Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's The Black Jacobins in Context

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Cultures, Languages and Area Studies

Abstract

Interest in Haiti generated by recent devastating events there comes in the context of wider debates both in academic and public spheres over the last few years about connections between Haiti's past and present, particularly the relevance of its Revolution and culture. One of the most important means of understanding the Revolution and its continued importance today is C.L.R. James's classic The Black Jacobins. Despite this work's continuing high profile among histories of the Haitian Revolution for both academic and non-specialist readers, not enough is known about the history of the work itself, nor its constant evolutions, impacts and afterlives in both play- and history-form. Uncovering James's crucial updating and re-presentation of the story of the Haitian Revolution at key points, three of the outputs related to this project---(i) book (entitled: Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's 'The Black Jacobins' in Context), (ii) contributions to a sound archive (radio broadcast and CD) on the history of the work, and (iii) programme notes for the new 2011 Liverpool production of The Black Jacobins play---chart the trajectory of The Black Jacobins over a period of almost sixty years, from the early 1930s right up until James's death in 1989. Two further outputs---an international conference and edited volume on 'The Haitian Revolution Now', and a series workshops for local schools based on The Black Jacobins and legacies of slavery today---will address the work's contemporary significance.

In terms of rethinking and updating The Black Jacobins, crucial changes which completely reorient both the history and the play will be revealed. These include the influence of new 'history from below' historiography; shifts from African- to West Indian-centred visions of the future; and James's marked political evolution since 1938. These changes will be read for the first time in the light of James's own comments in correspondence, lectures and annotations in newly-discovered manuscript and typescript versions of both his plays based on the Haitian Revolution, outlining the actual processes of rewriting, and important fundamental changes to Marxist language and terminology will be examined.

Particular emphasis will be given to the myriad metamorphoses of James's second play The Black Jacobins (1967), which reworks his earlier 1936 Toussaint Louverture play, and also both versions of the history The Black Jacobins: Toussaint Louverture and the San Domingo Revolution (1938 and 1963). Major changes to characterisation will be explored, focusing on the foregrounding of alternative popular leaders and the progressive writing-out of Toussaint Louverture. Turning the past back into drama, it will be argued, enables James to imagine the Haitian Revolution 'from below' as he puts words in the mouths of new protagonists of whom there is little archival trace. Shifting the focus to the never published or performed epilogue, the outputs will show that James updates and repositions the work's present- and future-oriented dimensions.

Finally, the impact, afterlives and centrality of The Black Jacobins to subsequent historiographical and literary accounts of the Haitian Revolution will be explored. To what extent, the research asks, did the work become, as James himself claimed, a 'Haitian bible', provoking political reverberations in a wide range of political situations? Key issues of translating, selling and packaging the work for readers in different countries will be outlined, focusing on the hostile critical reception received by Pierre Naville's 1949 French version and the ultimately abandoned projects of a Cuban translation in 1960, and a trip to Haiti in the late 1950s to promote the work. Engaging with a range of different audiences, all parts of the project will bear witness to the continuing impact, relevance, adaptability,and afterlives of The Black Jacobins.

