Performing hip-hop Englishness: The performance of alternative British identities through rap

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Social Sciences

Abstract

The proposed research will examine the performance of rap in English social and penal institutions. The origins of rap can be traced back from the first commercial recordings of hip-hop in the 1970s, through slavery, to precolonial Africa. The performed character of rap is of significance to understanding the origins of poetry and the role of oral-poetic forms in maintaining the structure of preliterate societies. Rap is now the most popular poetic form in the world. With artists such as Dizzee Rascal, Roll Deep, Wretch 32, Tinie Tempah, Chipmunk and the So Solid Crew reaching the top of the UK charts, rap music has also entered into the mainstream of British life. UK hip-hop and grime are also politically significant subcultures, through which working-class youths use rap to represent their conditions of urban dwelling. However, there is little scholarship on rap in the United Kingdom. The development of hip-hop over the last 35 years into a mainstream pop music genre and the production of grime as a distinctively British vernacular culture, highlight the importance of examining how the identities of British youths are shaped through rap.

As a generation of Britons have grown up with rap as an ordinary part of their everyday lives, the proposed research will examine urgent questions regarding the impact that rap culture has on the identities of English youths and how state funded organisations influence the articulation of alternative English identities through rap in the wider hip-hop and grime scenes. Through this focus on the performance of rap in these institutions the project will examine the rhetorical and performative techniques used by rap artists to solicit identity from their audience members; to analyse how audience members produce identification in response to rap performances; to investigate the circulation of rap culture within and between different state funded institutions; and the impact of this cultural form on the communities from which young rap artists emerge.

Studies of rap songs have predominantly employed textual analysis in a manner that obscures the significance of performance in this oral culture. Attempts to develop a hip-hop poetics and highlight rap's literary qualities are significant contributions to making rap amenable to incorporation within English studies. However, the textual analysis of rap lyrics fails to account for the mutually constitutive relations between the formal qualities of rap as a performed oral-poetic genre and the social forms produced within rap subcultures. By attending to the interaction between performers, audience members, and the performance context, the research will provide a fuller account of the social, cultural and aesthetic significance of rap. The project will investigate the impact that rap performances have on the identities of children and young adults and analyse how the rhetorical and performative techniques employed by rappers produce identities and identification between and within communities. Through a critical engagement with rap performances in one youth centre, a community centre, a young offenders institution and a prison, the team of researchers, with expertise in literary studies, cultural sociology, performance studies and prisons research, will investigate the impact that rap has on these organisations and analyse how rappers' performances, in institutions funded by national and local governments, produce alternative British identities. The research will address the following questions:

What are the relations between between the rapper, dj, audience members and performance context in rap performances?
How are alternative British identities produced through rap performances in state funded institutions?
How does rap contribute to the culture and ethos within youth clubs, community centres, young offenders institutions and prisons in England?
How are prison rap cultures interconnected with those in mainstream society?

Planned Impact

The research will impact upon five distinct groups.

1) Youths and young adults in the youth and community centres will benefit from the opportunity to reflect on their cultural practice through a combination of interviews and workshops organised by the principal investigator and research assistant. The research is aimed at improving understanding of rap in England and how this cultural form shapes the identities of British youths. Through attending the first day of a two-day seminar in June 2016 these youths and young adults will benefit from the opportunity for informal exchange with scholars with interests in an area of cultural practice that is meaningful to these young people.

2) Staff and managers in the youth and community centres will benefit from the opportunity to reflect on their professional practice through a combination of interviews with the Principal Investigator and Research Assistant. The research is aimed at examining how this cultural form shapes the identities of British youths and the impact that it has on a variety of government funded institutions. Through attending the first day of the two-day seminar in June 2016, youth and community centre staff and managers will benefit from feedback on the youth and community centre fieldwork and the opportunity for exchange with scholars with interests in an area of cultural practice that is meaningful to the young people that they provide services to and are responsible for.

3) Prisoners in the young offenders institution and high security prison will have the opportunity to discuss important aspects of their social and cultural lives through interviews, seminars and workshops, in contexts in which such opportunities are rare. The Principal Investigator will organise and lead a series of rap workshops in the young offenders institution and high security prison, providing offenders with the opportunity for reflection on their cultural practices and for personal growth, in institutional contexts that substantially limit educational opportunities.

