Social Choreography Network

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: Sch of Performance & Cultural Industries

Abstract

What does social choreography mean today, and to what extent can this field provide new frameworks to help address the issue of cultural stereotyping of refugees?

Violent military conflict, environmental crises, breakdown of social, racial or ethnic integration, are some of the many reasons why millions of peoples are being displaced across the world. Immigration is regarded today as arguably one of the most pressing political issues by voters and the wider public, and not only in a post-Brexit UK. Whilst the problem of forced migration is typically addressed from within the social sciences (e.g. migration and diaspora studies, sociology, political science, or development studies), little is known about the way in which the movement arts and bodily perspectives are responding to such crises.

The gap in knowledge that the network is aiming to address concerns a lack of understanding of embodied socio-choreographic practice at a regional and cross-national level. There is no existing platform that has developed a framework devoted to movement as the chosen medium, nor a project that has mapped movement-based practices, models or methods dealing with refugee crises. There is a gap in the ethical understanding, which is why we need to ask ourselves what constitutes "good practice" across different regional and national contexts in social choreography, especially in relation to pressing issues such as forced migration.

This network also seeks to build upon a current interest in expanded choreography. In recent years the term "choreography" has been used in an ever-widening sense, becoming synonymous with specific structures and strategies disconnected from aesthetic bodily expression, style and technique. The function of choreography as an expanded trope has shifted from a set of protocols or tools used primarily in dance (or applied dance), to an open cluster of knowledge production concerned with the organization of bodily movement in social, political and even economic contexts. Our network is clear about its focus on non-stage practices. We have decided not to focus on the treatment of migration within aesthetic choreography (e.g. Akram Khan, Sidi Larbi Cherkaoui, etc.) but to foreground work that is being carried out more directly with local communities and through motor activity that is not typified by technique or style. Named participants have been chosen on the basis of their specialist knowledge across different areas and the capacity to deliver workshops, forums, public engagement, mediation, relief work and therapy. What kind of ethos and theoretical discourse is emerging from such practices, and what kind of synergies can be leveraged across projects in different geopolitical contexts?

An area of intense study in dance history (Hewitt 2005, McNeill 2007, Jackson 2008), social choreography offers a theoretical link between everyday movement and the choreographic arts that can inform a number of other disciplines. According to Hewitt, social choreography redefines ideology's mode of operation, linking "aesthetic" and "performative" perspectives with more abstract socio-political understandings of social movement and action. Histories of the discipline and biopower are currently problematized by movements of people and goods in disorganised and undisciplined flows. The historical approach to social choreography needs to be revisited in order to take into account present-day issues such as the impact of digital technology, the closing of national borders, the restriction of free mobility, and crucially, the stereotyping of "refugees" or "asylum seekers", both negative cultural tags that seem to efface the individual person behind the label.

By bringing together experienced practitioners working on the ground, and by linking communities affected by forced displacement, we will help lead social choreography to a second phase of development as an interdisciplinary and international field of study.

Planned Impact

Beneficiaries of this project include the wider public, creative industry network members, and Refugee Community Organisations (RCOs). Project participants have been identified in each beneficiary group to maximise impact. All participants are heavily invested in community work involving integration of displaced groups through movement and embodied practices. Key beneficiaries include:

1. Colegio del Cuervo, Cartagena (Colombia). CdC is a creative hub and dance school led by Alvaro Restrepo (network member). The organisation works with displaced children in the community of Portezuela. They will benefit from internationalisation of their school, specialist knowledge exchange, and a visit from UK experts (Co-I and PI).

2. Arkadi Zaides Dance is an Israeli based independent project led by Zaides (network member). The role of this project is to reach out and bring together different communities and different sectors of society, focusing primarily on the Arab sector in Israel. Zaides will benefit from contact with likeminded practitioners, knowledge exchange, and use of new technologies within his work through work with PI, Co-I and named participant Cherene.

3. Led by network member Taigue Ahmed, Ndamsena is a Chad based dance training company that supports cultural dialogue between different ethnic groups, enhancing social cohesion in Chadian society. They will benefit from opening their work to English-speaking audiences, by engaging with new communities and stakeholders in the UK, and by knowledge exchange.

