Life:Moving Onwards: Ethical Praxis and the use of film in the International End of Life Community

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: Film & Television Studies

Abstract

The proposed project responds to and develops significant and wide-ranging benefits for the end of life (EOL) community. These emerged during the original 'Digital Technology and Human Vulnerability: Towards an Ethical Praxis' (DTHV) research and crystallised during the ensuing multiple impact and engagement activities. Its primary objective is to extend these benefits to the international EOL community, focusing initially on Uganda, Rwanda and Australia.

Part of the AHRC's 'Digital Transformations' theme, this pilot study ran from October 2016 - March 2017. Partnering with John Taylor Hospice (JTH) in Birmingham, it centred on a participatory filmmaking project (Life:Moving) in which participants from JTH co-created six short films later exhibited locally. It explored the ethical issues for filmmaking in relation to terminal illness, and produced prototypical guidelines for this filmmaking praxis. During DTHV, and since, it became clear that the importance and value of the films themselves for the EOL community matched, perhaps even exceeded, the original emphasis on both ethical praxis (still central to the films) and the digital film and media arts community as primary stakeholder. While DTHV sought to challenge public misconceptions of terminal illness and support hospice provision, it did not foresee Life:Moving's impact upon participants, audiences and EOL professionals, nor how this impact could be rolled out to new EOL audiences and contexts. Life:Moving Onwards extends, and further realises, this impact.

DTHV demonstrated that film can be used effectively and ethically within a palliative care context for therapeutic and broader socio-cultural goals relating to common perceptions and prevailing assumptions about death. The co-created films challenged existing representations of, and knowledge about, the personal and clinical experience of dying, and provided both an outlet and opportunities for reflection for members of the EOL community. For the public, the films stimulate discussion of illness, grief and wellbeing, thereby promoting 'death literacy'. For participants, they can enhance quality of life and foster creative expression. For JTH, the films provided important perspectives on care and clinical experience, not picked up elsewhere in the hospice. They were subsequently shared with clinical and wellbeing staff there, at other EOL care events in the Midlands and beyond. With the burgeoning use of film within public health contexts, the findings were especially appealing to these organisations and their value for the purpose of EOL staff training and for developing 'best practice' for film use has thus been established.

DTHV opened up collaborative possibilities not foreseen in the original research proposal. After it ended, the PI took Life:Moving to numerous non-academic venues in and beyond the UK and, consequently, two international partners invited the films and research to be shared at, and around, their annual events. This project brings Life:Moving to these key venues for the discussion and dissemination of African and global work in the field. The first is the African Palliative Care Association. Launched in 2003, its has a pan-African membership of 2163 institutions in over 25 countries. The PI will participate in its annual conference, in Rwanda in September 2019, and in the Cancer and Palliative Care conference in neighbouring Uganda preceding it. The second partner is Public Health and Palliative Care International, which will hold its annual conference this year in Sydney in October. In collaboration with these organisations, the films and findings will be shared with various EOL professionals and publics through papers, workshops, community and media activity. Through this, the PI and CoI will test out the the films' potential for generating debate in these different English-speaking contexts, and, subsequently, will turn them into training materials for the international EOL community.

Planned Impact

This project will provide a range of benefits-personal, social, creative/practical and professional-to the non-academic international Palliative Care community and the publics that interact with it. One of UKRI's three definitions of non-academic impact concerns 'enhancing quality of life, health and creative output'. Life:Moving Onwards aims specifically at fulfilling this through its very focused ambitions and activities. These have been developed through the PI working closely with Jed Jerwood, on the original study's research team as John Taylor Hospice's (JTH's) art psychotherapist. Jerwood's significance grew as the EOL community's interest crystallised and, thus, he is sole CoI here. The project has also been developed through the PI's close contact with the partner organisations.

Its main and immediate beneficiaries are the EOL professionals attending the conferences and connected events in Uganda, Rwanda and Sydney. Delegates to these conferences are clinical staff - doctors, nurses, wellbeing staff - and those involved in the administration of care, research and outreach, in palliative health settings. They will learn about the value of using film within these settings and how to use it ethically and, therefore, productively to further their own goals and their organisations' care agendas. These are international gatherings but the countries represented, especially in Africa, have their specific challenges in relation to both universal and palliative health care. According to head of research at APCA, Life:Moving seems likely to resonate because of their nascent but resistant relationship to the value of EOL care issues. In Sydney, the role of Life:Moving Onwards will be more geared to progressing, rather than provoking, discussion of EOL issues, the role of arts projects in health care contexts and of ethical praxis.

