Suicide Voices: Neoliberal Globalisation and Workplace Trauma

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: School of Modern Languages and Cultures

Abstract

France, during the 2000s, experienced what the international media has described as an 'epidemic' of workplace suicides with unprecedented numbers of workers choosing to kill themselves in work or because of work. With a 70% increase in recorded cases since 2000, France today has the second highest rate of workplace suicides in the world after Japan. French workplace suicides are part of a rising international phenomenon with well-publicised cases in Germany, Spain, Australia, China and Japan. Recent French suicides have been marked by an intensified production of texts through which suicidal individuals have sought to describe for themselves the experiences that have pushed them to take their own lives. The purpose of the fellowship is to examine, through a close reading of testimonial material, what these 'suicide voices' can tell us about the lived conditions of human labour in the historical juncture of neoliberal globalisation.
The fellowship undertakes an analysis of a corpus of testimonies linked to 82 suicide cases within three French companies during the period 2005 to 2015: telecommunications multinational, Orange; car manufacturer, Renault; and French postal services, La Poste. Each of these companies experienced an acute 'suicide wave' amongst its employees at a time of restructuring in response to the external economic imperatives linked to neoliberalism. The research examines an extensive corpus of letters, audio recordings, e-mails, press statements and legal documents written by suicidal individuals and intended for both private and public audiences. Whilst testimonies in a number of well-publicised cases have been published by the media, the full corpus of testimonial material has not yet been subject to academic scrutiny.
The fellowship examines suicide narratives as a unique testimonial mode that can shed light on subjective experiences of economics in the contemporary neoliberal and globalised workplace. The research locates suicide testimonies at a juncture between the everyday and the extreme. Whilst embedded in everyday life, these testimonies also reveal how the quotidian workplace can be transformed into a site of extreme human suffering. Why and how does work or conditions of work push some individuals to take their own lives? What are the social conditions to which these testimonies bear witness? Why is self-killing envisioned as a response to everyday experiences of work?
The fellowship aims to bring an arts and humanities perspective to bear on our understanding of a critical social and public health phenomenon by combining innovative theoretical and methodological insights from literature (testimony studies), social sciences scholarship and public health.
Three principal objectives are sought during the eighteen months of this fellowship. A first objective is to examine suicide narratives as a form of testimony that can transform personal trauma into public meaning and shed light on the conditions of labour in the contemporary historical juncture. The research aims to provide a critical alternative to 'top-down' theories of economics that often overlook experiential and quotidian dimensions of work. A second objective is to examine the historically-specific conditions of workplace suicides and ask why neoliberalism, as compared with earlier economic phases, has exacerbated suicidal tendencies in the workplace. A third objective is to consider the contemporary significance of suicide and ask whether workplace suicides constitute a new and radical mode of protest. To what extent do suicides stem from a failure of collective representation and a re-embodiment by the individual of grievances that might otherwise be given social expression?
From the vantage point of the singular and extreme experiences narrated in suicide testimonies, the fellowship aims to investigate the human and social effects of neoliberal economics in the workplace within the contemporary historical juncture.

