Curating Childhoods: Developing a Multimedia Archive of Children's Everyday Lives

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sussex
Department Name: Sch of Education and Social Work

Abstract

Curating Childhoods is a 12-month study that forges links across disciplines in order to transform the way we document and archive children's everyday lives in the digital age. To date, accounts of children's lives have been conspicuously absent from the Mass Observation Archive - in large part due to the ethical challenges of documenting and recording intimate accounts of children and young people's lives. Such a trend stands in stark contrast to increased growth and proliferation of young people's use of online social media platforms as a means of self-documenting and curating multimedia accounts of their lives. In response to these trends, the study facilitates dialogue between young people's private digital data practices and public archives seeking to document the everyday.

The project builds on a previous research initiative called 'Face 2 Face: Tracing the Real and the Mediated in Children's Cultural Worlds' (2012-3) which developed micro ethnographic and multimedia tools for documenting the temporal rhythms of children's everyday lives. The Curating Childhoods study is the next logical and necessary step in the development of this initiative and seeks to explore how researchers and archives can work with children and young people to address the ethical challenges of documenting and curating public records of everyday life. With the increasing democratisation of 'documentation' it has been ever more important to reconsider the role of the researcher, the archivist, and the professional as arbiters of ethical governance and practice. Consequently, the documentation of children and young people's lives will act as a key test case for our ability to work through this terrain, investigating alternatives to the simple privatisation of responsibility for protecting privacy (Hope, 2014).

In collaboration with the Mass Observation Archive, the project's team will develop a series of knowledge exchange activities and resources bringing together the expertise of archivists, researchers and young people around issues of ethics and responsibility in the curation and sharing data. In the first instance, the research team will invite a panel of young people involved in the 'Face 2 Face' study to participate in a day workshop with archivists to talk about their everyday practices of curating, storing and sharing personal data. This workshop will then form a key contribution in the development of a set of new open-access knowledge exchange materials around 'good practice' in the curation and management of private digital data, targeted at young people, archivists and researchers.

A key outcome of the Curating Childhoods project will be the development of a new on-going multimedia dataset on 'Everyday Childhoods', to be hosted and maintained at the Mass Observation Archive. This dataset will provide a rich new resource for researchers that will provide invaluable insights into the changing social and cultural configurations of childhood and youth over time. The dataset will initially comprise data collected as part of the Face 2 Face study, but will also later incorporate new data contributions from a 'self documentary day' for children on 12th May 2015, co-organised by the research and archive teams. Throughout the process of creating and compiling this dataset, the research and archive teams will critically examine the practical and ethical challenges of a establishing a new multimedia dataset on 'Everyday Childhoods' in the Mass Observation Archive. More broadly, this study will seek to contribute to on-going discussions across the arts and humanities and the social sciences on the challenges of recording and preserving digital and multimedia accounts of the everyday, as well as the wider ethical implications of researching and documenting children's lives in the digital age.

Planned Impact

Curating Childhoods involves a partnership between the interdisciplinary Centre for Innovation and Research in Childhood and Youth (CIRCY) at the University of Sussex and the Mass Observation Archive. The project builds on more than two years of sustained work within CIRCY on the theme of Digital Childhoods including successful public engagement (the Space Invaders competition), interdisciplinary methodological innovation (New Frontiers in QLR) and the development of a new multimedia data set on children's everyday lives within a digital landscape (Face 2 Face).The commitment from the Mass Observation Archive to work collaboratively to establish a public archive on everyday childhoods is enormously valuable, assuring a legacy for a growing collection which will enrich and invigorate this national resource and provide a focus for collaboration and development into the future. The project aligns with the University of Sussex's strategic research investment in the area of Digital Humanities.