4. BeAnotherLab will also benefit from this project. This international lab co-led by Christian Cherene (network member) involves the use of Virtual Reality technology, and its implementation in the creation of empathy within the broader public. Through a customised Virtual Reality and mirror interface, BeAnotherLab are dedicated to placing members of the public inside the bodies of individuals labelled as minority groups (e.g. migrants). They will benefit from application of their technology to a general embodied ethical framework and discussion of their work in Leeds symposium, as well as published article.

Two local Refugee Community Organisations (RCOs) have been approached and will engage in key activities planned as part of this AHRC network. Refugees and asylum seekers associated with the Coventry Refugee and Migrant Centre (Sabir Zazai) and Leeds Refugee Forum (Ali Mahgoub) will be invited to key events, and will take part in workshops that will ensure local community impact.

The project will engage beneficiaries through public engagement activities in Leeds, London and Coventry. Regular team meetings, scholarly publication, and dissemination of impact case studies via project website will further enhance impact (see CfS for details). PI Salazar Sutil will lead these activities with close support from UoL support structures: i.e. from Faculty Research Office, PCI management, and through close mentorship from Co-I Whatley, who has plenty of experience delivering AHRC funded projects. Salazar Sutil and Whatley have previously collaborated on an AHRC-funded Network.

Finally, the project will continue an existing collaboration between PI and the Theatre of Sanctuary project at West Yorkshire Playhouse (network activities were carried out there in October 2016), and with key network partner Platforma (Tom Green) a leading arts and refugee network in the UK. Impact will be generated by taking part in Refugee Week 2017, organised by Green in collaboration with Southbank Centre, Rich Mix and British Museum.

All these network collaborators will be encouraged to share their definition of the problem statement (what is social choreography today?), by participating in brainstorming for potential solutions, and assisting in the evaluation of the network. An ethical guideline drafted by the network participants will be shared globally (online), providing an important resource, we hope, for future work.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Nicolas Salazar Sutil (2018) Coventry Welcomes 2018: Event Report

publication icon
Nicolas Salazar Sutil (2019) Get the camps to dance: "refugees" and life ethics from a Central African perspective in Journal of Dance and Somatic Practices

publication icon
Salazar Sutil, N (2018) Dance for Life

publication icon
Sarah Whatley (2018) Conflict's Choreographics

 
Title BeAnother Lab workshop 
Description As part of the Dance for a Life event held in N'Djamena, Chad, we organised a Virtual Reality Lab organised by project partners BeAnotherLab. The event involved use of the BeAnotherMachine, a Virtual Reality set-up that enables users to exchange bodies with other users in real-time. We conducted the workshop at the Institut Francais in N'Djamena (Chad), with members of the refugee community of Maro camp and members of the public. The workshops, held in May 25, 26 and 27 2018, were attended by over 300 people. the workshops were led by Norma Deseke and Daanish Masood (BeAnotherLab) and Sara Houston. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact The VR body-swap workshops were instrumental in engaging young people in our work, and also opening an intimate and embodied space for engagement and trust building between members of the invited refugee community (Maro camp, UNHCR) and the general public. 
URL http://resistanceforce.org/2018/05/23/beanotherlab-in-chad-danser-pour-la-vie/
 
Title Dance workshop (Pas en Avant) 
Description Choreographer and dancer Taigue Ahmed delivered two dance workshops, one in Coventry (Centre for Dance Research) for members of the Coventry Refugee and Migrant Centre, and one at the Institut Francais, N'Djamena (Chad), involving members of the Ballet de Refugies de Maro. Each dance workshops was attended by around 30 participants, and it included network members Sara Houston, Jonathan Skinner, Sarah Whatley, Nicolas Salazar Sutil (Coventry workshop) and Sara Houston and Nicolas Salazar Sutil (N'Djamena workshops). 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact The effect of dance practice in building trust between people, whether or not they are refugees, is immediate. Ahmed's workshops provided instrumental in building trust between the researchers and Central African refugees involved as part of the Danser Pour la Vie festival that this AHRC fund made possible. The impact is societal, as dance improves social relations and sensitises people to each other, fostering a more caring way of relating to others, and fomenting joy in situations of conflict. 
URL https://www.facebook.com/ifTchad/videos/1343991269067234
 
