A publishing and reception history of Charles Dickens' "Great Expectations" 1860-2012

Lead Research Organisation: University of Southampton
Department Name: Faculty of Humanities

Abstract

A publishing and reception history of Charles Dickens' Great Expectations 1860-2012 is a commissioned monograph of approximately 110,000 words, to be published by Ashgate in 2014. The book combines approaches drawn from literary, adaptation and reception studies and book history in order to investigate the writing, publication and global impact of a novel that was indelibly shaped by the crucible of the Victorian periodical press in which it was created, but continues to have relevance to global audiences in a wide variety of media even today. This novel has had an exceptionally long and varied afterlife even by Dickens' standards. It was pirated several times for publication and performance on both sides of the Atlantic before it was even completed, adapted, translated and reissued dozens of times in the remaining decade of its author's lifetime (not always with his consent), and has spawned numerous adaptations and spin-offs ever since, including catch-phrases, silent movies, an abandoned André Previn musical, novels by Kathy Acker, Peter Carey and Lloyd Jones, pop songs, a South Park episode, and a poem by Carol Ann Duffy. In addition to providing the fullest account yet available to students and scholars of this novel's multiple lives and their reception by audiences and critics over a century and a half - a resource useful in and of itself - I argue that the value of such a close focus on a single text extends far beyond Dickens scholarship or even Victorian Studies. This 'biography of a novel', I suggest, enables a deeper understanding of the phenomenon of cross-cultural, cross-media translation more broadly. It will shed new light on a range of issues including the politics of translation and of censorship, the interactive histories of various branches of the global media industries, the ways in which national and other identities are represented (or resisted) through and by cultural artefacts, and the ways in which these representations and appropriations change over time. By collating previously scattered information on the novel's creation, dissemination and reception gathered from archives in Britain and the US, through a range of recently available electronic resources, and via interviews with modern adaptors, I ask the following key questions: how did this novel's creation under the specific conditions of the periodical market of the 1860s, and during a period of considerable upheaval in its creator's personal and professional lives, affect its form and its central thematic concerns? Which aspects of this much-reprinted and adapted novel retain their power over time and space and across different contexts? What is the historical significance of the novel's adaptation in each instance: are there patterns, trends or shared cultural concerns in these various incarnations? What can their repeated translation and re-casting tell us about the ways in which media industries and audience expectations interact, and old cultural icons serve new needs? The book contains 4 sections. Section 1 explores Dickens' own complicated life in the late 1850s and early 1860s and its impact on his writing of Great Expectations, generally acknowledged to be the first novel of his late 'darker' period and one of his most innovative and autobiographical. This section situates the work within recent critical debates about the periodical press, authority, authorship, and the relationship between biography and fiction. Section 2 covers the distribution of the novel over time and space, discussing in depth key editions, translations, adaptations and re-castings. Section 3 focuses on the critical and general reception of the various versions, drawing on published and unpublished sources and electronic resources for reader and audience response. Section 4 comprises appendices of editions, translations, adaptations and spin-offs, a selection of critical reviews, and transcripts of interviews with modern adaptors.

Planned Impact

The impact goals of the proposed research are largely intellectual and cultural. I cannot claim potential beneficiaries in the private sector, but the book's accessible style and in particular its intended modes of dissemination (see Case for Support and Pathways to Impact documents) are intended to have impact beyond academia, both for the general public and for other targeted beneficiaries.
i) Impact for general audiences
Dickens' novels and adaptations have many fans and continue to engender interest from the general public worldwide. This is truer still of the Victorian period more generally, as witness the many recent television documentaries and dramas on aspects of nineteenth-century culture. In recognition of these wider audiences the project aims to encourage a general audience to:

- Understand more about how writers like Dickens lived and worked in the Victorian period, too often over-simplified and idealised.
- Learn how Victorians responded to his work. The testimony of ordinary Victorians - not all of it complimentary - will bring the author's impact in his own day vividly to life, provide information about Victorian reading conditions, and support a re-assessment of Dickens' supposedly universal popularity.
- Re-consider the tendency to see the works of Dickens - and writers like him - as immutably classic phenomena, entities fixed in time and space which represent a golden era in British history. The project's book-historical dimension will remind general audiences that Dickens' novels have had many different incarnations and meanings and many different audiences, and help foster an understanding of the function of literature in the modern world.
- Re-assess the relationship between what is often thought of as a quintessentially 'English' novel and its many global incarnations; between literature and film, theatre, TV and radio; and between history and the contemporary heritage industry.
These impact factors may help individuals to understand the crucial role Britain's cultural heritage plays in a global economy. They may also suggest to general audiences how the cultural products emerging from a historical period of economic volatility can teach us something about our own times.

