A Vision for Europe: Academic Responsibility and Action in Times of Crises

Lead Research Organisation: University of the Arts London
Department Name: Central Saint Martin's College

Abstract

The network examines the key question of academic responsibility and action in times of crises, focusing its enquiry particularly on the scholarly use of image-led practices to comment and shape political reality. Central to this enquiry is a unique engagement with the little-explored material archive of British Art and the Mediterranean (BAM), a photographic exhibition curated by Fritz Saxl and Rudolf Wittkower in England in 1941, which asserted Britain's cultural connections with Europe. The network brings together artists, historians, media theorists, curators, journalists, photographers and activists to reactivate this unique archival resource and to make it accessible following the methodology of the digital humanities.

BAM was organised by the Warburg Institute and leveraged a European history of art through new media, namely photographic reproductions of historical artworks. It expressed ideas of cultural continuities between Britain and Europe at a critical time of conflict. Consisting of 500 photographs, the exhibition was representative of the new art-historical approach imported from Germany via the Warburg Institute, namely an image-driven enquiry about cultural transmission. The exhibition was shown in London and in 20 other cities around Britain, taking its educatory ideas to as wide an audience as possible. Thus, foreign academic expertise converted into a highly successful enterprise with no compromise in its standards, due to the support of British institutions (CEMA) and key public figures, including the art historian, museum director and broadcaster, Kenneth Clark.

Re-evaluation of BAM as a paradigm of scholarly engagement is critical in today's European political climate. The curators took action on the basis of their research in a time of crisis, widespread nationalism and populism. That BAM's curators were refugee scholars in Britain is all the more relevant today, opening an exploration of the migration of knowledge which will be investigated in two ways: as an object of historical study and as a barometer of how politics have impacted on the movement of scholars, particularly in the 20th century. What examination of this rich archive offers the network is the opportunity for concrete analysis of an historical example of scholars engaging with the crisis of their time, which opens up space to discuss and challenge narratives of national histories and questions of academic action and responsibility.

Using the untapped BAM archive (photographs, glass slides, floor guides, correspondence) the network has four key objectives:
1. To address themes of academic responsibility and action, migration of knowledge and intellectual history, technologies of reproduction and dissemination, image-led practices and academic impact, and archives of conflict.
2. To reactivate and document a historical source using digital interfaces: website, social media, video-streams
3. To enable critical engagement with the future of academic action and responsibility in a conference, focusing on interactions between scholars and a general public, and so facilitate a two-way knowledge exchange that engages with the archive material.
4. To present three public-facing events in London (WI), Munich (ZI) and Rome (BSR) in the form of partial displays (exhibitions), workshop, study day and a conference.

The network will capitalise on the combined expertise and experience of PI, Co-I and Project Partner networks, which target different disciplines, interests and audiences. To address its objectives, it will network significant academics and professionals from the Arts and Humanities as well as a wider public through its public-facing activities and meetings. The mutual work enabled by the network and its activities during its lifetime will feed into a long-term objective: scoping funding towards a touring exhibition in the UK and Europe, and wider media engagement, involving further research applications.

Planned Impact

Who might benefit:
The activities of the network will crystallise a sustainable organisation of academics (art historians, historians, media theorists), artists and activists as well as practitioners and professionals (journalists, curators, photographers), concerned with questions of image-led practices, academic responsibility and cultural transmission, including-
- UK and European scholars working on academic impact in times of crises in historical terms and as current practice
- Practice-based professionals, such as artists, photographers, curators as well as journalists and other media practitioners
- Educational professionals invested in the development pedagogical strategies that assess images, exhibitions and archives
- Cultural and political institutions, such as the Arts Council England and Council for at Risk Academics (CARA) whose origins are bound up with the Warburg Institute, its émigré scholars and war-time activities, and whose activities today support the sharing of academic expertise and its dissemination into the public domain
- Non-specialists interested in the role of culture and the humanities in public discourse
- A broad public who will be interested in the confluences between BAM and the current political climate enabled by the activities of the network in Munich, Rome and London, social media and mainstream media output.