The second set of beneficiaries, immediate and unknown, will be members of the wider community who will come into contact with the films and research through public exhibitions and other outreach events during the trip. The exact nature of these, in Uganda and Rwanda, are yet to be fixed but under discussion are television interviews and working with arts initiatives. In Australia, the Blue Mountains fringe arts festival accompanying PHPCI will be the principal venue for impacting this audience through the films' screenings and a launch event where the PI will speak to the relationship between Arts and EOL. Further activities are being set up within Sydney itself after the conference.

The third set of beneficiaries are EOL professionals worldwide who will be exposed to the films, research and ethical guidelines via colleagues attending the international events and via the online training resources. These will be developed during the project and promoted to this more extensive network by our partner organisations, as the Letters of Support note.

A further set of stakeholders is more abstract: the nation's health and wellbeing which will benefit from the general value of the project in its support of palliative care (especially in the African context) and of death literacy, more widely. A final set is worth noting - the media, arts and film professionals who will come into contact with the films and findings, especially the ethical guidelines, during this project. In addition to our targeting of the EOL community, and its related publics, we will also take the opportunity to share the research with groups identified in the original study, encompassing diverse range of individuals and groups who harness the power of film within their work: video advocacy and rights organisations, journalists, editors and activists. Like the original study, this project responds, and caters, to the burgeoning use of film in all areas of contemporary life, and the urgency that this use be, or be more, ethically wrought. In this sense, there remains an additional abstract or unknown set of beneficiaries for it.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The repercussions, and applications, of the project continue to be felt and evolve. Its initial aim (in Phase 1) was to share the films and findings of the original research (DTHV) with various international End of Life (EOL) professionals and publics via papers, workshops, community and media activity and through this, the PI and CoI, would test out the the films' value in these different English-speaking contexts. This would inform their subsequent translation into training materials for the national and international EOL community (Phase 2). With these Phases complete, the PI and CoI are - with the relative post-covid situation in the UK - again engaged with properly promoting these materials, now toolkits, to extend the value of, and interest in, them for the international community. A proper launch of the toolkits, ias a collaboration with the EOL community, is scheduled to take place in the summer 2022.

The international sharing of the films and research proved extremely effective and opened up new avenues for further application and development of research (as well as further avenues for the application of the original research and films). The value of the prospective training materials was made clear in the various (clinical, community-based, educational and creative) contexts in both East Africa and Australia where the films and research were shared during Phase 1.

However, working with APCA in particular, what became clear was both the universal appeal of Life:Moving and its ability to generate debate on care and on advocacy in any situation, but also the urgent need to apply the research to the East African context itself - to create films, and research their use, for Palliative care and for social health advocacy locally/regionally there too - and how this could have a wider and more-impactful reach. While the Australian context had many affinities with the UK, the extremely different relationship to universal health care, to palliative medicine or even treatment, and to the use of film for social action/welfare issues, within East Africa (and elsewhere on the continent) highlighted the urgency of these kind of research initiatives.

The PI's emerging and ongoing discussion with contacts made through the East Africa trip (specifically at the Ugandan Cancer Institute, at Rays of Hope Hospice, Jinja, and at Makere University, Rwanda), about designing a research project that might address the urgent need, just identified, is, was put (and continues to be currently) on hold as a result of the pandemic.

It also became clear through Phase 1 that it is really important that the films be subtitled to enhance their value, and support access, for the international audience. This was not anticipated nor budgeted for. The wider issue of access - with the films being in, and subtitled in, English only - is also an issue for future consideration with regard to the films' (and toolkits') truly international appeal.
Exploitation Route The award's key outcome - the creation of the online training materials - has been completed and the two 'toolkits' (which emerged as the best ways to achieve the project's goals) are available on the project's website. The clinical toolkit and the creative toolkit continue to be worked on and improved via feedback received from 'critical friends' (clinicians, educators, hospice outreach officers) ahead of our launching of the resources through, and to, local, national and international stakeholders. The creative toolkit - originally envisaged as enabling EOL professionals or community groups to replicate the Life:Moving filmmaking project within their own organisations - is being developed to also be used by, and reach, creatives/filmmakers who are working with vulnerable individuals. The value of the ethical guidelines that emerged from the original research have been harnessed by this toolkit and disseminated more widely through it.

