Late-life Creativity and the 'new old age': Arts & Humanities and Gerontology in Critical Dialogue

Lead Research Organisation: Keele University
Department Name: Inst for Humanities

Abstract

The UK's population is ageing, and this demographic trend poses challenges and opportunities for our societies and the knowledge economies that serve them. A key topic, we believe, is creativity and specifically late-life creativity. Our primary set of questions is: what is 'late-life creativity'? How might we define it? And in what ways is it different from creativity at earlier phases of life? We will explore these questions by bringing together scholars in arts and humanities and in critical gerontology, along with creative artists and performers, social care practitioners, and older people. The network will be shaped by four themed workshops focused on: identity and discipline; 'late style'; memory; and community.

In recent years, gerontologists have explored new lifestyles in later life and their implications for understanding community and well-being; while in literature and theatre, art history, and music, there has been a critical focus on the limitations of common understandings of old age in the assessment of late-life creative output - there has, for instance, been a steadily growing interest in ideas of 'late style', that is, of the relationship between writers', artists' or composers' final works, the style of those works in relation to their earlier output, and the practicalities of their creativity in old age and/or the proximity of death - and, in reminiscence theatre, practitioners have worked with people across different generations to create new understandings of the past and of late-life creativity. These different modes of research and creativity have worked to similar ends but in parallel and rather frustratingly out of contact with each other. The point of the proposed network is to bring them together, so that new understandings of late-life creativity will emerge from critical dialogue and will be able to cross boundaries.

Our proposal represents an opportunity for arts & humanities scholars both to influence policy and practice in gerontology and to learn from the traditions of gerontological research, which has always sought to translate ideas into actions designed to enhance social inclusion. For this reason, the dialogues we propose will include not only academics in the two fields but writers, performers, older people involved in creative activity and those involved in the theory and practice of old-age care. The ideas developed will be translated into outcomes that can be widely understood and help give shape to future interdisciplinary research and policy thinking. This, in turn, we believe, will help create new openings for HE's engagement with later life and specifically with late-life creativity, both in research and in practice.

Planned Impact

The network we propose has significant impact potential precisely because it will draw together, and place in dialogue, a very broad range of people involved in a variety of ways with questions of the long life, of ageing, and of late-life creativity: arts & humanities scholars from a range of disciplinary perspectives and traditions (literature, theatre & performance studies, art history, musicology); archivists, creative artists and performers; social scientists (sociologists, gerontologists, psychiatrists, anthropologists); social care practitioners; and older people as both practitioners and consumers. This mix has, we believe, the potential to generate genuinely wide-ranging social impact. In other words, the network offers the prospect of impact on a wide range of beneficiaries and users who will be as diverse as the discussants comprising the workshops. They include:

(1) later life activists, advocates and performers who will be able to take the insights of the research back into the community networks in which they are already active and engaged;
(2) professional performers and artists, with outstanding reputations and international profiles, whose consciousness of the issue of creativity in later life will have been raised, and which could raise the profile of the issue, and the research, through future discussions and events in which they will participate;
(3) carers, who will be able to develop new strategies for understanding and implementing the positive role that creativity in later life can play, even and especially in situations where cognitive impairment seems to have had a regressive effect on selfhood;
(4) curators of archives, galleries and museums, who over time might be encouraged to see their collections as health-promoting resources, stimulating cultural reflexivity through a raised awareness of late life creativity;
(5) Medical and health professionals, whose reflexivity and critical awareness will be enhanced by exposure to accessibly expressed key traditions of humanistic thought, and new knowledge formations such as medical humanities; and
(6) policy makers, who are planning the development of communities and physical resources for people in later life, and who can take the fruits of this research into account.

We believe, then, that the network has the potential to make a positive impact on the nation's health and culture; it also has the potential to develop valuable, research-informed and well-targeted guidance on public expenditure.

