Therapeutic placemaking as a pathway to improved public health: realising our health and care centres of the future

Lead Research Organisation: University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Geosciences

Abstract

'Good design' for health and care, and the development of industry and public sector skills to support such improvements in infrastructure, will be key if the devolved governments of the UK are to address the challenges brought about by an ageing society, and the need for clean growth. The aim of this research is to examine and advance an interdisciplinary design innovation piloted by a West of Scotland Health Board NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (NHSGGC) over a sustained period of building modernisation that identifies lessons of immediate regional relevance, and for wider future application in other UK regions. 'Therapeutic placemaking' is a bespoke Arts and Health strategy that supports facility functionality through novel design features (including interactive way finding, personalising patient dignity, and positive distraction installations) and promotes wellbeing by bringing a cultural dimension into the healthcare environment. The innovation is delivered by a public artist working at the interface of a built environment team, the health service, local communities, and local authority partners, to develop generative placemaking concepts that will inspire the design of a new-build NHS project.

The Fellowship's programme of research will take place in the post-industrial town of Clydebank, where the development of a new NHSGGC primary care facility is being envisioned as the catalyst for wider processes of urban renewal. Efforts at local regeneration programs have so far struggled to identify solutions to the complex and compounded legacies of industrial decline, including the deterioration of public health, wellbeing and the local environment. Research leadership is required to ask if another approach is possible, and evaluate its effectiveness. Partnering with NHSGGC, Architecture and Design Scotland, and three local authority departments (West Dunbartonshire Health and Social Care Partnership, West Dunbartonshire Libraries and Museums, and West Dunbartonshire Planning and Building), the Fellowship will develop a practice-led therapeutic placemaking approach for the new facility (Clydebank Health and Care Centre), and then evaluate its impact on service-users, service providers and the wider community upon its opening in September 2020. Through the collaborative and iterative development of such an approach, this project will advance research around critical and creative placemaking in the fields of feminist urban studies, arts and health, and heritage futures.

The Fellowship will enable innovative and collaborative research leadership in regional efforts to improve infrastructures and facilities for health provision in NHS Greater Glasgow. It will embed a 'therapeutic placemaking' approach in the health, public and education sectors, and the architecture and design industry. Additionally, it will engage local community representatives in knowledge exchange, and consultative and evaluative processes around the application of novel therapeutic placemaking interventions. Concentrated Fellowship actions at the local-authority level will scale up through research outcomes and skill-sharing, making research Leadership an asset in UK-wide industry settings and regional public sectors. Transferable innovations and insights will be shared via national Arts and Health and design programs, generating improved industrial capacity to deliver renewed spaces of health and care that are health and place improving for our ageing society.

Planned Impact

The proposed project will identify the role that TP, as an emerging interdisciplinary innovation, can play in making spaces of health and care that are health and place improving, and futureproofed to face pressing societal challenges. The project design identifies and creates opportunities for maximising impacts in an innovation ecosystem encompassing local community members, and relevant stakeholders in the public sector, and architecture and design industries. Research is embedded in a 'live' capital works project to realise the benefits of TP at the local scale, and this impact is then scaled up with the production of skilling resources and knowledge exchange (KE) activities that harness the potential for nationwide impact. In this way, the project design enables and accommodates emerging opportunities during the project lifecycle for the maximization of impact.

PATHWAY 1 TO TP: DELIVERING IMPROVEMENTS IN INFRASTRUCTURE AND IMPACTING ON CULTURES OF HEALTH AND WELLBEING - This pathway centres on capacity building within a built environment team, a local authority, and local communities, to envision and deliver a health improving and place enhancing NHS primary care facility. Integrated thinking and working is enabled by participatory research that is conducted in the community to identify compelling placemaking concepts, and to create opportunities for knowledge sharing, learning and engagement, around matters of Health and Place, in the run up to the opening of the new facility. The pathway culminates in the coproduction of a TP intervention with an empowered local interest working group that will be embedded in the new facility for the benefit of service-users, service-providers, and elderly users in particular.

