Performing Landscapes: Mountains

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: Sch of Performance & Cultural Industries

Abstract

For thousands of years mountains have been intrinsically connected to modes of artistic and aesthetic performance. From ancient Greek transformation rituals in Arcadia, through designated ceremonies in the Himalayas, to sacrificial rites in the Andes, the topography, visual impact and remoteness of mountains have encouraged complex performance-based behaviours to develop. Since the first documented reflection of Petrarch in 1336 (1898: 307-20), mountain climbers have translated their experiences into prose and poetry, seeking meaning in the surrounding topography and within themselves. This mountain 'prehistory' (Frison-Rouche and Jouty 1996: 17) was superseded by a flourishing of mountain activity and its accompanying literature once the Alps were opened up after the first ascent of Mont Blanc in 1786. Creative responses to mountains have covered several art forms with fine art, literature, poetry, music and film figuring strongly in the movement of C19th and C20th mountain aesthetics and criticism. Notably absent, though, is a body of literature examining the theatricality of mountains - a curious paradox given the ancient connection points between mountains, ritual and theatre and the extent to which mountains have inspired writers and artists to produce performances both within traditional theatre spaces and much more recently in mountain environments themselves: NVA (The Storr, 2005); Simon Piasecki (The Nightflight project, 2006); Louise Ann Wilson (Fissure, 2011, Y Helfa, 2014, Warnscale, 2015); Sprinkle and Stephens (Goodbye Gauley Mountain, 2014) Maria Fusco (Master Rock, 2015).

Through the production of a monograph, the creation of a new piece of mountain performance (working with a Post Doctoral Research Fellow), several public events and the inauguration of a new interdisciplinary network via a symposium, this fellowship seeks to address this lacuna in mountain studies, delivering the first comprehensive critique of how mountains are exploited as sites for performance, are represented in dramatic literature, and how they themselves 'perform'.

Mountains are one of the most visible victims in the exploitation of the planet, both in terms of hard industry (the practice of Mountain Top Removal, for instance) and softer eco-tourism (the impact of tourist climbing on Everest and other 'signature' peaks). They continue to attract enormous interest from the media and many climbers enjoy celebrity status, equal to that of their acting counterparts in mountain films. This visibility, fuelled by social media, is a blessing and a curse for mountain environments; on the one hand it raises awareness of the uniqueness of mountainscapes and the need to preserve them and on the other it builds expectations of participants' direct experience of those landscapes, encouraging long-haul travel and increasing footfall in delicately balanced environments. Focusing on behaviour, space, psychology and technology, the project seeks to raise significant awareness of the challenges to mountain environments, both for arts-based audiences and outdoor enthusiasts, collaborating with the project partner Kendal Mountain Festival and disseminating research findings using the mountain festival network (Fort William, Llanberis and internationally in Banff and Jasper, Canada).

In sum, this fellowship will carry out and disseminate research that develops a new understanding of the relationship of theatre and performance to mountain culture and mountaineering. It will harness performance-based histories and embodied knowledges to expand our understanding of how specific communities interact with, value, and mediate mountains, asking fundamental questions of our changing relationship to high places.

Planned Impact

This fellowship project will increase the undertstanding, effectiveness and impact of mountain-related culture, specifically in theatre and performance, by demonstrating a range of models for sensitive engagement with the outdoors. It is intended for the project to have cultural impact and social impact but there may also be a level of economic impact for the first area identified - festival organisers.

Impact can be summarised in the following areas:

1. Mountain festival organisers, regionally and internationally
2. Site-specific arts practitioners
3. Outdoors enthusiasts (for instance members of mountaineering clubs)

