Articulating Women: Interrogating Intersectionality and Empowering Women Through Critical Engagements

Lead Research Organisation: Liverpool Hope University
Department Name: School of Humanities

Abstract

Gender equality is of central importance to progress within an increasingly global world, but gender roles and attitudes to gender shaped centuries ago continue to influence cultural, social and economic behaviour, and to affect decision making at a local level. This is the case even where equal opportunity policies and rhetoric pertain at a national or corporate level. Too often, policy commitments to equal opportunities for women and rhetorical statements of the importance of women's contribution to society mask real-life behaviours that inhibit women's advancement; indirectly, if not directly reinforce women's subordinate position; and translate multicultural anxieties into conflicts over gender roles and behaviours.

This project offers a unique approach. It is not only multi-organisational, multinational, and multi-disciplinary, but also places theoretical concepts of gender, particularly that of intersectionality, in dialogue both with artistic expression and representation and with the experiences of professionals who make on-the-ground interventions (as teachers, volunteer trainers, academic leaders, those in charge of arts organisations). The interchanges between these strands enable theory to inform, but also to be tested against the expressive and experiential. In the process, public awareness of the complexities of gender issues, particularly within complex social and cultural, and sometimes multi-cultural, contexts can raise awareness about the expectations associated with women's place in the community while helping to refine current feminist theories of intersectionality. The project facilitates comparative discussions, exposing individual researchers to the possibilities implicit in alternative disciplinary and theoretical methodologies, different cultural frameworks, and diverse historical periods.

The intellectual frameworks developed as part of Second and Third Wave feminism for understanding the dynamics of women's subordination, together with critiques of subaltern status developed as part of postcolonial perspectives have provided women with a set of methodological tools for responding to consciously perpetuated gender discrimination. These movements have also provided the means of exposing both institutionalised sexism and the assumptions and unexamined preconceptions that unconsciously naturalise women's subordinate position, often generating hostility when women assume positions of power. Intersectionality has emerged as a promising paradigm for addressing the complexities of compounded social marginalisation, but it is a concept born within a particular socio-historical context. As a result, it needs to be interrogated, translated, and transformed if its potential utility is to be fully realised. Local factors such as caste, which the current framework struggles to fully articulate and analyse, pose a challenge to this and other universalised models and modes of feminist theorising. Understanding and acknowledging this challenge is an important precursor both to refining the concept and to supporting successful interventions-- be they local, national, or international in origin.

The project will strengthen and extend the collaborative activities of four partner institutions dedicated to harnessing research for social change. It will develop support networks among women within academia in both India and the UK, furthering the interests of gender equality within Higher Education and beyond. The project will produce material outputs including documentaries, piloted English Language Teaching resources and volunteer training materials, and the creative reflections of an artist in residence. A volume of selected essays on "Interrogating Intersectionality" is envisaged that would help to clarify the theoretical and methodological issues, possibilities and current limitations of the concept.

Planned Impact

Pronouncements and debates over gender identity and gendered expectations in the UK and India continue to pervade public discourse, popular culture, and political debates over policy. Forging a network where lived experience, professional practice, and creative representation are brought into dialogue with academic research and theorising enables mutual interrogation and paves the way for more nuanced and informed formulations, descriptions, representations, and professional practices. Public debates are enriched by well-designed, public facing dissemination events around the degree of gender equality that has been achieved and is achievable, particularly as gendered norms, expectations, and policies relate to the vexed issue of multiculturalism, inclusiveness, and respect for difference. By promoting an international dialogue through exchanges in both Liverpool and Bangaluru, small, targeted interventions enable multiple pathways to impact.

Increased awareness of the diversity of women's roles and status within and between different communities will help to break down simplistic assumptions and stereotypes around national, cultural and religious differences. Using women's stories to inform the development of a documentary highlighting diversity will further awareness. The documentary will serve as a starting point for discussions and analysis of the interplay between women's role and community needs and expectations within a range of different social contexts. Although focused on the experiences of Indian women, the issues raised have more general currency and will reinforce the need for sensitivity to gender issues informed by cultural awareness.

Issuing a challenge to students to produce three-minute documentaries on the subject of "women in community" will both increase public awareness and produce additional material displaying the diversity of experience. The best of the entries will be screened, introduced by their producers and followed by discussions, as part of dissemination events. Well-publicised public events will also highlight the role of women in the arts, heightening the visibility of women in this sector. Documentaries will be screened as part of public program in two important centres of culture-Bangaluru and Liverpool.

A visiting artist from Karnataka and collaboration with Milapfest will help to highlight the multiple components and complexities of women's position in the Arts. In Liverpool, public facing events will take place at Bluecoat Arts Centre and FACT, venues that facilitate public engagement. Christ University is itself readily accessible within Bangaluru and well-versed in hosting events for a non-academic audience.

English language teaching materials designed by MA students at Christ University to promote gender sensitivity through, among other things, the incorporation of gender neutral language, will develop and reinforce an awareness of gender issues among the MA students who develop the materials, the trainee teachers who make use of them, and the students who are taught with this material. Resources and materials for training volunteer workers in marginalised communities will promote an increased awareness of the need to consider gender in relation to the local social and cultural context when promoting gender equality.

