Challenging Domesticity in Britain, 1890-1990

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Arts Languages and Cultures

Abstract

Housing and the mass provision of homes were central to social reform and cultural change in Britain, 1890-1990. Yet programmes of house building and 'slum' clearance marked cycles of destruction and regeneration in which the notion of 'home' was continually contested by planners, seemingly with minimal input from residents. This has led scholars of the home to focus on the design of new houses, their amenities, living standards, and the implications of slum clearance. Subsequently, much research on the nineteenth and twentieth-century in Britain and beyond emphasises the links between domesticity and the rise of the nuclear family and the idealisation of housewifery. By the mid-twentieth century a domestic ideal dominated western culture wherein the home remained associated with privacy and as a refuge from the dangers and risks of the external world. This Network will challenge these associations and discuss how the home could mask or enable a range of behaviours and activities that seem, on first sight, to be incongruous with the domestic ideal.
The purpose of the Research Network is to organise three workshops, through which we will innovate approaches to analysing the home and domesticity. The first examines how the home may have facilitated criminal enterprise; the second addresses the home within the history of activism; and the third discusses how ideas about domesticity contributed to the idea of 'home' as curative, especially as moral treatment for those considered 'deviant' or the poor. The Network will produce a new research methodology that will revitalise the way historians think about the home and domesticity. Research questions include: How far were meanings of 'home' shaped by intersections of class, gender, race, and region? To what extent could individuals subvert the language or materials of domesticity to facilitate a range of behaviours and activities? To what extent did 'home' become a form of treatment for the offenders and the poor? How does looking at different types of domestic spaces, including older types of housing, transform our interpretations? We suggest that the Network's emphasis on employing new sources and methodological frameworks challenges current historiography on domesticity by showing that cultures of domesticity could be subverted and fostered the very kinds of behaviours and activities that 'modern' homes aimed to act as refuges from or treatments against.
The Network will forge a new partnership between the University of Manchester and the Pankhurst Centre. The framework of the criminal home, radical home, and curative home will add to our understanding of the importance of the Pankhurst Centre at 60-62 Nelson Street. The house was the setting for the first meeting of the Women's Social and Political Union in 1903, and is central to the history of the militant suffragette movement and women's activism. It might also be understood as a criminal home, being the residence of Christabel Pankhurst who, along with other members of the WSPU, was jailed for violent militancy. It is also a curative home. Standing within the grounds of Saint Mary's NHS Hospital and sharing its premises with Women's Aid, the Centre facilitates a women's centre and provides a therapeutic garden for service users. The partnership will contribute to an exciting phase for the Centre as it embarks on an ambitious period of expansion, fundraising and redevelopment. The Network will assist in training guides and producing materials on the history of the Pankhurst home, public lectures and podcasts aim to attract new audiences and promote the museum, and the PI will contribute to three thematic training projects for volunteers. The shared research priorities indicate potential for a longer-term relationship between the Pankhurst Centre and the University of Manchester and one of the key Network aims is to develop relationships with the Centre and other non-HEI partners for future research collaborations.

Planned Impact

Our impact strategy focuses on two aims. The first is to develop long-term strategies for knowledge exchange by forging a new partnership between the University of Manchester and the Pankhurst Centre. The second ensures the Network impacts on a wide range of beneficiaries, through training sessions for Early Career Researchers and developing new relationships with other non-HEIs.
The activities of the Network would therefore have the following non-academic beneficiaries:
1. The Network looks to make a timely and valuable impact to the Pankhurst Centre as it embarks on a particularly exciting period of fundraising, redevelopment and expansion. The Pankhurst Centre will benefit from the Network in several ways, particularly in shaping new storylines for interpretative possibilities. The Network will produce training material for volunteers and activities for young visitors, and the use of the Centre as the location for the second workshop, and the public lectures and subsequent 'Pankhurst Podcasts,' will support the Centre's strategies to enhance its provisions, increase visitor numbers, and help establish the Pankhurst Centre as a centre of research activity. The wider public will benefit from free to access material provided by the Network, based on cutting-edge research that the Centre would not ordinarily have access to. The Network's contribution to the Pankhurst Centre will enhance the experience of its visitors when it re-opens in 2023, by providing content for new tours to encourage repeat visitors and for specific activities to encourage attendance by younger audiences. The history of the Pankhursts and the Suffragettes remains a popular subject amongst a range of users and we look to communicating new knowledge about the Pankhurst home.
2. Museum and heritage sector. The workshops aim to encourage further collaborations between museums and heritage partners by fostering discussions about potential partnerships, knowledge exchange, and new ways to engage with academic research. The aim is to use these innovative conversations between researchers, practitioners and non-HEI partners, in conjunction with the Early Career training sessions, to create new collaborations and new types of impact activities, with a focus on engaging difficult-to-reach audiences and users, such as youth groups. Through this, the Network intends to foster a long-term impact in knowledge transfer activities.
3. Policy, public, and charity sectors. Since the Network engages with important issues such as homes, crime and poverty, it aims to use the research to benefit those working in or receiving the services of related charity and public sectors. It will do this by facilitating consultation meetings between charity and public sector workers and the Network Coordinator, PI and Co-I, focusing on exchanging ideas and asking how these potential partners would benefit from academic collaboration, discuss best practice, make links for future work, and get a greater understanding of how to maximise the benefits of collaboration with academics. The Network aims to engage with organisations such as Women's Aid, who merged with the Pankhurst Centre in 2014, and those who work with care-leavers and the probation system. These meetings will help to ensure that these sectors will benefit directly through the activities set out in the PI and Co-I's AHRC Research Grant application.
4. Dissemination. The Network will make use of social media, including a dedicated Twitter feed, the PI's research blog, the Pankhurst Centre's blog, and the dedicated website to promote and disseminate its activities. The Network will also make use of the support offered from the University of Manchester, particularly the Press Office, and Pankhurst Centre's own media support. The PI and Co-I have a strong track record in appearing in local and national broadcast media and will utilise their contacts and experience to promote the Network, particularly to popular audiences.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We held the first of three workshops at the Pankhurst Centre 13-14 September 2019, which addressed the theme of the deviant home. We asked key questions about the relationship between the home and illegal behaviours and addressed the Pankhurst's home as a site of deviant behaviour. Key discoveries and achievements included:
- generating important definitions of domesticity and its historical specificity as a term
- the originality of looking at domesticity through the lens of crime and court records
- gathered a range of academics specialised in the history of crime in various themes and approaches to address the idea of the criminal home directly for the first time
- considered new approaches and methods to this theme.

