Completion of the full draft of a monograph entitled 'Hadrian's Wall: A life history'

Lead Research Organisation: Durham University
Department Name: Archaeology

Abstract

Introduction: HW is one of Britain's most important ancient monuments & also the most prominent of the works which defined the frontiers of the Roman empire. Its international significance is secured by a long tradition of scholarly study & its designation as a World Heritage Site. It plays a major cultural role in northern England today, signified by the use of the title 'Hadrian's Wall Country' for the central & most impressive section of its physical remains. It also plays a vital role in the economy of this region (Management Plan 2009). Owing to the scholarly study of this monument since the C16, it has become the best understood frontier of the Roman world.

The major Output from this grant is a monograph which will explore the lifecycle of the Wall. This will include: c. 100,000 words, c. 70 illustrations & a 600-reference bibliography. It will communicate approaches & materials derived from the major research project, Tales of the Frontier. Arising from the historical research undertaken by the applicant (PI), it was not a specified Output from this previous grant (see case for support).

Research Context: Recent books have explored the Roman construction & use of HW (e.g. Breeze 2006; Breeze & Dobson 2000 & Symonds & Mason 2009). These stress HW's elemental 'Romanness', its relative completeness & coherence as a Roman frontier work of world significance (Management Plan 2009). Its historical origin and context, constituent elements & the exactitude of detailed knowledge are emphasized (e.g. Symonds & Mason 2009). This significant body of knowledge, built up since the C16, serves to alienate HW from its post-Roman landscape and culture (Witcher et al in press). The fame of HW, recognized at least as early as the C14, has led it to play a particular cultural role, creating a rich body of artistic, mythological, antiquarian & archaeological material; recent archaeological approaches, however, sideline alternative valuations.

This book explores HW's powerful & contradictory significances through time, including ideas of permanence & decay, domination & resistance, exclusion & commonality, stability & mobility. It draws on a wide variety of sources to address the life & after-life of HW, its ongoing destruction & recreation from the C2 to the C21.

Methodology: The research methodology, deriving from Tales, draws on histories, handbooks, maps, excavation reports, classical texts, inscriptions, novels, poems, letters, paintings & photographs. A range of roles for the Wall are defined, in popular, mythical, artistic & scholarly accounts. To place the rise of scholarly knowledge in a broader context, mythical knowledge, folklore, literary history & art history are explored. Using a number of theoretical approaches deriving from archaeology, classics, literary studies, history & geography, the Wall's life is narrated, drawing, in particular, on approaches to monument biography, reception studies & chorography.

A number of tales associated with HW are identified, including its roles as:
- a symbol of Roman imperial might;
- a symbol of early medieval Christian identity (Gildas & Bede);
- a genealogical frontier in the medieval border conflicts between England & Scotland;
- a conceptual boundary for the definition of lowland (English) 'civility';
- an indicator of ancestral valour for those living to its north;
- a major ancient monument which played a role in the formulation of antiquarian & archaeological methodologies;
- a conceptual model for Britain's colonial frontiers in India & Africa; and
- a contemporary inclusive monument for multi-cultural Britain.

Audiences: Include archaeologists, classicists & cultural geographers. The book also has significance for planners & heritage managers. Posting drafts on the Tales project website will enable a range of audiences to read chapters in progress (see case for support).

Planned Impact

Students and the public: The author has also written a number of books which aim to be accessible to the public (e.g. Hingley and Unwin 2005) and it is expected that this monograph will be of interest to undergraduate students & members of the public who have a detailed interest in HW. Indeed, much of the content of the book is fairly accessible. The Tales of the Frontier project communicated its aims & results to a broad audience through the website, a regular e-newsletter, exhibition & public lectures. This has created a public audience for its Outputs. Lectures given over the past 12 months include Hingley's talk to an audience of 150 at the British Archaeology conference in Cardiff in February 2009. He is currently involved in various initiatives including outreach through a contribution to 'Know your Hadrian's Wall', March 2010 (http://www.hadrians-wall.org/page.aspx/Know-Your-Hadrian's-Wall-Country). Consideration will also be given to the production of a popular volume to summarise the results in a more approachable manner after April 2011 (although this is not an Output of this application).

It is intended to make draft chapters of the book available on the Tales of the Frontier website as they are written. This will enable members of the public, undergraduates, taught postgraduates, research postgraduates & academic colleagues to sample the draft texts. This will also generate awareness of the issues to be covered in the published book.