PATHWAY 2 TO TP: REGIONALISING IMPACT BETWEEN CLYDEBANK AND GREENOCK - This pathway opens the scope of research to the NHSGGC Health Board region. The impact pathway centres around the coproduction of a TP intervention with the lead artist on an NHSGGC building modernisation project in Greenock, that will enable the exchange of knowledge and creative, resourceful TP techniques between neighbouring post-industrial riverside communities, forging new community resiliencies and solidarities. Capacity building will be consolidated with the delivery of a TP intervention - a 'Healthy Journeys' scheme - that will impact on the clean growth credentials of both facilities, and provide health improving opportunities for service-users, service-providers and wider communities.

PATHWAY 3 TO TP: EVALUATION, CAPACITY-BUILDING AND RESKILLING - This pathway builds on practice-led research, to develop skilling resources, including a TP Portfolio and Guidance Note, that will enable UK Arts and Health leaders, UK design and construction industry (including architects, and public artists) and UK local authorities to take up the TP approach. Resources will be disseminated at a TP KE Symposium, attended by stakeholders from across the UK, and then deposited in the NHSGGC Public Health Resource Unit for future use. Such capacity building will impact on NHS infrastructure development that supports health improvement, and sustainable growth.

Impacts across pathways will be consolidated through regular KE meetings with the director of Architecture and Design Scotland (A+DS), Scotland's leading professional body for excellence in the built realm, to advance A+DS' placemaking objectives in the context of deindustrialisation, and to identify how TP can vitalise design policy for health.

To ensure strategic oversight of impact planning and delivery across the project's lifecycle, and to identify research impact legacies and potential follow-on Leadership Fellowship activities, a TP Impact Advisory Group (IAG) will be established. The P-I's prior experience with socially engaged arts practice and ethnographic research in health and regeneration settings will drive all pathway to impact activities and associated outputs.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Artworks in settings for health and care 
Description As part of fellowship, the PI has collaborated with a number of commissioned artists to deliver artworks into settings for health and care (the new Clydebank and Greenock Health and Care Centres). The artworks have been realised through experiments in therapeutic placemaking - participatory activities with patients, staff and the public, exploring the intersection of health, wellbeing and place. In Clydebank Health and Care Centre, the PI has worked with commissioned artists Bespoke Atelier to develop, through site work and public engagement: 1) Metal front gates laser cut with an illustrative graphic, 2) Window manifestations for privacy in consultation rooms, 3) Examination room curtains, 4) Linen prints in waiting rooms. In Greenock Health and Care Centre, the PI has worked with the lead artist Stephen Hurrel to develop overarching narrative and approaches for commissioned art works, and a participatory art program for young carers in Inverclyde and West Dunbartonshire, allowing young people to explore the design of therapeutic environments for health. The PI has also worked with other commissioned artists who have designed and delivered integrated art and landscape interventions in the civic space surrounding both new health and care centres. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Staff and patients using the new Clydebank and Greenock Health and Care Centres have reported... 
 
Description The purpose of this research was to further develop and advance therapeutic placemaking approaches in the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde health board, specifically in settings for primary health and care which have a strong connection with local communities. Through collaboration with artists and design teams this research advanced a set of approaches for engaging with patients, staff and wider publics in the creation of therapeutic art and design in settings for health and care, which has informed the evolution of approaches adopted by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde in the delivery of Arts & Health into new capital build projects. Through this research a successful arts and environment strategy was delivered into two new health centres which met the expectations and aspirations of communities, local authority partners (planning and building, health and social care, arts and heritage), and industry partners (artists, architects, landscape architects etc). The research set up valuable multidisciplinary collaborative spaces that have demonstrated the integral role that the arts, and artists, can play in design teams from the beginning of a capital build project, and how the processes and findings and outcomes of therapeutic placemaking processes can inform the development of capital build projects across a range of design stages. The methods and approaches that have been explored and developed in both Clydebank and Greenock has raised the profile of the arts and its role in capital planning within NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, and an ambition to ensure that artists are involved in capital build projects from the very beginning.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of therapeutic placemaking approaches in the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde health board could be evaluated long-term for impact on patients, staff and wider publics.
Sectors Healthcare

