The Aesthetics of Protest: Visual Culture and Communication in Turkey

Lead Research Organisation: University of Brighton
Department Name: Sch of Applied Social Sciences

Abstract

Recent years have seen a large increase in the number of protests around the world which have challenged economic institutions and political practices, including the Arab Spring, Occupy movements, pro-democracy movements in Hong Kong, and anti-austerity movements across Europe. This project focuses on the recent protests in Turkey, particularly in Gezi Park in Istanbul. This project examines the aesthetics of protest, in particular, how protestors use social media to communicate their messages to the public and how they attempt to engage the public, politicians and fellow protestors. Protestors have a range of options open to them in order to have their voice heard and increasingly protestors use aesthetics in order to communicate their ideas. This project looks at protest aesthetics, which we consider to be the visual, material, textual and performative elements of protest, such as images, symbols, graffiti, clothes, art, but also to include other elements such as forms of rhetoric, slang, humour, slogans, as well as the choreography of protest actions in public spaces. Through the use of social media, protestors have been able to create an alternative space for people to engage with politics that is more inclusive and participatory than traditional politics. The use of social media allows people to share ideas on protest activity and deliberate with one another in an online environment. What was significant about the protests in Turkey was how images were shared across social media platforms in order to communicate the messages of the protestors, to unite the public and to challenge the unpopular policies of the government which had provoked the protests in the first place. The project will explore how the public and politicians in Turkey interpreted protest aesthetics and if they attached any significance to particular protest aesthetics, and whether these have changed since 2013, particularly in light of the electoral defeat of the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) in the national elections in June 2015.

The recent protests in Turkey are notable because protestors inhabited public spaces in urban areas and used public spaces to communicate their ideas, emotions, and interests to the public in order to foster support and raise political awareness of issues. However, the power of the protestors was strengthened by social media platforms where members of the public, who were sympathetic with the protestors or lived in a different part of the country or beyond, did not have to occupy the same physical public space, but could engage and deliberate with one another through social networking sites and blogs. Social media platforms are increasingly an interactive space which form part of the political world where people can engage with one another and potentially become powerful. Drawing on McGarry's research on marginalised voices in politics and his work on identities and social movements, this research will provide new insights into how protestors come together and make the choices they do.