Title The Crossing: a psychogeography 
Description This psychogeography (or performance walk) involved creating a subjective map and walking performing in and around Roehampton University. The walk was inspired by Gerard Manley Hopkins' poem The Wreck of the Deutschland, which was written in honour of five Franciscan nuns who died in a shipwreck whilst crossing the English Channel, in an attempt to flee religious persecution in Germany, in 1875. Participants walked from the Gerard Manley Hopkins plaque located at the entrance of Whitelands College, all the way up to Froebel College, via the Alton Estate. With up to 13,000 residents, Alton Estate is one of the largest Council Estates in the UK. It is considered a landmark of modernist architecture and urban planning in London. The walk strung together the scant graffiti found on the walls and bins of the Alton Estate, and the memorial death site of a local mother who was run over by a lorry whilst crossing Danebury Avenue in 2013. The graffitied messages were put together to form a text that echoes the Manley Hopkins poem. A series of concrete poetic statements were added to form a palimpsest, each layer focusing on one sensation felt by the participant whilst performing the walk. The performance was devised by Tom Tlalim, Nicolas Salazar Sutil, and it was performed by Sara Houston, Sarah Whatley, JJ Deveraux, Christian Cherene, Jonathan Skinner, Michaelina Jakala and Sandra Noeth. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact Networking, team building, and engagement with social issues in and around the University of Roehampton. 
URL https://www.socialchoreography.co.uk/events
 
Description The focus of the grant was to explore ethical practice in the context of refugee community engagement through dance. Our question was: what constitutes good practice when artists work with refugee communities? Over the course of this project, we identified several practices that we considered to be ethical, based on criteria for good practice outlined in consultation with a number of key partners, including Platforma Arts + Refugees (the largest network for refugee arts in the UK), Centre for Peace, Trust and Social Relations (Coventry University), Centre for Dance Research (Coventry University), Coventry Refugee and Migrant Centre (Coventry), Dance Department (University of Roehampton), BeAnotherLab (VR technology for conflict resolution), and the Migration Leadership Team (SOAS). The work of Taigue Ahmed, artistic director of Association Ndam Se Na, was identified as being exemplary in the delivery of dance based pedagogy in conflict, based on a number of ethical premises. We followed ethical guidelines as highlighted in the RISE document for artistic work in refugee communities, which we identified as an excellent guide for ethical practice in the field of refugee arts.

http://riserefugee.org/10-things-you-need-to-consider-if-you-are-an-artist-not-of-the-refugee-and-asylum-seeker-community-looking-to-work-with-our-community/

In addition to identifying a key document outlining how good practice works, we were able to support engagement and outreach events curated by Ahmed, which showcased good practice in refugee arts across Central Africa. The event in question was called Dance For a Life, which was held in N'Djamena (Chad) thanks to support from the AHRC. The event included contributions from the Ballet of Refugees of Maro, a group of refugee artists from Central African Republic, as well as scholars from the UK, France and Germany.

In sum, our key finding is that good practice in refugee arts projects must always be determined by the communities themselves, not the artists. The importance of artistic work with refugees is process, not result, and the aim of work must be longitudinal, to ensure sustainability of practice long-term.

The findings and events obtained as a result of this fund can also be accessed via the following online sites:

Embassy of France (Chad): https://td.ambafrance.org/Culture-et-integration-des-refugies-d-Afrique-et-d-ailleurs

Institut Francais (Chad): https://www.facebook.com/ifTchad/videos/1343991269067234/

Association Ndamsena (Chad): http://www.ndamsena.org/

Platforma (UK): http://www.platforma.org.uk/dance-for-life/

Coventry Refugee and Migrant Centre (UK): https://coventry2021.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/CRMC-Report-of-Coventry-Welcomes.pdf

CNN (US) https://edition.cnn.com/videos/international/2012/05/18/a-african-voices-ahmed.cnn
Exploitation Route Our insights will be published in an article entitled Get the Camps to Dance, to be published by the Journal of Dance and Somatic Practices, where we hope our findings can be taken up for future work by colleagues and stakeholders. In addition to this academic form of knowledge dissemination, we hope that the web outputs listed above (and our project website) will serve as a useful resource for researchers interested in conducting artistic practice with refugee communities.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.socialchoreography.co.uk
 