Workshops and roundtable discussions around the issue of "Women and Leadership" are built into PGR Conferences and Dissemination Conferences as well as a Global Youth Congress to be held at Liverpool Hope. These will enable empowering strategic discussions, mentoring, and network building. Such events have long played an important role in helping women to achieve their potential. They build confidence, provide strategic advice, and encourage the building of mutual support networks and interest groups capable of pushing the agenda of gender equality and women's issues within the academic world and beyond.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Abhaya N (2021) Decolonizing the Home at Home in the Pandemic: Articulating Women's Experience in English: Journal of the English Association

 
Title Breaking the Screen 
Description Breaking the Screen is a video presentation exploring feminine frustrations with the computer interface using a collection of found clipart and stock images. The video is made in the style of corporate presentations that often talk about workplace ethics, sexual harassment and/or work-life balance and attempts to use those aesthetic and storytelling techniques to provoke a more complex consideration of gender politics in corporate spaces. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This video was created by one of three winners of a project sponsored competition on "Women and Intersectionality in India". The artist who created the video has since been awarded a prestigious grant. She used her work for the project in her application for the grant. The competition winner has received mentoring from an established artist, the Artist in Residence for the project. The final version of the video has only just been released, but it, together with the essay written by the video's creator has very considerable potential to be used in gender sensitisation training and teaching materials. It will also be useful in teaching materials that interrogate the relationship between gender and technology, between technology and corporate culture. The video also invites the interrogation of the nature of art and the power of irony, both in the classroom and beyond. 
URL https://empowering-women.net/watch-breaking-the-screen/
 
Title Documentary: Antanrangada Maatu 
Description This is a video produced by staff and students from Christ University in collaboration with the Centre for Social Action at Christ University. It illustrates issues of intersectionality as it recounts the struggles of three women who have fought to overcome different kinds of disadvantage: the daughter of a devadasi, a woman who married young and whose economic status disadvantaged both her and her extended family, and a woman farmer who, as a woman, is affected by both climate change and global economic developments but who is not recognised as a farmer and so is absent from statistics and is denied both government assistance and a voice in shaping policies. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact The making of the film provided staff and students with a development opportunity; the learning process over the course of the making of the film has meant that the film's production has been protracted. The completed film has been screened at FACT during a programme on Contemporary South Asian Films by Women. The event attracted about 30 registrants. One of the two directors of the film was present to field questions and comments and the film prompted a good discussion. The film was also screened in a special session at Notre Dame Catholic College in Liverpool where it was introduced by one of the two directors and became the focus of a workshop on gender, cultural difference, and intersectionality. The workshop was attended by a group of 20 selected sixth form students and their teachers; it was facilitated by the Head of Teacher Education at Liverpool Hope University and by an educational consultant from the Merseyside, Cheshire and Greater Manchester ITT Consortium. The film is being used within teaching packs currently under development on gender, culture, and intersectionality. 
URL https://empowering-women.net/watch-antanrangada-maatu/
 
Title Hosa Belaku 
Description "Hosa Belaku", by Nirmal Thomas, was the winning entry in a mini-documentary competition run by the Articulating Women network. It is a short, six and one half film about an organisation in India that helps women to develop skills and earn income to support their families through the construction of handicrafts using surplus and recycled materials. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact The film has raised awareness of the self-help organisations in India and has helped to publicise a view of Indian women as capable and resilient rather than as absolute victims. The film has been screened at the Earl's Court Film Festival and the Josiah Media Festival in San Antonio, Texas. 
URL https://empowering-women.net/watch-hosa-belaku/
 
Title Myriad Voices of Bhawaiya 
Description Myriad Voices of Bhawaiya is centered around three Bhawaiya artists from the Darjeeling district of Bengal: Arati Roy, Nirmala Roy, and Parboti Roy. The objective of the film has been to promote Bhawaiya artists, particularly women, and to celebrate their identity as Bhawaiya artists. The film seeks to secure them recognition by bringing them to the attention of a broader audience. By emphasizing the link between these artist's experience and the songs they perform, the film resists claims that would reduce women's oppression to the realm of fiction and locate Bhawaiya as an imaginative literature only. Finally, Myriad Voices of Bhawaiya seeks to understand Bhawaiya as an oral and folk genre of resistance against institutional inequality. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This video was created by one of three winners of a project sponsored competition on "Women and Intersectionality in India". The final version of the video was released recently, but it, together with the essay written by the video's creator has very considerable potential to be used in gender sensitisation training and teaching materials. It will also be useful in teaching materials that interrogate the relationship between gender and artistic recognition, and in relation to gender and cultural history. 
URL https://empowering-women.net/myriad-voices-of-bhawaiya-2021/
 