Planned Impact

The research will benefit diverse groups including: activists/protestors; Studio X gallery; V&A Museum; individuals in the creative arts; the media; policy audiences; the wider public. Activists and protestors will benefit from the project by inputting into the design of the research project including helping to formulate research questions and objectives as well as identifying areas of research which are meaningful to activists. The project's activist reference group has already specified that they are keen to understand how the political aesthetics resonate with the public which we will uncover through the survey and want to comprehend why protestors deploy particular aesthetics and how. Activists and protestors will benefit from the increased attention on Gezi Park protests and benefit from insights into how protest aesthetics are communicated across social media platforms. The website has the potential to act as a resource for teaching and learning about the protests which activists can use to promote their ideas. Studio X gallery will benefit from a high profile exhibition being held in their exhibition space focused on a key event in contemporary Turkish history. The curator of the exhibition at Studio X will build an international profile for his work. V&A Museum will benefit by hosting a seminar to discuss the findings of the project which will feed into the V&A design and protest series providing an international dimension to its work and will benefit the museum-attending public interested in the role of art in protests. The project will benefit curators and artists around the world by contributing to the digital galleries commission and exposing them to a wider audience including to activists and academics which will generate debate concerning the role of creative arts in protest including how protest aesthetics can capture and communicate the meaning of protests around the world. The media will benefit from covering the exhibition. We will issue press releases and invite key news media and current affairs reporters and cultural critics to a press preview to generate interest in the exhibition and simultaneously generate interest in different media outlets. Policy audiences will benefit from the website, blog and research updates which will document and inform visual aesthetics from protest aesthetics from around the world. The wider public will benefit from attending the exhibition in order to understand better how protestors shaped the Gezi Park mobilisation and why particular protest aesthetics were deployed. The website will also act as a learning resource for the public to understand diverse facets of the Gezi Park protests as well as generate understandings of protests around the world.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Digital Galleries 
Description As part of the project we will commission three digital galleries. We formulated a rationale/specification to provide guidelines for the production of the digital galleries. Aesthetics of Protest - Digital Galleries/Films - Specification The Digital Galleries concept is an important element of the Aesthetics of Protest project. In our bid to the Arts & Humanities Research Council we described them as follows: Digital galleries: The digital galleries aim to offer a visual and/or audiovisual response to visual data. This innovative methodology draws on theories developed within the field of the academic audiovisual essay, demonstrating the potential additional insights gained from extending the analysis beyond 'textual' analysis of visual data, to incorporate critical responses in other modes than written ones. Artists and digital media practitioners will be invited to respond to data sets or emerging themes of the research project and their work will be curated in the project website. The output can be still or moving digital images. The technical specifications will be set to meet the requirements of the AHRC should the research council wish to showcase some of these image sets or films on their website. By the end of the project, in December 2017, we will deliver three 'galleries' as a core outcome of the project. The intention is to offer a creative opportunity to those we commission to direct each gallery. The opportunity must advance the ideas developed during the project and help communicate them to a wider public. We hope each opportunity will enhance the experience and profile of those we commission to work with us in collaboration. While each Digital Gallery 'Director' will have autonomy and the full backing of the project team, there are particular benchmarks and milestones that need to be adhered to. Specification We require each Digital Gallery to take the form of either a film (less than 30 minutes) and to be accessible on Vimeo. The AHRC define a 'Film' as 'a series of moving images, but the nature of the images is open and unspecified'. Or, we can accept a digital gallery as a set of images that could be delivered in the existing framework produced by the AHRC. (I will be speaking to them directly about this format and its suitability - we may want to produce all the 'galleries' as films on Vimeo) http://www.ahrc.ac.uk/funding/opportunities/archived-opportunities/rifa-2016/ Synopsis and rationale Each Digital Gallery/Film needs to be accompanied by a 150 word synopsis. We require each Director to produce an accompanying text relating to the ideas and the process, this will be published on the AoP website. (2,500 words) Directors Each Digital Gallery should be credited to those involved in its making. It should be led by a named individual who is responsible for communications with the AoP co-ordinator. Fee The fee for each gallery is £4000 and this should be spent on production and contributors'/director's fees. Details of the payment process will be agreed with the AoP co-ordinator. Selection, timeframe and delivery Each prospective Director should prepare a short proposal (500 words) and a selection of indicative images, making the case for their project. This proposal will be discussed by the AoP investigators who will then approve the decision to proceed with each commission. Work should start on the Gallery/Film in the spring of 2017 with the Director providing brief monthly progress reports to the AoP team. In July the investigators would like a brief presentation of work achieved to date. Each Digital Gallery should be made available in its completed form by 1 October 2017. Creating opportunities to allow the exploration of the themes underpinning the Aesthetics of Protest project was an important element of the research process. We wanted to work with others to demonstrate the potential of extending the boundaries beyond the core social media data set and survey findings created by the project, and to incorporate creative and critical responses to its wider themes in modes other than written ones. Artists and digital media practitioners were invited to advance the ideas developed during the project and to interpret and communicate them to a broad international public. The brief was to work with either still or moving digital images and to create a gallery or film. The three works created are very different in their approach and scope yet all add meaning and texture to our understanding of what the aesthetics of protest might mean and the forms it may take. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The Digital Galleries have been shared and discussed. We had to be careful with some of the content as the government has become increasingly authoritarian. The three collaborations were fantastic processes which helped the project team to reflect and better understand our own research arguments. It led to one contributor, Anil Orcan, becoming part of another research bid to the AHRC working with CoI Korkut, CoI Erhart and PI McGarry on digital voices of refugee youth. One of the digital galleries was used to support the exhibition we had as part of the Istanbul Biennial and so was shown to all people who attended the 'Maybe we will benefit from our neighbour's good fortune' exhibition. 
URL http://www.aestheticsofprotest.com/digital-galleries/
 
