Pre-Columbian Tropical Urban Life: Placing the past in designs for sustainable urban futures (TruLife)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Kent
Department Name: Sch of European Culture and Languages

Abstract

Facing the challenge of increasing urbanisation, strategies for future city development are not considering the long urban past. Archaeologists of ancient cities recognise that long-term urban processes can teach us about diverse human-environment interactions. Thus, TruLife's core research question is: Can studying the diversity of long-term urban traditions, exemplified by pre-Columbian Maya tropical cities, effectively inform designing for sustainable urban futures?

Research activities
Under the current Cross-Council Enquiry Highlight Notice, TruLife will create a humanities led network of researchers that incorporates the environmental and social sciences. They will convene in three workshops dedicated to pivotal concerns ubiquitous to building sustainable cities:
A) Food Security
B) Decay and Waste Management
C) Spatial Practice
TruLife's workshops establish concrete foundations for comparative frames of reference, associated terms, data, and analysis relevant to pertinent topics, which will be widely disseminated.

Background
The longest time span and most diverse cases of urban developmental pathways are being recorded by archaeologists. This significantly expanded evidence base of urban scenarios is currently not used in designs for sustainable urban life. A lack of comparative frames of reference (including commensurable methods and data presentation) causes the absence of direct, mutually informing dialogues.
With a focus on the well-documented 2,500 year history of the Maya Neotropical urban tradition, workable, high-potential outcomes for wide-ranging research and innovative design applications can be achieved. Maya urbanism offers an elucidating case. It flourished without the 'human-animal grazing complex' Old World urban growth relies on. This contrast asks crucial questions about critical differences in human-environment interactions. Maya everyday urban life and development thrived in different urban ecological relations and metabolic processes to those of globalised temperate-climate models. European colonisation replaced Maya urban configurations with such models, causing the loss of key practices, including its long-term adaptability to change. Dependence on grazing animals results in declining soil fertility, soil erosion, massive deforestation, and misdirected investments (e.g. growing crops to feed cattle), all of which pose a global threat to humanity.
Urban design and environmental engineering aspire to balance ecological relations of cities to attain more sustainable social life. The usability of ideas derived from TruLife's cross-disciplinary encounters follows from both a better appreciation of archaeological contributions outside the discipline and allowing environmental and urban social science to influence archaeological investigation.

Dissemination and Impact
TruLife will examine the relevance of long-term Maya tropical cities to offering critical contexts and alternatives to current discussions on strategies for urban futures, disseminating results in a special issue of an international journal (TruLife has links to Journal of Urbanism and Ecology and Society) and abridged methodological pointers on an existing research website.
Developing a brief for a Design Ideas Competition will test the ability of new insights and frames of reference in areas of shared concern. The competition and resulting exhibition will be organised with non-academic project partners creating a powerful arena of knowledge exchange and impact, both of research and impacting subsequent research scopes.

Reach
The network comprises an international membership with a strategic UK base (12 in 6 countries), expert invitees (6), and non-academic project partners (2). Diverse membership, including links to related NGOs, steering group, and external partners ensure the quality and broad leverage for TruLife's outputs. Impact activities concern urban populations, urban professionals, students, and public.

Planned Impact

Urban Design and Environmental Engineering
[1] Network members include urban design and environmental engineering experts working towards research applications. This opens a route to influencing design and engineering implementations commercially or as part of governmental policy. Connecting archaeological evidence to other research practice, which regularly informs consultation and application processes, prepares for innovative use and awareness of alternative developmental paths and social practice in future planning of interventions;

[2] A Design Ideas Competition will influence urban design and environmental engineering practitioners directly. Contestants will work to a brief and submit implementable ideas for urban design, engineering, and practice interventions, which improve sustainable urban life and development. Producing the brief is an intellectual outcome of TruLife's research workshops. Targeted are professionals, students, and knowledgeable members of the public, who think and work creatively on urban challenges. Participation will promote their work and abilities, while salient research insights within the brief will take root in contestants. This means new insights will live on in the sector, benefitting urban development;

[3] Promoting the competition and its exhibited results will reach a wider audience involved in urban design and environmental engineering. The partnership with RIBA Southeast (Royal Institute of British Architects), a key architectural representative, enhances this.

Heritage Museums and Audience
[1] Producing an exhibition of competition winners with the Sainsbury Centre for Visual Arts (SCVA) exemplifies how archaeological and heritage knowledge can be active components of ideas for the future. This realises an incremental innovation in how the presentation of heritage can be relevant to the improvement of the world today, and may act as a model for further parallels in which heritage is used;

[2] Museum visitors are made aware of alternative paths towards sustainable urban life as inspired by past solutions in an exhibition combining research insights with design and engineering ideas. A greater appreciation of the importance of archaeological recording and preservation, as well as stimulating support for sustainable innovations in people's own living environments are expected mid-term effects.

Urban Prosperity (esp. the developing world and Neotropical indigenous populations)
Designing sustainable cities determines prosperity for a growing majority of the world's population. Understanding successful and unsuccessful outcomes of urban life and development can help cities become better and more sustainable places to live. This can inform smarter public investments, according to diverse environmental and cultural urban conditions. TruLife learns from scenarios of past human developmental processes for the long-term benefit of human inhabitation.