Title Sheroes 
Description Bluecoat Centre for Contemporary Arts and the Centre for Social Action (associated with Christ University, Bangalore) worked with artist and animator Laura Spark to make a short animated film of children's "Sheroes". The children were involved in programmes hosted by the Centre for Social Action and by Bluecoat's "Out of the Blue" programme. The animation workshop for families in Liverpool took place on 22 June 2019 at Bluecoat. The film has been uploaded onto the website and will be used to foster discussion as part of educational packs on gender currently under development. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact The collaboration has led to discussions about further collaborative activity with the Centre for Social Action in relation to developing educational material for schools. 
URL https://empowering-women.net/watch-sheroes/
 
Title Ubuntu: I am because you are 
Description This is a short anthology of poetry created by students as part of the "Storytelling, Identity, and Community". It has since been used in promotional material by the English Department at Liverpool Hope University and in teaching within the Social Work Department on Identity. 
Type Of Art Creative Writing 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact The group of eleven students from the UK, India, the Philippines and the USA who worked on shaping, writing, and producing the anthology had their horizons widened; working together changed their attitudes about identity and otherness. 
URL https://empowering-women.net/anthology/
 
Description 1) Process-- and awareness and sensitivity to process-- is in itself an outcome, particularly when it builds awareness of the complexities of the issues involved and when problem-solving builds stronger and wider involvement and networks.
2) Partnerships between academia, artists, curators and arts institutions produce a powerful dialectic through which it is possible to reach a wider audience while reflecting and reflecting on the complexities of gender issues, confronting viewers with the impact of intersectional dynamics more directly, and often more viscerally, than is the case with academic discussions. It is important to "show, not tell".
3) Bringing practitioners from different sectors, including those working in NGOs, into conferences and workshops prevents the discussion from becoming an academic echo chamber. Such involvement also invites further participation in the project and the consequent expansion of the network, extending its reach and impact. The fruits of such a strategy are unlikely to be seen within the duration of the short-term funding of a project, however.
4) There is a gender gap in the curriculum, not only in India where there is some awareness of the need for materials aimed at promoting gender equality, but also in the UK where this gap is, at present, not seen as an issue. Instead, in the UK, the focus is on differential performance of boys and girls.
5) The international collaborative production of teaching materials can produce useful dialogue and partnerships that promote better cross-cultural understanding, but the different curriculum structures and emphasises make it difficult to develop resources for use in both cultures without considerable local modifications. The process can be enhanced through international visits to schools by teachers and tutors that build greater understanding of the sensitivities to context. The resultant dialogues have multiple benefits in promoting better cross-cultural understanding among all those involved both at the personal level and at the level of the delivery of the curriculum in the classroom.
6) Student competitions are not a reliable way of securing resources for use in teaching and training materials, nor does the reward of expenses, access to technical resources, or the promise of mentoring produce much interest unless the competition is promoted by a recognised figure within the local community of artists.
7) When dealing with a complex international project, an advisory committee that meets regularly, with minutes taken and action items recorded, is needed. Beyond ensuring that objectives are met in a timely fashion, the advisory committee ensures that all parts of the project are aware of where their components fit into the whole picture; facilitates discussions that enable collaborative activities both within and beyond the remit of the project; and promotes creative problem-solving with input from multiple perspectives.
8) In an international network, travel for key individuals between countries should be prioritised in costings to ensure that the benefits ascribed to an advisory committee pertain across the project as a whole.
9) When the strategic thinking behind a project emphasises the importance of "grass-roots" initiatives, its achievements are likely to be invisible within the metrics of impact predicated on influence at a more formal, institutional level.
Exploitation Route 1) The teaching and training materials can be developed and refined with the help of the network of practitioners and academics who have become involved with the project over the past two years. It will be possible to integrate the films produced and currently being produced in these materials and handbooks. This is the perfect time to do so, with the public dialogue on gender issues becoming both more intense and more nuanced. Materials are sorely needed that give access to this debate in a way that is both structured and informed by a theoretical framework that facilitates recognition of complex dynamics. In the UK, there is a gap in the syllabus around these issues. In India, gender inequalities, complicated by class and religion within the context of the rise of Hindu nationalism, remain a pressing issue, both within the women's movement in India and within the development agenda.
2) The expansion of the network can extend the reach and potency of its impact in the area of Education. In India, the interest of the Director of the Centre for Social Action in becoming more involved in project initiatives around education and education policy with regard to gender equality presages a potential for increased impact of the project within those making policy decisions on education and development in Karnataka. Project conferences and workshops in Bangalore have brought a number of key figures from Delhi into the orbit of the project. A former director of the Centre for Women's Development Studies and a Senior Advisor for the Livelihoods Mission, UNDP India are two of those who could, potentially, extend the reach and influence of the project by becoming more involved.
3) The potential impact of expanding the involvement of artist, curators, and art institutions in India is also noteworthy. The Artist in Residence appointed as part of the project is helping to extend the network of artists and institutions connected to the project. The production of art and the curation of art can, as we have learned through the project, effectively foreground gender issues and have a deep impact on community awareness of gender inequalities.
4) There is the potential to create other kinds of resources, particularly app based resources. Involvement of an individual associated with UNDP in a Liverpool workshop has highlighted the potential of developing an app based on her experiences of developing the iWomen app in Myanmar. This has raised the possibility of a future initiative, should funding be secured, developing a pilot project for a similar app for women in self-help groups that will be usable for particular cohorts in India and the UK.
5) By screening films, both those produced in association with the project such as Hosa Belaku, Sheroes, and Antanrangada Maatu and rarely shown films such as those featured in our programme of Contemporary South Asian Films by Women (FACT, December 2019), we can showcase talent that does not receive enough recognition and bring issues of gender equality and the complexities of intersectionality to a wider audience. Project films are available for viewing on the project website and are attracting hits.
6) The skills developed during the making of the project documentary, Antanrangada Maatu, can be used and further developed in the making of future films. A documentary highlighting the lack of recognition accorded to farmer women in India is currently at an early stage of planning.
7) A proposal for a volume of essays that interrogates intersectionality from a global perspective is now being written. This volume of essays will take the approach of "showing, not telling" and will include essays from those involved in professions with a public face, particularly professional women in India. Such a volume can help to raise international awareness of the complexities of gender politics in India, helping to break down stereotypes and simplistic thinking about "development".
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://empowering-women.net/
 