Title Istanbul Biennial Exhibition- Maybe, We will Benefit From Our Neighbour's Good Fortune. 
Description As part of the original proposal we planned to have an exhibition in Istanbul addressing the theme of 'The Aesthetics of Protest'. Our partner was Studio X in Istanbul. Due to the changing political context in Turkey with increasingly authoritarian measures, Studio X were reluctant to get involved as they were concerned about the content of the exhibition. Recently, artists, journalist and academics have been targeted, fired from jobs and arrested. This required a serious rethink about whether the exhibition could proceed. The PI went to Istanbul in September 2016 and met with artists and discussed what could be done. He met with a curator who suggested exploring how artistic communities have responded since the protests in 2013 and the coup attempted in 2016. One response has been the flourishing of collectives and community art projects and we felt this emphasis on community and participation would be important as it is often neglected by mainstream arts and academic endeavours. A new gallery space and partnership was then established with 'Hakta Art' in Istanbul. The exhibition was a series of 'live' performances/workshops on themes of food and neighbourhood. The exhibition was part of the Istanbul Biennial, the second largest in the world (after Venice). 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The exhibition generated a huge amount of media attention: the curator gathered over 30 pages of press clippings from national and international press. It is not possible to include those clippings as a document but these are available on request. More significantly, the exhibition was highly praised included by The Freize magazine, the key publication on contemporary art which hailed it one of the critic's choices of the Biennial (https://frieze.com/article/critics-guide-istanbul-0). The theme of the project and its collectivist positioning spoke to broader themes of the Istanbul Biennial. A review of our exhibition was written by CoI Moriarty (see the link below). The exhibition was curated by Isil Egrikavuk (Berlin School of the Arts) who identified the art collectivies, the key themes, the partners and dealt with all aspects of media. Our funders logo was present at the exhibition as well as on the programme. 
URL https://www.aestheticsofprotest.com/2017/10/03/exhibition/
 
Title Project Website 
Description This is the project's website which has details of our project but also is populated by a blog and twitter feed. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The wesbite and Twitter are primarily used for diseemination and engagement. 
URL http://www.aestheticsofprotest.com/
 
Description We have explored how protestors use visual images/culture to communicate with one another and the public. We have compared how different social media platforms have been used by protestors and how. We have examined how mobilization is negotiated across digital and material spaces. We have developed the concept of protest aesthetics to capture the performativity of protest through bodies, colour, humour, to promote solidarity and to communicate ideas of hope and freedom. We learned that social media is often used by protestors in very humdrum or ordinary ways but this is potentially politically significant too as protestors communicate everyday activities to project the kind of society they want to live in. The key finding from the book (forthcoming) is the aesthetics are not just matters of taste and style but are performative and communicative.
Exploitation Route Our research has focused on Gezi Park protests in Turkey in 2013. One of the most interesting aspects of the project is having artists, activits, journalists, and academics contacting us from all over the world to say how much they like the project and our approach and how they want to be involved. This has directly fed into our book project which looks at protest aesthetics and visual culture and communication in places such as Thailand, USA, Brazil, Greece, Northern Ireland, Israel/Palestine, South Africa and Argentina. It was always the idea that this project would test out concepts and promote a new approach to social movement theory and activism and our ideas are being taken up by others. We are currently exploring how this might develop in the future. Our website features article we have written, for example, we were approached by OpenDemocracy when it curated a week on protest in December 2017. PI McGarry and CoI Jenzen wrote an article which communicated our research findings on the visual spectacle of protest (https://www.opendemocracy.net/protest/performance-of-protest-gezi-park) and the article was published in Spanish on the OpenDemocracy. Additionally, PI McGarry interviewed a perfromance artist from New York called Morgan O'Hara who became interested in the project after reading about our research (http://www.aestheticsofprotest.com/blogs/). We have a blog section on our website which we post more substantive content which helps get the word out there. We also have a active Twitter handle and use this to make links with articts, researchers, and journalists around the world @aestheticsgezi
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy

URL http://www.aestheticsofprotest.com/
 
Description The findings have been used to engage with artistic practices. We collaborated with a New York based artist on a piece of performance art and protest: 'The Introvert's Protest: Handwriting the Universal Declaration of Human Rights' for the 70th anniversary of the UNDHR. The research found that aesthetics are perfromative and communicative and this performance art activity was inclusive and reflective.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Peer Review
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
 
Description (DEMOS) - Democratic Efficacy and the Varieties of Populism in Europe
Amount € 3,037,781 (EUR)
Funding ID 822590 
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 12/2018 
End 11/2021
 
Description (RESPOND) - RESPOND: Multilevel Governance of Mass Migration in Europe and Beyond
Amount € 3,310,405 (EUR)
Funding ID 770564 
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 12/2017 
End 11/2020
 
Description EURIAS Fellowship for PI McGarry to work at Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study (Amsterdam)
Amount £27,000 (GBP)
Organisation European Commission 
Department Seventh Framework Programme (FP7)
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 09/2018 
End 06/2019
 
Description Newton International Post Doctoral Fellowship (PI McGarry to work with co-applicant with Ozge Ozduzen)
Amount £81,000 (GBP)
Organisation Newton Fund 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2018 
End 04/2020
 