How they might benefit:
- The network of institutions, academics, artists and other key participants will play a significant role in disseminating the network's ideas, discussions and activities to a wide range of audiences in London, Rome and Munich based around the three principal bodies (University of the Arts London, Warburg Institute and Bilderfahrzeuge).
- Through the interdisciplinary dialogue enabled by the network and made accessible through the network website, public-facing events, filmed panel discussions, video essays and social media postings
- By holding events in London, as well as Munich and Rome the network reaches out to wide and varying audiences and academic communities enabling intellectual and cultural exchange
- Through the visibility and accessibility of the BAM archive by the display (physical and online) of key materials chosen during the lifespan of the network. Also in their display in London, Rome and Munich, all of which will be accompanied by accessible published outputs.
- Through the peer-reviewed publications of the network, including a catalogue and conference proceedings
- By engaging with critical discourses that mediate academic expertise in mainstream media affecting society in its entirety: Brexit, nationalism, the history of migration and its current crisis, the question of the role of the humanities, how images operate in society.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The exhibition at the Zentral Institut (ZI) in Munich was the means by which the material of the British Art and the Mediterranean from the Warburg Institute's Photographic Collection and Archive was analysed and formalised in a manner that the public could understand the 1941 exhibition, the impact it had and its relationship to wider contexts. This exhibition was comprised of 7 sections that correspond to the key questions and areas of inquiry with regard to the British Art and the Mediterranean (BAM) material. The sections were:
I - Kulturwissenscaftliche Bibliothek Hamburg: Photography and Exhibition
II - The Warburg Institute, London: Photography and Exhibition
III - Exhibition: English Art and the Mediterranean (1941)
IV - Lecture Program and Tour, 1942-45
V - English Art in Exhibitions and Writings
VI - The Publication: British Art and the Mediterranean, 1948
VII - Visual Education

These themes were explored in the catalogue section of the accompanying publication, 'Image Journeys: The Warburg Institute and a British Art History', through a series of essays and detailed catalogue entries for the exhibition material.
The key findings that were generated here were; the deeper context of Aby Warburg's exhibition methodology, how this translated into a photographic exhibition methodology when the Warburg Institute (WI) was in exile from 1933, deep research into the context of English Art and the Mediterranean (EAM) in relation to archive material from the WI, archive documentation detailing the lecture program and the exhibition tour, the art historical context around the development of an English art history, archive material related to the production of BAM (the catalogue of EAM) and research that uncovered key material tracing the roots of the WI's exhibition methodology to a German context of visual education. In addition, the context of support for EAM from the Council for the Encouragement of Music and the Arts (CEMA) and other wartime exhibitions was discussed in a catalogue essay by Joanne Anderson. Johannes von Muller's essay discussed the wider context of WI's exhibitions as well as the refugee status of many of the WI's and its associate scholars. Mick Finch's essay examined Kenneth Clark's support of EAM and his relationship to photography. The essay also made the link between Clark's interest in the WI's activities and his own popularisation of the arts that culminated with the 'Civilisation' series made for the BBC.
In the network meetings John Wyver brought his research to extend the context of Clark's broadcasting experience. Constanza Caraffa made links between the Kunsthistorisches Institut in Florenz's holdings and the WI's and Christina Riggs made a link with another archive in relation to ruins in the form of the The Sanam Albums. Helmut Gernsheim's photographs made for the National Buildings record (and used in EAM) and the British School at Rome's Ward-Perkins archive explore the relationship to the threat of ruins in the case of the Gernsheim material and actual ruins with the Ward-Perkins archive. Michael Berkowitz also discussed The National Building Record and Gernsheim's work in depth.
William Owen brought his expertise of digitised photographic archives to the project in terms of examining how a digitisation of the Cresswell archive could function and how high resolution images and using the open source 'International Image Interoperability Framework' would turn a digital version of BAM into a powerful tool.
The collected findings and documentation provide a comprehensive context from which to stage an exhibition and/or assemble an on-line resource of the BAM material. At the closure of the Network project it is evident that there is case to make a Follow-on grant as well as preparing a Standard bid.
Exploitation Route The project has amassed a wealth of material that could be further put to work in the form of an exhibition or an on-line resource. Its scope would go beyond the capability of the current project website, a point that was highlighted in our network meeting a discussion about the feasibility of such a resource not only in presenting the immediate context of BAM but also its relationship to wider contexts and to academic exhibitions and visual education. Thus, museums, curators and web-designers will be who the outcomes could be developed by and this was the subject of much discussion in our network meetings. It was our feeling that an on-line resource would be the most relevant way to take the material forward with the idea of different publics in mind; a scholarly audience who would use it as a research tool and a non-specialist audience who could engage with the material in terms of who it originally addressed in 1941 as well as its deeper contextual levels.
The project has already mounted 2 exhibitions and produced a publication is concrete outcomes and thus to develop an ambitious on-line resource would seem like the project's logical next step.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://visionforeurope.arts.ac.uk
 
Description A Vision for Europe Instagram account 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This site was put up to disseminate more widely the project's activities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.instagram.com/vision_for_europe/
 
Description A Vision for Europe: Academic Responsibility and Action in Times of Crises Network Meeting, colloquium event, British School at Rome , 13th & 14th November 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Wednesday 13 November, keynote lecture by Claudia Wedepohl from the Warburg Institute (WI), Aby Warburg's Pictorial Mnemosyne Atlas: a lifelong project, an audience of approx 80 people in the Sainsbury Lecture Theatre, British School at Rome (BSR).