 
Description - Informing and inspiring approaches in therapeutic placemaking in two new primary care settings that are due to open at the end of 2020 - Clydebank Health and Care Centre, and Greenock Health and Care Centre - Challenging institutional thinking within local authority Health and Social Care partnership about the role of the arts in health - Educating Cultural Services within local authority about the intersection of arts, health and heritage - Supporting and encouraging experimental activity and original thinking within NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Improvement - Skilling architects, landscape architects and public artists in therapeutic placemaking approaches
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Environment,Healthcare,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Impact Advisory Group for practitioners involved in Therapeutic Placemaking
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Those professionals who took part in the Impact Advisory Groups (IAG) reported a change in opinion/perspective about the role of the arts in the delivery of environments for health. The IAG challenged professional orthodoxies, and highlighted to practitioners from health, architecture, planning and regeneration, about the role that the arts and artists can have in the delivery of health-improving settings for health. Therapeutic Placemaking became a better understood concept and practice for people working to deliver settings for health and care.
 
Description Impact on Arts & Health practitioners
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or Improved professional practice
Impact The PI's collaboration with a variety of public artists helped to consolidate and develop artist's approaches and techniques in the delivery of art and creative practice within settings for health and care. These artists have gone on to have further commissions with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and they are bringing the insights of this development to subsequent projects. The art works delivered by these artists have been reported to have health-promoting and health improving impacts e.g. reducing work place stress amongst staff in the health centre.
 
Description Impact on Arts and Health practice NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or Improved professional practice
Impact New experiments in therapeutic placemaking practice were trialed in the Clydebank Health and Care Centre commissioning process, and another capital build project Greenock Health and Care Centre that was delivered around the same time, which advanced the role of the arts, and the role of artists in the capital build process. The resulting health centres have become an exemplar of the impacts of creative practice within capital planning, and the learning from these project has then been taken forward in the commissioning and planning of subsequent NHS capital build projects. Approaches in therapeutic placemaking have advanced through these projects, and it has galvanised commitments to Arts and Health within Capital and Public Health directorates within NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde.
 
Description Participation in NHS Greater and Clyde Greenspace and Biodiversity Working Group
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or Improved professional practice
Impact The impact of the PI's involvement was raising the profile of Arts & Health and its contribution within the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde health board, particularly within the Capital Planning directorate. There was greater interest and acceptance of the embedded role that artists can play in the delivery of health-improving environments. A number of projects were initiated through the Greenspace and Biodiversity Working Group with artists as part of design teams.
 
Description Participation in Queens Quay Place and Design Panel
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or Improved professional practice
Impact As as result of PI's participation in the place and design panel, health, heritage and regeneration leads within West Dunbartonshire council were introduced to the role of the arts in the delivery of health-improving places, and the ways in which the arts can be enrolled progressively in regeneration to improve places for people. The PI was involved in the critique and review of regeneration projects for Queen's Quay and advised on how projects could be improved through greater connection to local communities, histories and ambitions (which creative work at the health centre was seeking to foreground). Another result of the PI's participation was West Dunbartonshire's commitment to delivering an Arts Strategy as part of the wider regeneration to enrol artists in the delivery of therapeutic placemaking beyond the health centre. The PI also advised on the production of a Queens Quay Design Code which was to inform regeneration design ambitions at Queens Quay.
 
Description Advancing Therapeutic Placemaking approaches nationally 
Organisation Architecture and Design Scotland
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution -Advancing research around critical and creative placemaking -Advancing research around health and place -Advancing research around placemaking in contexts of deindustrialisation and decline -Identify how Therapeutic Placemaking can vitalise design policy for health
Collaborator Contribution -Director of Design is a member of the project's Impact Advisory Group -Project meetings and knowledge exchange activities
Impact In progress
Start Year 2019
 
Description Advancing Therapeutic Placemaking within the NHS 
Organisation NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (NHSGGC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution -Advancing approaches in therapeutic placemaking within two new NHSGGC primary care facilities -Reviewing the critical role that therapeutic place making plays in making new spaces of health and care that are health improving - an approach which has been piloted by NHSGGC Arts & Health leaders -Examining and advancing the progressive Arts & Health approaches taken by NHSGGC identifying lessons for future application in other UK regions, Arts and Health leaders in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and Scotland wide.
Collaborator Contribution -NHSGGC Arts & Health Leader providing non-academic mentoring once a month -NHSGGC Arts & Health Leader nabling/supporting design intervention delivery via Arts and Environment Steering group -NHSGGC Health Improvement enabling access to archives and people
Impact In progress
Start Year 2019
 