Title Research Methods 
Description This study draws on methodologies from across the fields of Media Studies, Political Science and Aesthetics. The project uses qualitative research including visual analysis, interviews and a qualitative survey of the Turkish public. The research is designed to capture the meaning of protest aesthetics, to understand why protestors used particular aesthetics, and to explore how this resonated with fellow protestors, politicians and the public. Our methodological tools capture aesthetics that are visual, audio/visual and material expressions which at once communicate a message and constitute the polity through performance. Pushing beyond analyzing images as text (in isolation) the research team will consider the mediated nature of still and moving images and their performative dimension across diverse social media platforms (including Twitter, Pinterest, Tumblr, Facebook, and YouTube) for protestors as they seek to subvert the monopolies of representations and interpretations and displace authorships and authorities (Alexander 2011). The participatory approach involves consulting activists and protestors from the outset -i.e. in co-producing the research questions and aims, and the research team seek to move participatory action research and socially-engaged arts and humanities research approaches more broadly speaking, up the research agenda by exploring its value in a diverse cultural context through reflection on associated methodological challenges and rewards (Banks and Manners 2012). The approach involves working with community partners and individual participants who engage as collaborators rather than being confined to the limited role of 'end users' (cf. Pain et al. 2011). The current political climate in Turkey makes this ambition of the project increasingly challenging. The aim remains nevertheless to be able to work with the activist reference group composed of a number of activists and protestors based in Istanbul and who were involved with the Gezi Park protests, at various stages through out the project. The project proceeds in three overlapping stages. At this time in point the team is mainly concerned with stage one, which entails Stage one will gather a wide range of data on the visual and material culture produced and shared by protestors on key social media platforms suggested by the activist reference group as well as based on existing knowledge of important social media platforms. Using hashtags such as #gezipark and relevant keywords, data has been collected from Twitter, pinterest, YouTube and tumblr and a proportion of the visual material has been coded for the purpose of initial scoping (see Research Databases section). Data about Facebook will be collected via participant-led interviews whereby the participant guides the researcher through their selection of content that is of particular importance to them rather than being guided by what is important to the researcher. This method can be described as a semi structured interview technique that incorporates elements of online participatory observations. The project employs the data analysis computer software NVivo for the organization and processing of different types of data, including social media data and visual data. With training from an NVivo specialist we seek to use the full capacities of the software to work in a dynamic and collective approach to the diverse types of data we seek to bring together. We are tackling challenges relating to issues such as the size of data sets collected from social media; the diversity in types of visual genres within the data; the polysemous nature of images; and working in two languages (Turkish and English). The analysis of the images and videos collected will be analysed using critical discourse analysis to research language use as 'social practice' (Fairclough and Wodak, 1997) intersecting with political practice. Such analysis will be combined with visual analysis (Rose 2012) that attends to the images both as aesthetic and political communication. Analysis will focus on textual and visual rhetoric, formal aspects and composition, frames of reference and intertextuality as well as the participation frameworks and the socialised nature of the media technology in question. In the next stages selected visual material in this dataset will be used to inform the interviews with protestors and politicians, as well as the public survey. Stage two, will comprise semi-structured interviews with 25 protestors, 5 politicians, 5 humanitarian NGOs, 5 journalists in Turkey, mostly, though not exclusively, in Istanbul. We will ensure the anonymity of interviewees who will be selected using input from our activist reference group as well as extant networks and those who participated in protest organisations such as Diren Gezi Park and Taksim Solidarity. The team has begun the recruitment for interviewees and developed interview guides. Given the somewhat volatile political climate in Turkey at the moment it has been decided to move forward on this in a careful and measured approach. There is a partial risk with interviewing activists who protest against the government which we need to continuously assess as we progress stage two. Stage three will determine the impact and future implications of the changing aesthetics of protest by gauging the opinion of the public through an online survey, aiming for 300 respondents who will be approached using active Facebook platforms and other social media forums focused on Gezi Park protests. If the aesthetics of protest have evolved in recent years then it is important to show that these changes have been noticed by wider society. The survey will highlight selected protest aesthetics selected by the activist reference group, interviewees, and identified as of particular interest in stage one, as mentioned above, and then ask if the public recognises and attaches any significance to the protest aesthetics. The survey will comprise of a combination of open ended and closed questions in order to capture attitudes to and familiarity with the social media and other visual communication employed by activists. The survey will be designed to explore public attitudes, perceptions and understandings regarding protest aesthetics. Data will be generated from the digital galleries to offer a visual and/or audiovisual response to visual data. The interviews will be processed using the qualitative coding. The interviews will be transcribed and organised using analytic coding, to aid the identification of key themes.Researchers will work through the transcripts and assign thematic coding principles to the respondents' narrative. Through a process of comparing the individually assigned thematic coding dominant themes in the material will be identified and used to determine the focus for further discursive analysis. The responses to the qualitative survey will be analysed by researchers reading each survey response independently then sifting and sorting themes and pre-determined code 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None as yet as the research has not been published. 
 