Planned Impact

My research aimed at producing a definitive study of the history of the The Black Jacobins provides an ideal opportunity for wider engagement with this text on its seventy-fifth anniversary. A key research objective is to trace the work's afterlives, and a good way to do this is through outreach activities which bring The Black Jacobins to a new generation in a city with historic connections to the Caribbean and slavery. Public and educational events, as well as outputs, directly linked to this research will have an impact on the local Liverpool Caribbean community, members of the general public with an interest in James, the Liverpool International Slavery Museum, national and local media, and Liverpool schoolchildren. The project will provide a major public event in Liverpool during Black History Month (October 2011). The staging of The Black Jacobins play will encourage the local community to reconsider: Liverpool's past as Britain's principal slaving port; the impact and long-term legacies of the Transatlantic slave trade; and Caribbean and African migration to Liverpool. This will be only the third time one of James's plays based on the Haitian Revolution has been produced in the UK. Previous productions were both London-based, Toussaint Louverture (1936) and The Black Jacobins (1986). As this will be the first time that The Black Jacobins has been performed in twenty-five years, and the only time it has been shown outside London, this is likely to be one of the most high profile events of Black History Month in Liverpool, drawing in high numbers and generating interest among members of the public and the media. It will create new partnerships between the UK theatre sector, in particular Britain's first-and today foremost-black theatre company (Talawa), the International Slavery Museum and National Museums Liverpool, and the University of Liverpool. Staging The Black Jacobins will be an opportunity to highlight both Liverpool's slaving past as inherent to the fabric of the city, and the Caribbean character and cultural roots of Liverpudlians of Caribbean origin, uncovering intersections between international and local culture. An international conference will also be held at the International Slavery Museum, which will strengthen international relations between the city, the museum, the University and a number of high-profile keynote speakers, including Madison Smartt-Bell, author of acclaimed popular histories of the Haitian Revolution and biography of Toussaint Louverture, and academics including historians, politics and literary specialists, sociologists, geographers, and scholars working in the interrelated fields of Caribbean studies, postcolonial studies, cultural studies, and American studies. To maximise the reach of the events and their educational and cultural benefits, I plan to involve younger members of the wider local community further by organising workshops at the museum on The Black Jacobins and the significance and relevance of the Haitian Revolution today. These outreach events will be organised as part of the University of Liverpool's current Widening Participation topic of 'the African Diaspora', which aims to promote a deeper understanding of the impact of the Trans-Atlantic slave trade on a local, regional, national, and international level. Further impact related to this project will result from my contribution during the award to an audio archive about C.L.R. James and his play and history The Black Jacobins produced by Adrian Leibowitz, audiovisual expert from the Open University, and David Neita, the Caribbean 'people's poet'. This recording will be produced as a radio broadcast, as a CD for sale at performances of the play in 2011, and will also be deposited with the British Library Sound Archive to extend the reach of the project still further to the media and thereby nationally to the wider pu

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Audio Recordings 
Description Sound archive produced by Adrian Leibowitz, audiovisual expert from the Open University and Common Custom: Documentary & Archive. Recordings of prominent people associated with the story of James's The Black Jacobins in both play and history form. These recordings will be used as radio broadcasts, a CD, and will also be deposited with the British Library Sound Archive to extend the reach of the project to the media and to the wider public in general 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2016 
Impact These recordings will be used as radio broadcasts, a CD, and will also be deposited with the British Library Sound Archive to extend the reach of the project to the media and to the wider public in general 
 
Title C.L.R. James Film 
Description Film produced by Worldwrite Every Cook Can Govern: Documenting the life, impact and works of C.L.R. James to be launched 31 March 2016. Contains footage of all The Black Jacobins events, including the play performance, and an interview with me. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2016 
Impact Impacts will be measurable after film launch on 31 March 2016. 
URL http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
 
Title Performance of Toussaint Louverture Play 
Description First performance since 1936 of precursor to C.L.R. James's classic history of the Haitian revolution The Black Jacobins, which started life as a play with Paul Robeson in the lead. These readings also include material never before published or performed. This performance was filmed by Worldwrite as part of their footage for the C.L.R. James film: Every Cook Can Govern to be launched 31 March 2016 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2013 
Impact Generated much interest as it was the first performance since 1936 of C.L.R. James's play, and included material performed for the first time. 
 