Thursday 14, Colloquium Event, 10am - 6pm in the Sainsbury Lecture Theatre, BSR.
Stephen Milner (director, BSR, Welcome)
Introductions to the history of the project from Mick Finch and Johannes von Muller.
Presentations followed by discussions:
Michael Berkowitz (UCL, Jewish Studies) - Walter and Helmut Gernsheim, Fritz Saxl, and the National Buildings Record project: before, during, after.
Alessandra Giovenco (BSR archivist) - Learning from images of the past: how the study of archives can contribute the preservation and protection of our cultural heritage in conflict areas.
Steffen Haug (Bilsderfahrzeuge, WI) - Walter Benjamin and the image archives of old Paris.
Martina Caruso (Assistant Director BSR) - Invisible Archives: Agnes and Dora Bulwer's Archaeological Photographs in the Mediterranean
Costanza Caraffa (head of the Photo collection, Kunsthistorisches Institut in Florenz) - Negotiating (national) heritage in the photo archive.
Julius Bryant Head of Word and Image V&A, London)- Wittkower, architectural photography and the period eye.
Christina Riggs (Visual culture, University of Durham) - The Sanam Albums: Destruction and Resistance in the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan
John Wyver ( Broadcast Media, University of Westminster) - "Cloaca maxima" or cornucopia? Early television and the visual arts.
The audience for this all day event was approximately 30 people comprised of scholars and personnel from institutions and academies across Rome.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.bsr.ac.uk/ruins-in-the-archive-constructing-visual-histories-in-photography-and-broadcast...
 
Description A vision for Europe Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The Vision for Europe was launch in March of 2019 as the portal to share information about the project and to document its outcomes
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://visionforeurope.arts.ac.uk
 
Description Archives of Conflict, Network Meeting (on-line) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was last the network that was a discussion between Constanza Caraffa, Julius Bryant, Stuart Franklin, Christina Riggs and the project team; Joanne Anderson, Mick Finch and Johannes von Muller. The discussion scoped three principle questions: * How do we define conflict in this context? * What strategies have been taken with archives of conflict to open them out to publics and publicise them?* How does the project proceed forward? The aim was to focus the expertise towards the project's next steps. As this was the final Network meeting of the project we aimed to get the networks advice about how we could proceed and in terms of specific points to do with our future strategy.
We discussed the general context of the Warburg Institutes photographic exhibitions and their relationships to the wider archives go the Institute. The changing status of objects due to COVID. The value of objects for their archival value and not necessarily their museological value. How could a large public been engaged with material?
How can secondary material, b&w photographs, be engaging to a wider public.
How to elicit value from photographs as objects rather than images, through narration. The problems with this how particular narratives can dominate or focus the material. How broadcast material can give a powerful focus. Question of a 'user interface' that can facilitate the creation of narratives through navigation. The different ways an object can be interpreted rather than how a single narrative can over determine an object. How does the Imperial War Museum consider their archive, anthropological and ethnographic sources and museums of migration have interesting approaches for example. The shift between analysis and/or communication is the major problematic for a digital outcome from the project. What are the systems of value that determine the status of the BAM archive? We also discussed the possibly of a touring exhibition.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Exhibition - Bilder auf Wanderschaft. Das Warburg Institute und eine britische Kunstgeschichte, Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte, Munich. 30/5 - 21/6/2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This was an exhibition of archive materials from The Warburg Institut that explored the exhibition, English Art and the Mediterranean and the publication British Art and the Mediterranean. It was held in Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte, Munich, 30/5 - 21/6/2019, which is Germany's most important Art History research Institute and Library. The Institute's building was formerly Where the Nazi party's membership files were kept. After the war it became the Collection Point for the Aliies to repatriate looted art works. It this resonates with the contextual background of British Art and the Mediterranean and the Warburg Institue's migration to London.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.zikg.eu/veranstaltungen/2019/ausstellung-bilder-auf-wanderschaft?fbclid=IwAR2zWl1H0mvhD9...
 
Description Lecture: A Medium of Sustenance: Photographs and Exhibition Practice at the Warburg Institute 1933-45, by Dr. Johannes Von Muller at the Warburg Institute 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This was a lecture about the exhibition practices that included British Art and the Mediterranean as well its wider context. This was a means to communicate about the project and the research material that was presented in the Zentralinstitut exhibition
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://warburg.sas.ac.uk/events/event/19092
 
Description Lectures given by Burcu Dogramaci and Johannes von Müller, Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte, Munich, 29 May 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The lectures were in the context of the exhibition, Bilder auf Wanderschaft. Das Warburg Institute und eine britische Kunstgeschichte, at the Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte, Munich. They narrated the key themes of British Art and the Mediterranean and presented the context of the Vision for Europe project. Burcu Dogramaci's presented material about other refugee cultural activities in London that were active at the same time as those of the Warburg Institute.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.zikg.eu/veranstaltungen/2019/ausstellung-bilder-auf-wanderschaft?fbclid=IwAR2zWl1H0mvhD9...
 