Planners: The research is relevant to government planners & heritage managers who care for the HW World Heritage Site. The recent Hadrian's Wall Management Plan (Management Plan 2009, 26-8) contains the 'Frontier of the Roman Empire WHS: Hadrian's Wall Draft formal Statement of Significance'. This document, following the usual archaeological emphasis (e.g. Symonds & Mason 2009), places a primary focus on the Roman nature of the Wall & the survival of evidence for the scope, extent & sophistication of the Roman frontier. It also explores a series of other associations held by HW; indeed, it specifies that the educational, recreational, social & economic values of HW are far wider than its Roman associations (ibid, 30-2). The book which is the subject of this application emphasizes these alternative valuations, exploring the complex relationships between these forms of knowing & the well-researched Roman associations of the monument. The Tales project was intended to help inform the wider appreciation of HW & the perspectives outlined in the monograph will be of relevance to the deliberations over the future management of the World Heritage Site. The applicant's membership on the Hadrian's Wall Management Plan Committee (http://www.hadrians-wall.org/ResourceManager/Documents/Hadrian) and the English Heritage Research Advisory Panel, enables him to ensure that planner & heritage managers are aware of this developing & published research. Broader appreciations should have an increasing input into the valuation, management & interpretation of the Wall over the next few years.

Academics: The monograph is primarily aimed at an academic audience, across a variety of disciplines (see above). The applicant will continue to network and lecture widely & develop his academic contacts in classics, geography, English studies & history in order to ensure that the work is widely read.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This project involved the completion of a monograph that addresses the life of Hadrian's Wall from its construction in the second century to the internet. This book was published in October 2012 and was updated and reprinted as a paperback in Spring 2015. It arose from the PI's contribution to the AHRC-funded 'Tales of the Frontier' project. It addresses the numerous ways that people have brought the monument to life since it fell into disuse in the fifth century. The book draws upon chorography by addressing a number of places along the Wall - it has been widely and positively reviewed. It has been very widely and positively reviewed over the past 6 years.
Exploitation Route There is a considerable public interest focused on this monument in Britain and across the world. The book is written in an accessible manner and I am hoping that it will communicate the results of this project to a wide audience, including scholars, local people and visitors to the Wall from Britain and overseas. For example, in May 2013, I gave a lecture drawn from the book to an audience of around 100 local people at the Hexham Local History Society. A number of media enquiries have already arisen and there appears to be considerable interest in the book.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Education,Environment

URL http://www.dur.ac.uk/roman.centre/hadrianswall/publications/rhbook/
 
Description The findings of the volume have been used in debates about the 4th and 5th iterations of the Management Plan for Hadrian's Wall and the Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Site. The emphasis on the post-Roman history of the Wall is being absorbed into the interpretation and management strategies for the Wall. I have drafted relevant sections of the Management Plan at the request of the Management Plan committee. My role as Chair of the Archaeological Research Delivery Group for Hadrian's Wall (from December 2015) and membership of the Hadrian's Wall Management Plan Partnership are enabling me to develop these aspects further.
First Year Of Impact 2012
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic

 
Description Chair of the Hadrian's Wall Archaeological Research Delivery Group for the Management Plan Partnership Group 
Organisation Northumberland County Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The Hadrian's Wall co-ordinator is employed by Northumberland County Council and helps to manage the various Delivery Groups connected to the World Heritage Site Management Plan. He has been involved with the development of the academic outputs of a number of our projects connected to Hadrian's Wall since 2007.
Collaborator Contribution Helping develop grant applications and supporting projects underway.
Impact Leaflets arising from the Tales of the Frontier follow-on project
Start Year 2015
 
Description Contribution to 4th iteration of Hadrian's Wall Management Plan (2103-2014) 
Organisation Hadrian's Wall Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Input into the 4th Iteration of the Management Plan for Hadrian's Wall (2013-2014)
Collaborator Contribution Input into the running of the Tales of the Frontier project including a cultural engagement post arising from this.
Impact none in particular. In due course, the 4th iteration of the the Management Plan
Start Year 2012
 
Description Lecture at 'Celtic Classical Conference' in Oxford in June 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Talk on Hadrian's Wall at Celtic Classical Conference in Oxford on the inclusive and divisive uses of Hadrian's Wall in the past decade. This is research deriving from the 'Tales of the Frontier' project and the paper is being written up for the final conference proceedings.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://torch.ox.ac.uk/celts-romans-britons-classical-and-celtic-influence-britain-55-bc---2016-ad
 
Description Talk at Hadrian's Wall Networking Day 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Around 120 participants attended the Hadrian's Wall Networking day and Hingley was the first speaker. This was a lively event at which the results of the Tales of the Frontier project were addressed and there was a lively discussion about broadening participation with regard to the monument.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.visithadrianswall.co.uk/whats-on/hadrians-wall-networking-day-celebrating-your-world-heri...