Title Research data processing 
Description Database We have collected - almost one million tweets using 'geziparki' as a word search in the tweet and separated those tweets which contain images. - a database of 750 images which have been coded. - a database of 2400 images from Tumblr - a database of 490 images from Pinterest. - a database of 121 YouTube videos - The Twitter API was queried using 'Gezi Parki' keyword. The time period defined for this query was between the 27th of May and the end of June 2013. This was the time period wherein Gezi Park was a regularly trending topic on Twitter and the protests were in full swing. - Gezi Park was chosen as a word as it was an unstructured and hence neutral term. As an unstructured query, the keyword was used in tweets both by pro and anti Gezi activists as well as tweets with factual information. - The data collection process was undertaken by a social media monitoring agency which compiled the data into large spreadsheets. The spreadsheets had to be converted into comma-separated value (csv) format. Excel was unable to open these files due to their size. Once the data was reformatted, the spreadsheets were broken down into smaller, more accessible files. Data retrieval operations were performed on these files using Bash, PHP and Python, three programming languages. - The operations performed include the separation of tweets into three separate groups: text-only, tweets containing images and tweets containing links to YouTube videos. - Once separated, links embedded in media-rich tweets were harvested using two separate scripts. To collect images, Bash was used to download the physical tweets from the Twitter API. Once collected, the images embedded within the downloaded tweets were extracted using a purpose-built PHP script. Duplicates were eliminated. A similar process will be deployed for YouTube videos. IMAGES The images that were related to Gezi Park movement and that were still accessible were downloaded. The images were then imported into Nvivo for Mac 11.4.0 (2065). Qualitative data analysis was done from the existing data, to reach new categories and themes, and to interpret them within a contextual framework. In this process, meaning categories are determined and integrated in different stages of increasing abstraction, so that both commonalities and differences are established using the constant comparative method. The computer software package Nvivo for Mac 11.4.0 (2065) was used to systematically code and analyse the raw data and to develop and integrate the emerging analytic categories and themes. The first stage of open coding was used to generate descriptive and summaritive codes for the visual images. These codes will answer questions like where the photo was taken (i.e. location) or the style of the visual image. Later more specific attributes were coded (i.e. the specific place, inside Gezi park). The project team sought to reach consensus during the process of coding. The team members came together and coded a number of images together to develop a common code book. During this process, researchers evaluated the appropriateness of the coded segments of the data and aimed to reach consensus. During these sessions, the research team came up with the most salient categories. For example, the categories that emerged as significant in the relation to the emotions that a visual image evokes, we defined three categories: affection, demand and humour where the affection category also had two sub categories solidarity and other. These categories will later form the basis for the organization of our results. Memos helped interpret both what was obvious in the image and the subtext or what was not obvious / what was hidden, and served to guide the ''naming'' of categories. 'Memo-writing' during the coding helped move the analysis from content reflection to content interpretation and facilitated the process of raising focused codes to conceptual categories, it also enabled communication among the project team. The list of are coding as it appeared in the Nodes section of Nvivo are: o Location (*) ? Available • Gezi Park • Around Gezi Park • Istanbul • Other Turkish cities • Outside Turkey ? Not Available o Style (*) ? Documentary • Everday Life • Praying • Other ? Screenshot • TV • Computer • Mobile ? Combination ? Cartoon ? Poster • Digital o Actors ? Children & Babies ? Elderly ? Football Fans ? Opponents ? Police ? Political Parties ? Politician ? Public Figure ? External Forces • The K • USA • Other o Side ? For ? Against ? Neutral o Evokes ? Affection • Solidarity • Other ? Demand ? Humour o Message (*) ? Yes • Banner • Debate - Discussion • Graffitti • Rally • Plain Text • o Language • Turkish • English • Other ? No o Confrontation ? Yes • Peaceful • Violent o Gas ? Yes ? No ? No o Composition Elements ? Image • Animal • People o Individual o Couple o Group 3-19 o Crowd 20+ • Nature • Objects o Vehicle o Represents a Gender Issue ? Yes ? No o Contains/Refers to well known Gezi icons ? AKM ? Ataturk ? Anonymous ? Carsi ? Converse - Genç Siviller ? Dervish ? Flag ? Lego ? O - P ? Penguin ? Standing Man ? Tents ? Tree ? Women in Red o Role of human body o Social Media related ? Restriction related o Us - them divide o Undefined VIDEOS - Same process will be repeated for videos. We are at the stage of downloading the accessible videos. Due to the sensitivity of the data collected and the deteriorating political climate in Turkey, including rising authoritarianism and the arbitrary imprisonment of journalists, artists, academics and activists, we have decided to withhold the databases at this time. We are concerned it could be used to monitor our research subjects. For this reason, the 40 interviews, all images, and 300 survey responses have been withheld. We requested and received AHRC permission to do this. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None as yet 
 