4) The National Offenders Management Service will benefit from the study of the impact of rap culture on two contrasting prison establishments. The research will deepen our understanding of prison social climates, in ways that have direct impact on the management of prisons. In feeding back results to the high security prison and young offenders institution, we will produce detailed reports of findings for each establishment. In order to maximise the impact on practice, the Principal Investigator and Co-Investigator will offer feedback presentations to senior managers and staff in each establishment. A one day seminar in December 2016, to be attended by academics and senior prison service managers, will explore the implications of the project for the National Offender Management Service.

5) The general public will benefit from the better understanding of the role that rap plays in shaping young people's identities. By selecting rap artists who have achieved recognition at local, national or international levels, to attend the seminar at Cambridge in June 2016, the project will aim to produce impacts in the local communities and amongst the wider audiences of these young people. The Principal Investigator will participate in a live radio interview on the community and internet radio station, Rinse FM. The interview will describe the research process and the main findings. By disseminating our research through this former pirate radio station, the PI will build upon his established relations with cultural practitioners in London's grime 'scene' and target the project's public engagement at an interested and informed audience. The Principal Investigator will also write an article for The Guardian newspaper on the impact of rap culture on state funded institutions, in order to address a wider non-specialist audience. This newspaper has featured number of articles on the development of grime music in England.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Our aim is to test the hypothesis that rap has come to have a substantial impact on the culture of a variety of statutory institutions in the United Kingdom and, through these institutions, on the representation of Britishness at local and national levels. Using a combination of ethnomusicological, sociological and literary approaches, we have been able to describe in differences in the values associated with rap in contrasting state-funded institutions, which leads to the production of distinct rap cultures within and beyond these settings.

Key Findings
The hypothesis has been broadly supported. Rap plays a significant role in a broad range of state-funded institutions in England. Furthermore, these institutions made important and contrasting contributions to the development of rap cultures in their local communities. Significant differences were found in the impact that rap made to the ethos of these institutions and how staff responded to rap. These differences were related to the aims of the institution, staff motivations and training, as well as assumptions about how rap could be valued. Staff at Docklands youth centre were more focused on ethical development, in the community centre rap was associated with both criminality and social responsibility, whereas at Raw Material (an arts charity with links to the community centre) staff emphasised professional and artistic development. All field sites were attended by a large proportion of ethnic minorities, particularly black Britons.

The findings are still emerging and we have provisionally organised them under three main headings: institutional impact; instrumentalisation of rap; and identity.

1. Institutional impact on local rap cultures
Youth centres make significant contributions to local rap cultures. Forest Gate Youth Zone in Newham, was once at the heart of London's emergent grime scene and served as a site in which young people could hone their creative skills. A number of rappers who went on to become nationally recognised within the grime scene practiced and performed at Forest Gate Youth Zone. The scaling down of the services provided by the youth centre, as a result of austerity related budget cuts, highlights the extent to which local and national government supported local rap culture. Historically this youth centre provided equipment, staff with expertise in using music technologies, and facilitated live rapping performances. Following substantial reductions in the youth service budget, there is now no significant rap culture in Forest Gate Youth Zone.

Docklands youth centre in St. Paul's, Bristol, currently makes an important contribution to the city's rap scene. The youth centre facilitates the rap culture within it in a variety of ways, including through the provision of space, technological resources, staff expertise, and the freedom to play. Docklands provides a nurturing environment in which young people can develop their rap skills through largely self-organised freestyling in the live room as well as gain experience in music production. The youth centre brings young people together, fostering social networks, and musical groupings. It also provides access to the broader music scene through the recording of young people's work and facilitating contact with cultural entrepreneurs. Several young rappers at the youth centre have had music videos recorded and posted on the YouTube channel SimzCityTV. The channel features over 400 videos featuring the work of Bristol's musicians and has over 6,000 subscribers. The owner of the channel regularly attends the Wednesday sessions at the youth centre.

2. Instrumentalisation of rap
Social policy objectives can have a significant impact on the rap cultures within youth centres. Youth workers drew on social policy language, alongside their own motivations, when discussing the work that they engaged in through rap. Rap was used by youth workers as a means of develop young people as ethical citizens. We observed the recording of lyrics that suggested that the form played a role in young people's resilience. However, rap was also seen to be bound up with risks of engaging in anti-social behaviour or criminal activity. Although youth workers frequently discussed the content of young people's rap lyrics, there was little discussion of the formal features of rap songs. The social aspects of rap carried great significance in the youth centre, whereas the aesthetic aspects were relatively neglected. This contrasted with the treatment of rap in the art-organisation, in which guidance about rhetorical and performance techniques was offered by staff. Rap was used by prison service managers to promote a 'rehabilitative culture'. In one case a function head wrote lyrics that were performed by a rapper for a CD. However, managers also expressed concerns about the potential for rap to be used to express values that did not accord with the aims of the institution.