Planned Impact

The fellowship is of direct importance to specific beneficiaries including public health organisations, trade unions and the general public. Impact activities are intrinsic to the project's rationale and have been integrated from the outset. Having established links with key stakeholder organisations in the UK and France, who will act as my project partners, I am ideally placed to exploit the fellowship's potential for impact.
1. A key innovation of the fellowship is to build collaborative links with leading public health organisations in the UK and France for purposes of disseminating my research to public health audiences (medical professionals, psychologists, occupational therapists, policy advisers) and shaping health policy agendas. I will use my expertise on French workplace suicides to contribute to public policy debates within my two project partner organisations which each work in collaboration with national governments, the European Commission and the WHO in formulating health policy proposals on suicide. Leeds funded a research visit to my project partner, the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, on 2 April 2015 where Professor Martin McKee (Co-Director) and I identified UK and European contacts and planned the fellowship's impact activities. These include a week-long research visit to the Observatory in June 2016 and a one-day international workshop hosted by the Observatory in December 2016. These will each provide a critical opportunity to present my research to both academic and non-academic audiences in public health. In France, I will work closely with my second project partner, the National Observatory of Suicide. Having held a workshop at this organisation in November 2014, I have been invited to return in October 2016 to present my research to an audience of French public health specialists. The fellowship will allow me to consolidate my collaboration with these two international organisations through a series of structured meetings and workshops.
2. Recent suicides have important implications for workplace policies at international level and I will build collaboration with trade union organisations in France and the UK which are likely to benefit directly from the research. A key aim is to raise awareness of workplace suicides and to help influence trade union strategies that are intended to inform, support and protect employees in relation to workplace risks. Having worked with the French trade union SUD at France Télécom (Waters 2014b), I will build collaboration with trade unions in two other French companies, Renault and La Poste, with whom I have already developed contact. In the UK, I am working in collaboration with Rory O'Neill, editor of the award-winning trade union magazine, Hazards and I have been invited to write an article for this magazine and to deliver a paper at the Hazards annual conference (June 2017), which is a major annual forum for trade unionists in the UK. This will allow me to reach a diverse audience of UK trade unionists.
3. The rise of workplace suicides is a critical issue for public health and I intend to disseminate the findings of my research to as wide a public audience as possible. My feature article in the American political magazine Jacobin reached a broad international audience which I was able to monitor through its extensive dissemination on social media (Facebook and Twitter). I plan further publications through general media outlets (The Guardian, Yorkshire Evening Post). The School of Languages, Cultures and Societies has strong links with BBC radio and the regional press through the Legacies of War and Transnational Holocaust Memories projects and I will take full advantage of these links in order to contribute to both radio segments and press articles. I will work closely with Arts Engaged at Leeds and Gareth Dent, the university's media adviser in developing the fellowship's impact activities.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Lane J (2018) 'Work in Crisis: film, fiction and theory' in Modern & Contemporary France

publication icon
Waters S (2018) Liberalisation, surveillance and suicide at La Poste in Modern & Contemporary France

publication icon
Waters, S (2020) Suicide au travail et restructuration de l'entreprise. Analyser les lettres de suicide in Observatoire national du suicide, Ministère de la santé (France) 4e rapport, 10 May 2020

publication icon
Waters, S (2017) Workplace Suicide and States of Denial. The France Telecom and Foxconn Cases Compared in Triple C. Communication, Capitalism & Critique

 
Description This is the first major multi-disciplinary study of the urgent and rising societal phenomenon of workplace suicide that combines humanities and public health methodologies to examine letters written by suicidal individuals in range of suicide cases across three French companies during the period 2005-2015. The key findings are: (i) Neoliberal transformations in the workplace have been characterised by a shift from the body to the mind as a core economic resource. Company constraints are increasingly internalised by the individual employee who identifies his/her identity with the goals of the company. This 'internalisation of constraint' can lead to deleterious effects on the individual employee; (ii) French workplace suicides have been prevalent in former public service companies undergoing privatisation and restructuring in which a new finance-driven ethos comes into conflict with deeply held public service values and beliefs which often define subjective and collective identities. Suicides are derived less from a transformation in material conditions of work, than from a profound disruption of the values and identity by which employees define themselves and their place in the world; (iii) Suicide letters are an extreme mode of communication in which individuals ascribe meaning to their death and interpret it for others. The letters unequivocally blame work and experiences of work as the cause of their suicide. Whilst they may point to a variety of causes (chaotic restructuring, forced redeployment, privatisation, management bullying), they portray a workplace undergoing radical reorganisation which has destroyed their sense of social identity, meaning and cultural belonging. Internalised constraint means that employees increasingly lack alternative conventional channels for communicating grievances; (iv) French legislation is protective of the employee in cases of workplace suicide. Where a suicide takes place in the workplace, it is automatically investigated as being work-related and the burden of proof falls on the company to prove that it is not work-related. This is to circumvent the need for families to engage in litigation in the aftermath of a suicide. In the UK by contrast, suicide is still treated as a voluntary and individual act. Where a suspected work-related suicide takes place, it is not recognised in legislation and the conditions which give rise to suicide are not investigated further, posing potential risks for other employees.
Exploitation Route My research provides an indepth analysis of the causes of rising workplace suicides in France as narrated by suicidal individuals themselves through their letters. It provides a critical model for the UK, where workplace suicide is not yet a subject of academic study and where policy makers do not tend to recognise the causal links between suicide and the workplace. Whilst UK trade unions and charities are increasingly aware of a rise in cases of work-related suicide, this has not yet been addressed in academic scholarship or in public policy.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice

 
Description (i) To inform UK trade unions about work-related suicides. My research is the key point of reference for the TUC (Trade Union Congress) guidlines on work-related suicidehttps://www.tuc.org.uk/blogs/why-suicide-workplace-issue . I provided briefing notes for trade union representatives to distribute to their members. I was keynote speaker at the NASUWT annual conference. I have published a feature article in a trade union magazine (Hazards). I held a meeting with representatives from the union organisation Families against Corporate Manslaughter (ii) To inform public policy. Submission to UK Parliament Health Committee on Suicide Prevention and meeting with Shadow Minister of Work and Pensions. I submitted a paper to the WHEC (Workplace Health Expert Committee) in January 2020 and in response, it has agreed to conduct a year long investigation into work-related suicide in the UK. I have lobbied the HSE (Health and Safety Executive) which has agreed to review mandatory reporting on work-related suicide in the UK. (iii) To support suicide charities. A summary of my research has been presented at the executive meeting of Papyrus (youth suicide charity)
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice,Other
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Lobbying for regulatory reform on work-related suicide
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
Impact I wrote a detailed statement to WHEC (Workplace Health and Safety Expert Committee) calling for regulatory reform on work-related suicide in the UK. The statement was signed by 17 researchers from six different countries. As a result, WHEC has agreed to launch the first year-long investigation into work-related suicides in the UK. I lead a group of international researchers that has lobbied the HSE (Health & Safety Executive) for regulatory reform and I have led negotiations with the HSE's senior psychologist Peter Kelly. As a result of this negotiation, the HSE has agreed for the first time to change its regulations in order to include mandatory reporting on workplace suicides.
 
Description University Research Scholarship
Amount £54,300 (GBP)
Organisation University of Leeds 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2017 
End 09/2020
 
Description International collaboration for research exchange and policy reform on work-related suicide 
Organisation President Stanislaw Wojciechowski State University of Applied Sciences
Department European Observatory of Health Inequalities
Country Poland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I collaborated with researchers at the European Observatory of Health Systems and Policies which was a partner organisation for my AHRC fellowship. My research helped to enrich the work of researchers at the EOHSP by bringing a Humanities perspective to bear on the phenomenon of work-related suicide and providing empirical insights on the French context. My AHRC fellowship is the first major research project on work-related suicide and it has brought new knowledge to bear on the work of researchers at the EOHSP whose work has hitherto focused on economic suicides (outside of the workplace). I organised two workshops hosted by EOHSP researchers at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. The first on 14th September 2016 brought together international researchers for a one-day workshop 'Suicide and Work in the Globalised Economy' (funded by Wellcome Trust) and the second, on 11 May 2017 (funded by AHRC) brought together trade unions, suicide charities and academic researchers for the purpose of building a campaign to lobby for legislative change on work-related suicide in the UK. Prior to the commencement of the AHRC award, I was lead author for a journal article written in collaboration with two EOHSP researchers published in Journal of Public Mental Health and we made a joint submission to the UK Parliament's Health Committee on suicide prevention. Since completing the AHRC project, I have continued to collaborate with the EOHSP on furthering research on work-related suicide. The London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine (where UK hub of EOHSP is based) appointed an honorary research fellow to work on a five-month contract in order to develop my research in the UK by working with coroners on individual cases of work-related suicide. Leeds University paid the salary of the part-time honorary research fellow and she was registered at London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and supervised by Prof Martin McKee (Director of EOHSP).
Collaborator Contribution Researchers at EOHSP provided valuable insight into the research methodologies used in public health for monitoring suicide and this was critical to the development of my AHRC fellowship project. Prof Martin McKee (director of EOHSP) was an active partner throughout the course of my AHRC project and we held regular meetings and jointly organised research events (in addition to joint publications prior to the start of the AHRC fellowship). Prof McKee put me into contact with leading international researchers on suicide which allowed me to build an international research network on work-related suicide. I was thus able to present my research to diverse audiences in the US (New York University, Fordham) and the UK (Oxford, Sheffield, Nottingham, LSHTM) through Prof McKee's contacts. Prof McKee appointed an honorary research fellow to work under his supervision and continue my research on work-related suicide in the UK. The London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine was the host institution and provided the research fellow with access to library. online services and room facilities
Impact 'Suicidal work: work-related suicides are uncounted' Hazards magazine March 2017
Start Year 2016
 