Description This project has told the story of how The Black Jacobins was written and rewritten. My research has been based on archive materials never previously used to show how this classic history of the Haitian revolution changed over a period of fifty years. I have shown that the well-known history The Black Jacobins in fact began and ended life as a play. As the work changes over time, James places more emphasis on the role of the people in accordance with his own political views and his desire to make the Haitian revolution serve as a model for political engagement across three continents, not only in the West Indies, but also in the United States, Africa and Britain.
Exploitation Route This project will raise the profile of C.L.R. James, persuading more people to read the book and the plays, and it will help to make The Black Jacobins more of a contemporary reference point. My research clarifies some popular misconceptions about this famous book, and others will now have a much firmer basis for their own engagements with The Black Jacobins.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description Performance of the play has led to public discovery of the play and raised the profile of the subject among general audiences. This was the first time the play had been performed since 1936, and contained never before published or performed material discovered through my archival research. Attendance at the conference and workshop contributed to political engagement and debate. Participation in conference by members of political organisations. The C.L.R. James documentary 'Every Cook Can Govern' has allowed this project to bring C.L.R. James's life and work to a whole new audience. This documentary has been produced by a group of volunteers from London's East End learning filmmaking, and informs a range of different audiences within the community about the subject. See documentary and knowledge portal at: http://www.clrjames.uk/. The performance of the play that I organised can also be accessed here: https://www.clrjames.uk/video/black-jacobins-conference/reading-of-toussaint-louverture-play/
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Glasgow and Liverpool Slavery Connections 
Organisation African and Caribbean Network
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Events organised were high-profile Black History Month events in both Liverpool and Glasgow, and attracted wide audiences to the International Slavery Museum and the Bluecoat.
Collaborator Contribution The International Slavery Museum Liverpool and the Bluecoat gave us free use of facilities. Worldwrite brought a crew of 20 to Liverpool to film the performance and conference. The Haiti Support Group and the African and Caribbean network provided us with much publicity for the Glasgow workshop Talking About Haiti. Common Custom: Documentary and archive helped to create a recorded sound archive of The Black Jacobins.
Impact Performance: Toussaint Louverture Play, Bluecoat Chambers Liverpool, 27 October 2013 Conference: Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's The Black Jacobins in Context, 27-28 October 2013, International Slavery Museum Liverpool Workshop: Talking About Haiti, Glasgow, 29 October 2013 Film: Every Cook Can Govern: the life, works & impact of C.L.R. James, 2016, http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
Start Year 2011
 
Description Glasgow and Liverpool Slavery Connections 
Organisation Bluecoat Chambers
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Events organised were high-profile Black History Month events in both Liverpool and Glasgow, and attracted wide audiences to the International Slavery Museum and the Bluecoat.
Collaborator Contribution The International Slavery Museum Liverpool and the Bluecoat gave us free use of facilities. Worldwrite brought a crew of 20 to Liverpool to film the performance and conference. The Haiti Support Group and the African and Caribbean network provided us with much publicity for the Glasgow workshop Talking About Haiti. Common Custom: Documentary and archive helped to create a recorded sound archive of The Black Jacobins.
Impact Performance: Toussaint Louverture Play, Bluecoat Chambers Liverpool, 27 October 2013 Conference: Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's The Black Jacobins in Context, 27-28 October 2013, International Slavery Museum Liverpool Workshop: Talking About Haiti, Glasgow, 29 October 2013 Film: Every Cook Can Govern: the life, works & impact of C.L.R. James, 2016, http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
Start Year 2011
 
Description Glasgow and Liverpool Slavery Connections 
Organisation Common Custom: Documentary and archive
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Events organised were high-profile Black History Month events in both Liverpool and Glasgow, and attracted wide audiences to the International Slavery Museum and the Bluecoat.
Collaborator Contribution The International Slavery Museum Liverpool and the Bluecoat gave us free use of facilities. Worldwrite brought a crew of 20 to Liverpool to film the performance and conference. The Haiti Support Group and the African and Caribbean network provided us with much publicity for the Glasgow workshop Talking About Haiti. Common Custom: Documentary and archive helped to create a recorded sound archive of The Black Jacobins.
Impact Performance: Toussaint Louverture Play, Bluecoat Chambers Liverpool, 27 October 2013 Conference: Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's The Black Jacobins in Context, 27-28 October 2013, International Slavery Museum Liverpool Workshop: Talking About Haiti, Glasgow, 29 October 2013 Film: Every Cook Can Govern: the life, works & impact of C.L.R. James, 2016, http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
Start Year 2011
 
Description Glasgow and Liverpool Slavery Connections 
Organisation Haiti Support Group
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Events organised were high-profile Black History Month events in both Liverpool and Glasgow, and attracted wide audiences to the International Slavery Museum and the Bluecoat.
Collaborator Contribution The International Slavery Museum Liverpool and the Bluecoat gave us free use of facilities. Worldwrite brought a crew of 20 to Liverpool to film the performance and conference. The Haiti Support Group and the African and Caribbean network provided us with much publicity for the Glasgow workshop Talking About Haiti. Common Custom: Documentary and archive helped to create a recorded sound archive of The Black Jacobins.
Impact Performance: Toussaint Louverture Play, Bluecoat Chambers Liverpool, 27 October 2013 Conference: Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's The Black Jacobins in Context, 27-28 October 2013, International Slavery Museum Liverpool Workshop: Talking About Haiti, Glasgow, 29 October 2013 Film: Every Cook Can Govern: the life, works & impact of C.L.R. James, 2016, http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
Start Year 2011
 