Description COSMOS, Florence (Centre for Social Movement Studies) 
Organisation Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa
Country Italy 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution In November 2017, PI McGarry was a Visiting Scholar at the Scuola Normale Superiore in Florence. He spend his time there writing the conceptual framwork for the book 'Aesthetics of Protest' and also presented research in progress on the visual data gathered from Twitter. PI McGarry worked at COSMOS because it is the leading centre for social movements studies in the world and the Director, Prof. Donatella Della Porta, is one of the leading authorities on protest mobilizations. Whilst there McGarry met with PhD students and senior researchers, including Dr Alice Mattoni and Dr Katy Hayward, who wll be part of the book project.
Collaborator Contribution COSMOS invited PI McGarry to be an Visiting Scholar. COSMOS also kindly agreed to host our academic workshop at the end of the project in Decemner 2017. Details of this are found in the engagement section. Additionally, CoI Jenzen is applying for sabbatical to spend part of her time conducting research at COSMOS. The result of this is not known yet.
Impact A book will emerge from this collaboration.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Exhibition: Halka Collective, Istanbul 
Organisation Halka Art Project
Country Turkey 
Sector Learned Society 
PI Contribution When the proposal was submitted in July 2015 we had a supporting letter from Studio X, a gallery in Istanbul, to host an exhibition relating to the project. Since the award (April 2016) and subsequent coup (July 2016) in Turkey, artists and academics are under increasing pressure from the government, with funding being withdrawn from educational and arts institutions and many artists, activists and academics being fired and/or imprisoned. It has created an atmosphere where artists are careful not to criticise the government. In September 2016, Studio X formally withdrew from the project. As PI, I went to Istanbul in September 2016 to search for another venue and explore whether an exhibition was viable. We have since found a suitable gallery space but the content of the exhibition has changed. It is no longer on protest aesthetics, but on community arts activism. We have a curator in place, Isil Egrikavuk, who has secured a gallery, Halka Sanat, in Istanbul for September 2017 which will coincide with the prestigious Istanbul biennial ensuring we have a lot much publicity for the event. We have stripped out the overtly political content of the exhibition as we were concerned with endangering activists and artists who will participate in the exhibition.
Collaborator Contribution The exhibition was in Istanbul in 2017. Details are to be found in the outputs sections.
Impact The collaboration is multi-disciplinary, bringing together artist, activists and academics.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Institute of Contemporary Arts 
Organisation Institute of Contemporary Arts
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We worked closely with the ICA to hold a panel discussion of the theme of art performance and protest. Details are to be found in the enegagement activities. Just less than 100 people attended the event, mostly members of the public. The project team identified key participants for the panel including Pelin Basaran and Isil Egrikavuk and arranged for their transport and accomodation at the event.
Collaborator Contribution The ICA agreed to host the event and they prmotoed in in ther marketing outreach. The result was that it was very well attended with approx 80-100 attendees.
Impact It was part of our project engagement and to promote our research to the public.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Social Movement Network 
Organisation University of Brighton
Department Advanced Engineering Centre
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The project has joined the University of Brighton Social Movement Network and is participating on the monthly seminar series. This will include a presentation of the research in progress in April 2017.
Collaborator Contribution We will present our indicative research findings on visual culture and twitter at the monthly seminar series. The presentation will be made by Aidan McGarry and Hande Eslen-Ziya.
Impact A conference paper will be produced.
Start Year 2016
 