 
Title Back to the Drawing Board: Pat Albeck, Peter Rice, late-life creativity 
Description A series of events in 2016/17 celebrating the long and remarkable creative lives of Pat Albeck and Peter Rice. Pat Albeck is one of the leading textile designers in modern Britain; the late Peter Rice (d.2015) was one of the preeminent stage and costume designers in modern British opera and theatre. Pat Albeck remains a highly active creative artist in her mid 8os: Peter Rice was an active creative artist right up until the moment of his sudden death at the age of 86 during the planning of the exhibition. The lives of both artists were an opportunity to explore careers spanning 60 years, from the 1950s to the present, and to celebrate later life creativity through examples of 'late style' work. For example, a reproduction of Peter Rice's stunning mural painting, 'A Bright Past for Stoke-on-Trent' (2013) was an important and much admired exhibit. The exhibition was developed in partnership with Emma Bridgewater Ltd; Matthew Rice (son of Peter Rice and Pat Albeck, husband of Emma Bridgewater) granted us unique access to the family archives. In addition to the main exhibition mounted in the exhibition space at Chancellor's Building, Keele University, an adjunct exhibition on Peter Rice's work was mounted at the New Vic Theatre, Newcastle-under-Lyme, and was launched through a theatre design discussion forum in front of an audience; the Ages and Stages Elders' theatre company, based at the New Vic performed their piece 'Our Lives as Art' at Keele; an interactive installation based on the exhibition's themes by Keele's Community Animation and Social Innovation Centre was established in Keele's Media Building; a textile design forum in which Emma Bridgewater conversed before an audience with Pat Albeck was held in Keele Hall; a documentary film about the lives of Pat Albeck and Peter Rice was screened at the Westminster Theatre, Keele. The research/creative team was led by Professor David Amigoni and Professor Fiona Cownie; it included Ms Kerry Jones (curator), Dr Pawas Bisht, Dr Rebecca Leach, Dr Ceri Morgan, Dr Liz Poole, Professor Mihaela Kelemen (CASIC), Professor Mim Bernard, Ms Jill Rezzano (New Vic Theatre), Lis Evans (New Vic Theatre) 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The exhibition was featured as a leading contribution to the launch of Stoke-on-Trent's bid to become UK City of Culture, 2021 (http://www.sot2021.com/news); the focus on ageing and culture will be important to the bid Visitor numbers to main exhibition, Chancellor's Building gallery, Keele: 1192 Textile design forum, Pat Albeck and Emma Bridgewater, Keele Hall: audience of 111 Peter Rice Exhibition at New Vic Theatre and 'theatre design forum', 50 attended the forum, an estimated 500 viewed the exhibition in the theatre's gallery space during the two weeks it was displayed Theatrical memories (Ages and Stages), Potteries writing memories, involvement of CASIC (community animators) at installation in Keele's Media Building Documentary film, 'Back to the Drawing Board': about later life creativity, partner loss and widowhood: dir. and ed. by Dr Pawas Bisht, opened and introduced by Darren Henley, chief executive of Arts Council England; audience of c.150 
URL https://www.keele.ac.uk/pressreleases/2016/backtothedrawingboard.html
 
Description 1. Late-life creativity is a key concept for expanding and adding meaning to the 'active ageing' agenda. 'Creativity' stresses the act of placing something new, and of value, in the world. When creativity is associated with older people, it challenges, by definition, unthinking deficit models of the ageing process.
2. By bringing arts and humanities academic experts into dialogue with experts in social and cultural gerontology, as well as with artists and creative practitioners in later life, our network developed new intellectual resources for thinking about creative approaches to ageing effectively and reflectively. Our discussions provided evidence of important relationships of continuity between 'creative' approaches to arts such as dance, literature, music-making, artistic production and consumption, as well as activities that are not normally regarded as 'artistic' such as community activism and organisation.
3. Narrative self-fashioning is a vital tool in the promotion of this sort of self-understanding. The so-called 'cultural turn' in gerontology is an especially insightful approach to the understanding of late-life creativity.
4. Our critical and deconstructive approach to 'late style' in literature, art and music, which challenged the individualistic, genius model of artistic production, consequently opened up a more democratic way of understanding late-life creativity admitting of more artistic practices; as well as collaborative practices of co-creation. These challenges could derive equally from historical and critical approaches to art, as well as from culturally-sensitive approaches to neuroscience.
5. Late-life creativity is specific to particular communities of practice and belonging (such as a locality), including communities marked by distinctive cultural or international markers of identity. Those communities may also consist of older people who experience cognitive challenges or losses (such as dementia), but who may still participate in artistic activities precisely because of the caring and collaborative activities of a community.
6. Late-life creativity has great potential to be cultivated as a valuable reflective practice in therapeutic and even clinical settings. It has a vital role to play in the medical/and or health humanities -- and this can include creative ways of representing, sharing, and coming to terms with the losses and forms of decline that later life can bring.
Exploitation Route As will be apparent from our engagement activities, we are actively continuing to bring our findings to a variety of audiences, from those in medical and/or health humanities, to concert audiences, to clinicians who have developed similar insights (for instance, Professor Desmond O'Neill, TCD)
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Education,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.latelifecreativity.org/
 