Description Our findings have been used by UNCHR (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees) in Chad, for development of a training programme for social artists in the refugee camp of Dar es Salaam (Baga Sola), which is the main aim of the GCRF fund we obtained following on from this network grant. The GCRF fund that follows from this network started in January 2019 and it will provide training for five social artists from across Sub-Saharan Africa (Senegal, Burkina Faso, Mali, CAR and Madagascar) for training in the UNHCRrefugee camp of Dar es Salaam in Baga Sola (Chad). We are working closely with UNHCR officers Yanik Yankeu and Priscilla Gomes.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Other
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Coventry Welcomes Advisory Board
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Membership of a guideline committee
Impact The writing of an evaluation report for the event Coventry Welcomes 2018, led to the inclusion of PI Salazar Sutil and Co-I Whatley in the advisory board of the Coventry Refugee and Migrant Centre 2019. Coventry Welcomes is a yearly event for the promotion of refugee culture in Coventry, organised by CRMC. In 2018, with support from this AHRC fund, PI Salazar Sutil conducted an evaluation report based on fieldwork carried out at the Coventry Welcomes 2018 event, held at Primrose Hill Park, Coventry. The full report provided an evaluation of the suitability of the location, the impact that cultural activity (music and dance especially) had on the audience participation and perception. The report was based on 50 interviews conducted by the PI, field-notes and 30 questionnaires.
URL https://coventry2021.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/CRMC-Report-of-Coventry-Welcomes.pdf
 
Description AHRC-GCRF Highlight Notice 'Education in Conflict'
Amount £55,709 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/S004068/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2019 
End 08/2020
 
Description Drying Prayers
Amount € 13,000 (EUR)
Organisation German National Theatre and Weimar State Orchestra 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Germany
Start 09/2019 
End 09/2020
 
Description Association Ndamsena 
Organisation Association Ndam Se NA
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Internationalisation, capacity building, asset development.
Collaborator Contribution Accommodation space, transfers (car), food and water, internet access.
Impact Train the trainee programme (Pas en Avant international) Train the trainee programme (Iyal Hille de Bol) Performance of Assalam Community engagement in 3 refugee camps in Chad Workshops in Coventry University and University of Roehampton Drying Prayers documentary dance and touring production UNHCR policy report UNESCO Art Lab directorate
Start Year 2019
 
Description Centre de Recherche en Anthropologie et Sciences Humaines 
Organisation Centre de Recherche en Anthropologie et Sciences Humaines
Country Chad 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Our contributions have advanced the internationalisation agenda of CRASH, and have enhanced their community based work in Lake Chad.
Collaborator Contribution CRASH have provided invaluable support in event organisation (Network meetings) and logistics for fieldwork, as well as support in risk management and ethical clearance protocols.
Impact Board meetings Collaborative fieldwork in Lake Chad Visit to Goudoumaria centre (Niger)
Start Year 2019
 
Description Institut Francais (Civil Society Organisation partner) 
Organisation French Institute in Chad
Country Chad 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We have facilitated workshops and provided links to operators, social artists and key stakeholders as part of public engagement events held at IFT (conference, performance and talks).
Collaborator Contribution IFT has supported our project by paying transport fees for participants involved in the performances and talks, and also by providing performance and rehearsal space, as well as meeting spaces, free of cost.
Impact Dance for a Life Festival 2018 Assalam performance
Start Year 2019
 
Description UNHCR Humanitarian partners 
Organisation United Nations (UN)
Department United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
Country Switzerland 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Our team has delivered several training programs, workshops and cultural activities.
Collaborator Contribution UNHCR has provided logistic support (travel intelligence) as well as risk management support and ethics clearance support. They have also facilitates spaces at the N'Djamena Headquarters, at their base in Baga Sola, and in various refugee camps where we have conducted work.
Impact Workshops in UNHCR camps of Dar es Salaam, Amboko and Gore.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Danser pour La Vie (Festive event) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Danser pour la Vie was a festive event involving a number of stakeholders and refugees in N'Djamena (Chad), held at the Institut Francais. the event featured Virtual Reality labs (with project partners BeAnotherLab); dance workshops (with Ballet de Refugies de Maro), academic seminars (with postgraduate students at the University of N'Djamena), social work events at Dakuna Espoir orphanage, and roundtable discussions with officers from UNHCR-Chad, and the European Union. The event also featured a stage performance entitled Waignedeh (created at the refugee camp of Belom), and presentation of the documentary film 'Sur Le Pas de Taigue' directed by Cyril Danina. The event is now conceived as a yearly or biannual event, whose aim is celebration of refugee art in Central Africa, and which hopes to establish a platform for the dissemination of the Pas en Avant system for informal education in refugee camps.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
URL https://www.facebook.com/ifTchad/videos/1343991269067234/
 