Description 'Political Voice and the Aesthetics of Protest' Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study, Amsterdam. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact The PI gave a talk to the Fellows at the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study in Amsterdam.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://nias.knaw.nl/events/the-aesthetics-of-protest-visual-culture-performance-and-social-media/
 
Description 'Political Voice as Visibility' Indian Institute for Technology of Bombay, Mumbai, India. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact I was invited to give a talk at Inida's leading university, IIT Bombay. I presented on the AHRC project findings and discussed democracy and political voice.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description 'Protest and Political Voice: Heros and Villains', Utrecht Literary Festival, Netherlands, Opening for Salman Rushdie at the Humanities Night. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact PI was invited to be the opening act for Salman Rushdie at the Utrecht Literary Festival, Netherlands, 19 September 2018.. He discussed 'Protest and Political Voice: Heros and Villains',
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.ilfu.nl/en/programma/humanities-night-met-salman-rushdie/
 
Description 'The Introvert's Protest: Handwriting the Universal Declaration of Human Rights', 10 December 2018. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I organized an 'Introvert's Protest' where we handwrote the Universal Declaration on Human Rights from start to finish on the 70th anniversary of the UNDHR. There were around 35 participants in Amsterdam. I began the events discussing the AHRC project. I wrote up the findings for a blog post (see below)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://blog.lboro.ac.uk/london/diplomatic-studies/the-introverts-protest-handwriting-the-un-declara...
 
Description Academic workshop (Florence) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The project convened an academic workshop at COSMOS, Florence. The purpose of the workshop is to provide feedback to the research in progress of the 'Aesthetics of Protest' (www.aestheticsofprotest.com) team. All 6 members of the Aesthetics of Protest team presented a paper each based on the data we collected during the project which will become 6 distinct journal articles on the themes of the aesthetics of protest. The second step was to discuss a book project which will emerge from the project and explore common themes and interests in our research. The draft conceptual chapter was circulated beforehand for all the participants to read. The draft conceptual framework was completed by the PI during his Visiting Scholarship at COSMOS in November 2017. We invited esteemed international academic researchers who work in the area of protest aesthetics, social media and protest and art and protest. Each participant has agreed to be part of the book project which the Aesthetics of Protest team will edit. Other members of COSMOS including researchers and PhD students attended the workshop in full or in part.

Professor Donatella Della Porta (SNS, Florence), Director of COSMOS
Professor Farida Vis (Sheffield University)
Dr. Simon Faulkner (Manchester Metropolitan University)
Dr. Alice Mattoni (Scuola Normale Superiore, Florence)
Dr. Dan Mercea (City University, London)
Derya Gü?demir (Hacettepe University, Ankara)
Dr. Özge Özdüzen (Lund University, Sweden)
Isil Egrikavuk (University of the Arts, Berlin)
Dr. Holly Ryan (Manchester Metropolitan University)
Julia Tulke (Rochester University, NY, USA)
Dr. Noah Viernes (Akita University, Japan
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Advisory Board 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact We invited leading academics working on Visual Culture (Prof Gillian Rose) and Social Movements (Prof Clare Saunders) and Social Media (Dr. Dan Mercea) to an Advisory Board meeting in November 2016.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Pi Aidan McGarry attended a workshop on 'Picturing the Social' as part of the Visual Social Media Lab in June 2016. This was a networking event to publicise our AHRC project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://visualsocialmedialab.org/blog/portfolio/picturing-the-social-2016-conference
 
Description Conference (Budapest) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact CoI Erhart and CoI Korkut were invited to present their research at a launch of a journal special issue in Budapest in November 2017. The two presented methodological issues around conducting research on Gezi Park and protest aesthetics. The feedback from the academic audience was extremely positive and they were impressed by the fresh perspective that our research was taking.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Conference presentation (San Diego, USA) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact CoI Olu Jenzen and PI Aidan Mcgarry presented their research at the 'Mobilization' conference in San Diego in May 2017.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://mobilizationjournal.org/page/news/conference-may-2017?code=hjdm-site
 
Description Conference presentation in Cartagena, Colombia (IAMCR) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact PI McGarry, CoI Korkut and CoI Eslen-Ziya atended the IAMCR conference in Cartagena, Colombia in July 2017. The conference is the largest in the world on media and communication research and this is a field which we wanted to present our research and publicise our project. At the conference, PI McGarry met Dr. Emiliano Trere who worled at COSMOS, the world's leading research centre on social movements.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://cartagena2017.iamcr.org/static/
 
