Early cinema in Scotland, 1896-1927

Lead Research Organisation: University of Glasgow
Department Name: Theatre Film & Television Studies

Abstract

The central aim of the project is to produce a comprehensive account of the early development of cinema in Scotland. Where were the early films shown; who by and to whom? Where were cinemas built; by whom and with what success? What films did they show and who went to them? How did films circulate, and who distributed them. What kinds of film were (and were not) produced in Scotland? Who produced them? What succeeded and what did not? How did cinema grow as a business? In what ways did cinema, within thirty years, become a major cultural form? What were the differences between rural cinema and cinema as an urban phenomenon? How were the expectations of cinema defined; what social, cultural and aesthetic values were ascribed to it; and how was the experience of cinema described in the press and other sources?

The popularity of cinema in Scotland - and in Glasgow particularly - is legendary. Purpose-built cinemas began to appear in 1910, and by 1920 there were 557 cinemas in Scotland. By 1929, according to the historian, Christopher Harvie, Glasgow alone had 127 cinemas. Green's Playhouse, opening in 1927 had a seating capacity of 4,368, and was, by repute, the largest cinema in the world outside the USA. In 1939, according to Bruce Peter, there were 'a staggering 114 picture houses in Glasgow with a seating capacity in excess of 175,000, more cinema seats per head than any other city in the world.'

Against this background, the absence of indigenously produced feature film is striking. In a period from 1915 to 1930, when the Irish Filmography lists around 30 Irish-produced fiction films, the Scottish record contains 6. In the same period, internationally, over 150 films have clearly identified Scottish themes; e.g. Bonnie Prince Charlie, Rob Roy, and Mary, Queen of Scots.

This disparity - between the popularity of cinema and the production of feature films; between the international market for Scottish stories and the apparent absence of a domestic industry which might sustain their production - points to a key element in the historical context for the research.

More broadly, the project addresses a fundamental gap in the historical record of Scottish culture, which is itself a disparity in current research: the disparity between the importance of cinema in 20th-century Scottish culture, the wealth of documentary evidence available in archives, and the lack of sustained academic research in uncovering, collating and making sense of this evidence. While early Irish cinema has been well surveyed in monographs and edited collections, while there are two monographs which address early cinema in Wales, and while the inventiveness of regional producers in Brighton, Sheffield or Blackburn is part of the international history of early cinema, research into history of the early cinema in Scotland is covered by a handful of articles and catalogue introductions.

This, then, will be the first major attempt to bring together systematically a range of resources and archive records in order to produce a comprehensive account of the beginnings of cinema in Scotland. It will cover production, distribution, exhibition and reception in order to understand the cultural, social and economic place of cinema in the early years of the twentieth century: the phenomenon which Francesco Casetti describes as 'the popularization of modernity and the modernization of popularity.' In this sense, the research will contribute to a more complex understanding of the cultural significance of the so-called 'silent period'. An understanding of the particular popularity of the 'cinema of attractions' in Scotland -- of 'shows', 'local topicals' and 'actualities' -- will add significantly to international research into film history and to the historical understanding of a period when it was not yet certain that cinema would become either a dominant form of culture, or, indeed, a narrative form of entertainment.

Planned Impact

Recognising the evident public interest in early cinema, the project is committed to public engagement of the highest standard. This will be achieved in a number of ways.

(1) Through the Collaborative Framework Agreement between Glasgow University and Culture and Sport Glasgow (see Pathways to Impact), we have begun discussions on the best way to provide a long-term display on early cinema, informed by the research of the project, in one of Glasgow Museums' venues. It is one of the advantages of the Geographical Information Systems (GIS) that it can be adapted and exported to more user-friendly formats to engage the museum public in accessible and interactive ways.
Through the project partnership with CSG, the project will significantly enhance the understanding of the early cinema collections in Glasgow Museums. This knowledge will be embedded in the museum's collection management system ensuring that future displays and other projects can be informed by this research. Additional content can also be developed for its publicly accessible online Collections Navigator (see http://collections.glasgowmuseums.com/). This will increase public access to the collection both digitally and physically at Glasgow Museums Resource Centre.

(2) We have been approached by Falkirk City Council to participate in a Silent Film Festival, to be held in the Hippodrome Cinema, built originally in 1911 and recently restored by the Council to its original state as a functioning cinema. This participation will provide both the focus and the profile to develop other outreach activities in Scotland: travelling exhibitions, presentations and workshops.

(3) We have had very positive discussions with Hopscotch Films, an independent production company, on a television series on the history of early cinema in Scotland. This would follow their current six-part series, currently in post-production, on Scottish cinema from the 1930s to the postwar period, and would be consistent with the profile of cultural programming to which they are committed.