Moving forward, the national and international Palliative Care and Public Health organisations, which expressed their support for and desire to promote the training resources during Phase 1, have, with the recent relative post-covid situation in the UK, been re-connected with again - as are new potential stakeholders - so that the resources have as far a reach as possible. The pandemic's impact on the schedules and commitments of public health organisations and professionals (as well as of the PI and CoI) created various obstacles to, and delayed, this happening. A launch event for the toolkits has now been scheduled for summer 2022.

Despite the covid-related delays to launching and promoting the training materials, this work already informs at least one related project. The PI is a consultant for a research application that has gone to the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology (FCT) entitled 'Filmmaking as Therapy: Challenging Stereotypical Views of Suicide'.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Education,Healthcare

URL https://lifemoving.org/toolkit/
 
Description This project was focused on engagement and impact activities in Phase 1, and the creation of online training materials in Phase 2. In Phase 1, it was the original findings of DTHV, the project, upon which this one built, that were opened up 'to various constituencies in the international EOL community': clinicians, palliative care professionals, students and users, community and filmmaking groups, and the public. These have been recorded within the Engagement activities section. These activities repeat the impact of the original project, but also proved highly effective at generating cross-cultural discussions of dying and for potentially extending understandings of the power of film to advocate for, give voice to, and illuminate the experience of the terminally ill. The consequences of the latter are still emerging, as is the value of the original research for further collaborations with new partnerships developed as a result of this project. With covid-related delays, it is still not yet known what their uses will be but prospective projects are planned. One based in East Africa continues to be on hold, however the PI began to develop further impact and engagement activities to take place in the Middle East. The PI sought funding for this project, Life:Moving in Israel/Palestine, in May 2022 from the ESRC IAA at Warwick but was unsuccessful in securing funding at that time. An improved application may well be submitted elsewhere in the future. A prospective international project has been informed by Life:Moving Onwards. This project, 'Filmmaking as Therapy: Challenging Stereotypical Views of Suicide', with Dr Paolo Stellino, as PI, at the NOVA Institute of Philosophy in Lisbon (and Professor Aaron as consultant), failed to gain funding from the Portuguese Foundation of Science and Technology. Dr Stellino plans to make another application in the 2023 cycle. The full impact of the training materials/the toolkits that have been developed - their health-oriented, creative and clinical value to existing and new local, national and international stakeholders - remains to be seen still as their completion and launch/distribution were significantly delayed as a result of the covid pandemic and the desire for an appropriate venue/occassion for the launch. With Birmingham becoming the first 'Compassionate City' in the UK in 2022, a major international conference with the Public Health Palliative Care Community - Compassionate Communities UK - will take place in July 2023. The PI has been collaborating with its organisers and will be sharing the Life:Moving films and project and officially launching and promoting the training resources there.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Healthcare
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description APCA 
Organisation African Palliative Care Association
Country Uganda 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Collaboration with APCA - the African Palliative Care Association - resulted in the PI installing the Life:Moving exhibition, and sharing the original research, at both the 2nd Ugandan Cancer Institute's annual conference and the 6th APCA conference in September 2019.
Collaborator Contribution This collaboration enabled the PI to connect with EoL (End of Life) professionals in Uganda and Rwanda and to generate a range of additional outreach activities that took place during the PI's visit. These connections are likely to lead to future further collaborations and together with the discussions they, and the additional activities, generated are currently feeding into the training resources which are under development by the PI and CoI.
Impact The main outputs of this collaboration and the project more broadly are the training resources currently under development
Start Year 2019
 
