Monitoring Object and Visitor Environments (MOVE)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Salford
Department Name: Sch of Science,Engineering & Environment

Abstract

Museums are repositories for our cultural heritage and are responsible for the care of precious collections for the benefit of present and future generations. Key to this stewardship role is the management of indoor conditions to prevent deterioration of vulnerable objects. Preventive control measures are required to keep the indoor climate within conservation limits by maintaining environmental conditions within certain parameters and by minimising environmental fluctuations. Visitors and staff also demand excellent thermal comfort, access to natural light and good air quality to enable them to access these collections. Conflicting environmental requirements often require a degree of compromise, and managing these environmental demands will become ever more challenging for museums as the impact of climate change leads to more frequent extreme weather conditions. Where environmental control and management systems in museums fail to respond to adverse and unstable climatic conditions vulnerable artefacts will inevitably deteriorate, and the need to accurately monitor microclimatic variations over time is fundamental to good museum practice.

The safe preservation of cultural heritage is an essential mission of Egyptian museums where some of the world's most ancient and valuable artefacts are conserved (Ingo et al, 2015). The lack of environmental control programmes in the region is generally attributed to resource limitations and skills shortages, which often result in compromised indoor environmental quality leading to the accelerated deterioration of vulnerable objects. These risks can be mitigated with adequate knowledge of the indoor environmental parameters required for collections care and with robust and accurate monitoring programmes. New user-friendly methods of monitoring using cutting-edge technology are needed if Egyptian museums are to take action in response to changing external conditions and reduce the threat of damage to artefacts from extreme weather patterns.

Our research project proposes to develop a visual live environmental dashboard of digital data that is aimed at assisting museum curators in achieving stable and controlled indoor conditions to address seasonal variations and unpredictable weather patterns. The project will contribute a new application for the use of real-time environmental data as a means of supporting actions to reduce risks to artefacts and improve comfort in visitor areas. A key principle of the digital platform will be its ease of use. One case study museum in Salford, UK and two in Cairo, Egypt, will provide the basis for prototyping the dashboard. Internal environmental parameters recorded at each site will be used to assess the performance of the case studies against relevant conservation requirements, comfort standards and energy benchmarks, and to develop a user-friendly prototype sensor management live dashboard that can be replicated in other museums across Egypt. The proposed dashboard will provide accurate measurements of a range of criteria including exposure and illumination in natural and artificial light, pollution levels (CO2 and dust particles), relative humidity, solar ultraviolet radiation, internal operative and air temperature, external temperature, and energy use figures. In-situ detailed live monitoring of this environmental data will inform decision-makers and staff on curation, exhibition design and safe storage environments while optimising consumption of resources.

Planned Impact

The current Egyptian cultural strategy aims to develop the capacity to display its large reserves of heritage and artefacts. The Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM) is an excellent example to achieve this objective. Cutting edge display technologies, indoor environment instant monitoring systems, and robust management protocols are essential components of a contemporary museum that preserve the artefacts as well as improving the users' satisfaction. The MOVE (Monitoring Object and Visitor Environments) project aims to develop a visual digital live environmental dashboard that aims at assisting museums curators in achieving stable indoor conditions at various seasons and weather patterns. This instant monitoring and visualisation of environmental factors will enable careful setting of variables that ensure maximum protection of artefacts.

The MOVE project brings together various stakeholders including academic institutions (the University of Ain Shams in Egypt, the Universities of Salford and Portsmouth in the UK), governmental actors such as the GEM - Conservation Centre GEM-CC, and Salford Museum. Bringing together academics, curators, technicians and managers of museums enriches the exchange of ideas and ensures practical application of academic and cutting edge knowledge.

The current ambitious museum strategy in Egypt requires growth and upskilling of human resources. MOVE will encourage and facilitate the participation of personnel and trainees in this endeavour. The project will develop training and learning courses for wider distribution on local, regional, and national levels; ensuring continuous capacity-building and offering access to expertise, and promoting industrial partnership. The project will also have wider impact for staff upskilling in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. Due to similar climatic, culture, and human resources conditions, museums across the MENA region would be able to benefit from the development of the monitoring dashboard, creating a sustainable and concrete vision and training networks across the region.

MOVE will disseminate the outcomes of the project to a wide audience of stakeholders in academia, research, governmental institutions and enterprise. The planned exploitation strategy ensures internal and external dissemination of the project outcomes at four levels of dissemination: awareness, information, engagement, and action. These dissemination levels are carefully planned and are outlined in the relevant work packages of the project. Raising public awareness of the project is planned to take place with the preliminary kick-off event through a number of tools. A website will be launched in the early stage of the project, providing background information and tracks the progress of the project objectives.