Description Impact was built into this project from the very beginning through the involvement of arts organisations, the incorporation of competitions aimed at students and early career professionals, the sponsorship of public outreach activities, and the development of teaching and training materials. The website, constructed to facilitate communication and to enable access to the resources developed, has attracted over 110,000 visitors from 30 countries. The problem-solving behaviour of the Advisory Committee facilitated the timely production of outcomes and enabled the team to work together to spot and develop opportunities, to finesse planned initiatives and to develop new ones. In the process, we were able to enhance the effectiveness of our outreach activities and to plan for possible ways to extend and expand our project. One can see the problem-solving behaviour of the committee in our response to the problems that arose with the lack of interest in our mini-documentary competition. Despite wide circulation, the first competition attracted only one entry. We were fortunate that the single entry was of such high quality that we were able to award a prize. We re-ran the competition, changing the entry procedures and increasing the value of the prizes. We also extended our efforts to publicise the competition by enlisting the help of film festivals such as the Earl's Court Film Festival. For the second competition, we received two entries neither of which was of sufficient quality to award a prize. We then ran a screenwriting competition that provided expenses for up to two winners to make the film proposed. This did not yield the desired results either. Finally, with the help of the Artist in Residence from Bluecoat who had returned to Bangalore, but who had kept her involvement with the project, we ran a competition with her as coordinator. As an academic, curator, and practitioner, she used her contacts in the world of the Arts in Bangalore to publicise the competition. We received thirteen high quality submissions and selected three projects with expenses of up to £500 paid to each of the three. Opportunity spotting has been equally important. Useful opportunities emerged from the problem we encountered when we found that the materials produced in draft form as teaching and training aids for use by trainee teachers as part of their training in curriculum development at Christ University proved unusable as presented within a UK setting. In the process of working to solve this issue, a lecturer in Education at Liverpool Hope University worked with his students to adapt the materials into a form more readily usable at Secondary school level in Liverpool. Two of the students involved are now working as NQTs in deprived areas of Liverpool. They have continued their involvement with the project and have been involved in direct dialogues with colleagues and the Project Fellow in Bangalore. Materials have been piloted in both Bangalore and Liverpool. The teaching and training materials are still in the process of being developed and refined, with the lecturer, now a consultant, co-opted onto the Advisory Committee. Notre Dame Catholic College expressed an interest in working with us to develop partnerships between schools in Liverpool and Bangalore and to introduce the theme of gender equality into their teaching materials. This gap in the curriculum at a time when gender issues are so prominent has been spotted as a major issue. The films produced as part of the project are also being incorporated into teaching and training materials. Both informal conversations between Advisory Committee members and other teacher educators and more formal workshop sessions involving students at different levels have shown that the materials developed by the project have made a lasting impression and provided a new lens to view and think about the ITE curriculum in the UK. One Geography trainee discussed the project and resources at her NQT interview and got the job, partly because of her passion and commitment to look at aspects and to develop these through her teaching. It is interesting that such resources as "Antanrangada Maatu", the film produced by the project, resonates effectively with different audiences, prompting useful discussions about intersectionality and gender equality. This was demonstrated by piloting the film with both sixth formers and with Secondary PGCE trainees in English, Geography, and Religious Education. Both groups of participants were being presented with material that was unfamiliar to them. The younger students were being asked to consider the concept of intersectionality and to look at the material and discuss the content of the film in that context guided by the session leaders and the teachers present. The teacher trainees were being asked to consider their understanding of the concept of intersectionality and its implications in their own teaching. They were asked to look at their work through the lens of intersectionality, both in their own subject discipline and the work within the wider school communities in which they were working. The film was useful in promoting thoughtful discussion. The credibility of the narrative and the clarity of the presentation stimulated animated and productive discussions in both contexts. The usefulness of the materials, particularly the videos, produced in association with the project has been further demonstrated by the request to use "Sheroes", "Hosa Belaku", and "Antanrangada Maatu" as resources for PRAXIS Nexus 'Transforming Conflict and Displacement through Arts and Humanities (16-27 November 2020). The videos were provided as requested. The differences in expectation and practice that have emerged within the contexts of India and the UK have been of interest in themselves and will be reported on separately. Discussions within the committee prompted new collaborations and initiatives by partner institutions both within and beyond the remit of the project, influencing strategic thinking both among those involved in the Arts and among the academics on the committee. It has been through these partnerships that the dialectical relationship between theory and praxis has become most fully realised in the project. Artists and curators who have worked