Description PHPCI 
Organisation Public Health Palliative Care International
Country Canada 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Collaboration with this organisation, saw the PI and CoI install the Life:Moving exhibition at the annual PHPCI conference in October 2019, share the films at the related, public, Blue Mountains Festival and discuss the project with EoL professionals from Australia and all over the world.
Collaborator Contribution The collaboration enabled the PI and CoI to make connections with EoL professionals from the region which led to a range of further outreach activities during the visit.
Impact The experience and discussions generated through this collaboration, and related outreach activities, are feeding into the main output of this project, the training resources currently underdevelopment by the PI and CoI.
Start Year 2019
 
Description 'From the Brink' festival (Blue Mountains) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The Life:Moving films were screened as part of the festival programme, and CoI Jed Jerwood participated in panel discussion of the Arts and EoL care
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description APCA panel (Kigali) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Participated in session on Digital Technologies and Palliative Care research. Large group of mostly East and Sub-Saharan Drs and Nurses, plus researchers/ staff from international health organisations and charities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Community event (CCNB Sydney) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Patients, carers and/or patient groups
Results and Impact PI and CoI presented and discussed films and research at Frenchs Forest Bushland Cemetery in Sydney to 25 members of the CCNB (Community Care and Wellbeing) organisation. Audience was comprised of patients, carers and volunteers/supporters of CCNB, outreach staff and palliative drs and nurses. Lively discussion ensued
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Hospice visit (Jinja, Uganda) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Shared research with Hospice staff. Accompanied team on daily work in the field. Continuing discussion with management about need for similar project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Kampala Exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Life:Moving exhibition was installed in the main hall of the Conference centre at the Sonata in Kampala. The PI spoke to numerous delegates at the conference about the films and research. Some watched the films as well.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Kampala panel 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact PI participated in panel on Arts and Advocacy for Palliative Care. About 60 people - mostly palliative Drs and nurses from East and sub-Saharan Africa - attended this event which sparked considerable discussion on the subject area and led to additional activities during the visit.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Kigali Convention centre exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Life:Moving exhibition was installed outside main conference space. I discussed the films and research with the various attendees who came to watch them.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Medical School visit (UGHE Butaro) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact Shared films and research with 25 medical students on the Arts-oriented foundation year. Powerful discussion of implications for training and care.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Monash talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation of films and research to the film research community at Monash. Discussion of ethical film praxis, research impact agenda and discussion of impact of research upon the researcher as she navigates this agenda and 'difficult' fieldwork.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description PHPCI exhibition (Blue Mts) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Exhibition installed outside main conference space at PHPCI annual event for 250 delegates to watch the films/learn about the research. Written feedback suggested personal impact of 'amazing' and 'inspirational films' but also potential professional/practical implications: 'Pal Care check your privilege', 'How good would it be to be able to offer this kind of creative practice to all PC patients' and 'Filming method and shifting institutional-family power. We'll adopt this movement in our work in Thailand. Thank you'
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Rwanda Arts Initiative event (Kigali) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Films and research shared with 20 young filmmakers (members of 250 Film Experiment Cine Club). I was joined by a Palliative Care Dr for a discussion on using film for social justice/education purposes, and communication EoL experience through film.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Shannon's Bridge event 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact PI and CoI talked about films and research and launched the Life:Moving exhibition at Shannon's Bridge. Enthusiasm for project led to increased publicity for week-long exhibition.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Shannons Bridge exhibition (Victoria) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Patients, carers and/or patient groups
Results and Impact The Life:Moving exhibition was installed during Compassion Week at this EoL community hub in Creswick, Victoria. It allowed Shannon's Bridge to reach new people and connect with them about end of life care issues as well as art as therapy as an advocacy tool. Some of the comments left by people who experienced the exhibition demonstrated the personal and potentially professional impact of the films/research. These comments included:

"Thank you for shining a light on death and dying", "These patients were blessed to be given the opportunity to share their experiences and stories"
"touching Exhibition. My friends and I really enjoyed it. A real highlight to our day!"

"The entire concept is inspirational. The facilitation of such a concept could be adapted to any and every provider of end of life care - The concept hit the nail on the head using the lived experience (of life) as narrative - so enable anyone who choses to consider the issues themselves in depth"

"Thank you - I am sure if the public saw these films they would be enlightened".
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019