Description Conference workshop (Istanbul) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact In addition to the academic workshop at COSMOS, Florence, the project also convened a workshop in Istanbul in December 2017. The purpose of this workshop was to provide feedback to the research in progress of the 'Aesthetics of Protest' (www.aestheticsofprotest.com) team. All 6 members of the Aesthetics of Protest team presented a paper each based on the data we collected during the project which will become 6 distinct journal articles on the themes of the aesthetics of protest. CoI Moriarty and CoI Eslen-Ziya could not attend in person but did so via skype. We had initially planned on holding a larger conference in Turkey to promote the research and disseminate the findings but the increasingly hostile environment including governmental crackdowns and arrests of academics and activists meant that we had to be very careful and hold an event which was under the radar. For example, the event was held at the Swedish Research Institute in central Istanbul because this was on diplomatic (Swedish) soil and so we could not be interrupted by the police. We invited a small group of academics and activists to attend and give us feedback on our 6 presentations/papers, which was an extremely useful entreprise. Some people who we invited were fearful to attend because they did not want the government to discover their names and their particpiation in the workshop depite assurances of anonymity from the PI. I will not list the academics and activists who attended but I have these details on file.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Design Salon at the Institute for Contemporary Art (ICA), London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This panel discussion focused on the relationship between art, protest and performance in June 2017. This panel brought together artists/practitioners and academics to discuss the performance of protest in contentious politics. Whilst panelists will discuss Turkey and the Gezi Park protests in particular it will other explore manifestations of the performance of protest around the world. This ICA was ticketed and almost 100 tickets were booked. All members of the project team attended with PI McGarry and CoI Korkut speaking alongside invited talks from performance artisrs Isil Egrikavuk and Pelin Basaran. The event was extremely well attended and allowed us to promote the project and develop links with students, artists, activists, policymakers and the media. ICA has asked to work with us again as they were so impressed with the quality of the panel and the turnout. This event was one of the main outputs described in the original proposal. We did this in conjunction with the V&A Design Salon curator, Professor Guy Julier.

This event was chaired by Prof. Catherine Moriarty (University of Brighton) and panellists include Isil Egrikavuk (Performance Artist, Istanbul), Pelin Basaran (Programme manager, Contact, Manchester), Dr. Aidan McGarry (University of Brighton) and Dr. Umut Korkut (Glasgow Caledonian University).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.ica.art/whats-on/performance-protest-panel-visual-culture-and-aesthetics
 
Description Festival of Social Science (Brighton, UK) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact PI McGarry, CoI Eslen-Ziya and CoI Jenzen presented some initial research at the Festival of Scocial Science at the University of Brighton in April 2017. The purpose was the promote the research and test out some ideas relating to social science methods using visual imagery and get feedback from an audience well versed in such methods. The impact was that it helped us to refine our methods and argument for a journal article.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Invited Talk (Lebanese American University) Beirut 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact The PI was invited to give a talk on the findings of the project to the Lebanese Amercian University in Beirut in March 2018. The PI was invited by Prof. Paul Tabar who works on social movements in Lebanon and the Middle East. The talk was an opportunity to meet students and discuss with staff potential collaboration. The staff were interested in how we did our research and used visual culture to explore how communication is acrried out in protest movements.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Invited talk at workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Olu Jenzen and Aidan McGarry presented our research from the book 'Aesthetics of Global Protest' at a Visual Politics workshop in University of Queensland (Brisbane).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Social Movement conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Aidan McGarry presented the outline and methodology of the research project at a Social Movement Conference in October 2016 to an audience of academics and activists.

The title of the presentation was 'The Aesthetics of Protest: Visual Culture and Communication in Turkey'
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://arts.brighton.ac.uk/research/research-events/research-conferences/social-movements-and-protes...
 
Description Talk at CAPPE Social Movement Seminar (Brighton, UK) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact PI McGarry, CoI Jenzen and CoI Eslen-Ziya wrote a paper to present at this seminar. The seminar is organised in a way that everyone who attends must read the paper in advance. We had approximately 15 people at the seminar who gave us very detailed comments and questions to help us to complete the paper ready for submission to a journal. The discussion lasted 90 minutes. That paper has since been submitted to an international journal and is being peer reviewed.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017