3. Identity
A range of identities and identifications are performed within rap cultures in the youth and community centres. These included identifications with local areas, home cities, and the UK. We observed young people viewing large numbers of rap music videos set in either their own city or other English cities. Rappers talked about representing 'the UK' and their own city though their creative practice. However, we observed that all of the cities in the UK featured in music videos viewed by young people in the youth centres and referred to by the rappers as significant to the 'UK scene' in their interviews were in England.

In the prison, prisoners talked about how the music production classes provided the opportunity for them to gain a sense of freedom: 'when I put the headphones on I'm just in another world, I'm not in prison', and equipped them with skills that orient them towards life beyond their imprisonment. Rap played an important role in connecting prisoners to the world beyond the prison and their former lives. In some cases rap played a role in prisoners narratives of how they would change their lives. Rap was said by officers to play a significant part of life on the residential wings, and may be one of the most popular music genres in the prison.
Exploitation Route There is very little research on the impact of rap culture on different types of organisations or how institutional settings influence rap. This culture seems to be used very narrowly by social organisations to engage youth potentially at risk of engaging criminality. The attempt to develop resilience and to produce ethical citizens through rap has potential value for the criminal justice system. Children and Young People's Services might draw on this research to broaden the role that rap plays in their organisation. Further research might engage with schools engagement (or lack of engagement) with rap culture and the role that this cultural form plays in educational settings. There is significant potential to broaden the focus on rap and ethics to engage with issues of aesthetics, entrepreneurship, and politics through rap.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Education,Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy

 
Description The activities have been grouped under three main headings, focusing on youth services, the criminal justice system, and the general public. Children and Young People's Services, Youth Service Managers, and Youth Workers The 'It Ain't Where You're From, It's Where You're At': International Hip Hop Studies Conference was a three-day event, which brought together over one hundred scholars from a range of disciplinary backgrounds to share their research in the field of hip-hop studies. Following the announcement of the call for papers the research team gave interviews with, and the upcoming conference was reported in, the Cambridge News and Times Higher Education. Subsequently, Dazed magazine and the Independent ran stories featuring or referring to the event. The conference also made an impact through radio. It was mentioned in the introduction to Any Questions on Radio 4 on Friday the 19th and Saturday the 20th February 2016. The significance of event was discussed extensively and gave rise to a one hour debate on the value of rap music on James O'Brien's LBC programme on the 26th February. We invited a journalist from the Economist to the event, and she attended the first two days of the conference. The Performing Hip Hop Englishness Festival took place on the third and final day of the conference. The Festival on day three was aimed at breaking down the barriers between the University and the 'outside world'. Amongst the non-academic beneficiaries were four young people (three rappers and one singer), three youth workers and a youth services manager from Docklands Youth Centre in St. Paul's, Bristol, where the PI and RA had been conducting ethnographic fieldwork for over six months. The event was also attended by the Head of English at School 21, a teacher at Rushey Mead School in Leicester, and a teacher at Kingsbury school in London. The young people participated in two workshops 1) an hour-and-a-half workshop on entering the music industry run by JJ, a leading grime DJ and 2) a two-hour workshop on stage performance techniques run by TY, a leading UK rapper. Both the young people and youth workers also attended a panel in which the Research Assistant presented findings from the research on rap at their youth centre in Bristol, which included their own testimonies. During the afternoon, the four youth workers (who specialise in developing young people's music production and performance skills) attended a panel on using hip hop in education. The six-person panel mixed researchers, school teachers, rappers and educators. After attending the conference, the youth workers spoke very positively about the value of the experience. As a result of attending the conference one of the youth workers began to recognise that their own practice was a form of hip hop studies: "We basically do hip-hop studies, because trying to instil ethics into young people, that is hip-hop." Further to this she felt that the conference helped her to see how the work being undertaken within academia could be relevant to her professional practice: "we can draw on it [hip-hop studies] more, but without even knowing it we have that within our organisation". It was clear that the youth workers thought the event had a powerful impact on them would have a lasting influence on the young people and their work with them. One said: "It was an eye opener for me, because I felt that the culture of hip-hop education is a lot bigger than I thought it was. That was really good for me and inspirational For ACE as well, its something that we can include ourselves in in the future to benefit what we're doing, and use to it as a resource really, to create better services for us. There was a lot of strong material, strong models, and strong ethos around using hip-hop to educate. I hope that this continues in the future and [we can use it to help us to] do what we do in a more effective way. There is a big body of work that could come from this and that's something that we'd want to be involved with." The youth workers and the youth services manager exchanged contacts with a number of people during the Festival that they intend to follow up on, with one saying: "It felt like we started something that day, by just having a debate. We almost started like a movement it felt like, that is possibly going to carry on because it seemed like everyone was going to keep trying to keep it going on. It felt like something started from there." From the feedback from the youth workers it was also clear that the particular way the Festival had been designed had facilitated important forms of engagements for the young people, as well as more generally. One said: "Having artists from the grime and UK hip-hop scenes made the event more relevant to the young people. Their [the young people's] session [with JJ] was very, very good. One of them has a picture on their Facebook. To be able to capture these kids for that long. They've learned a lot from him." The event helped to break down barriers between the University and youth services. As one of the youth workers explained: "The link between us [higher education and youth work] isn't as vast as we thought. The fact that Cambridge are looking at hip-hop as a way of educating and bringing people together, that alone puts us on the same page in a lot of ways and there's no reason that that can't continue and grow even bigger. A lot of barriers are broken in that respect." Criminal Justice System In October 2016 HMP Full Sutton hosted its first black history month programme in six years. The PI played a leading role in planning the event in conjunction with managers in the prison. Approximately 100 prisoners, staff members and members of the senior management team attended talks given by members of the research team. In November 2016 the PI hosted a symposium for David Lammy's review of the treatment of, and outcomes for, Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic (BAME) individuals in the Criminal Justice System (CJS) at Wolfson College, Cambridge. The Rt Hon. David Lammy MP and 24 individuals drawn from a range of organisations, including the prison service, probation service, third sector organisations and the Ministry of Justice attended the event. Research team members presented their work on the role of rap in prison. One of our research partners, from Dockland's Youth Centre, presented on the work they do through rap to engage at risk youths. Another of our research partners, from HMP Full Sutton, presented on the work they are doing to engage with BME prisoners. Attendees included Laurie Hunte (Lammy Review), Paul Ansell (Lammy Review), Nick Smart (Probation Institute), Becky Conyers (HMP Full Sutton), Richard Preece (HMP Full Sutton), Laura Chinnery (Catch 22), Steve Oko (Association of Black Probation Officers), Kimmett Edgar (Prison Reform Trust), Kate Shaw (Ministry of Justice), Ian Wood (National Offender Management Service), Nigel Hoskins (London Probation, Community Rehabilitation Company) and representatives from other organisations. General Public On the 11th December the PI participated in the Hip-Hop Museum Exhibition at the National Museum of World Cultures, Amsterdam. The PI gave a talk based on the youth centre fieldwork conducted during this research project to an audience of 50 members of the general public. The audience included the Head of the Research Center for Material Culture at the Tropenmuseum, a curator at Amsterdam Museum, a music journalist, and members of the general public. The talk was followed by a Q & A session. After the talk and Q & A session the PI had the opportunity to discuss the presentation with members of the audience. Several said that the talk had given them new insight into the role that rap plays in society. On the 24th of January 2017 the PI participated in a debate on BBC Radio 5 Live on whether rap can be a force for social change. The PI is in ongoing contact with youth service managers at Dockland's youth centre in Bristol, senior prison service managers, and curators at Amsterdam museum and the Tropenmuseum. We expect to see significant impacts arising from this research in the criminal justice system as well as in youth services. Members of the team continue to work closely with our partners.
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description BBC Radio 1Xtra documentary interview 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact The principal investigator gave an interview for a documentary, which was broadcasted on BBC Radio1 and Radio 1Xtra on the 1st October 2017. The audience for the documentary was 15 - 24 year olds, primarily but not exclusively from ethnic minorities. The intended purpose of the principal investigator's contribution to this documentary was to contribute to public debate about grime music, the experience of working class ethnic minorities, and contemporary social issues.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b096ynqn
 
Description HMP Full Sutton Black History Month 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact In October 2016 HMP Full Sutton hosted its first black history month programme in six years. The research team played a leading role in planning the event in conjunction with managers in the prison. Approximately 100 prisoners, staff members and members of the senior management team attended talks given by members of the research team.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Hackney Council Improving Outcomes for Young Black Men Symposium 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Presented research to councillors, policy makers and professionals at Hackney Council's Improving Outcomes for Young Black Men symposium. Approximately 50-100 people attended the event in Hackney. These included police officers, mental health professionals, youth service managers, third sector organisations, councillors, and local government policy makers. The presentation led to several substantial conversations with professionals and policy makers during and following the event. The principal investigator is in discussion with policy makers in the council about further involvement with their Improving Outcomes for Young Black Men initiative.

