CMOP: Cleaning Modern Oil Paints

Lead Research Organisation: Courtauld Institute of Art
Department Name: Conservation & Technology

Abstract

Within the context of safeguarding tangible heritage for current and future generations, 20th- and 21st-century oil paintings are presenting a range of challenging problems that are distinctly different from those noted in paintings from previous centuries. Problems are often but not exclusively associated with unvarnished, unprotected surfaces. Phenomena increasingly observed include the formation of vulnerable surface 'skins' of medium on paint surfaces, efflorescence, unpredictable water and solvent sensitivity, and alarming incidences of dripping paints several years after the paintings have been completed. The current lack of understanding of the nature of change in modern manufactured oil paints means that the established empirical approach to conservation treatments such as surface cleaning are not applicable to a great number of works. In particular, commonly used systems that rely upon water as a major component cannot be applied to clean modern oil paintings. So far, few alternative methods of treatment have proven effective and as a consequence the presentation of modern oil paintings may be compromised. This project aims at making a significant impact on our understanding of the reasons behind these phenomena by exploring several aspects of paint formulations (oil fraction, pigment-medium interactions, additives) and case study works of art. This will in turn facilitate the modification and development of surface cleaning systems that are more appropriate for use on the increasing numbers of unvarnished oil paintings in international and private collections. New cleaning systems will be trialed on works of art in several internationally significant public collections. This information will be disseminated via web platforms, seminars, conferences and a documentary for the general public and the cleaning systems will be introduced through continuous professional development workshops for practicing conservators, thereby offering practical solutions to conservators facing these difficult challenges.

Planned Impact

20th and 21st C painting collections are now of global importance, exemplified by the increasing international demand for exhibitions in museums and galleries. Modern and contemporary art represents recent history and reflects the politics and societal developments of nations and the contribution of museums and galleries to global economies is significant and remains reliant on access to works for display. Thus the conservation and preservation of art is essential to maintaining this public benefit, and the outcome of the new knowledge generated by this project will have a direct impact on public access.
While the outcomes have long term benefits to the public and private stakeholders by provision of access to modern art, the contribution of ideas and knowledge can be delivered to a wide range of audiences in a number of ways such as dissemination by publication and lectures in a range of media (print, web-based including Youtube films, public lectures, etc). In addition, the progress of research would form an integral part of education in conservation and conservation science (see Academic Beneficiaries). Through the same process novel high value tools developed as an outcome of the research will be implemented in the education of conservators, curators, and key stake holders in the public and private sectors. These concepts, research outcomes and practical solutions will be directly shared through seminars to ensure that more balanced conservation approaches can be achieved as quickly as possible. Scientific and conservation publications will be published and transferred via internet platforms including Tate Online and the GCI Modern Paints site (see Academic Beneficiaries). An international professional seminar/conference will be held at the end of the 3-year project where main findings and implications for conservation treatment and methodologies will be presented and discussed. Research content and tools will also be incorporated into professional development workshops for conservators and heritage scientists.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have investigated a number of oil paintings and paint samples related to British paint manufacturers and identified trends in the chemical condition of paints that are water sensitive. We have prepared a significant publication that follows an invited conference contribution on these findings and two further abstracts will be submitted to the forthcoming ICOM-CC congress in Copenhagen, deadline April 15th 2016.
A book has been published that comprises the results of the whole project:
Conservation of Modern Oil Paintings, van den Berg, K.J., Bonaduce, I., Burnstock, A., Ormsby, B., Scharff, M., Carlyle, L., Heydenreich, G., Keune, K. (Eds.), Springer (2019) ISBN 978-3-030-19254-9
Exploitation Route The findings have already had direct impact on studio conservation practice and further research in easel painting conservation.
Sectors Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.tate.org.uk/about-us/projects/cleaning-modern-oil-paints-0
 
Description The outcomes directly affect practical conservation practice - it is arguable whether that is non-academic, however I am entering the data.
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Characterising water sensitivity in modern oil paintings 
Organisation Tate
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Graduate student research project 2016 - Lucia Bay. Supervision, active research data contribution, provision of resources for research, training of graduate students.
Collaborator Contribution Intellectual input, provision of resources, training.
Impact Submission of a paper for the preprints for ICOM-CC Copenhagen 2017 - in peer review stage. Bay L, Burnstock A, Lee J, Ormsby B, van den Berg KJ, Water sensitivity of modern oil paintings
Start Year 2015
 
Description Cleaning unvarnished modern oil paints 
Organisation Tate
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Graduate research project by Jae Youn Chung 2016 in collaboration with Tate and RCE Amsterdam. Intellectual input, training of students,
Collaborator Contribution Practical research involving production and ageing of paint samples for testing using a range of microemulsions for surface cleaning - Tate provided co supervision (Bronwyn Ormsby), space and analytical resources. RCE Amsterdam collaboration (Klaas Jan van den Berg) for analytical and library resources.
Impact Co-authored paper submitted to forthcoming congress ICOM-CC Copenhagen 2017 now in peer review stage. An Investigation of Methods for Cleaning Water-sensitive Oil Paint Based on Methods developed for Surface Cleaning Acrylic Paintings Jae Youn Chung, Bronwyn Ormsby,*Aviva Burnstock and Klaas Jan van den Berg Courtauld Institute of Art, Tate, Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands (RCE)
Start Year 2015
 
Description Water sensitivity of modern oil paintings Judith Lee et al Lucia Bay, Bronwyn Ormsby, Klaas Jan van den Berg, Aviva Burnstock 
Organisation Tate
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Doctoral student research co supervision - intellectual input and resources
Collaborator Contribution Doctoral student research co supervision - intellectual input and resources
Impact Submitted to preprints for ICOM-CC Copenhagen 2017 - in peer review stage Water sensitivity of Modern oil Paints; Judith Lee, Lucia Bay, Bronwyn Ormsby, Klaas Jan van den Berg, Aviva Burnstock
Start Year 2014