Knowledge exchange is designed into Curating Childhoods at every stage with key activities conceived as ways of sharing understanding between the relevant stakeholders (young people, parents, researchers, archivists and professionals). Over the course of 12 months, researchers from CIRCY and Mass Observation staff will engage in a number of forms of knowledge exchange, securing the real-world impact of the project. In the first six months these will include:
(a) workshops hosted by within the MO Archive to bring together young people with archivists;
(b) a Brighton Fringe Festival event that allows us to engage with a wider 'public';
(c) child and youth participation in a Mass Observation on May 12th involving a collaboration between MO, CIRCY and East Sussex schools.
The second half of the project will involve distilling and sharing learning from the study through:
(a) using the CIRCY YouTube channel as a platform to share short films on 'data sharing', 'privacy' and 'consent' aimed at audiences including young people;
(b) learning for researchers and archivists to be disseminated through two targeted scholarly journal articles; guidelines on good practice in the form of accessible tips and principles being made available through relevant organisational portals.

The project delivers impact at three levels:

Instrumental impact - The creation and deposit of a new data-set on everyday childhoods will have a direct impact on the MO and the interdisciplinary field of childhood research, encouraging re-use as well as demanding organisational adaption. Learning from the project will be shared with key stakeholders in a range of targeted ways.

Capacity building impact - The proposed project will contribute directly to the capacity of Mass Observation to engage with a number of pressing challenges associated with technological change and the ability to document everyday life in a digital age. In bridging practices of data collection and data sharing/ re-use it will also contribute to the skills and understanding of childhood researchers. Liam Berriman, the Research Fellow on the project, will act as a key intermediary point - combining and synthesising insights developed across the panel of young people, and the archive and research teams. The active participation of young people in the discussion of archiving practice will have an impact on individuals and institutions and will enhance relationships with professionals and educational institutions for all partners.

Conceptual impact - The project will make an impact on intellectual and popular agendas through our interrogation of three linked conceptual binaries- between protection and participation in research ethics, between personal and public archives in data management, and between concrete and abstract audiences/ publics in young people's perceptions of risk and privacy.
 
Description Methods of dissemination and outreach have included staging events as part of public festivals; utilising social media for advertising and sharing open access project materials and reports; convening multi-professional meetings; presenting findings at academic conferences and writing scholarly outputs. The Everyday Childhoods website has been the primary portal for project outputs and since January 2015, Google Analytics records the website as receiving 7200 visitors and 13,000 page views. Since January 2018, when we launched the book, we've had 1016 visitors, and nearly 2000 page views. Our visitors in the last year have been from the US, UK, Ireland, Italy and Denmark primarily. Immediate project impacts have centred on participants and a connected academic community. Planned future impacts will include bringing project findings and materials to a wider audience and cultivating a secondary user community around the 'Everyday Childhood' collection which at the end of 2019 was formally published data set. The ethical learning from this research has had impact other researchers in the humanities and social sciences through reference to the materials in institutional and professional guidance. By reaching out to private sector data archives and re-users we have extended the impact of our research across sectors with a view to demonstrably influencing policy formation in this field. The project has also found an audience among young people, featured as a lead article in the February 2016 issue of Sociology Review 25 (3) the national magazine for A level sociology students and teachers
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Title Everyday Childhoods collection 
Description The Everyday Childhoods collection is comprised of a body of multi-media data documenting the lives of children (aged 7-8 years olds) and teenagers (12-16) over a period of 18 months between 2013-15. The full data set was deposited at the Mass Observation archive in January 2018 and a showcase data set is available online and open access through at https://sussex.figshare.com/Everyday_Childhoods 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The everyday childhoods data set was collected using 3 bespoke methods: a day in a life observation; a favorite things interview and a recursive interview where participants are invited to reflect on change over time and to agree what of their data can be shared publicly. These methods themselves have be adopted by a range of childhood researchers (see Thomson & Hadfield 2014 for a description of the methods) and the showcase project itself has acted as a demonstration of what is feasible in terms of creating ethically robust open access public documents in a participatory way. The project team have been invited to present and talk about the practicalities and ethics of the project to a range of research groups. The collection is now published through the University of Sussex Repository. 
URL https://sussex.figshare.com/Everyday_Childhoods