within project initiatives have produced work that reaches a wider audience while reflecting-- and reflecting on-- the complexities of gender issues, confronting viewers with the impact of intersectional dynamics more directly, and often more viscerally, than academic discussions. Both FACT and Bluecoat changed their strategic thinking as a direct result of involvement in the project. As the former Head of Innovation at FACT, and Advisory Committee Member of the Project has commented, engagement led to the search for novel ways of sharing the research project with non-academic publics, of finding new methodologies to communicate complex social and cultural differences across both sectoral and geographical borders, of developing ways to "show, not tell". Helen Star's "You Feel Me" was one result of this strategy. A similar dynamic happened at the Bluecoat, with the Chief Executive Officer sitting on the Advisory Committee of the project. Bluecoat's development of activities leading to the production of "Sheroes", and the production itself stands as another direct outcome of this project partnership. Sensitivity to the politics of intersectionality has been the result of sitting on the Advisory Committee for the project and of taking an academic Advisory Committee member onto the Bluecoat Board. The Chief Executive Officer of Bluecoat has affirmed that, as a direct result of being involved in the project, Bluecoat have benefitted from a growing awareness of Intersectionality and have applied the resulting insights in the context of their ongoing work across all programmes. The impact has not simply been reflected in the public-facing programmes, but also in internal and operational matters, such as tendering for contractors for recent capital works, and a greater sensitivity to the issues that emerge in the day-to-day workings of board and staff. Bluecoat has also used its involvement in the project to develop links with Arts institutions in India more fully, helped by the continuing involvement of the Artist in Residence appointed as part of the project. The competitions sponsored and events themselves have helped to promote networking and provided developmental opportunities for those involved. Conferences and workshops have provided an opportunity to reach beyond the academic community with invitations to participate being issued to those in a range of professions and involved in activities promoting gender equality within NGOs. This has enabled discussions that foreground the dialectic between theory and praxis. That insights gained have been implemented in subsequent initiatives is evidenced in the exhibition "You feel me", in the running of a film programme on Contemporary South Asian Films curated by a participant at an earlier event, and by the commitment of trainee teachers to developing teaching materials and international school partnerships. The material productions associated with the project have also been used in ways that develop the impact agenda of the project: through public screenings, web-posting, and through their incorporation in teaching and training materials. The Covid pandemic thwarted further initiatives as well as hindering the development of materials. The dialectical relationship between praxis and theory, which had been at the heart of the project, met with problems in both India and the UK because of major disruption in the Arts and Education sectors. Despite this disruption, some publications with potential impact were developed from the project. Abhaya Gurumurthy published a newspaper article on the Mysuru gang-rape in the Deccan Herald in September 2021 and an article in a special issue of English (Oxford University Press) on Decolonizing the Discipline; "Decolonizing the Home at Home in the Pandemic: Articulating Women's Experience" explores the pedagogical issue of remote teaching in relation to gender politics. In addition, two training manuals have been produced in association with the project. Mirrors and Windows: Gender Sensitivity Training Manual was written by project fellow Bhumika Sahani and edited by Abhaya N B and Cynthia S Hamilton. This manual is built around six themes: Choice, Gender Roles, Relationships, Work, Ambition, Violence. The activities mirror situations that men and women experience across the world. Guided discussions, reflections, and brainstorming lead participants towards insights that can promote a more equitable world. The modules contain visual, audio, and other text-based activities to encourage the critical approach towards gender equations. Gender Justice: Journey of Empowerment was produced in response to the extent to which the COVID-19 Pandemic exacerbated structural inequity and placed a disproportionate burden on women, children, the queer community, the disabled, the aged, and those marginalised by class, caste, race, colour, and ethnicity. With the objective of bringing much needed attention to the stories of those marginalised, two intersectional feminists from India, Aarushee Shukla and Rahat Sharma, collaborated on the manual under the mentorship of Dr. Abhaya N B. The resulting guide can be used as an educational and practical guide promoting Gender Justice. It is composed of six chapters: Understanding Gender, Sex and Sexuality; Understanding Gender Identities and Gender Roles; Understanding Ambition and Work; Understanding Power and Masculinity; Understanding Gender Based Violence; and Self Reflection and Soul Searching. Each chapter deals with appropriate Theoretical Underpinnings; Practical Learning and Unlearning; Introspection; Voices Heard Beyond the Pandemic; and Mapping One's Growth. Both manuals are available for download as pdfs from the project website. The increasing number of hits received by the website and the greater range of nationalities accessing the website are indications of the continuing interest in the project and its productions.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Creative Economy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Board Member Acting as Critical Friend for FACT
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact The Project Steering Committee member has acted as a critical friend for FACT as they develop their work with diverse young people in Liverpool..
 