1. The project partner, Kendal Mountain Festival approached the PI before this fellowship proposal was conceived, asking whether he was interested to develop a new piece, in parallel with his authorship of the monograph, Performing Mountains, to build the cultural offer of the festival. This was in recognition of the growth in numbers and in popularity of the festival and with a desire properly to reflect the range of media engaged in mountain culture. Current theatre work has been modest at KMF - in 2015 a one man show, based on George Mallory - but the ambitions of the festival organisers are in line with the growth of the festival over the last fifteen years and reflect a new set of international partners now branded as KMF subsets (in China and in South America). The fellowship's immersive installation, based on the Indian Face first ascent, will offer a potentially mobile model of innovative mountain performance, designed (with appropriate sponsorship from the private sector) to be taken to KMF partners abroad who are actively commissioning content for the next three years of festivals, 2016-19. Thus the fellowship will help introduce contemporary performance strategies into the mountain festival circuit both regionally and internationally, impacting on the programming of KMF and networking the PDRF (who will have practice-led expertise and landscape performance experience) with key figures shaping the cultural offer of the North.

2. As the case for support outlines there is a diversity of performance companies working in challenging mountain landscapes currently and in recent history. This fellowship will impact on this community in three ways. Firstly by inviting selected practitioners to share a platform with established mountaineers, in the seminar series titled MountainAct. 6 public seminars will be held over the period of the fellowship and contributors will be invited to consider points of connection based on themes identified in the monograph (dark play, display, training). By bringing these two communities together, it is intended to elevate the critical languages of theatre and performance studies and to change opinions regarding their efficacy within the mountaineering community. Secondly by surveying the range of work in this field and offering the first comprehensive listing of contemporary mountain performance, work created by this community will be placed in context and by extension appropriately valued. Thirdly by contributing to the Research and Development of the Indian Face piece, contemporary practitioners (such as Angus Farquhar, Louise Wilson, Dan Shipsides and Maria Fusco) will be invited to consider their own work in a new critical context.

3. The monograph is pitched both at the academic community and the discerning enthusiast reader and the publisher has guaranteed an early move to paperback to secure the latter audience is not 'priced out'. More instrumentally there are 10 public events planned to access this wider audience and a designated mini-tour of mountain festivals to engage mountaineering clubs specifically (in England, Wales, Scotland and Canada). The Yorkshire Mountaineer club celebrates its 75th anniversary during the fellowship: this group will be approached to offer commentary and consultancy during the making of the PlR piece.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Pitches J (2020) High Culture Presentations of the self in mountain environments in Performance Research

publication icon
Pitches J (2019) Introduction: On Mountains in Performance Research

publication icon
Pitches J (2017) Training and the wild(erness) in Theatre, Dance and Performance Training

publication icon
Pitches Jonathan (2020) Performing Mountains

 
Title Black Rock 
Description BLACK ROCK is a practice-led research project run by Dr David Shearing. The central research question for the piece is: how can the experience of mountaineering be translated to an audience on the ground? BLACK ROCK is a digital performance that explores the extraordinary desire of humans to move through mountains, to scale vertical walls and to seek new physical heights. The project climbs from two of Johnny Dawes' first ascents in Snowdonia, to wider concepts of risk, vertigo, adventure, partnership and the physical boundaries between body and rock. BLACK ROCK traces the meanings of mountains, a narrative, collaged and momentary. These spaces are both a home and a void, a cradle for inspiration, and a corridor to death. They are blurred by mist but sharp in our fingers. Directed and designed by multi award-winning artist David Shearing, this unique multimedia environment presents a newly commissioned sound score by artist and composer James Bulley with choreography by Carlos Pons Guerra, poetic text by Claire Carter and digital technology by Invisible Flock. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact Played 12 times in three days to sell out audiences in Leeds. Take up as professional piece for Kendal Mountain Festival - in 2019. Film documentary of production taken to UK and Canada. Follow on Funding planned. 
URL https://performing-mountains.leeds.ac.uk/black-rock/
 
Description In October 2016, I began work on the Performing Mountains project. Supported by £250,000 funding from the AHRC and £15,000 from the Arts Council, the project set out to discover the meeting points between theatre, performance and mountains.

Over the period of my fellowship and to make sense of a huge hitherto unmapped area, I have constructed a new canon of mountain drama, developed a new model of mountain rituals (from the personal to the epic), and formulated a new micro-history of site-specific work - from Iran to Snowdonia.