Description David Amigoni and Gordon McMullan have engaged audiences with their findings through presentations and talks. Amigoni has addressed a prominent older peoples' educational organisation (Ransackers); they have both addressed a large pre-concert audience at the Royal Festival Hall on the topic of late style (February 2016, London Philharmonic Orchestra). McMullan developed this occasion through the considerable resources of the Shakespeare400 festival, of which he is academic director. Some of the ideas about late style which our research network helped to advance have been exhibited through the curatorial and commentary work of Professor Sam Smiles in the exhibition 'Late Turner: Painting Set Free' (Tate Gallery, London, Sept 2014-January 2015). Smiles collaborates with McMullan and Amigoni and is an important member of the research network. At present, Amigoni's work is in the form of public engagement activities. We would expect this research to mature as the source of a deeper impact in the coming year as it helps, conceptually, to shape Keele University's partnership work with the Emma Bridgewater Ltd over the 'Vintage Now' exhibition (November 2016), celebrating the artistic and design careers of Pat Albeck and Peter Rice as they continue to produce art in later life. In addition to the exhibition which will take place at Keele University, an accompanying documentary film will be produced; along with theatrical/social animation work on creativity and later life delivered in partnership with the New Vic Theatre, Newcastle-under-Lyme: Jill Rezzano, educational director, was also a member of the network. This narrative will be further developed and updated in future submissions. 2017: An entry on this exhibition, which ran successfully between November 2016-January 2017, and eventually titled 'Back to the Drawing Board' is added this year under as an Artistic/Creative Output. This work, along with the University's research and engagement work on and with older people, has been used to promote Stoke-on-Trent's bid to become UK City of Culture 2021. 2018: The work of this network continues to inform debate in the Live Age Festival (29 September 2017), a partnership between Keele University and the New Vic Theatre, which has also been in receipt of Arts Council England Funding under the 'Celebrating Age' award scheme. Amigoni chaired the 'Live Age Debate at the New Vic Theatre on the 'Contribution of Creative Ageing': which included contributions from the City Council's director of public health, a local dramatist, and the deputy director of education, National Museums Liverpool. The event coincided with the submission of Stoke's bid to DCMS for City of Culture 2021 (ultimately not successful); see http://www.liveagefestival.co.uk/live-age-festival-2017
Sector Creative Economy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description A talk to a meeting (at London, Europa House Smith Square) of the Ransackers Association, an educational organisation for intergenerational learning. The talk was about late-life creativity 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact e-mail received from Alan Watson, a member of the thoroughly engaged audience:
Dear David,

Thank you for the interesting discussion on age and creativity. I enjoyed it tremendously and it provoked much thought.

I start my course at Ruskin at the end of this month and please keep in touch.

Again many thanks; it was a delightful day,

Alan.

I have been invited to contribute to the organisation's development of its educational strategy.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://ageinginnovators.org/2013/02/26/ransackers-association/
 
Description CABS (Centre for Ageing and Biographical Studies)/CPA (Centre for Policy of Ageing) Multi-Disciplinary Research Seminar: Open University, Faculty of Health and Social Care, London: 'Knotty issues' in multi/interdisciplinary working' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Wide-ranging discussion of the challenges of working in interdisciplinary mode on contrastingly organised ageing projects, comparing and contrasting the experiences of working on 'Late-Life Creativity' research network (Amigoni, McMullan) and the 'Ages and Stages' projects (Keele, Bernard, PI, Amigoni CI).

Follow-up article for forthcoming CABS/CPA monograph on the theme.
invited talk at 'Ransackers Association' (see related engagement activity)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.open.ac.uk/health-and-social-care/main/research/research-events/project-seminars-workshop...
 