Through the collaborative work, data sharing, visits and training of the academic and research staff, partners will have the opportunity to disseminate the knowledge and experience acquired to colleagues at their institutions and gather constructive feedback through seminars and workshops. Trained museum staff will also have the opportunity to cascade the acquired knowledge to other fellows in their cohorts through conferences, discussion groups, voluntary work, and sharing material acquired from their training.

The continuous alignment and benchmarking of the MOVE project with UK standards will guarantee a high quality transfer of knowledge and training. The training will not be limited to staff employed in the selected case studies but will be further extended to include staff from more museums across Egypt.
The final planned international conference will be the apex of the dissemination plan of the project. The conference will provide opportunities for creation of further global networks and exchange of knowledge and expertise in the area of preservation of cultural heritage.
 
Title MOVE_Salford Museum DWG 
Description Plans and locations of sensors in different galleries at the Salford Museum 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2022 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_Salford_Museum_DWG/19349330
 
Title MOVE_Salford Museum DWG 
Description Plans and locations of sensors in different galleries at the Salford Museum 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2022 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_Salford_Museum_DWG/19349330/1
 
Title MOVE_sensors-installation 
Description Details of locations and process of installation of sensor for indoor climate in Salford museum 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2022 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_sensors-installation/19349363
 
Title MOVE_sensors-installation 
Description Details of locations and process of installation of sensor for indoor climate in Salford museum 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2022 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_sensors-installation/19349363/1
 
Description We have just completed the first year of the project. Here are the progress and findings in relevant work packages. Progress on the delivery of Work Packages
As stated in the first progress report, the MOVE Project has six interrelated work packages:
• WP1 Theoretical review
• WP2 Monitoring programme for case studies
• WP3 Prototyping of Dashboard
• WP4 Staff training & Feedback
• WP5 Digital data analysis
• WP6 Setting up procedures and final report