I have also developed three extended case studies of specific mountains and mountain ranges, using the languages of performance to understand how people behave on them: mountains as sites for scenographic experiment, for training, and for play (these ideas all appear in a monograph, Performing Mountains, which has just been completed and is due to be published by Palgrave in 2019).

One of the most enduring insights of the project is the discovery that live performance offers a unique platform to translate mountain experiences, inciting the emotions and exciting the senses in much the same way as climbers and hikers experience on the mountainside.

In November 2017, a practice-led research performance, Black Rock, presented in collaboration with the legendary British climber Johnny Dawes, premiered at stage@leeds in the School of Performance and Cultural Industries. Created by a team of artists led by Post-doc David Shearing, we followed the live performance with screenings of a professional documentary at the Kendal Mountain Festival (our project partner), on the Isle of Arran, and at the largest mountain studies conference in the world, at Banff, in Canada in 2018.

As a multi-media and sensory performance, Black Rock is influencing the way in which mountain festival organisers and producers think about the value of live performance, encouraging some of the most influential players on the festival circuit to embrace the performing arts as a key part of their cultural offer in the future.

The project has also provided a hub for other artists working in (and on!) mountains and has brought them together with prominent mountaineers and climbers in a series of recorded public talks Mountainsides and at an international symposium, all hosted by PCI. Everest veterans Doug Scott and Stephen Venables as well as contemporary explorers such as Jo Bradshaw have rubbed shoulders with performers and artists including the performance company Lone Twin and the site-specific artist and designer, Louise Ann Wilson.

Unplanned but equally welcome is a new project, sparked by these meeting points led by photographer Rachel Ross and Occupational Therapist Marlisse Elliott, using film to give voice to climbers' sense of (sometimes fragile) identity. Marlisse joined the project for 9 months on a funded internship scheme, feeding in her OT expertise.

Dr Shearing and I are now working on a Special Issue of the Performance Research journal, On Mountains, with contributions from academics, mountain archivists, artists and performers and there are developed plans to follow on the research with a Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) dedicated to mountain arts.
Exploitation Route Now the book has been published, the intellectual framework relating to Mountain Culture and laid out in the Introduction is being picked up in conversations regarding a Leverhulme Research Centre Bid, with St Andrews, Lancaster, UCLAN and LEEDS.
Sectors Environment,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://ahrc-blog.com/2019/01/23/performing-mountains/
 
Description Research data gathered under the auspices of the project has been taken up by climber and writer, Mick Ward and used in an article for the UKC climbing website entitled 'Wall Warriors! A history of training for climbing'. This has been accessed more than 25,000 times (as of 7th March 2018): https://www.ukclimbing.com/articles/features/wall_warriors_a_history_of_training_for_climbing-3398 The International symposium, Performing Mountains, modelled an approach to mixing performance, poetry, climbing and mountaineering, and included a number of practice research examples which have influenced the Kendal Mountain Festival programming in 2018.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Formal Partner KMF 
Organisation Kendal Mountain Festival
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Contribution of new piece of practice-led research to be programmed at future Kendal Mountain Festival in 2017
Collaborator Contribution Brokerage with mountaineers, programming of practice-led piece at KMF 2017, producing and support in finding additional sponsorship
Impact 'Indian Face' practice-led performance Multidisciplinary collaboration across theatre & performance and mountain festival management and curation
Start Year 2014
 
Description Occupational Therapy Internship 
Organisation NHS England
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Mentoring an Occupational Therapist on a formal internship scheme run by Sheffield Hallam, to expose her to practice-led research and to mountain cultural activity, with a view to a new piece of research (on ageing/injury) and elite climbing to be produced by the intern.
Collaborator Contribution The mentor has viewed outcomes from the research and commented upon them from the perspective of access. She has contributed to the School research group associated with the project: Place and Performance
Impact Outcomes Pending
Start Year 2017
 
Description Book launch - Performing Mountains 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact 100 people attended an online book launch for the Performing Landscapes series. I presented on Performing Mountains
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Chaired Public Talk titled Mountainsides: Composition at Leeds 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The vertical axis of mountain environments has inspired artists, writers and dancers to create new and rich vocabularies of expression.