We had organised our second workshop for April 2020 on the Home and Activism, but was cancelled due to Covid. Some of our speakers accepted our invitation to record versions of their talks, which we disseminated via Twitter and charlottewildman.com. Their work featured the complex links between women's engagement with domestic space and a range of forms of activism through a variety of contexts and case studies, with a particular emphasis on women from migrant and ethnic minority groups and diasporas.

The third workshop on the Curative Home took place in July 2021, via Zoom. It brought together network members and some additional speakers who addressed the concept of domesticity as possessing a curative role and considered the relationship between the home and wellbeing. The presentations discussed key issues relating to the concept of the home itself; emotion and grief; and the home as a restorative response to problems.

The workshops helped to produce new insights into the meaning of domesticity and into the varied ways in which women, particularly, could challenge, exploit or transgress cultures of domesticity. This is a key theme in the Special Issue of Women's History Review, produced by the Network.

Network activities have also shaped and contributed to the PI and Co-I's academic work more generally - such as shaping the idea of the 'criminal home', which is central to the concept of the PI's current project on working-class women, crime, home and family life. It has also shaped the PI and Co-I's collaborative research, and their work on child emigration with scholar of law, Ruth Lamont, using the idea of the deviant and curative home to address the processes and policies of child emigration systems from the North-West of England to Canada, 1870-1930. This concept has shaped our jointly-written monograph on this topic, which is under contract with McGill-Queen's University Press.

The partnership with the Pankhurst has been key to the achievements of the Network and we have responded to their changing needs and priorities in light of the substantial impact of the Covid pandemic. Key achievements include:
1. the three sets of volunteer training, which have upskilled the heritage volunteers and enabled them to conduct their own historical research on the Pankhurst family to feed into the new exhibitions at the museum.
2. The resources created that have been donated to the Pankhurst Centre for their use, including the training materials (such as the later history of the Pankhurst museum and its battle for survival in the 1970s/80s); resources for the public; and user-friendly information on the Pankhurst family.
3. The success of the public lectures in attracting members of the public to Pankhurst Museum and to disseminate knowledge relating to the Network themes of the deviant home; the activist home; and the curative home.

The collaboration with the Pankhurst Centre has also helped the PI and Co-I develop their engagement with other heritage organisations and the PI took up an invitation to join the Board of Trustees for the registered charity Manchester Histories in 2021, which aims to engage communities with the city's diverse history. The findings also contributed to the Co-I's new funded project, History at Risk: Activism and the Contested Past around the World, which seeks to engage with heritage groups in Manchester, and to to the PI's new funded project on working-class homes and crime.
Exploitation Route The Network facilitated new conversations and discussions that re-frame how historians may conceive of domestic space. This outcome will benefit academic discussions around a key concept in modern British history. Network activities brought together a diverse range of academics that fostered important conversations about methods and sources as well as encouraging scholars to consider communicating their research via methods of public engagement. These findings are communicated via publicly available resources and through the Special Issue for others to use. Our engagement with the Pankhurst Centre provided resources and knowledge that heritage volunteers will continue to engage with and inform the work they do with public users and our public events facilitated new methods for the museum to engage with publics in different ways that they can build on.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://charlottewildman.com/
 