Description Institutional Impact of Project on Bluecoat
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
Impact The impact on Bluecoat as an organisation has been significant. Since the project, Bluecoat have benefitted from a growing awareness of Intersectionality and have applied it in the context of our ongoing work across all programmes. This has been greatly helped by having a member of the project steering committee on the board. The impact has not simply been reflected in the public-facing programmes, but also in internal and operational matters, such as our tendering for contractors for recent capital works, and a greater sensitivity to the issues that emerge in the day to day workings of board and staff.
 
Description Invitation to the Board of Governors, Bluecoat
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
Impact A member of the Advisory Board for the Articulating Women project is currently serving on the Board of Governors of the Bluecoat Arts Centre as a direct result of discussions in the Project's Advisory Committee Meetings. She is a specialist on race and mental health and has already influenced the development of policies and training practices with regard to her area of expertise.
URL http://www.thebluecoat.org.uk/content/board-members
 
Description "Mysuru gang-rape: Chamundi's silence" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact An essay written by the co-investigator, Abhaya Gurumurthy in response to the gang rape of a young woman in the Chamundi hills outside of Mysuru. The essay raises the issue of male responsibility, victim blaming, and control masquerading as protection.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.deccanherald.com/opinion/in-perspective/mysuru-gang-rape-chamundi-s-silence-1025624.html
 
Description Articulating Women Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The website has been designed to publicise initiatives and events and to provide information about outputs and resources.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.empowering-women.net
 
Description Big Hope 2 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact I took part, together with the project co-investigator, in a panel on "Women and Leadership" at an International Youth Congress held at Liverpool Hope University. This was one of the best-attended discussion panels. The project also planned and ran a workshop strand on "Storytelling, Identity, and Community" for a small group of nine students. At the end of the workshop, the students had produced a magazine of poetry, "Ubuntu".
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://empowering-women.net/big-hope-2-storytelling-identity-and-community/
 
Description Contemporary South Asian Films by Women 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We screened thirteen short films over an evening and an afternoon at FACT; three of the films had been produced in connection with the Project. The other films were by directors from India, Myanmar, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan. The programme was curated by a specialist from the University of East London. A discussion of the films, both with comments on the making of the films by those involved in project films (from India and Bluecoat) and in relation to ideas of intersectionality followed the screenings. The curator introduced the films and led the discussions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://empowering-women.net/contemporary-film/
 
Description Dissemination Conference, Christ University 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The programme for the conference ran for two and one half days and was interdisciplinary, with speakers from a range of organisations and institutions of higher education. As a result, it offered networking opportunities for the participants and facilitated planning for a volume of essays on "Intersectionality in a Global Perspective." In attendance at the conference were representatives from FACT and Bluecoat who not only gave presentations, but who also made contacts with local arts galleries and organisations with a view to expanding the present network. The Artist in Residence attached to the project was also in attendance and assisted in networking with local artists.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://empowering-women.net/conference-india/
 
Description Experiencing Intersectionality: Other Perspectives, Other Lives (FACT) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The showcase explored the 'intersectional experience' of gender with a day of talks, presentations, and audience-involved discussions between artists, academics, and the public.It presented the work of artists and academics working across the UK, Asia, Africa and North America. One of the participating artists was the Project's Artist in Residence. Throughout the day, a 360° Virtual Reality story, "The Other Dakar" (Tribeca Film Festival 2017), by Dakar-based artist and designer, Selly Raby Kane, was available for guests to experience in the FACT Learning Space. The event was well attended and filled the allocated space almost to its capacity (50). It was successful enough that several of those attending who had not planned to stay for the Academic symposium at Liverpool Hope did so. Discussions were wide-ranging with participation by the artists, academics, and the general public.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://empowering-women.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/FACT-Showcase-Programme1.pdf
 
Description Family Workshop: ARTiculated Women: Animation workshop (Bluecoat) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Bluecoat's Children and Families Manager designed a resource which was shared with the Director of the Centre for Social Action in Bangalore. CSA staff ran some of the Sheroes activities with children in Bangalore. An email with video clips was sent from Bangalore to the Bluecoat with project participants talking about their Sheroes and with some of the children's artworks. In Liverpool, Bluecoat ran sessions with 65 Out of the Blue members, children aged 5-11 from weekly art clubs across Liverpool which Bluecoat targets at some of the most disadvantaged areas. In these workshops, children created jointed figures of their own "Sheroes" and recorded short sound clips about who their Shero is and why. This enabled a discussion of the roles women play and how they can inspire us. A sample of the children's artwork and commentary from Bangalore, combined with a sample of the work from Liverpool, was incorporated into the animated film. The range of sheroes was impressive, and while a number named their mothers, there were national figures and international celebrities among the women celebrated.