Since this presentation I have visited the London Borough of Hackney on numerous occasions, to meet staff and managers in a range of council services (including education, youth justice, youth services, Hackney Museum and Archives, as well as officers in the Policy and Partnerships team. I have shared my research at these meetings and the meetings have contributed to plans for developing further impacts arising from my research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://hackney.gov.uk/young-black-men
 
Description Keynote presentation and workshop at a Hackney Learning Trust conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Approximately 60 head teachers, deputy head teachers, and assistant head teachers as well as approximately 40 education professionals, individuals from third sector organisations, and a local councillor attended the Hackney Learning Trust conference on improving outcomes for young black men, at which I gave the keynote presentation, titled 'Negotiating Black Identity: A Challenge for Schools' and a workshop on Black Britishness in Classrooms and Playgrounds. The workshop was attended by approximately 30 school leaders. The conference took place in the London Borough of Hackney. There were a numerous positive responses by school leaders to both the keynote and the workshop. Following the workshop I received several invitations to develop collaborations with or to give talks at schools and other organisations in the borough.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.hltconferences.co.uk/project/ybm/
 
Description Lammy Review Symposium, Cambridge 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact The research team hosted an event for the Lammy Review, which is examining the experiences of ethnic minorities in the criminal justice system. David Lammy and 24 individuals drawn from a range of organisations, including the prison service, probation service, third sector organisations and the Ministry of Justice attended the event. Research team members presented their work on the role of rap in prison. One of our research partners presented on the work they do through rap to engage at risk youths.

Attendees included David Lammy MP (Lammy Review Chair), Laurie Hunte (Lammy Review), Paul Ansell (Lammy Review), Nick Smart (Probation Institute), Becky Conyers (HMP Full Sutton), Richard Preece (HMP Full Sutton), Laura Chinnery (Catch 22), Steve Oko (Association of Black Probation Officers), Kimmett Edgar (Prison Reform Trust), Kate Shaw (Ministry of Justice), Ian Wood (National Offender Management Service), Nigel Hoskins (London Probation, Community Rehabilitation Company) and representatives from other organisations.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Radio appearance, The Afternoon Edition BBC Radio 5 Live 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Dr Bramwell participated in a debate on BBC Radio 5 Live on whether rap can be a force for social change.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08b12xh
 
Description Roundtable discussion- The Quito Papers: A New Urbanism 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact "The Quito Papers" is a research collaboration between Theatrum Mundi, NYU and UN-Habitat, developed in the run-up to the United Nations Habitat III conference held in Quito, Ecuador in October 2016. The principal investigator participated in a closed round table aimed at questioning the ideas of "Quito Papers", what they mean and how they can be interpreted in local contexts. The principal investigator launched the discussion in the roundtable by providing a response to Professor Richard Sennett's contribution to the Quito Papers, grounded in the London fieldwork on the Performing Hip Hop Englishness project. Amongst the participants in this closed roundtable were a number of architects and urban practitioners, including Deborah Saunt, Architect, co-founder of DSDHA; Patrick Richard, Director, Stanton Williams; Gavin Henderson, Director, Stanton Williams; Steve Tompkins, Architect, Founding Director, Haworth Tompkins; Mark Shaw, Architect, Studio Shaw.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://www.lse.ac.uk/Events/2017/01/20170131t1830vSZT/The-Quito-Papers
 
Description School visit (Birmingham) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The principal investigator contributed to two lessons to a class of approximately 25 pupils at a secondary school in Birmingham on language and rap. The lessons sparked discussions afterwards and the class teacher reported increased interest in the topic. This led to the principal investigator returning to the school and leading three workshop sessions with a smaller group of pupils on rap culture.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Tropenmuseum, Amsterdam: The Hip-Hop Museum Exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact On the 11th December I participated in the Hip-Hop Museum Exhibition at the National Museum of World Cultures, Amsterdam. I gave a talk based on the youth centre fieldwork we have conducted to an audience of 50 members of the general public. The audience included the Head of the Research Center for Material Culture at the Tropenmuseum, a curator at Amsterdam Museum, a music journalist, and members of the general public. The talk was followed by a Q & A session. After the talk and Q & A session I had the opportunity to discuss the presentation with members of the audience. Several said that the talk had given them new insight into the role that rap plays in society. Both the Head Research Center for Material Culture and the Curator at Amsterdam Museum were interested in having me return to Amsterdam to participate in the work in their museums.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016