(4) The project partner, Scottish Screen Archive, has extensive experience of working with schools, both through public cinemas and festivals and through classroom practice, in the promotion of film archive holdings for use in cultural and social history, and in deepening pupil's awareness of film and media history. One of the major contributions in kind of the partnership will be the time of the SSA's Education and Outreach Officer, who will work in collaboration with school teachers to adapt research materials for use as teaching packs and workshops for use in schools throughout Scotland.

(5) Through the development of digital discovery and dissemination as a distinctive element of the project's research methodology, and with the support of Glasgow University's Humanities Advanced Technology and Information Institute (HATII), we will contribute to the professional development of museum and archive staff. This will be facilitated by the partnership with the Scottish Screen Archive/National Library of Scotland, and by the Framework Agreement with CSG, one of the aims of which is to provide training in academic research methods to museum and gallery researchers, and to promote exchange between academic researchers and museum curators.

(6) The project will have indirect, but measurable, economic impact by contributing in the short term to Glasgow's cultural programme for the Commonwealth Games (2014), in which museums and galleries will play a significant part. On a longer term basis, a research-informed display of early cinema in Glasgow Museums, and in local museums throughout the country, will contribute to Scotland's tourist profile.

(7) More directly, an independently produced documentary series on early cinema in Scotland has the potential to make a direct contribution to the Scotti
 
Title Joining Up: Scotland, cinema and the First World War 
Description Video-essay by David Archibald and Maria Velez-Serna (University of Glasgow). This short film edits archive footage from the National Library of Scotland's Moving Image Archive, of local topical films shot in Scottish towns and cities during the First World War. The edited clips, voiceover and music from gramophone records advance an argument about the value of local film's unscripted detail as a counterpoint to the overwhelming big narratives of the War. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2015 
Impact The film has been shown at community screenings and film festivals: Document Human Rights Film Festival 2014, Glasgow Short Film Festival 2015 (where we were invited to a video-essay panel to present it), 'Fail Better' spoken word night, Govanhill Baths, amongst others. It has been reviewed online (see e.g. http://filmtofile.com/digital-cinema/2016/7/12/film-to-file-film-studies-edition) and used for teaching. 
URL https://vimeo.com/122680865
 
Description The project has not only added new knowledge to early cinema in Britain, it has engaged in the development of geo-databases as a historical method and has emphasised the importance of the local in national cinemas. It has also had a significant international impact, has contributed substantially to the Routledge Companion to New Cinema History, and will publish a book through Edinburgh University Press, 'Early Cinema in Scotland', with chapters written by members of the research team.
The project was important in using the website as the major repository of data. This makes it both accessible, responsive and dynamic. The focus on local cinema cultures also made full use of geo-mapping as a way of mapping cinema history.
Two PhD projects were completed successfully within the terms of the project:
Julia Bohlman, 'Regulating and Mediating the Social Role of Cinema in Scotland, 1896-1933
Caroline Merz, 'Why Not a Scots Hollywood: fiction film production in Scotland, 1911-1928' The edited collection from the project, 'Early Cinema in Scotland' was an additional output, not anticipated in the application but commissioned by Edinburgh University Press. In his endorsement of the manuscript, Professor Robert C. Allen (University of North Carolina) says: '"Early Cinema in Scotland" represents an important benchmark in what has come to be called "new cinema history". The fruit of three years of dogged research by a talented team of cinema historians, it situates the emergence of cinema within the complex political, social and cultural contexts of "place". In doing so, it productively complicates notions of the local, the national; urban and rural; modernity and tradition. It is revealing in its account of the particularities of "Scotland" and "Scottishness" while, at the same time, establishing a framework for comparative analysis. John Caughie and his colleagues have set a new standard for cinema historiography.'
Exploitation Route The development working web has invited comment and new information from interested members of the public. The web is a publicly available resource, which will be supplemented by an edited collection from the project, Early Cinema in Scotland, edited by the P.I., the Co-I. and the postdoctoral researchers and with contributions from all members of the research team. Printed data from the research was forwarded to the Campbeltown Restoration Project, a £3.5 million restoration of the Campbeltown Picture House, first built in 1913, funded by Heritage Lottery Fund and the Scottish Government, and has been incorporated into their community website. Further primary data has been deposited in the National Library of Scotland Moving Image Archive for continued public availability.
Sectors Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://earlycinema.gla.ac.uk
 