Description Meeting at the British School at Rome with the Photographic Collection 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact This was a visit to the British School to decide which materials from their Photographic Collection to use in the upcoming exhibition in November. Archive materials from the Ward-Perkins collection will be used with photographs from the National Buildings record from the Warburg Institute, In terms of this material the conference schedule was established so that a relationship between the two events can be established.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Network meeting at the Central Saint Martins College of Art and Design, 27 September 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact The title of the event was Technologies of Reproduction and Dissemination. From the project team were Joanne Anderson and Mick Finch and from the network were Julius Bryant, Visitor Claass and Stuart Franklin. Also invited were Louisa Minkin (Central Saint Martins, MA Fine art), William Owen (Made by Many, media company), Lynda Nead (Birkbeck, art history) and John Wyver (Westminster University, broadcast media).
Presentations were made about the project by Anderson and Finch, about Photogrammetry by Minkin, about Photography by Franklin and about digital photographic archives by Owen. The presentations facilitated discussions which facilitated the project's thinking into the final stage of the project
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Network meeting at the Warburg Institute 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact From the project team were Johannes von Muller and Mick Finch and from the network were Julian Adler, Anna Nyburg and Stuart Franklin.The network were briefed about the project and its background. The latter was facilitated by visits to the Warburg Archive and the Photographic Collection to engage with primary material from the British Art and the Mediterranean exhibition, publication and its wider context. Reference material was provided for the network members.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Network meeting at the Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact In the context of the exhibition at the Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte and the publication of Image Journeys the network members, Julian Adler, Anna Nyburg, Stuart Franklin, Victor Claass and Julius Bryant and the project team discussed the exhibition material and attended the lectures during the opening. There were presentations by Anna Nyburg about refugee publishers Thames and Hudson and Phaidon and about historical examples of Nationalist identities through exhibitions by Victor Class. there was much discussion about the the future steps of the project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Participation in the workshop - Paul Mellon Centre, London - 'Going with the Grain? Post-War British Film, Photography and Audiovisual Argument' 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Joanne Anderson and Mick Finch were invited to attend this workshop because of its focus on academic research outcomes taking the form of audio visual and broadcast outputs. This is in line with key objectives of our project in terms of academic responsibility in the face of crisis leads to seeking wider and diverse audiences and using means aside from the academic journal essay. We met here with John Wyver - who is a film based broadcaster and academic, Lynda Need - who is historian who has an image-led practice and through collaboration with John Wyver has made short videos in relation to her research and Catherine Grant - a Film Studies academic who has pioneered the audio-visual dissertation. We also met with people from the Mellon Centre where a focus was also on their photographic collection and its digitisation. Questions around Photo collections have emerged as being relevant to our project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Ruins in the Archive, exhibition, British School at Rome Gallery, 14 November - 27 November 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This was exhibition of archival documents from The Warburg Institute and the British School at Rome. On display were photographs Helmut Gernsheim made of important London monuments for the National Buildings Record to document them in case of their destruction during World War II, and John Bryan Ward-Perkins photographs of war damaged Italian buildings and monuments, also taken during World War II.
The opening of the exhibition was visited by Lord Fowler, the Speaker of the House of Lords.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.bsr.ac.uk/ruins-in-the-archive-constructing-visual-histories-in-photography-and-broadcast...
 
Description Émigré Art Historians and Britain (London, 5-6 Nov 19), Queen Mary, University of London - Graduate Center 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The conference aimed to reappraise and -challenge the received narrative about the history of art history in Britain.
Art History as an academic discipline in Britain is commonly regarded as a German import. Before the 1930s, British art writing was allegedly the domain of the amateur and connoisseur. This only changed radically with the influx of émigré scholars - most of them of German-Jewish descent - to Britain after 1933. These highly skilled professional art historians played a pivotal role in developing the research and teaching programmes of both the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes.
This context was highly appropriate for the Vision for Europe project and the project team member, Johannes von Muller, presented the paper 'Under the most difficult Circumstances'. The Warburg Institute's Exhibition Practice, 1933-48 where the intellectual context of the project was presented within the framework of the the AHRC framework and its events and activities. This disseminated the work of the project and provoked conversation and made links to other relatedprojects and scholarship.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://arthist.net/archive/21817