Over the last five months, the UK team has continued focusing on the implementation and delivery of sub-tasks related to WP1, WP2, WP4 & WP5. Detailed information on the sub-tasks (being) undertaken since July 2019 is given below:
WP1: Review of the impact of extreme weather events on museums artefacts, best practice in monitoring and conservation and environmental regulations.
WP1_ Sub-task1:
The UK team have reviewed over 30 journal articles and reports in the first two months of the project and currently are in the process of reviewing another 30 papers. The papers/publications selected are focused on museum environment and operation, visitor comfort and collection care within the UK context and Europe.
The Egyptian team have reviewed around 20 journal papers including a few publications related to the management of Egyptian museums.
The UK project lead has drafted and shared with the team an outline/structure for two literature review journal papers. One paper will focus on the current operation practices in the UK museums and the western world and the second paper is on the Egyptian museums and their inspiration to meet international conservation standards in the context of climate change. The timeframe for the papers first draft is 3 months. The content of the papers will be utilised in drafting the project final report.
The MOVE first literature review paper is on going. The team is progressing well with developing the content, of the main and sub- sections. Nearly 120 journal articles have been identified, discussed among the team and confirmed as the paper core sample. The first early draft of the paper was discussed at the UK team monthly meeting end of August. The structure of the paper was re-visited and amended afterword. A revised second version of the paper is being shared and re-discussed at the team regular meeting in November .
A new version of the paper (draft 3) is to be completed and shared with the rest of the team for discussion, feedback and comments before the Christmas break (December 2019).
In addition to the review of the selected sample, the paper will provide a review and summary of the international standards concerning the museum environment and the current debate on adopting more flexible customised conservation and comfort targets.
A second paper is led by the Egyptian team on the development of standards for exhibits in museums environments in Egypt. This article is in preparation.
WP1_ Sub-task2: Best Practice & Engagement Event
As planned, the first public engagement event took place in London and Portsmouth on Friday the 14th and Monday the 17th June. The first day of the event includes a three hours meeting with the Head of Conservation Science at the Victoria and Albert Museum and tour of the gallery spaces where one of the pioneering in-situ environmental monitoring systems in the UK has been developed and created to ensure the safety of the museum microclimate. In line with the project's aim at providing an advanced tool for environmental monitoring in the form of an innovative digital dashboard, this first MOVE event is seen by the project team as a very successful first step towards establishing collaboration with some of the UK leading museums. The morning of the first day of the visit also included an informal project team meeting at the British Museum and visit.
The second day of the event, which was hosted by the UoP team, started with 3 hours project team meeting and a visit to the Mary Rose where one of the most recent environmental monitoring systems in UK museums is being developed to protect its priceless collections as well as a tour to the historic dockyard. The final programme for the event was created and shared with the Egyptian team before the field trip/visit. The main items of the agenda that was covered at the project team meeting included the following: Welcome & Update (HEK & MR), Team Discussion on Work Packages, Presentation on paper - (UK team), UK museum case study_(CH), Equipment, UK visit to Egypt, and Website. The project meeting was also attended by the partner museum at Salford (the Heritage Development Manager on behalf of the Salford Museum and Art Gallery_ SMAG) who provided a summary of some of the challenges as well as the measures taken by the museum to control its environment and reduce the threat paused to the objects by the high seasonal fluctuation in the indoor conditions.
WP2 _Monitoring Programme for Case studies
o SensorsinstallationattheSalfordMuseumandArtGallery(theSMAGCase)
The UoS team has collaborated with the staff at the museum partner (SMAG) to install the monitoring system/wireless sensors over the summer period. The installation process was carried out at two stages between the end of August and the beginning of September. Firstly, the sensors at the two chosen art galleries (Victorian & Langworthy) were installed at the week commencing the 19th August (2019) and then the sensors at the museum's archive (two zones) were fixed on the 4th of September.
o Theinstallationdate(s)wereagreedinadvancedwithProjectPartnerandtheHeadofSalfordMuseumandArtGallery (Ceri Horrocks). The installation was carried out under the supervision of the Collections Manager (Peter N Ogilvie).
o AshortdrafttechnicalreportsummarisingtheinstallationprocessofthesensorsattheSalfordMuseumcaseisdrafted by the project RA (UoS) and shared with the rest of the UK team for discussion and feedback at the next project meeting in December.
o DelaysandadministrationchangesattheGreatEgyptianMuseum(GEM)ledtosignificantdelayinpurchasingand installing the sensors. We believe the matters are now resolved and purchase order were made on 01.12.2019.
WP4_ Staff training event
o Learning materials
Since the training of curators and museum personnel is a core element of the MOVE project, the installation of the monitoring system and the gateways at the museum was fully recorded with the assistance of one of the School technicians. The UoS team is currently working with the technician on editing the videos and creating a digital learning material that could be shared with the partner museum in Egypt. This material will be used in developing the training package and presented at the training event that is to take place in Cairo next year 2020.
o A3Dvistaofthegalleryzones?stallationprocessfilming
A 3D vista showing the location of sensors, type of artefacts and characteristics of the monitored zones (gallery spaces only) is being partially created for the Victorian Gallery and the filming of the 3D vista for the second gallery is to be carried out next. This additional 3D representation of the galleries will be used as part of the project website, the partner museum website and (possibly) to be embodied in or linked to the digital platform, the main outcome/product of the project. The objective is to enhance the readability of the data and the usability of the platform by offering various visualisation techniques.
In total 38 sensors were installed at the museum recording the following parameters: Air Quality (measuring air particulates in µg/m^3), Air Velocity (mps), Carbon Dioxide (ppm), Light Levels (Lux), Motion (Boolean), Relative Humidity & Temperature, (Humidity: XX% Temperature: Co), Temperature only (Co).
WP5_Digital data analysis
The monitoring programme and the environmental assessment of the partner museums included also comfort survey (s) of museums visitors. Prior to the implementation of this component of the project and any empirical data collection exercise, ethical approval for the project should be completed and submitted to the University of Salford ethics committee. As the project lead, the team at the University of Salford have completed and submitted the required form and information. As part of the ethics application, the team has created and developed the study tool (the survey) and shared a copy of the instrument with Egypt team. Once the ethical approval is obtained (in 4 -6weeks) the first round of the survey will be carried out around the middle of summer allowing for sufficient time for data collection.
o Data collection, inspection and processing
Over 2 months of fine data (15 minutes intervals) have been recorded in the galleries so far and about 7 weeks of data collected in the archive/storage areas. The data recorded in one of the galleries over the first month of monitoring is being inspected to highlight any early issues with the monitoring system and the recording of the various parameters. A more thorough analysis of the measurements will be carried out in the coming months after the completion of the literature review paper and the collection of more detailed seasonal data.
Exploitation Route Too early to decide
Sectors Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description MOVE project has supported both Salford museum and Greater Egyptian Museums to pilot models to assist their curators in achieving stable indoor conditions at various seasons and weather patterns. This instant monitoring and visualisation of environmental factors will enable the careful setting of variables that ensure maximum protection of artefacts. The work so far was a result of collaboration between various stakeholders including academic institutions (the University of Ain Shams in Egypt, the Universities of Salford and Portsmouth in the UK), governmental actors such as the GEM - Conservation Centre GEM-CC, and Salford Museum. Bringing together academics, curators, technicians and managers of museums enriches the exchange of ideas and ensures the practical application of academic and cutting-edge knowledge. The project has a wider impact on staff upskilling in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. Due to similar climatic, culture, and human resources conditions, museums across the MENA region would be able to benefit from the development of the monitoring dashboard, creating a sustainable and concrete vision and training networks across the region. That was clearly highlighted in the further collaboration with the Jordanian museums and the Jordanian Ministry of antiquity on the same subject. Recently discussion and collaboration were established with the museum of San Agustin in Manila, the `Philippines.
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Policy & public services

