues in Achaemenid history for which the Arshama documents provide one (but characteristically only one) of the important bodies of evidence. A conference will draw together conclusions reached, and new problems identified, in the workshops and be an opportunity to present projects results to an academic audience beyond the network's core participants. Both workshops and conference will benefit from the participation of major non-UK scholars in the field.
Objectives
- fuller understanding of the correspondence as an archive associated with a particular office-holder
- better location of the correspondence in the context of other types of bureaucratic document from other imperial regions
- sharper sense of the relationship between imperial masters and their subjects
- new perspectives on many issues of governmental procedure and ideology

Exhibition. An exhibition of original documents and associated material from the Bodleian dovetailing with an 'Arshama trail' in the Ashmolean. There will be an annotated catalogue and an accompanying public lecture.
Objectives
- to publicize the Arshama material and its implications
- to provide (in the catalogue) a resource for outreach activities

Publication. Research results will be disseminated in two forms: a large multi-author volume (containing texts, commentary and thematic papers) and an Oxford-hosted web-site (texts, photographs, basic annotation).
Objectives
- dissemination of new data and ideas to the relevant academic community
- provision of a reference point for further research on Achaemenid Egypt and on other regions or aspects of the empire.

Planned Impact

Though the network's activities do not in the first instance address constituencies beyond the academic world, its findings have the potential to interest a wider public. These will be presented - in print, in library and museum exhibitions, through a public lecture, and online on a website - in forms that can benefit not only the professional academic but also the general, historically-minded public.

In view of the attention that is currently paid to Iran in the media and in certain areas of policy-making, these latter groups may turn out to be quite sizeable. More generally the network's activities belong within the wider project of breaking down the barriers, not only institutionally disciplinary but also intellectually and morally substantive, between 'west' and 'east'. The point is to confront the paradigm of 'Oriental despotism' (much abused by certain thinkers close to recent policy-makers) with an informed sense of the complexity and depth of a Middle Eastern past in which an Iranian elite could use a Semitic lingua franca in its administration of an Egyptian, Jewish, Phrygian or Bactrian population and evoke in Greek subjects and opponents not only hostility but also an uneasy sense of admiration. The activities and outputs of the research network thus have the potential of increasing awareness and understanding of this past among the general public. Public (notably media) attention will be drawn to the acitivities of the network through the Press Office at Oxford University.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Thus speaks Arshama: letters of a fifth-century BC Persian prince" 
Description Freely accessible exhibition of material from the Arshama archive, in Proscholium of Bodleian library: presentation of some of the letters (originals, text, translation), some of the sealings (with new drawing of Arshama's seal and another seal which belo 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2011 
Impact xx 
 
Description The findings of the project can be described under two headings. The first is a set of detailled findings, which are important for the scholarly and philological aspect of the Arshama latters; the second is a set of general historical insights, of importance for our understanding of the Achaimenid empire and empires in general.



A.. Detailed findings.

The project generated a number of detailed findings involving the documents in the Arshama archive. The constant reading of the letters, in interdisciplinary sessions involving scholars with overlapping specialties in ancient history, Akkadian, Iranian languages, and Aramaic, generated a stream of corrections or alternative interpretations in the text of the very well known and important letters of Arshama. The examination of the material objects in the archive generated findings on the association between letters and sealings, and the storage methods for this archival dossier (the Bodleian has two, not one leather bag). Finally, the extremely high quality of all the objects was emphasized by all participants who handled the material, in repeated seminar-like meetings before the objects.

B. General findings

The general points are of great importance for the study of empires. First, the crucial importance of the relationship between "public" (the realm of imperial power and administration) and "private" (the realm of estate administration and profit). The distinction does exist, but is blurred, especially in the case of the Achaimenid super-elite, the "sons of the house" which belong to the ruling dynasty. More generally, the theme of the economic self-interest by the imperial elites within the Achaimenid empire appeared in sharp relief throughout the discussions.