Description Glasgow and Liverpool Slavery Connections 
Organisation International Slavery Museum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Events organised were high-profile Black History Month events in both Liverpool and Glasgow, and attracted wide audiences to the International Slavery Museum and the Bluecoat.
Collaborator Contribution The International Slavery Museum Liverpool and the Bluecoat gave us free use of facilities. Worldwrite brought a crew of 20 to Liverpool to film the performance and conference. The Haiti Support Group and the African and Caribbean network provided us with much publicity for the Glasgow workshop Talking About Haiti. Common Custom: Documentary and archive helped to create a recorded sound archive of The Black Jacobins.
Impact Performance: Toussaint Louverture Play, Bluecoat Chambers Liverpool, 27 October 2013 Conference: Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's The Black Jacobins in Context, 27-28 October 2013, International Slavery Museum Liverpool Workshop: Talking About Haiti, Glasgow, 29 October 2013 Film: Every Cook Can Govern: the life, works & impact of C.L.R. James, 2016, http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
Start Year 2011
 
Description Glasgow and Liverpool Slavery Connections 
Organisation Worldwrite London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Events organised were high-profile Black History Month events in both Liverpool and Glasgow, and attracted wide audiences to the International Slavery Museum and the Bluecoat.
Collaborator Contribution The International Slavery Museum Liverpool and the Bluecoat gave us free use of facilities. Worldwrite brought a crew of 20 to Liverpool to film the performance and conference. The Haiti Support Group and the African and Caribbean network provided us with much publicity for the Glasgow workshop Talking About Haiti. Common Custom: Documentary and archive helped to create a recorded sound archive of The Black Jacobins.
Impact Performance: Toussaint Louverture Play, Bluecoat Chambers Liverpool, 27 October 2013 Conference: Rewriting the Haitian Revolution: C.L.R. James's The Black Jacobins in Context, 27-28 October 2013, International Slavery Museum Liverpool Workshop: Talking About Haiti, Glasgow, 29 October 2013 Film: Every Cook Can Govern: the life, works & impact of C.L.R. James, 2016, http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
Start Year 2011
 
Description Conference on The Black Jacobins at the International Slavery Museum, Liverpool 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact International conference held at the International Slavery Museum which strengthened international relations between the cities Liverpool and Glasgow, the museum, the Universities. It featured a number of high-profile speakers including: Selma James, Robert A. Hill, Bill Schwarz, Yvonne Brewster, Rawle Gibbons, Nick Nesbitt, and Matthew J. Smith. This event was filmed by Worldwrite and will be an important part of the C.L.R. James film Every Cook Can Govern to be launched on 31 March 2016.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013,2016
URL http://www.clrjames.uk/video/black-jacobins-conference/
 
Description Film of The Black Jacobins Events 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Events filmed form during the events organised in Liverpool (Conference, Performance of Toussaint Louverture 1936 Play) form a major part of the major documentary produced by charity Worldwrite in London:

Every Cook Can Govern: Documenting the life, impact & works of CLR James

This film will be launched on 31 March 2016
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013,2016
URL http://www.clrjames.uk/the-film/
 
Description Performance of Toussaint Louverture Play 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Sunday 27 October 2013, 7.30pm, The Bluecoat, Liverpool. Toussaint Louverture: The Story of the Only Successful Slave Revolt in History (1936). A Reading of Extracts by Tayo Aluko & Friends. First performance since 1936 of precursor to C.L.R. James's classic history of the Haitian revolution The Black Jacobins, which started life as a play with Paul Robeson in the lead. These readings also included material never before published or performed.

This performance was filmed and will be an important part of the film 'Every Cook Can Govern: Documenting the life, impact & works of CLR James', which will be launched on 31 March 2016 in London.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013,2016
URL https://blackjacobinsrevisited.wordpress.com/performance-toussaint-louverture/
 
Description Workshop Talking About Haiti: 60 participants 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Workshop in Glasgow: Talking about Haiti, 29 October 2013. Attended by 65.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL https://blackjacobinsrevisited.wordpress.com/talking-about-haiti-glasgow-event-29-october-2013-3-6pm...