Description Drawing Dance: children workshop at Association Dakouna Espoir, N'Djamena Chad 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact During the Danser pour la Vie event, PI Salazar Sutil conducted an engagement workshop in Association Dakouna Espoir, an organisation that provides shelter and informal dance-based education to homeless children in N'Djamena (Chad).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://tchado-star.org/qui-sommes-nous
 
Description Network Meeting and workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact We conducted two group walks that involved local people, one around the Citizens Advice Bureau area and adjoining Estate complex in Roehampton, one in and around Marc Bolan's shrine also in Roehampton. We created a public space within Roehampton University (a wall) where we posted questions concerning our AHRC project, and where we engaged local student community on core themes and issues of the network.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://nicolassalaza5.wixsite.com/socialchoreography
 
Description Network meeting and workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Workshop with Taigue Ahmed (Ndamsena Arts, Chad) and refugees (members of Coventry Refugee and Migrant Centre)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016,2018
 
Description Social Choreography network website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact For the purpose of online dissemination of network grant findings, we created a project website
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.socialchoreography.co.uk/
 
Description What is Social Choreography 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact How is Social Choreography? Controlling the movement of the displaced



Coventry University London Campus

109-117 Middlesex St, London E1 7JF

https://www.coventry.ac.uk/london/



October 29th 2018, 10:00 -12:00 pm



This is the final event of the Social Choreography network (AHRC funded)





Social Choreography is a trope that stems from Louis Althusser's Marxist theory of ideology. For Althusser, ideology can be conceived as a spatial edifice or infrastructure determining social formations (1970, cf. 2006). Andrew Hewitt (2005) coined the term 'social choreography' drawing on Althusserian theory, in order to critically interrogate the inscription- on bodies- of state ideology. More specifically, Hewitt emphasized the role played by dance and everyday movement in the spatial dynamics of ideological formation, particularly in terms of how power relations can underpin the 'choreographic inscription' (Derrida and McDonald 1982). The trope was re-coined by Gabriele Klein (2012, 2013) to speak of everyday movement and popular dance as micro-politics of protest and political participation (see also Lepecki 2006; Kostanic 2013, Milhonic 2013, Cjevic 2014). More recently, the term has been recast so as to encompass not only aesthetic practices, but also, the infrastructural design of movement and mobility among stateless people. In the present context, Social Choreography refers to the formation of spaces of temporality, zones of transition, and encampment. Social Choreography articulates a spatial and kinaesthetic ontology, characterised by non-edificial and low-infrastructural conditions found in the political rifts between state and non-state formation. Generally speaking, refugee and reintegration camps function as buffer zones for strategic control and measurement of refugees and Internally Displaced Peoples (IDPs), perpetuating the dynamics of social formlessness and statelessness. The design of displacement is arguably defined by suspension of temporary, precarious, unstable, and makeshift conditions of living, as well as paternalistic politics of food and security provision that are not inherently conducive to self-reliance and autonomy. Encamped people typically live in a null-space that actualizes not only a physical debility, but also an ontological indetermination (a political and existential non-entity). What cultural and political strategies for self-determination can disrupt the social choreographic control of displacement, giving stability, dignity and resilience to the encamped?



Clara Lecadet (Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales, Paris)

"Beyond humanitarianism: the choreography of human (im)mobility as designed by UNHCR"



Nicolas Salazar Sutil (University of Leeds)

"Choreographing Refuge: (dance) steps for refugee resilience in Moula and Yaroungou camps (Chad)"



Henry Staples (University of Sheffield)

"Understanding political re-integration in post-conflict Colombia: socio-spatial perspectives"



Chaired by Professor Sarah Whatley (Coventry University)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019