Description Therapeutic Placemaking in West Dunbartonshire 
Organisation West Dunbartonshire Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution -Advancing the devlopment of therapeutic placemaking approaches for a new health and care centre within the local authority -Challenging institutional thinking about the role of the arts in health within the local authority Health and Social Care Partnership -Highlighting the role of place, and placemaking in health improvement, which is impacting on regeneration services within the local authority -Educating on the intersection of arts, health, heritage and place which is impacting on cultural services and the way that they communicate cultural heritage -Identifying opportunities for cross-departmental thinking and doing, and sharing of resources
Collaborator Contribution -Access to a hot desk three days a week in Clydebank health centre within the local authority to enable close-working with key Health and Care personnel -Head of Health and Community Care, the Head of Planning and Building Standards, and the Head of Cultural Services are a member of the project's Impact Advisory Group -A regular working relationship with the Place and Design Officer, Planning and Regeneration Officers -Meeting space for a local interest working group in the heritage department of the library -Health and Social Care Partnership officers providing support in accessing contacts and information -Regular contact with heritage officers to discuss archives -Regular contact with Place and Design Officer to review regeneration activity within the local authority
Impact In progress
Start Year 2019
 
Description Community steering group 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of fellowship, a community steering group 'Makers and Menders of Clydebank' was established to enable members of the local community to participate in the creation of art works for their new health centre Clydebank Health and Care Centre. This group, comprised of 8 members, met every 2 weeks from 2020-2021, and they got involved in creative workshops that informed the design development of integrated art works in the health centre, including the health centre gates, reception desk, window manifestation, and 2D art works. Creative workshops included online creative classes, print studio workshops and classes, and creative site-based activity in and around Clydebank. The group learnt about the design process from concept through to delivery, and explored the impact and value of therapeutic design in environments for health and care through the activities. The purpose of this steering group was to explore ways in which members of a local community can be involved in the delivery of meaningful design processes within communities that enhance the therapeutic potential of settings for health and care.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Podcast 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of fellowship, a podcast entitled 'Tributaries' was created to explore the intersection of health, wellbeing and place through stories of local community and local histories. 8 podcasts were published online on a freely accessible platform. The podcast aimed to share stories about place, place-attachment, and place-connections, and the impact that these can have on health and wellbeing. The gathering of stories, histories, public opinion then inspired the development of art works for the new Clydebank Health and Care Centre, that had a deep and meaningful connection with the local community. Local authority partners and members of the wider design team also listened to the podcast and thus it informed wider design processes and decision making. The podcast was used as a tool to explore alternative forms of creative placemaking for health.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Presentation to members of the Glasgow-Pittsburgh City Partnership 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presented research to members of the Glasgow-Pittsburgh City Partnership. Partnership has explored the intersections between health, heritage and placemaking across two postindustrial cities, Glasgow and Pittsburgh, to explore joint solutions to public health and city futures. The partnership were interested in grounded research emerging from a primary care setting on a postindustrial site, and methods employed to enrol communities in creative placemaking as a therapeutic response to deindustrialisation and public health. The partnership are looking to develop pilot initiatives of a similar nature.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Therapeutic Placemaking design masterclass 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact As part of the fellowship, a Therapeutic Design Masterclass was delivered to undergraduate students on the Sculpture and Environmental Art program at Glasgow School of Art, the leading course for public artists in the UK. The purpose of the masterclass was to introduce students to the field of Arts and Health, and approaches in Therapeutic Placemaking which is creating significant new roles for practitioners in public art. Students were introduced to case studies, and learnt about methods and approaches, and were invited to respond to a creative brief set by Arts and Health coordinator for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. This introduced students to a growing field of practice in the UK through real world experience with an NHS client. Arts and Health coordinator for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde intends to continue this masterclass as a yearly event to help nurture the next generation of artists who will work with the NHS in Greater Glasgow and Clyde, and Scotland more generally.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021