In what ways do mountain environments inspire compositional strategies? How can the technical and phenomenological experience of climbing be useful to creative practice and composition? How do the natural processes of rock formation and erosion of mountainous landscapes function as a means to consider compositional practice (in relation to time, space, materials of creative process/work)? What do line, layer, tension, feeling mean in the space between climbing and art practice? What does the practice of naming or authoring tell us about the artistry of climbing and about climbing inspired art? To what extent does the vertical offer alternative perspectives on dance and physical performance?
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://performing-mountains.leeds.ac.uk/mountainsides-talks/
 
Description Chaired Public Talk titled Mountainsides: Light at Leeds 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Since the use of beacons on hilltops to fast track the news of the Trojan war, the manipulation of light has been an essential element of mountain environments. But how has this relationship been exploited in recent years? What explains the fascination with night walking where beacons become night torches? And how has the technology of theatre crept into mountainsides to enhance their topography and to engage new audiences?
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://performing-mountains.leeds.ac.uk/mountainsides-talks/
 
Description Chaired Public Talk titled Mountainsides: Risk at Leeds 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This was the first in a series of chaired conversations between academics, climbers and artists. This event was focused on Risk and asked the general questions: What is it that drives people to take risks? How are risk and identity caught up in one another? What characterises the experience of risk beyond the physical? Can it be understood at a social, emotional, cultural or cognitive level? What meeting points are there between risk-taking in mountain environments and risk-taking in cultural contexts? And has extremity begun to define both fields?

The presenters were: Prof Victoria Robinson and Stephen Venables

More generally the Mountainsides series aims to engage wider audiences in the creative landscape of mountains and of mountaineering. It asks: what shared languages are there between climbing and performing and what gets in the way of a good conversation? How are terms such as, risk, composition, line, narrative, movement and training understood in the two domains? How far is it true to say that climbing is a form of performance and can learn from the languages of theatre and performance studies? And what are the key ideas in hiking and climbing that resonate with the live art of performance?

Each event is introduced by a concise 'micro-lecture' on the theme, followed by contributions from each speaker. The majority of the time is given over to animated conversation, robust debate and productive interjections from the floor.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://performing-mountains.leeds.ac.uk/mountainsides-talks/
 
Description Chaired Public Talk titled Mountainsides: Training at Leeds 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact How has physical training developed in the last fifty years? In what circumstances can walls be thought of as teaching machines? Is it possible to make the transition from indoors to outdoors in training? Or are they two different cultures? Are there contact points between training for physical performance - in forms such as yoga - and the preparation needed for advanced rock climbing? Or have these forms in fact already met, in the heightened mountain performances so popular on YouTube?
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://performing-mountains.leeds.ac.uk/mountainsides-talks/
 
Description How do Artists Touch the Void? A KMF Panel 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact In November 2018, Jonathan Pitches, Professor of Theatre and Performance, chaired a panel of leading contemporary theatre and arts practitioners at the award-winning Kendal Mountain Festival (KMF). The event followed a highly successful panel discussion at the 2017 KMF which saw Pitches lead a conversation between theatre-makers, artists and legendary British climber Johnny Dawes.

Described by one participant at the 2017 festival as 'a totally compelling discussionedgy, engaging and totally memorable', last year's panel was accompanied by the screening of a short film about the making of Black Rock, the digital performance element of Pitches' AHRC-funded research, Performing Mountains. This year's panel started from the idea that film and literature have always been wedded to the mountains but at the cost of the other arts. It asked: how have theatre makers, land artists and scenographers interpreted mountains for instance?

Prof Pitches discussed these issues with internationally renowned playwright, David Greig (Touching the Void and Pyrenees), artists Rob and Harriet Fraser (from somewhere-nowhere), and designer and theatre maker Dr Louise Ann Wilson (The Gathering/Yr Helfa).

Location details

The panel discussion will take place at the Abbot Hall Centre, Kendal.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://ahc.leeds.ac.uk/performance/events/event/1077/how-do-artists-touch-the-void-a-panel-discussi...