The book itself provides only one outlet for the project's findings among the general public. I plan to further increase the project's cultural benefit by:

- Updating relevant Wikipedia sites, which are often out of date or incomplete. Wikipedia is the world's most visited reference site, attracting over 400 million hits per month (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ComScore). Actively updating sites is a key way in which academics can contribute to the wider community's knowledge base.
- Offering public lectures in non-HE institutions, including those in the public sector such as the Charles Dickens Museum, London, and the Wisbech and Fenland Museum.
- Writing articles for non-specialist newspapers, journals and websites and contributing to radio broadcasts.

ii) Impact for targeted non-academic audience
The project is also aimed at a specific non-academic target audience: school teachers. In conjunction with colleagues in the University's School of Education, I will offer a talk and workshop in Southampton to primary school teachers who took part in the recent Charles Dickens Primary School Project (http://www.history.org.uk/resources/primary_resource_4606_7.html). Targeting teachers in Kent, London and Hampshire, the talk on Dickens will support their interdisciplinary work in teaching local history through literary figures whose work forms part of the English curriculum, while the workshop will provide the opportunity for colleagues in Education to receive feedback from the Dickens Primary School Project and offer advice about next steps (see 'Pathways to Impact' statement).

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description I have discovered new archive material relating to hitherto unknown stage and radio versions and translations of Great Expectations, and have analysed the novel's global journeys over 150 years. I have thus been able to demonstrate how the fortunes of a 'canonical' novel wax and wane over time, and depend heavily on their adaptability for new media industries.
Exploitation Route In addition to analyses of all extant readers' responses to and piracies and adaptations of the novel, the monograph contains over 30,000 words of appendices of previously undiscovered reviews, translations, and lists of adaptations for stage, film, radio and TV.
Sectors Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description Charity fund-raising event, the Great Expectations read-a-thon, took place on 15/16th January 2017. We raised over £3000 for the new Centre for Cancer Immunology.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic

 
Description 'Fluid geographies and global mobilities: recovering Southampton's translocal book trade networks in the long nineteenth century.' 
Organisation Victoria University of Wellington
Country New Zealand 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The work on digital and local archives I carried out for my funded project has enabled me to contribute directly to this project to map the Southampton printing trade. I am now very familiar with the archives. A research bid to the British Academy for a Visiting Fellowship is in process, but the outcome is not yet known.
Collaborator Contribution The project partner is a world renowned expert on printing and digital technologies. If the project is successful she will be able to construct the app required to map the local trade as part of a public facing outcome.
Impact Previous outcomes included two funded project symposia with 7 international partners; my new skills have enabled the project to be revivified and we hope if this Fellowship bid is successful it will lead to a larger bid to extend the knowledge outcomes to other countries.
Start Year 2010
 
Description 'Great Expectations@ 21st-century Dickens: a 1-day workshop aimed at teachers and trainess (KS2 and KS3) for Curriculum 2014 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This 1-day workshop took place in the School of Education, University of Southampton, on 23 March 2013. It aimed to introduce practicing and trainee teachers to innovative and effective ways of teaching Dickens in the 21st-century classroom. The day began with an hour-long plenary lecture by the grant-holder (Hammond) titled 'We all have Great Expectations: new interpretations of Dickens's classic novel' in which delegates were introduced to her project findings, including Dickens's close relationship with the Victorian publishing industry, the ways in which the novel's first readers encountered it in Britain and the US (largely in small sections), and how Dickens understood and catered in the structure of the novel for the different competencies of his various readerships. Hammond demonstrated that this inbuilt formal flexibility enables Dickens to be translated effectively and enjoyably to the 21st-century classroom. Thereafter the day comprised talks and workshops as follows: 1/ 'Then and Now: teaching Dickensian themes in the 21st century'; 2/ 'Exploring the language of Dickens'; 3/Dramatising Dickens in the classroom.' The day ended with a roundtable titled 'Back to the Future: can Dickens survive in 2014?' The workshop was attended by 28 trainee and practicing teachers from Hampshire schools. The feedback questionnaire distributed at the end demonstrated the success of the day. All participants deemed all aspects of the workshop 'Excellent' or 'Good'; many commented that they would be using the ideas it had generated in their classrooms; and most stated that as a result of attending, they felt more confident about teaching Dickens effectively in the face of sometimes restrictive National Curriculum imperatives. The only downside of the day was the significant drop-out rate; 50 teachers signed up, but ultimately almost half found they were too tired and busy to give up a Saturday. All these, however, asked to be sent the teaching pack produced for the workshop.

Practising and trainee teachers who attended provided feedback which indicated that they generally felt the workshop had made them more comfortable teaching Dickens in the classroom, and given them ideas for making the novels accessible to 21st-century schoolchildren
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
 
Description Dickens 24-hour charity read-a-thon 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A group of almost 40 undergraduates, postgraduates, colleagues (University-wide) and members of the public read the whole of Charles Dickens's Great Expectations aloud in 14 different languages over the weekend of 14th/15th January 2017 to raise money for the Southampton Centre for Cancer Immunology. Dickens's great-great granddaughter participated, tweeted to the wider Dickens family, and publicized the event via the Charles Dickens Museum. Numbers of participants tweeted throughout, gaining an international response. Local radio stations Radio Solent and Radio Wave 105 interviewed myself and Kate Dickens about the event and broadcast the interviews during prime-time radio slots, thus reaching large numbers of listeners regionally.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://www.southampton.ac.uk/scnr/news/2017/01/23-dickens-read-a-thon-raises-over-2600-for-centre-fo...