Description The project has filled a gap in the understanding of Scottish and British early cinema. The website, which will be publicly launched in March 2016, provides a significant data resource for film historians internationally and for public interest. There have been a number of enquiries from scholars and members of the public, and new information has been added. We have also collaborated with Britannia Panopticon Music Hall Trust in digitising a major collection of scrapbooks from one opt the pioneers of cinema and much hall, A.E. Pickard. The end of project conference, organised in collaboration with the international scholarly network, HoMER (History of Moviegoing, Exhibition and Reception), was a major contribution to the historical study of cinema-going and the social history of cinema. It had keynote speakers from USA, Canada, Australia, the Netherlands, and from the AHRC project and involved around 100 scholars from Europe, North America and Australia. A number of papers are to be published in the Routledge Companion to New Cinema History, edited by Richard Maltby, Philippe Meers and Daniel Biltereyst. The project, and its website, have also attracted local public interest which has been attracted particularly by the focus on cinema in small towns. We have attracted particular interest from local historians and heritage organisations in such towns as Bo'ness, Campbeltown, Dumfries, Coatbridge and Bonnybridge. There has also been some interest from schools, particularly in cinema during Word War 1. The book from the project, 'Early Cinema in Scotland',was shortlisted for the Saltire Society Research Book of the Year award in 2018,
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Title Website 
Description The project website is a major output of the project. It is a MySQL database containing tables on venues, people, companies, films, newspaper and trade press articles. The venues and film locations (mainly for non-fiction Scottish films) are georeferenced. This is used to generate map markers to display on the public page, allowing users to click through from the map to otherinformation in the database. We have used the underlying data in other ways - classifying and comparing layers in response to specific research questions - so we intend to make the raw data available for other film historians. However the 'front end' of the web site will present a simpler interface for public access, with just venues and film locations. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The final website will be publicly launched in March 2016. We have made the WordPress site available to other scholars, 
URL http://earlycinema.gla.ac.uk
 
Description Collaboration with Britannia Panopticon Music Hall Trust 
Organisation Britannia Panopticon Music Hall Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We collaborated with the Trust in purchasing twenty scrapbooks of the cinema and music hall pioneer, A.E. Pickard, a key figure in late-19th and early 20th century in Glasgow. Through a successful bid to the Heritage Lottery Fund we were able to digitise the scrapbooks and make them publicly available.
Collaborator Contribution The scrap[books are the property of the Trust, and they facilitated the digitisation.
Impact The digitised version of the archive will be linked to our website as a complementary resource
Start Year 2014
 
Description Collaboration with HoMER in the end-of-project conference 
Organisation History of Moviegoing, Exhibition, and Reception
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We worked with HoMER in the call for papers and in the selection of papers to be presented. Keynote presentations were given by members of the HoMER network (including the P.I.) and the conference provided an opportunity to move beyond the local issue of early cinema in Scotland to an international debate on the nature of the history of cinema and of early cinema in particular from the perspective of world cinema history.
Collaborator Contribution HoMER provided an international network of interest.
Impact the Routledge Companion to New Cinema History, edited by Richard Maltby, Philippe Meers and Daniel Bitereyst, draws on papers from the conference and is largely inspired by the questions it addressed
Start Year 2013
 
Description Contribution to exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Contribution to an exhibition organised by the Mitchell Library, Glasgow, including public talk on Glasgow cinemas

Broad public interest
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Development of a learning resource for Secondary Schools 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The collaboration resulted in the preparation of a DVD, 'Cinema and the First World War in Scotland' as a learning resource for schools nationally.

The collaboration was useful in bring together the collaborators and in the production of a long-term learning resource.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Early cinema in Bo'ness 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A contribution by two researchers to the Bo'ness Silent Cinema Festival, a public event organised by Falkirk District Council, in the Hippodrome Cinema (a 1912 cinema recently re-opened as a public cinema venue). The presentation to around 75 people for an afternoon event was intended for an interested but non-academic audience, and was well received.

Increased public interest in the history of local cinema in Bo'ness. Significant contribution to the Festival of Silent Cinema at the Hippodrome Cinema, supported by Falkirk District Council.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
 
Description Glasgow Film Theatre World War 1 event 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact An audience of just under 100 attended an afternoon event on Cinema during World War 1. Included selected screenings and talks by three members of the research team, together with appropriate music from a trench gramophone.

Strong public interest, and an agreement to contribute to the cinema's educational and outreach programme
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Hippodrome Festival of Silent Cinema 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact 75 members of the public attended an event at the Bo'ness Festival of Silent Cinema on the impact of the First World War on local cinema. Strong public interest and engagement.

Agreement to provide school workshop in the area in 2015.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014