Description King's College, London: Wellcome funded 'The Health Humanities and Ageing' seminar 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact This talk for 'The Health Humanities and Ageing' seminar focused on some of the collaborative, humanities-based research on ageing that has been conducted at Keele University. It will focus on 'The Ages and Stages' project on ageing and theatre; and also the AHRC-funded 'Late-Life Creativity' project, conducted in partnership with King's College, London. As Desmond O'Neill commented, late-life creativity 'is of great importance to clinicians and society alike' (Lancet, Nov 28, 2015) and the talk took the idea of 'late style' in order to explore, but also perhaps seek to reconcile, different approaches to evaluating the place of art works and art practices in older people's lives. To undertake to explore an artist's 'late style' is to suggest, perhaps, expert historical knowledge of the kind that the art historian and curator Sam Smiles brought to his recent exhibition of 'Late Turner'. This kind of knowledge and approach sits perhaps in tension with Andrew Newman's participative, audience-focused approach to the everyday viewing of art by older people. My talk will explore the ways in which an approach to a 'late style' work (the large mural 'A Bright Past for Stoke on Trent', displayed at the Emma Bridgewater Factory, Lichfield Street, Hanley) of an older artist, the eminent theatre designer Peter Rice, may play a role in reconciling these approaches, and realising the significance of later-life creativity that O'Neil envisions.
The talk was attended by a multi-disciplinary audience (medical humanists, literary specialists, art historians, gerontologists); the talk lasted for 45 minutes and stimulated 30 minutes of intense questioning and discussion.
The talk was a contribution to a collaborative partnership that Amigoni and other colleagues at Keele University are building with the Emma Bridgewater Co., in particular Emma Bridgewater's parents-in-law, the artists and designers Peter Rice and Pat Albeck. A major exhibition celebrating the careers of the couple, and in particular their continuing artistic activity into later life, and to be entitled 'Vintage Now', will be held at Keele (and the New Vic Theatre) in November 2016 (Peter Rice died suddenly in December 2015, prompting a re-focus but with no change to the timetable).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL https://humanitiesandhealth.wordpress.com/2015/12/07/david-amigoni-comes-to-kings-7-december-2015/
 
Description Narrative and Ageing colloquium, Keele University 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The talk provoked questions and discussion from a diverse audience (health practitioners, academics, postgraduate students from diverse disciplines) because it encouraged the audience to explore relationships between narratives of ageing, the history of advice books about ageing, and well known figures celebrated for their active ageing ranging from Gladstone to Joan Bakewell.

Keynote at the event was Professor Arko Oderwald, Professor of Medical Humanities, University of Amsterdam. Oderwald, a specialist in the use of narrative literature in medical interventions; there were synergies between his talk and my own which have the potential to influence medical humanities teaching as a facet of ageing studies.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.keele.ac.uk/research/researchnews/2013/ageingconference28-06-2013.php
 
Description Plenary Panelist, 'Cultural Gerontology: Key Themes, Future Directions', BSA Ageing, Body and Society study group annual conference (University of Manchester, 26 Feb 2016) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The plenary panel assembled three speakers: Twigg, J. (Kent), Phillipson, C. (Manchester), and Amigoni, D. (Keele); it was chaired by Martin, W. (Brunel). The aim was to discuss the directions established by the landmark publication of the 'Routledge Handbook of Cultural Gerontology' (2015) of which Twigg and Martin are editors; Amigoni was invited because of the distinctive and innovative nature of his chapter on late style and late-life creativity, jointly authored with McMullan G., which appeared in the handbook. The panel was in the form of a debate designed to stimulate thinking among the conference participants. There was a spirited Q&A session and much interest in the cultural, writerly approach to age-studies analysis advanced by Amigoni.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.britsoc.co.uk/media/109289/ABS_2016_260216.pdf?1456588800024
 
Description Pre-concert panel discussion of 'late style' and creativity for London Philharmonic Orchestra/Shakespeare400 Festival (Feb 10, 2016, Royal Festival Hall, London South Bank) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The pre-concert talk was delivered in panel format by four contributors/experts from the disciplines of literary studies and musicology: G. McMullan (King's, London), D.Amigoni (Keele), L. Tunbridge (Oxford), D. Grimley (Oxford). The focus was on late style in art history (McMullan), the late work of Thomas Hardy (Amigoni), the late work of Schumann; and Sibelius' incidental music for 'The Tempest' as a late work and the subject of the conference (Grimley). in part, the presentation was designed to illuminate (especially the Sibelius, which the audience were to hear performed and narrated (by actor Simon Callow). Drawing on our research expertise, the aim was to invite the audience to re-think their assumptions about 'late style' and work completed in proximity to death by focusing on the structural and ideological commonalities between constructions of late style at work in and across different art forms. The presentation stimulated among the audience questions about constructivist approaches to the idea of late style, and its place in historical understandings of later-life creativity.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.lpo.org.uk/shakespeare-400-news/shakespeare400-the-tempest-and-incidental-music.html