The second cluster of findings concerned Achaimenid Egypt. The nature of control (with thinly distributed means, concentrated in case of crisis) was very vividly understood from the information in the Arshama archive; and, equally important, the seriousness of revolt in Achaimenid Egypt (a finding which has consequences in challenging the current orthodoxy about the Achaimenid empire). Finally, the multi-cultural nature of the presence of empire in Achaimenid Egypt was also commented on, notably by G. Vittmann, the specialist in Demotic who participated in the project.

All these findings about Achaimenid Egypt also threw light on the general structure of empire and administration: military control, diversity of administrative personnel, and most importantly, the importance of language and communication in mediating and structuring empire.
Exploitation Route Our findings are of interest to the general public, because they illuminate how multi-cultural empires work- with a combination of collusion, force, and economic exploitation- in the context of the ancient Near-East.



They also show how complex historical problems can be shown to the public, with a combination of exhibition and web presence.
Sectors Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other

URL http://arshama.bodleian.ox.ac.uk
 
Description Arshama and Egypt: the world of an Achaemenid Satrap
Amount £3,410 (GBP)
Funding ID 112/233 
Organisation University of Oxford 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2011 
End 07/2011
 
Description The Arshama archive: prospects and conclusions
Amount £2,600 (GBP)
Funding ID John Fell Award C8027 
Organisation University of Oxford 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 05/2011 
End 09/2011
 
Description Long-term collaboration around the letters of the satrap Arshama 
Organisation University of Liverpool
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Fostering interdisciplinary links around a specific dossier of Achaemenid material; encouraging further exploration of the material and conservation aspects of this material.
Collaborator Contribution Constant and sustained contact between researchers at both universities, across several institutions (Department of Archaeology, Classics and Egyptology, Liverpool; Faculty of Classics, Oxford; Oriental Institute, Oxford; Bodleian Library, Oxford).
Impact 'Thus speaks Arshama' exhibition, Bodleian LIbrary Proscholium, 30 June-16 July 2011 On-line publication of the Arshama letters in the Bodleian, with introduction, text and translation, glossary, and commentary (December 2013) On-line publication of photographs of all sealings and letters in the Bodleian (December 2013)
Start Year 2010
 
Description Long-term collaboration around the letters of the satrap Arshama 
Organisation University of Oxford
Department Bodleian Library
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Fostering interdisciplinary links around a specific dossier of Achaemenid material; encouraging further exploration of the material and conservation aspects of this material.
Collaborator Contribution Constant and sustained contact between researchers at both universities, across several institutions (Department of Archaeology, Classics and Egyptology, Liverpool; Faculty of Classics, Oxford; Oriental Institute, Oxford; Bodleian Library, Oxford).
Impact 'Thus speaks Arshama' exhibition, Bodleian LIbrary Proscholium, 30 June-16 July 2011 On-line publication of the Arshama letters in the Bodleian, with introduction, text and translation, glossary, and commentary (December 2013) On-line publication of photographs of all sealings and letters in the Bodleian (December 2013)
Start Year 2010
 
Description Article in Guardian 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The activities of the Arshama project, specifically the Aramaic lessons, were the object of an article in the Guardian, which provoked interest and subsequent enquiries

Thanks to the press release from Oxford University, the Arshama project attacted the attention of the Guardian. The subsequent article, published on 21 December 2010, provoked great interest on the part of the public (our website crashed under the weight of its in the wake of the article)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
URL http://www.theguardian.com/education/2010/dec/21/aramaic-language-oxford-university
 
Description Exhibition in Bodleian Library 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The exhibition "Thus speaks Arshama: the world of a Persian Prince" allowed for the presentation of material from the Arshama archive to the general public, and draw attention to its interest, as part of the findings and advances of the new Achaimenid history.

The exhibition was located in the Proscholium of the Bodleian Library, the main space in one of the main tourist attractions in Oxford, during the high touristic season. Great work and care was spent, in collaboration with the exhibitions staff at the Bodleian, to make the material and the explanatory texts as concise and accessible as possible, without sacrificing any scholarly or historical rigour.

The Bodleian Library recovered much of the material and reused it as part of a webpage on the Arshama archive
http://arshama.bodleian.ox.ac.uk
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
URL http://arshama.classics.ox.ac.uk/exhibition/index.html