Description UK-France collaboration on work-related suicide 
Organisation Government of France
Department National Suicide Observatory
Country France 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The Observatoire national du suicide in Paris, a government-funded agency that monitors and promotes research on suicide in France, was a partner organisation for my AHRC fellowship and I worked closely with this organisation throughout the course of the research project. I helped the Observatoire to build international links with UK researchers and I invited a representative from this organisation to participate in a workshop that I organised in London on 14th September 2016 (funded by the Wellcome Trust) that brought together international researchers on suicide. Following a first meeting at the Observatoire in November 2016, I presented my research to practitioners, policy makers and researchers based at the Observatoire on 27 April 2018. The Observatoire is funding a further travel and accommodation costs for a futher visit on 14th May 2019 where I will participate in a workshop on work-related suicide. The Observatoire has invited me to publish an article summarising my research findings in its next annual report (November 2019) that presents the latest research on suicide and is the key source on suicide research for researchers, policy makers and practitioners in France.
Collaborator Contribution (I) Providing contact with leading academic researchers, practitioners and policy makers on suicide in France (ii) Informing the academic development and progress of my AHRC fellowship (iii) Allowing me to present my research to academic and non-academic audiences in France. (iv) Funding a research visit to France where I will present my research (v) Providing policy documents and reports on suicide in France
Impact I will contribute an article to the next annual report of the Observatoire national du suicide 'Etats des lieux des connaissances et de perspectives de recherche' which will appear in 2019.
Start Year 2016
 
Description I set up a lobbying group in the UK to campaign for improved recognition and monitoring of work-related suicides 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I have used my in-depth research on work-related suicides in France to create a lobby group in the UK to campaign for improved recognition, monitoring and legislative reform on work-related suicide. Whilst work-related suicide is legally recognised in France and data is collected by the public authorities, it is not recognised in UK legislation and there is no statistical monitoring. This creates significant risks for occupational health. Because suicide is considered a voluntary act in UK legislation, there is no investigation of working conditions following a suspected work-related suicide, so that these conditions remain intact and may continue to pose significant health risks for other employees.

Following my meeting with the Shadow Minister of Work and Pensions at the UK Parliament (March 2016) and a submission to the UK Parliament Health Committee's Suicide Prevention Enquiry (8 June 2016), I organised a workshop for trade unions, suicide charities and academic researchers at London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine on 11 May 2017.

The purpose of this workshop was to discuss a concerted strategy on improving public understanding, recognition and legislation on work-related suicides. The participants included a representative from each of the following trade unions: NASUWT, Unison, RMT, Unite, NUT and GMB, from two suicide charities (Papyrus and Samaritans) and researchers from the University of Bristol, LSHTM and Leeds.

The workshop built on my media visibility as a leading researcher on work-related suicides. I published a front-page research article in the award-winning trade union magazine Hazards in March 2017 which drew on my research on France to shed light on the current UK context on work-related suicide. I have also published in international occupational health magazines. The Swedish occupational health magazine Arbetsliv published an interview I gave on my research on 9 January 2017 https://www.prevent.se/arbetsliv/ovrigt/2017/samre-arbetsvillkor-bakom-sjalvmord/.

As a direct outcome of this workshop, I was asked to provide briefing notes on work-related suicides for each of the trade union representatives. These briefing notes were then circulated by union representatives to all other union members. I was also invited to give a keynote lecture to trade union members at the annual NASUWT conference (30 June 2017). Papyrus approached me to ask permission to present my research findings at their executive board meeting. Representatives from the trade union group Families against Corporate Killers requested a meeting with me and this meeting took place at the University of Leeds on 8th June 2017. A journalist from another independent Swedish workplace magazine (Arbetarskydd) is coming to the UK in February/March 2019 to carry out an in-depth interview on my research for publication in their magazine.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018,2019
URL http://www.hazards.org/suicide/suicidalwork.htm