Understanding the functioning of past urban designs and spatial practice can help mitigate the rural-urban migration crises in the developing world. Utilising rural migrants' own practical expertise, knowledge of past indigenous Neotropical food security and waste management may teach current populations workable models. Network members have worked on cities in the developing world, making it feasible to advance TruLife's outcomes for various place-specific, bio-cultural adaptations.

Impact Timeframe
TruLife's direct impact follows the three research workshops, supported by the publication strategy and social media promotion. The competition brief has its greatest impact at the end of year two. Beyond the network, the exhibition and online resources continue mid- and long-term impact. Third parties (internationally) will be encouraged to put on the exhibition after its initial SCVA run. This would enlarge the audience and create further awareness of the heritage and sustainable urban messages.
 
Title Dust to Dust: Redesigning urban life in healthy soils 
Description Dust to Dust is a research-led urban design challenge to take inspiration from basic principles of urban life as practiced by the ancient Maya to inform proposals for sustainable urban futures. Maya archaeology highlights that there is an enhanced relationship between soil management and urban life. The exhibited development schemes aim to give this relationship centre stage in contemporary urban settings to improve the long-term sustainability of cities worldwide. Out of sight, out of mind The benefits of healthy soils extend far beyond a ground surface to live and build on. Life on Earth relies on effectively functioning and biodiverse soils, which provide the food, feed, fibre, and fuel that sustain plants, animals, and humans. With most urban soils having been built and paved over, they are often out of sight and out mind. Today, the sustainability of city life depends on agricultural land and production outside the city. However, as populations rise and cities become larger, there is an urgent need for urban spaces to forge close-knit relationships between urban inhabitants and soil health. In their sight, on their minds Examples of past indigenous tropical urban design teach us about alternatives to present-day city life. The Maya in the lowlands of Mexico and Central America built vast cities for over two millennia, which looked radically different from cities today. Open and green spaces dominated the sprawling landscape and housing was associated with large shared plots of cultivated land. Paved areas were concentrated to raise buildings, frame monumental architecture, and channel water runoff from public spaces, while unpaved land remained accessible to everyone for growing and manufacturing. Therefore there was a special relationship with soil management in everyday Maya urban life. In our sight, on our minds: Dust to Dust set a challenge Teams of designers, urban planners, engineers, and environmental scientists from around the world were invited to submit proposals, inspired by Maya urbanism, to stimulate an enhanced relationship between inhabitants and the ground they live on. From this, six shortlisted teams took part in an intensive research and design workshop at The Prince's Foundation in London. This exhibition presents a number of progressive visions to place healthy and productive soils at the core of sustainable urban life. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact Media exposure 1 BBC Radio Norfolk interview 2 Press release 3 Interest form local school and group of sixth formers 4 Over 11,000 visitors exposed to the exhibition (visitors are people accessing the buildign with and without tickets, not the particular section of the building) 
URL http://www.dusttodustcompetition.org/
 
Description As per instructions, these are included in the associated entries with this award.
Exploitation Route Findings are feeding into Fellowship and job applications by applicants and others, further collaborations, grant and project applications, and continued joint authored publication planning and writing.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Education,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other

 
Description As per instructions, these impacts are described in other parts of the researchfish entries associated with this award.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Input for the Belgian Economic Mission to Mexico 2019 (from Dust to Dust exhibition
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
Impact The input will have been used via Prof. Philippe de Maeyer to influence decision-making on research and education regarding indigenous population, national heritage, environmental and urban planning.
URL https://www.belgianeconomicmission.be/programme
 
Description Proposal submitted by Dust to Dust participating team to Amsterdam Municipality
Geographic Reach Europe 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact A solution was proposed for a tender of the city government. It has therefore influenced decision-making, but it is not yet known if it was selected to have further impact.
 
Description Mistra environmental humanities Seed Box program
Amount 357,300 kr (SEK)
Organisation Swedish Foundation for Strategic Environmental Research 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Sweden
Start 01/2018 
End 12/2018
 
Description The Prince's Foundation 
Organisation The Princes Foundation
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We engaged a member of staff as a network member who contributed to our urban design ideas competition. The Foundation subsequently hosted the charrette as a direct outcome of the competition
Collaborator Contribution Hosting the international multiple day charrette of the urban design ideas competition (July 2018).
Impact Multiple day international charrette, involving six teams from various countries, with cross-sectoral roots, including NGOs, city government, research, architecture and planning firms, and civil engineering consultancy. Disciplines included: Archaeology Architecture Anthropology Urban Studies Urban Planning Urban Design Civil Engineering Waste Management Geography Ecology Environmental Sciences History etc. What was produced during the charrette formed the basis for a public exhibition and has influenced the practice of the participants.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Dust to Dust exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interview by BBC Radio Norfolk on exhibition launch, increasing interest and knowledge about the exhibition beyond visitors. Over 11,000 people visited the venue where the exhibition was held over its duration.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018