Description We have been working closely with the Pankhurst Centre to use our findings to help inform and shape their ambitious plans for development and reinterpretation. The findings have been used in a number of ways: 1. The curator and engagement teams were involved with the planning and delivery of the academic workshops and public lectures and we used the outcomes of these important discussions to shape and facilitate the Pankhurst's funding bids and strategy for reinterpretation and development of the museum - one bid focused on bringing to light the home life of the Pankhursts, which this project has directly informed and brought new academic approaches on the history of domesticity to the story of the suffragette movement. 2. Training for volunteers: PI has delivered three programmes of training using findings on to train heritage volunteers at the Pankhurst to shape, inform and increase confidence in their role in the Pankhurst museum. 1. Our findings have also shaped wider forms of public engagement: Co-I contributed a session to the University of Manchester Learning Together programme at HMP Styal that brought together our findings on gender, deviancy and domesticity through the lens of the Pankhurst family's history and the museum. 2. It has also shaped our wider research and influenced our work on children and emigration, which we delivered as two public workshops as part of the Being Human Festival 2019 One of our key objectives was to deliver training for volunteers at the Pankhurst Museum and including four sessions via Zoom in September/October 2020. The training in helped underpin volunteer contributions to a new funded exhibition 'At home with the Pankhurst family, that will facilitate part of the museum's post-Covid reopening. 'The exhibition aims to reshape the way that visitors experience the Pankhurst Centre and understand the story of the Pankhurst family for years to come. Volunteers were tasked with ensuring the museum's narrative accurately reflected the histories of the Pankhurst family, and were asked to help to prepare information packs for the designers working on the exhibition. The Autumn training sessions covered finding and using secondary sources; Research Via Historical Newspapers (with contributions from the Network Coordinator); How to Navigate Archives (with contributions from a PhD student); and Writing, Presentation and Referencing. The research training sessions were well attended and worked well via Zoom delivery because it facilitated good attendance. They equipped volunteers with knowledge and understanding of the history of women and Manchester alongside the research and presentation skills, which all aim to help them shape their the design and delivery of their own research projects to facilitate the new exhibition at the Pankhurst Museum. Our Coordinator also used the projects findings to produce some schools resources such as a quiz, which have been passed on to the Pankhurst Centre, plus two substantial blog posts on the Pankhurst family that are designed to be accessible to public audiences. In September 2022, PI delivered a third programme of training sessions for volunteers, focussing on the history of suffrage and women, and the later history of the Pankhurst house and the campaign to prevent its demolishment and its subsequent reopening as a museum and women's centre in the 1980s.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description History at Risk: Activism and the Contested Past around the World
Amount £27,363 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/W003937/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2022 
End 08/2023
 
Description Reconsidering Crime in Urban Working-Class Homes and Family Life, 1918-1979
Amount £212,528 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/X000338/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2023 
End 07/2025
 
Description Public Lecture 2 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The public lecture was delivered by Dr Sumita Mukherjee (Bristol University), titled 'Suffrage, Childhood and Home Life for Indian Girls in Early 20th Century England.' In discussion with the Pankhurst Centre, we decided to host it via Zoom because it allowed the Pankhurst team to test a new potential digital offer to their supporters and to the general population. There was a lot of interest in the talk 75 plus 25 Pankhurst Museum Volunteers booked to attend: 28 did attend, with similar numbers viewing/listening to a digital version of the talk that we made available for c. 4 weeks after the talk.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Public Lecture 3 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The talk was given by Professor June Purvis, titled 'The Pankhurst Family and the Suffrage Campaign.' Delivered via Zoom, it helped the Pankhurst Centre develop their new plans and strategies for engaging with supporters via digital platforms. It was very positively received - we had 140 plus 25 Pankhurst Museum Volunteers booked to attend - 44 attended and the digital recording (made available for c. 4 weeks) attracted further views.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Public Lecture by Jill Liddington 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Jill Liddington delivered the first public lecture for the Network titled Anne Lister and the Deviant Home, held at the University of Manchester and followed by a reception at the Pankhurst Centre. Our evaluations demonstrated that 41% of respondents had not attended an event at the University of Manchester before and 41 % had not visited the Pankhurst before so the event brought new audiences and attracted non-academic audiences.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020
URL http://charlottewildman.com
 
Description Training for Pankhurst Volunteers 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Supporters
Results and Impact I gave the first training session to Pankhurst volunteers that used research findings to contextualise and explain the Pankhursts and suffragette activism. It aims to give volunteers more confidence and training as historians to help their own research into the house, women's lives, and the history of feminism and activism.

I gave four further sessions via Zoom in September/October 2020, which aimed to help Pankhurst volunteers contribute to a new exhibition on the Pankurst family.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Training for Volunteers at the Pankhurst Centre 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact I delivered three in-person training sessions to heritage volunteers at the Pankhurst Museum. They focussed on the history of women in nineteenth-century Britain; the Suffragette movement and Pankhurst family; and the later history of the Pankhurst Centre. It aimed to equip volunteers with the skills to build confidence and enhance their roles as guides and as experts in the history of the Pankhurst family; the museum itself; and the suffragette movement.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022