 
Title Photos of the installation of sensors at Salford Museum and Art Gallery 
Description https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_Photo_sensor_installation/19364381 
Type Of Material Data handling & control 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact A comprehensive set of photos show the different stages of the insulation of sensors at the Salford Museum and Art Gallery. 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_Photo_sensor_installation/19364381
 
Title Salford Museum and Art Gallery (SMAG) - Drawings 
Description Floor and roof plan drawings of the museum including the plans of the art galleries where the sensors are installed. 
Type Of Material Data handling & control 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Floor and roof plan drawings of the case study museum including the plans of the art galleries where the sensors are installed. 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_Salford_Museum_DWG/19349330
 
Title Salford Museum and Art Gallery (SMAG) - Monitoring zones, sensor locations and installation 
Description https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_sensors-installation/19349363 
Type Of Material Data handling & control 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The documents show the selected monitoring zones, the location of the sensing devices and their installation in the two art galleries at the Salford Museum and Art Gallery. 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/figure/MOVE_sensors-installation/19349363
 
Title Salford Museum and Art Gallery (SMAG) Data Design 
Description https://salford.figshare.com/articles/online_resource/SMAG_Data_Design/19360805 
Type Of Material Data handling & control 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Data protocol for sensors installed at the Salford Museum and Art Gallery. 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/online_resource/SMAG_Data_Design/19360805
 
Title Salford Museum and Art Gallery (SMAG) Data Processing 
Description https://salford.figshare.com/articles/online_resource/SMAG_Data_Processing/19360847 
Type Of Material Data handling & control 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Data processing procedures for sensors' data installed at the Salford Museum and Art Gallery. 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/online_resource/SMAG_Data_Processing/19360847
 
Title Salford Museum and Art Gallery (SMAG)- Recorded environmental data set 
Description https://salford.figshare.com/articles/dataset/SensorData_IndoorEnvironment/19325729 
Type Of Material Data handling & control 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The data set provides data of sensors installed in two galleries. 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/dataset/SensorData_IndoorEnvironment/19325729
 
Title The performance of a heritage museum under lockdown 
Description https://doi.org/10.17866/rd.salford.19355657.v1 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Report produced as part of The Monitoring Object and Visitor Environments (MOVE) project on 'The performance of a heritage museum under lockdown.' The report is included here with permission as part of the research outputs for the MOVE project. 
URL https://doi.org/10.17866/rd.salford.19355657.v1
 
Description Salford Museum & Art Gallery www.salfordmuseum.com 
Organisation Salford Museum and Art Gallery
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The Museum and Art Gallery at Salford has been the focus of the environmental monitoring campaign for the project. The UK research team has worked closely with the Head of Salford Museum and Art Gallery and Collections Manager at the different stages of the project starting from the insulation of sensors in 2019 through to the more recent data and sensors checking. The Head of Salford Museum and Art Gallery contributed to the MOVE International conference through her keynote presentation on the second day of the event.
Collaborator Contribution Provided the case study for the MOVE project and contributed to the project international conference.
Impact Head of Salford Museum and Art Gallery has contributed to our international conference by giving a keynote speech. Presentation title 'Building Back Better - how our museum has weathered the storm'.
Start Year 2018
 
Description An International Conference on Museum Environments: Challenges and Opportunities 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This final international conference was MOVE's end event, and the apex of the dissemination plan of the project. The conference was materialised through the collaborative efforts between the Egyptian and UK consortium. Hosted by Ain Shams University in Egypt, while planned in collaboration with the UK team, this two-day virtual conference on Museum Environments: Challenges and Opportunities brought together a diverse audience of stakeholders in academia, research, museums, and cultural organisations. Over 100 participants attended this virtual hybrid event which was split into four sessions over two days offering a platform for over15 international contributions and six keynote speeches sharing their knowledge, research, and experience in the field of museology and management of museum environments. Planning the event over two days and the interactive nature of the TEAMS online platform allowed opportunities for global networks and exchange of knowledge alongside the conference proceedings/ papers presented by the participants. The conference was successfully concluded with a technical workshop elaborating by the leading institution (UoS) on the environmental monitoring campaign, the data recording procedures adopted by the team for the partner museum (SMAG), and a keynote speech by the operational manager of the museum.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://eng.asu.edu.eg/research/projects/move/185521/574177/574185