The project also enabled Bluecoat to deliver two public workshop sessions, reaching 36 children and their families. The Sheroes film was shown and staff from the Bluecoat. together with artist Laura Sparks, supported people in creating their own figures and animations. Children were invited to celebrate their "Sheroes", the "amazing women in their lives", through drawing, making and animation activities. The workshop was facilitated by artist filmmaker Laura Spark.

The animated film was screened later that day as part of the Bluecoat roundtable on "The Spectre of Colonialism: Art, Feminism and Humanity in the 21st Century". The film was also screened as part of project film screenings and has been made available to those in the project developing teaching packs on gender equality.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.thebluecoat.org.uk/events/view/events/4007
 
Description Film Screening 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Hosa Belaku, the winning mini-documentary by a student at Christ University was screened at the Earl's Court Film Festival on the final, gala evening. Dr Abhaya and I made some introductory remarks about the project, the film, the filmmaker, and the subject of the documentary.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.filmearlscourt.com/2018-special-features/
 
Description Gender Sensitivity Training: Government Teachers India 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The two one-day workshops were designed to increase gender awareness among government teachers. The sessions were interactive, focusing on the social construction of gender, on the expression of gender by teachers and students in an academic environment, on the influence of mass culture and the media on gender perception, and on gender representation in text books. Worksheets were used to prompt the participants to think about gender perception in regular life; these worksheets then provided a platform for extending the discussion to the academic sphere. Participants requested further sessions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://empowering-women.net/first-workshops-india/
 
Description International Symposium, Liverpool Hope University, June 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact A day-long workshop with papers given by an international range of scholars on "Intersectionality in a Global Perspective". Every paper was followed by a good discussion and the conversations spilled over into breaks. Contacts were made that have been followed through and have led to networking and collaborative activities outside the project. Invitations will be issued to selected participants to contribute to a volume of essays on "Intersectionality in a Global Perspective". Two of the participants were PGCE students and their tutor; the three of them have been liaising with colleagues in India in order to develop teaching materials for secondary school English on intersectionality and gender issues. The students and their tutor did a presentation on their progress and findings.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://empowering-women.net/liverpool-symposium-21-june-2019/
 
Description PRAXIS: ARTS AND HUMANITIES FOR GLOBAL CHALLENGES 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact The Project Co-investigator participated in 'Transforming Conflict and Displacement through Arts and Humanities (16-27 November 2020), PRAXIS: ARTS AND HUMANITIES FOR GLOBAL CHALLENGES, in collaboration with GCRF, UKRI, AHRC and University of Leeds. Participation in the workshop gave space to talk about the project with a peer group who are involved in similar projects. Participation also enabled the co-investigator to understand the nuances of networking among different cultural groups. It exposed her to different research methods and helped to familiarise her with the other projects across Europe and South Asia. The Project also provided three videos generated by the project for the event that were used as resources: Hosa Belaku, Antanrangada Maatu, and Sheroes.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://changingthestory.leeds.ac.uk/praxis/praxis-opportunities/nexus-events/conflict-and-displacem...
 
Description Piloting Teaching Materials 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact In December 2019, a teaching session was held for teachers and twenty sixth form students at Notre Dame School in Liverpool. The session was facilitated by the Head of Teacher Education at Liverpool Hope University and an educational consultant from the Merseyside, Cheshire and Greater Manchester ITT Consortium; it also involved those who had developed teaching materials in Bengaluru and Liverpool. The focus of the discussion was the film "Antanrangada Maatu" produced in association with the project by colleagues at Christ University, Bengaluru. One of the two directors of the film was present for the discussion. The session had multiple purposes: to assess the impact and utility of the documentary for teaching; to initiate collaborative activities at the secondary school level between Bengaluru and Liverpool; and to enable those involved in the development of teaching materials to assess the dynamics of teaching materials within different cultural contexts. Teachers from Notre Dame have since evinced an interest in becoming involved in the refinement and testing of teaching materials for the project. Discussions are currently underway to create a working group of teachers from the university partnership who will work with university teacher educators to refine curriculum materials that will support initially subject areas of sociology, Geography and Religious studies. The working group will be led by the Head of Teacher Education at Liverpool Hope University and by an educational consultant from the Merseyside, Cheshire and Greater Manchester ITT Consortium.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://empowering-women.net/teaching-for-gender-equality/
 
Description Piloting Training Materials 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Two Liverpool secondary school teachers and an educational consultant from the Merseyside, Cheshire and Greater Manchester ITT Consortium travelled to Bengaluru in January 2020 for sessions piloting training materials on gender equality developed by a project fellow at Christ University to observe the impact of different cultural contexts on the ways in which training and teaching materials are received and implemented. Discussions between those involved in the development and refinement of training materials within the project followed. Further discussions are ongoing. The Director of the Centre for Social Action at Christ University has indicated his interest in becoming more involved in the project in relation to the development of training and teaching materials and the establishment of school partnerships between Bengaluru and Liverpool. Prior to the event, the Head of Teacher Education at Liverpool Hope University and an educational consultant from the Merseyside, Cheshire and Greater Manchester ITT Consortium were in discussions with the Project Fellow and Project lead at Christ University, both during the visit of these colleagues from Bengaluru to Liverpool and through email correspondence, with suggestions and comments about the ways in which the package could be adapted to make it more useful within a UK setting.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://empowering-women.net/teaching-for-gender-equality/
 
Description Postgraduate Conference Liverpool Hope University 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The conference was attended by postgraduate students from the Northwest, by participants in the project, and by postgraduate students from India. There were two keynote presentations and nine papers delivered to a small but targeted group who were working within the field creating lively discussions and excellent feedback for the presenters. Two of those presenting did so virtually via the StarLeaf software platform. Another student from India attended the conference virtually using the same platform. A padlet was set up for the day enabling participants to upload additional material for those attending.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://empowering-women.net/conference-programme/
 
Description Postgraduate Workshop: Christ University 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact This was a two-day "Workshop on Gender Studies-Contemporary concerns and methodological issues" for postgraduate and early career lecturers. Two keynote lectures and sixteen papers were presented. It was attended by postgraduate students from Universities across India. The papers were scheduled to allow ample time for questions and feedback.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Student Mini-Documentary Competition 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact We ran a competition for students to raise awareness of the importance of women in communities. We had hoped to receive a range of mini-documentaries on the theme of "Women and Community" that could be incorporated into training materials for teachers and community workers. The response to the competition was very disappointing despite widespread advertising and a significant number of hits on the information pages about the project on the website. The competition was also advertised on websites run by Bluecoat and FACT, through an email campaign to University media departments, and through the project's social media (Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram). In the end, we only awarded one prize to a film made by a student at Christ University, Bangalore. That film has since been screened at a number of festivals and has received a number of laurels. We ran a second competition with larger prizes and received few entries, none of which were of sufficient quality to warrant a prize. We are now in the process of running a third competition with the rules changed again, this time it is a screenwriting competition for a documentary.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://empowering-women.net/watch-hosa-belaku/
 
Description Student and Early Career Documentary Competition 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact A competition for a documentary/ photo-essay on women and intersectionality in India was advertised on the website and through social media and personal contacts facilitated by our former Artist in Residence. The competition was for students and early career practitioners and was designed to provide the Project with material that could be incorporated into teaching and training packs on gender equality. It was also intended to provide students and early career practitioners with exposure and mentoring by an experienced artist-researcher. We had over 300 hits to the webpage providing information on the competition and received 13 applications from India. Three awards have been made with projects due for completion within the next six months. Payment of reasonable expenses have been agreed.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020
URL https://empowering-women.net/competition-winners/
 
Description The Spectre of Colonialism: Art, Feminism and Humanity in the 21st Century (Bluecoat) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Two visual artists, including the Artist in Residence attached to the project, and a poet were joined by Bluecoat's Assistant Curator to share their work as artists and writers belonging to societies haunted by Britain's colonial history. The three practitioners discussed their artistic practice in relation to intersectional politics. A discussion followed the session.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.thebluecoat.org.uk/events/view/events/4013
 
Description Women and Leadership Symposium Christ University 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact "Women and Leadership" provided an opportunity to look back at the progress women have made, to acknowledge our debts to pioneering women, to listen to the lessons of those who have achieved prominence, to take stock of the current political climate and its impact on women, and to discuss the way forward for women who can position themselves to exercise leadership within different professions and spheres: political, economic, legal, medical, social, educational, and within the arts. In the process, A range of speakers from different sectors were invited to the symposium which was attended by students and staff from Christ University as well as by the PI, a social work lecturer from Liverpool Hope University who spoke at the symposium, two secondary school teachers from Liverpool who have become involved in the project, and the Taught Programme and Quality Manager from the Merseyside, Cheshire and Greater Manchester ITT Consortium. Talks were recorded for future use in teaching and training materials. Selected speakers will be invited to contribute to a volume on "Intersectionality in a Global Perspective." I received enquiries from several participants in terms of becoming involved in the network and participating in future events.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://empowering-women.net/women-and-leadership-a-symposium-6-7-january-2020/
 
Description Workshop for PGCE trainees at LHU 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Three workshops were delivered in February 2020 to raise awareness of intersectionality as a concept with groups of PGCE trainees from Liverpool Hope University which centred on a viewing of the film Antanrangada Maatu. Altogether forty six trainees from the secondary English, RE and geography programmes took part in the two-hour workshops. Three main areas of impact emerged from the feedback: firstly, that less than half of the trainees (43%) had heard of the term intersectionality or were conversant with the concept; secondly, that the vast majority (96%) considered the film to be a powerful and appropriate vehicle to stimulate discussion on issues of gender inequality with secondary aged learners; thirdly, there was a broad feeling (50%) that not enough was being done in schools on this theme either in subject lessons necessarily following the National Curriculum or in the broader context of PSHE and tutorial programmes. Comments from these groups suggested that all of the RE trainees and most of the English trainees (68%) had found opportunities to include discussions in their work which examined gender stereotypes. Several of the geography trainees mentioned that whilst they appreciated the importance of discussing cultural issues in the subject but were constrained by curriculum demands.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020